“Religious Mission”

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,260
2,614
113
Have they mastered it, or is there a selection bias? Because they keep winning individual titles they keep getting interviewed mat-side at the tournament, and they keep professing their faith on national TV. But I seem to recall that it was happening with just about every winner, if not every winner. But I confess my memory is limited in this regard.
There have been plenty of religious types in all sports that profess their faith anytime a microphone is put in front of them. Penn State didn't start it nor are they the driving force behind it (everyone knows it's the Chicago White Sox!). Iowa certainly has had their share as well, and that's all well and good IMO.

At the end of the day, I just hope Carl is able to overcome the trauma his latest personal sacrifice is going to have on him. His support system might have to put in a little overtime this time around.................
 
  • Haha
Reactions: grapplefan

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
619
1,656
93
This is where I'm at as well. The lengths these guys are willing to go in order to stay in at psu says as much about our program as it does theirs.

Honestly its truly impressive Cael can dictate a year of the kids life and the kid & the parents just fall in line. I cant imagine being a 20 year old kid and told delay your life one year, move out of you apartment and away from your friends, give up how awesome just being in college in a college town is on command. Its very cult like. Truly impressive!

What's throwing a lot of us off guard is we all correlate this with Mormon faith. I can name lots of those athletes but this is truly a first for me that other Christians have ever done this. I can't name one that wasn't Mormon?

I was also thinking about the Messenbrink interview where he didn't know if he would be wrestling this season as obviously was waiting on the Haines ruling. But just think about that thought process....

1. So Messenbrink doesn't think he could beat Haines out at 174, didn't even want to try to and accepted his fate could be a mission year.
2. Cael has that much influence if Haines didnt wrestle to just take it, not even try to win the spot? I know Mitchell is religious as heck but most kids would transfer or choose not to hold there life up just so the coach can finds ways to but together current and future lineups together. So the kid is a bit of a hypocrite when running his month about how unimportant wrestling was in his life. Then why even wait on Haines for anything? Just walk away or still take your year. Obviously Cael tells him what important for Cael's sake

And these kids and parents are just playing ball. Mitchell didn't even know to pack his bags with the other two or get ready to man 174. He was just prepared to jump either direction when Cael snapped. I don't know any other coaches ever having this type of influence.

Sure its legal but there is a difference between being religious versus being in a religious cult. All honesty its getting pretty borderline in Happy Valley. Cael is the legal David Koresh of college athletics.
 
Last edited:

Corby2

Heisman
Jul 14, 2025
5,814
12,996
113
Honestly its truly impressive Cael can dictate a year of the kids life and the kid & the parents just fall in line. I cant imagine being a 20 year old kid and told delay your life one year, move out of you apartment and away from your friends, give up how awesome just being in college in a college town is on command. Its very cult like. Truly impressive!

What's throwing a lot of us off guard is we all correlate this with Mormon faith. I can name lots of those athletes but this is truly a first for me that other Christians have ever done this. I can't name one that wasn't Mormon?

I was also thinking about the Messenbrink interview where he didn't know if he would be wrestling this season as obviously was waiting on the Haines ruling. But just think about that thought process....

1. So Messenbrink doesn't think he could beat Haines out at 174, didn't even want to try to and accepted his fate could be a mission year.
2. Cael has that much influence if Haines didnt wrestle to just take it, not even try to win the spot? I know Mitchell is religious as heck but most kids would transfer or choose not to hold there life up just so the coach can finds ways to but together current and future lineups together. So the kid is a bit of a hypocrite when running his month about how unimportant wrestling was in his life. Then why even wait on Haines for anything? Just walk away or still take your year. Obviously Cael tells him what important for Cael's sake

And these kids and parents are just playing ball. Mitchell didn't even know to pack his bags with the other two or get ready to man 174. He was just prepared to jump either direction when Cael snapped. I don't know any other coaches ever having this type of influence.

Sure its legal but there is a difference between being religious versus being in a religious cult. All honesty its getting pretty borderline in Happy Valley. Cael is the legal David Koresh of college athletics.
Mitchell was going 165 and Duke 157 if Levi was back. They certed down for that reason. Mitchell was never gonna have to beat Levi.
 

