Thoughts on Minnesota game and remainder of season

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,704
5,543
113
PSU is playing better, especially on defense.
The OL is improving which is great news considering most are eligible to return next year.
Minnesota was horrible in the first half. They get as much credit for our 28-0 lead as PSU does.
Second half doldrums continue. Offense got conservative too early. I'm not sure what changed with the defense.
Going for it on 4th and 1 from our own 34 yd line worked but was dumb. We were leading 28-0 and if we didn't make it Minny would have been in business.
Peoples and Martin have taken a back seat.
Brahmer finally used his 6'7" to high point a ball in the EZ.

What could have been...
PSU blew a 17 pt lead vs Wisconsin giving up a 76 yd TD when our DB fell down
PSU lost by 3 to Michigan because the most experienced QB in college football had 3 TOs

This team with all of it's flaws could have been looking at 10-2 which would have been 3rd in the BiG and better than OSU, Oregon, USC.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
PSU is playing better, especially on defense.
The OL is improving which is great news considering most are eligible to return next year.
Minnesota was horrible in the first half. They get as much credit for our 28-0 lead as PSU does.
Second half doldrums continue. Offense got conservative too early. I'm not sure what changed with the defense.
Going for it on 4th and 1 from our own 34 yd line worked but was dumb. We were leading 28-0 and if we didn't make it Minny would have been in business.
Peoples and Martin have taken a back seat.
Brahmer finally used his 6'7" to high point a ball in the EZ.

What could have been...
PSU blew a 17 pt lead vs Wisconsin giving up a 76 yd TD when our DB fell down
PSU lost by 3 to Michigan because the most experienced QB in college football had 3 TOs

This team with all of it's flaws could have been looking at 10-2 which would have been 3rd in the BiG and better than OSU, Oregon, USC.
I have been critical of Campbell and what’s happening with the program but am happy to give credit where credit is due. The team is playing much better since the bye week. Let’s hope the team finishes strong and can parlay that into success with recruiting and the portal since IMO the most important factor for success is still talent.
 

WestSideLion

All-American
May 29, 2001
5,156
5,579
113
I have been critical of Campbell and what’s happening with the program but am happy to give credit where credit is due. The team is playing much better since the bye week. Let’s hope the team finishes strong and can parlay that into success with recruiting and the portal since IMO the most important factor for success is still talent.
They’re playing better. That’s the good news. The schedule has greatly helped them play better. The bowl game may be the best measure on whether they’ve improved.
 

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,531
2,529
113
I have been critical of Campbell and what’s happening with the program but am happy to give credit where credit is due. The team is playing much better since the bye week. Let’s hope the team finishes strong and can parlay that into success with recruiting and the portal since IMO the most important factor for success is still talent.
The most important thing and what absolutely had to happen is that since the bye, this program now has some positive momentum which hopefully Campbell and his staff will be able to parlay into a strong recruiting and, probably more importantly. portal finish. That’s why these last two games and whatever bowl game they play are important and not meaningless regardless of the competition.

By the way, and I don’t know which bowls are affiliated with the Big 10 and ACC except for the Pinstripe Bowl. I could see a PSU-VT bowl game which probably would be played with a greater intensity than a typical bowl game these days.
 

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,531
2,529
113
They’re playing better. That’s the good news. The schedule has greatly helped them play better. The bowl game may be the best measure on whether they’ve improved.
Regarding the schedule, before PSU played Purdue, Purdue had lost in OT to Wake Forest which may be in the playoffs, won at Illinois and crushed Minnesota. Also, Washington now is 6-4, and Minnesota, except for the Miss State and Purdue games and last night, plays in mostly one score, competitive games. I’m not saying that either of those teams are great because they’re not, but they’re just as good if not better than Wisconsin and Michigan, which I think that we would beat now (we never should’ve lost to Wisconsin in the first place and probably not to that wretched Michigan team).
 