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
619
1,656
93
Mitchell was going 165 and Duke 157 if Levi was back. They certed down for that reason. Mitchell was never gonna have to beat Levi.
He may have done that as a contingency but that wasn't the live plan. Have you listened to the interview I speak of? Pretty clear if Levi is eligible Mitchell would have been the 3rd kid on a mission. Let me see if I can find it to post. I promise you the plan wasn't to then waste a Kasak year either in your scenario.

Edit found it. 3 weeks ago. Go to the 10:06 mark and start. Talks about Levi and the lineup. At one point say trust the coaches, also Levi comes back I sit a year. Later on at the 15:30 again mentions I am going to help even if I have to sit out a year.

Sorry Corby. You are right on most things but it absolutely was floated around otherwise why talk like that. He talks like the cult members sit when dear leader speaks. The cult leader is above questioned.

We can agree to disagree but lemme know your thought's?

 
Last edited:

T8KUDWN

Senior
May 2, 2025
223
835
93
This is where I'm at as well. The lengths these guys are willing to go in order to stay in at psu says as much about our program as it does theirs.
Obviously, the team has a lot of success, but a lot of these kids can't afford not to stay in the program.
 

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
619
1,656
93
Obviously, the team has a lot of success, but a lot of these kids can't afford not to stay in the program.

You talking like NIL money to even ride a bench? I agree. My question is can an athlete receive NIL while supposedly on mission time? Technicaly doesnt the church foot that bill?

If so now you are back to my statement of someone named IRA got into the church donation business. Is Cael using the same church for everykid? How do we know the NIL is paid through and then a little extra for you pastor?

Its like Bob is now suddenly a member at Mocco's chuch. Is it like Iowa school voucher and church donation are above being audited?
 

Corby2

Heisman
Jul 14, 2025
5,814
12,996
113
He may have done that as a contingency but that wasn't the live plan. Have you listened to the interview I speak of? Pretty clear if Levi is eligible Mitchell would have been the 3rd kid on a mission. Let me see if I can find it to post. I promise you the plan wasn't to then waste a Kasak year either in your scenario.

Edit found it. Go to the 10:06 mark and start. Talks about Levi and the lineup. At one point say trust the coaches, also Levi comes back I sit a year. Later on at the 15:30 again mentions I am going to help even if I have to sit out a year.

Sorry Corby. You are right on most things but it absolutely was floated around otherwise why talk like that. He talks like the cult members sit when dear leader speaks. The cult leader is above questioned.


Mitchell likes to talk . I have never heard he was gonna sit a year . He's still a 165 and will be 74kg he's up because Levi isnt there. Kasak would've been the odd man out. I will ask around and see what I hear
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stick Kitty

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
619
1,656
93
Mitchell likes to talk . I have never heard he was gonna sit a year . He's still a 165 and will be 74kg he's up because Levi isnt there. Kasak would've been the odd man out. I will ask around and see what I hear
Fair. I get you wouldn't hear it. Why would Cael have wanted any religious mission info leaked anywhere prior. I totally get Mitchell is a free spirit and probably on the spectrum somewhere but why would he talk like he did. Especially given he has used a redshirt and its 5 for 5 time.

I could be wrong but it seemed one of two things 3 weeks ago. Probably both

1. He wasn't sure if he was going to be asked to sit or not- I'm assuming because Levi's appeal was up in the air. I dont believe he was moving back down because Kasak or Duke loss a year that cant be recouped. Obvious Cael isn't going to give away years on title contenders anymore with 5 for 5. This is his new path. No other school accumulates this much talent overlapping so they will be the poster child of what could be viewed as very shady.

2. Say Mitchell was just rambling. Even at that how apparent is it that Cael has set precedent and drilled it into the team's thinking to have that attitude that when asked- you will sit and take your year.

Mitchell multiple times talked like a cult member speaking to sitting when dear leader asks. Why does anyone talk like that with 5 for 5 now?

I am all ears and don't doubt your reach but they/PSU aint tryin to talk about this outside the facility doors. I imagine after reading me calling this out and somehow this makes it back to Cael he will nicely remind his kids to never talk like Mitchell did.

IMO he messed up. Not incriminating like when McNamara accidently ran his mouth on Ferentz coach staff making prior contact later leading to NCAA violations but you get the point. Cant prove anything illegal from it but you can read between the lines pretty clearly this is going to be a thing to be expected to be in the program. I have a feeling if you want to wrestle for Cael and aren't religious enough he will find someone else who will commit to a church right after the LOI.

Its gonna be a thing until NCAA sets up tighter guidelines. See if you can find out if both PSU kids are taking the same mission/same church. I mean different kids going to different churches back home is one thing. But to set up a church as a feeder system year after year is like the new go to city high or Stilly high prior to your freshman year. But gaming at a much higher level.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Fatwoodchuck

Wrestleknownothing

All-American
Oct 30, 2021
2,525
6,884
113
Fair. I get you wouldn't hear it. Why would Cael have wanted any religious mission info leaked anywhere prior. I totally get Mitchell is a free spirit and probably on the spectrum somewhere but why would he talk like he did. Especially given he has used a redshirt and its 5 for 5 time.

I could be wrong but it seemed one of two things 3 weeks ago. Probably both

1. He wasn't sure if he was going to be asked to sit or not- I'm assuming because Levi's appeal was up in the air. I dont believe he was moving back down because Kasak or Duke loss a year that cant be recouped. Obvious Cael isn't going to give away years on title contenders anymore with 5 for 5. This is his new path. No other school accumulates this much talent overlapping so they will be the poster child of what could be viewed as very shady.

2. Say Mitchell was just rambling. Even at that how apparent is it that Cael has set precedent and drilled it into the team's thinking to have that attitude that when asked- you will sit and take your year.

Mitchell multiple times talked like a cult member speaking to sitting when dear leader asks. Why does anyone talk like that with 5 for 5 now?

I am all ears and don't doubt your reach but they/PSU aint tryin to talk about this outside the facility doors. I imagine after reading me calling this out and somehow this makes it back to Cael he will nicely remind his kids to never talk like Mitchell did.

IMO he messed up. Not incriminating like when McNamara accidently ran his mouth on Ferentz coach staff making prior contact later leading to NCAA violations but you get the point. Cant prove anything illegal from it but you can read between the lines pretty clearly this is going to be a thing to be expected to be in the program. I have a feeling if you want to wrestle for Cael and aren't religious enough he will find someone else who will commit to a church right after the LOI.

Its gonna be a thing until NCAA sets up tighter guidelines. See if you can find out if both PSU kids are taking the same mission/same church. I mean different kids going to different churches back home is one thing. But to set up a church as a feeder system year after year is like the new go to city high or Stilly high prior to your freshman year. But gaming at a much higher level.
You set up some crazy either /ors.

Either they go to different churches back home or if they go to the same church it must have been set up just for them? That kind of conspiracy theory can get you paid on the broader internet. You are wasting your talents here.
 

Stick Kitty

All-Conference
Jul 7, 2025
619
1,656
93
You set up some crazy either /ors.

Either they go to different churches back home or if they go to the same church it must have been set up just for them? That kind of conspiracy theory can get you paid on the broader internet. You are wasting your talents here.

No worries my man. I realize you will be one of the last to catsup. How do I change my name to Stickkittyknowtoomuch?

Now if you will excuse me I have a happy hour to attend to get ready for a wonderful night of wrestling! Go Hawks!
 

Wrestleknownothing

All-American
Oct 30, 2021
2,525
6,884
113
No worries my man. I realize you will be one of the last to catsup. How do I change my name to Stickkittyknowtoomuch?

Now if you will excuse me I have a happy hour to attend to get ready for a wonderful night of wrestling! Go Hawks!
Now you are talking my language. Enjoy - both the happy hour and the wrestling.
 

District 4

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2018
1,305
2,880
113
A Christian is a follower of the Jesus Christ of the Bible. Mormon, while being generally very kind and morally upright people, are not followers of the Jesus Christ of the Bible. They follow the cosmic Christ that is a created being who has Satan as a brother. Nice folks, not Chri

Honestly its truly impressive Cael can dictate a year of the kids life and the kid & the parents just fall in line. I cant imagine being a 20 year old kid and told delay your life one year, move out of you apartment and away from your friends, give up how awesome just being in college in a college town is on command. Its very cult like. Truly impressive!