MacNit

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,369
2,303
113
PSU is playing better, especially on defense.
The OL is improving which is great news considering most are eligible to return next year.
Minnesota was horrible in the first half. They get as much credit for our 28-0 lead as PSU does.
Second half doldrums continue. Offense got conservative too early. I'm not sure what changed with the defense.
Going for it on 4th and 1 from our own 34 yd line worked but was dumb. We were leading 28-0 and if we didn't make it Minny would have been in business.
Peoples and Martin have taken a back seat.
Brahmer finally used his 6'7" to high point a ball in the EZ.

What could have been...
PSU blew a 17 pt lead vs Wisconsin giving up a 76 yd TD when our DB fell down
PSU lost by 3 to Michigan because the most experienced QB in college football had 3 TOs

This team with all of it's flaws could have been looking at 10-2 which would have been 3rd in the BiG and better than OSU, Oregon, USC.
All true…but this is still a poor team…not just PSU…overall poor (no high end talent).
 

Alphalion75

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
15,310
4,438
113
Outside of UCLA and Indiana there are many mediocre teams in the BIG including Penn State. Any of the games between this group can go either way. Over the course of the season, IMHO, Oregon and Penn State have improved the most amongst this bunch. The cohesion of this team seems to be improving. Campbell has pointed this out in his media events. We don't have any superstars, except for Rojas, but we seem to be coming together as a team and playing better. Especially the OL.
 

ClydeKickstand

Sophomore
Sep 3, 2026
68
138
33
The most important thing and what absolutely had to happen is that since the bye, this program now has some positive momentum which hopefully Campbell and his staff will be able to parlay into a strong recruiting and, probably more importantly. portal finish. That’s why these last two games and whatever bowl game they play are important and not meaningless regardless of the competition.

By the way, and I don’t know which bowls are affiliated with the Big 10 and ACC except for the Pinstripe Bowl. I could see a PSU-VT bowl game which probably would be played with a greater intensity than a typical bowl game these days.
PSU-Spitt
 

o_Grass

All-American
Oct 28, 2021
1,430
5,517
113
Outside of UCLA and Indiana there are many mediocre teams in the BIG including Penn State. Any of the games between this group can go either way. Over the course of the season, IMHO, Oregon and Penn State have improved the most amongst this bunch. The cohesion of this team seems to be improving. Campbell has pointed this out in his media events. We don't have any superstars, except for Rojas, but we seem to be coming together as a team and playing better. Especially the OL.
I also believe Iowa deserves a mention. I heard today that they have only given up 13 TD's in 10 games. That's pretty impressive.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,358
1,349
113
They’re playing better. That’s the good news. The schedule has greatly helped them play better. The bowl game may be the best measure on whether they’ve improved.

Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Blair10 and psu83

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!
God--imagine how Va Tech fans feel right now playing the 99th hardest schedule and having faced opponents with a combined record of 41-60 knowing they can't even go 8-4 with what is truly the easiest schedule of any P4 team.

And, no, look our schedules back in the day
 

o_Grass

All-American
Oct 28, 2021
1,430
5,517
113
Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!
leaning trailer park boys GIF
 

Psu21310

Sophomore
Jul 11, 2025
37
153
33
So some of us are saying Iowa and Indiana are good teams
Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!

LSU just lost a game at the last second to a top ten team. Minnesota lost a game in OT to top 10 team after the team needed a 60 yard fg on the last play. LSU has 0 wins over top 25 teams. Minnesota has beaten a top 15 team.
 

Bvillebaron

All-Conference
Feb 4, 2004
3,434
3,350
113
God--imagine how Va Tech fans feel right now playing the 99th hardest schedule and having faced opponents with a combined record of 41-60 knowing they can't even go 8-4 with what is truly the easiest schedule of any P4 team.

And, no, look our schedules back in the day
And I should care how VaTech fans feel today why?
 

CDLionFL

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2021
1,784
2,725
113
Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!
Quit ******* bitching about winning. Would you have preferred they lose all these conference games?
 

psu83

Junior
May 29, 2001
311
390
63
Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!
Pity GIF
Married At First Sight Lol GIF by Lifetime
Cry Crying GIF by Rhymesayers
Cheddar Cheese Crying GIF by Dietz & Watson
Sad Talk Show GIF by iOne Digital
The Office What GIF
Sad Baby GIF by Bounce
Cub Swanson Crying GIF by UFC
 
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
I have been critical of Campbell and what’s happening with the program but am happy to give credit where credit is due. The team is playing much better since the bye week. Let’s hope the team finishes strong and can parlay that into success with recruiting and the portal since IMO the most important factor for success is still talent.
This team shows improvement given nothing but adversity. Now you want to jump on the bandwagon? You've got a few more years of apology to do. Your post history doesn't get absolved or forgiven that easy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

leinbacker

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
2,533
4,059
113
They’re playing better. That’s the good news. The schedule has greatly helped them play better. The bowl game may be the best measure on whether they’ve improved.

I wish this was true about the bowl game. But with players sitting out, it will be a glorified scrimmage and not mean a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WestSideLion

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,164
4,610
113
Exactly! If we play a legit 4-loss team like LSU in postseason, we will get absolutely pasted and taken to the woodshed. The only reason we will end up 8-4 (if we do), is that we played the easiest schedule we ever played since joining b1g - by a country mile - and quite possibly the easiest schedule PSU ever played in their entire history! Our 5 b1g wins would be against a cast of b1g characters with a current combined Conference record of 11-24!

Excellent point. I don’t get the over the top optimism when the reality is Penn State has been playing the softest part of their B1G schedule. Reminds me of 2025 when Penn State’s only B1G wins came against teams at the bottom third of the conference.
 
Last edited:
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
Excellent point. I don’t get the over the top optimism when the reality is Penn State has been playing the softest part of their B1G schedule. Reminds me of 2025 when Penn State’s only B1G wins came against teams at the bottom third of the conference.
I see that the both of you would rather lose. Then you could justify b itching even more.

You two are both obviously great supporters of the program.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

Alphalion75

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
15,310
4,438
113
Excellent point. I don’t get the over the top optimism when the reality is Penn State has been playing the softest part of their B1G schedule. Reminds me of 2025 when Penn State’s only B1G wins came against teams at the bottom third of the conference.
The realty is that the BIG has many mediocre teams. Is arguable that Washington and Minnesota are no worse than Wisconsin and Michigan. And USC and NW are not that good either. At least at thus stage if the year. So to say we are into the softest part of our schedule is a bit misleading. A more accurate post would be that ALL of our schedule is equally soft. Who would have thought Maryland would beat Wisky. You can lump together about 8-9 teams who are all equally mediocre, including Penn State. And any of them can beat the other or lose depending on the direction of the wind that day. I believe fans are celebrating this teams improvement more than beating the opponent.
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,164
4,610
113
The realty is that the BIG has many mediocre teams. Is arguable that Washington and Minnesota are no worse than Wisconsin and Michigan. And USC and NW are not that good either. At least at thus stage if the year. So to say we are into the softest part of our schedule is a bit misleading. A more accurate post would be that ALL of our schedule is equally soft. Who would have thought Maryland would beat Wisky. You can lump together about 8-9 teams who are all equally mediocre, including Penn State. And any of them can beat the other or lose depending on the direction of the wind that day. I believe fans are celebrating this teams improvement more than beating the opponent.

It sounds more like wishful thinking. Until Penn State defeats or starts winning against the better programs, I don’t count that as improvement. It‘s the same position the program has been stuck in for years.

In 2027, Penn State will have an opportunity to prove it on the field when they play Michigan, Oregon, and Indiana. Defeating those B1G teams would be real improvement.

Until then, people are deceiving themselves thinking wins over the likes of Minnesota and Purdue represent improvement for the program. Penn State is expected to beat those teams.
 