What's throwing a lot of us off guard is we all correlate this with Mormon faith. I can name lots of those athletes but this is truly a first for me that other Christians have ever done this. I can't name one that wasn't Mormon?

I was also thinking about the Messenbrink interview where he didn't know if he would be wrestling this season as obviously was waiting on the Haines ruling. But just think about that thought process....

1. So Messenbrink doesn't think he could beat Haines out at 174, didn't even want to try to and accepted his fate could be a mission year.
2. Cael has that much influence if Haines didnt wrestle to just take it, not even try to win the spot? I know Mitchell is religious as heck but most kids would transfer or choose not to hold there life up just so the coach can finds ways to but together current and future lineups together. So the kid is a bit of a hypocrite when running his month about how unimportant wrestling was in his life. Then why even wait on Haines for anything? Just walk away or still take your year. Obviously Cael tells him what important for Cael's sake

And these kids and parents are just playing ball. Mitchell didn't even know to pack his bags with the other two or get ready to man 174. He was just prepared to jump either direction when Cael snapped. I don't know any other coaches ever having this type of influence.

Sure its legal but there is a difference between being religious versus being in a religious cult. All honesty its getting pretty borderline in Happy Valley. Cael is the legal David Koresh of college athletics.
Dumbest thing i ever read on here. Grow up. You and all this drama about cael making kids do things. Listen to yourself. Wtf. Okay maybe not the dumbest i just remembered the turd and all his rants but still the same old drama lmfao.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Random4598375

District 4

All-Conference
Feb 16, 2018
1,305
2,880
113
Mitchell likes to talk . I have never heard he was gonna sit a year . He's still a 165 and will be 74kg he's up because Levi isnt there. Kasak would've been the odd man out. I will ask around and see what I hear
Don't waste your time they already drank the kool aid
 
Aug 11, 2023
218
334
62
You guys have spend an inordinate amount of time on this board bellyaching about how religious PSU wrestlers are, then when they act upon their religion you bellyache about that too. You are skeptical they are religious, then you are skeptical when they live it. Seems performative at worst, jealous at best.
go fuuk a boi
 

grapplefan

Senior
Oct 3, 2010
333
736
93
and I feel bad for the bois around you; what Christian would actually have anything to do with that university is beyond me
I've heard the same smears about Harvard and Nebraska at one time or another. Arguing about who is and who is not a real Christian is generally a political, not a religious exercise.

Suffice to say that Carl is great at manipulating rules, and we don't like that. If the NCAA doesn't like that as well, then they could change and enforce new rules.
 
  • Like
Reactions: el dub

mvattivo

All-Conference
Jun 23, 2005
643
3,056
93
I've heard the same smears about Harvard and Nebraska at one time or another. Arguing about who is and who is not a real Christian is generally a political, not a religious exercise.

Suffice to say that Carl is great at manipulating rules, and we don't like that. If the NCAA doesn't like that as well, then they could change and enforce new rules.

What rule would you like to see enforced? The one that they are following?
 

UTHawk4life

Junior
Nov 16, 2025
79
203
33
A Christian is a follower of the Jesus Christ of the Bible. Mormon, while being generally very kind and morally upright people, are not followers of the Jesus Christ of the Bible. They follow the cosmic Christ that is a created being who has Satan as a brother. Nice folks, not Christians.
It’s called the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. Paul wrote his epistles to the saints and we are in the last days. Doesn’t get any more Christian than that. Secondly, it’s clear you’ve never attended one of their church serves becasue it’s all centered around Christ. They do believe in the Bible and preach from it. Some reading from the internet and go attend a church service and come back and tell me they’re not Christian. It’s an asinine comment.
 