Last edited:
Dec 14, 2021
568
817
93
Woulda/coulda/shoulda. The team could have folded in on itself. It didn't. The coaches could have made excuses and/or placed blame on someone/something else. They didn't. They held themselves accountable and made adjustments. Of course, the team still has limitations and the staff is not perfect. But, I feel a lot better about the future of the program than I did a month ago.
 

Alphalion75

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
15,310
4,438
113
It sounds more like wishful thinking. Until Penn State defeats or starts winning against the better programs, I don’t count that as improvement. It‘s the same position the program has been stuck in for years.

In 2027, Penn State will have an opportunity to prove it on the field when they play Michigan, Oregon, and Indiana. Defeating those B1G teams would be real improvement.

Until then, people are deceiving themselves thinking wins over the likes of Minnesota and Purdue represent improvement for the program. Penn State is expected to beat those teams.
I never posted we are playing at a natty level nor that we are beating the Pittsburgh Steelers. We are not even close to playing at that level. We simply don't have the athletes. We are a mediocre team in a mostly mediocre conference. I was merely pointing out that I've seen some improvement since that 2nd half of the Wisky game. Am I satisfied or being wishful for pointing out the obvious.
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,164
4,610
113
I never posted we are playing at a natty level nor that we are beating the Pittsburgh Steelers. We are not even close to playing at that level. We simply don't have the athletes. We are a mediocre team in a mostly mediocre conference. I was merely pointing out that I've seen some improvement since that 2nd half of the Wisky game. Am I satisfied or being wishful for pointing out the obvious.

I understand your point. I really do. My point is the goal of Penn State is to compete for a National Championship. That has been the goal since the late 1960s. It’s not going to change.

Only mediocre, 2nd tier, or bottom dweller programs care about moderate improvement. Programs like Oregon, Michigan, Ohio State, and USC are dialed-in to a National Championship mindset. Coaches at these programs are not hired to make moderate improvements. It‘s not good enough.

That said, I do agree with your point about the improvement Penn State has made.
 

Alphalion75

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
15,310
4,438
113
I understand your point. I really do. My point is the goal of Penn State is to compete for a National Championship. That has been the goal since the late 1960s. It’s not going to change.

Only mediocre, 2nd tier, or bottom dweller programs care about moderate improvement. Programs like Oregon, Michigan, Ohio State, and USC are dialed-in to a National Championship mindset. Coaches at these programs are not hired to make moderate improvements. It‘s not good enough.

That said, I do agree with your point about the improvement Penn State has made.
Trust me. I've been following Penn State football since the Rip Engle tenure. So my bar is very high for my expectations.
 

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,147
32,302
113
I never posted we are playing at a natty level nor that we are beating the Pittsburgh Steelers. We are not even close to playing at that level. We simply don't have the athletes. We are a mediocre team in a mostly mediocre conference. I was merely pointing out that I've seen some improvement since that 2nd half of the Wisky game. Am I satisfied or being wishful for pointing out the obvious.
There has been definite improvement since the Bye week. If people can't see that, then thats on them.
 

DaytonRickster

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
3,487
4,005
113
And we played without our best wide receiver and our starting running back only played one half of football. That's how things go.
PSU had been playing without Howard since game 4. Hansen started and played well for first half. Minnesota's DTs didn't play one down vs PSU which gave PSU's OL an advantage in the trenches where much of game outcomes are decided.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Wrestling Penn State wrestling beats Oklahoma 41-0 to earn its first shut out of the year: Recap
  2. 02 BWI Basketball Penn State basketball cruises past New Haven behind complete effort
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Penn State offer puts Nittany Lions in strong position with DB Carlos Gordon
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State notebook: Carson Hansen’s big night, Alex Manske’s opportunity and more
  5. 05 BWI Wrestling How to watch, follow, Penn State wrestling at Oklahoma on Sunday: New start time and streaming info, probable lineups, more