Sdwrestler_20

Junior
Dec 21, 2021
82
304
53
It’s called the church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. Paul wrote his epistles to the saints and we are in the last days. Doesn’t get any more Christian than that. Secondly, it’s clear you’ve never attended one of their church serves becasue it’s all centered around Christ. They do believe in the Bible and preach from it. Some reading from the internet and go attend a church service and come back and tell me they’re not Christian. It’s an asinine comment.
I stand by what I said without apologies. If anything I should have more strongly opposed their false teaching - and that is what it is, false teaching. It would not be deception if it did not look like the real deal. If you think that Mormon's are Christians then I have a bridge to sell you.
 
May 4, 2025
86
208
33
I swear, all you PSU visitors are trying to pee down our backs and tell us it's raining! If you're going to visit our board and try and sell us a bill of goods that these guys aren't taking a "misson" to hopefully save a year of eligibility then you must think the rest of the wrestling world are a bunch of idiots. I'm not blaming Carl for this "genius" manuver but just call a spade a spade. Own that sh*t, it's okay, it's within the rules but it's shaddy as hell and you guys know it. Just stop trying to defend it, it's beneath even you guys.
 

TarpHawk1

All-Conference
Jul 6, 2025
112
1,280
93
The religious mission is a loophole so large you could drive an ark through it. "5 for 5" was supposed to eliminate loopholes and create a simple, level playing field for all. But the NCAA erred by not actually eliminating all the loopholes! Until they do that, coaches and athletes will continue to exploit it. (It's pretty obvious that these are "missions of convenience" vs. conviction. But that's irrelevant.) The solution is no exemptions, period. If you choose to spend part of your time doing something else--competing for an Olympic spot, going on a mission, joining the military, or simply recovering from injury, God bless you, do it. But 5 for 5 needs to be 5 for 5. I'm happy to join the NCAA rules committee and replace the dolts who botched this.
 

AndreTheHawk

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
1,260
2,614
113
The religious mission is a loophole so large you could drive an ark through it. "5 for 5" was supposed to eliminate loopholes and create a simple, level playing field for all. But the NCAA erred by not actually eliminating all the loopholes! Until they do that, coaches and athletes will continue to exploit it. (It's pretty obvious that these are "missions of convenience" vs. conviction. But that's irrelevant.) The solution is no exemptions, period. If you choose to spend part of your time doing something else--competing for an Olympic spot, going on a mission, joining the military, or simply recovering from injury, God bless you, do it. But 5 for 5 needs to be 5 for 5. I'm happy to join the NCAA rules committee and replace the dolts who botched this.
Well, they'll have to confer with Carl first, to see if he has any more coming down the pipeline. If not, this rule will get changed as soon as the current duo return to Happy Valley....
 
  • Like
Reactions: TarpHawk1

HikeNatParks

All-Conference
May 12, 2023
235
1,196
93
Sure its legal but there is a difference between being religious versus being in a religious cult. All honesty its getting pretty borderline in Happy Valley. Cael is the legal David Koresh of college athletics.
A trance-like fixation on the occult to describe Cael/PSU makes you sound like, well, a cult follower. Message board or not, wild, unproven accusations define a tortured soul emboldened by online anonymity. Smearing a coach as a cult leader using thought control over athletes, parents, and church administrators is sick and sad.
Better to say the timing of these NCAA-allowed missions looks suspicious, even deceitful, in regard to new eligibility rules. That’s an accurate jab, regardless of proof. Should be enough for those needing excuses why their team is falling behind more than just PSU.
Trolling hiker’s take: You have too many exciting storylines (DeLuca, Crookham, Gabe at right weight, Ben at #1, healthy Angelo, etc.) to waste time on this. Drop it and enjoy the season. Best thing about becoming the underdog is that successes resonate more intensely. Hawks will have their share.
 
Hawkeye Report

Latest

  1. 01 On3 Football College Football Playoff Top 25: Third official 2026 CFP rankings revealed
  2. 02 Hawkeye Report Football Kirk Ferentz updates injuries, talks Fighting Illini
  3. 03 Hawkeye Report Football Hank Brown prepares to face Fighting Illini defense
  4. 04 Hawkeye Report Football Recruiting In-state athlete Paul Beswick receives opportunity from Iowa
  5. 05 Hawkeye Report Football Iose Epenesa hopes to follow in brother's footsteps at Illinois