College Football Playoff tiers: From locks to those who need to lobby
Published November 12, 2026 08:00 AM
Less than a month from now, the College Football Playoff selection committee will release its final rankings. We’ll know which 12 teams will make up the Playoff field, and we’ll surely hear from the teams that consider themselves snubbed.
In the meantime, we’ll argue, debate and dissect. We’ve now had two sets of in-season CFP rankings, so we have a decent idea of this committee’s approach to evaluating teams. That helps as we start to go through remaining schedules and pick winners in order to project the potential 12-team CFP bracket.
But...let’s save that for another day.
For this exercise, I’ve decided to put the sport’s top at-large teams in tiers.
Obviously, the champions of the SEC, Big Ten, ACC and Big 12 will all secure auto-bids, but we’ll label all the teams as at-large candidates for the process of this exercise (without assuming any bid thieves). I have been projecting Boise State as the top-ranked Group of 6 champion. The Broncos would make the 12-team field with an auto-bid.
Here’s a look at the top at-large teams heading into Week 11:
TIER I: NEAR LOCKS
Georgia
Probably the best team in the country. I do not understand how this team lost to Auburn, but I have been informed that very weird things happen in that rivalry. The committee loves the Dawgs, as do I. They’re well-positioned to land the overall No. 1 seed depending on how the rest of the regular season (and conference championship weekend) shakes out.
Utah
The Utes have been one of the biggest surprises of the season. It’s not that I didn’t expect Utah to be competitive in the Big 12 — I did, but I didn’t think they’d be a top contender to win the whole league — it’s the way this team has beaten its opponents. Blowing out most of ‘em. Beating Houston and then BYU in hard-fought, physical battles with a fun, creative offense led by the electric Devon Dampier and a defense that remains the calling card of the Utah football program. Morgan Scalley has done a phenomenal job in Year 1.
Alabama
The selection committee told us in its first set of CFP rankings that it believed the Crimson Tide are one of the very best teams in the country. Alabama went and backed that up in an impressive win at LSU. Considering the Tide are up to No. 3 in the current rankings despite two losses … this team is essentially in already.
UCLA
The Bruins are the last undefeated team in the Big Ten — just like we all predicted back in August! I thought Bob Chesney would have this program trending in the right direction, but even I couldn’t have imagined we’d be talking about an undefeated UCLA
football team sitting here in November. The Bruins have weathered a season-ending injury to their starting quarterback and won games in a variety of ways. They are No. 1 in FBS in Strength of Record (a metric that reflects the chance that an average Top 25 team would have team’s record or better, given the schedule it has faced). They remind me a lot of Indiana in 2024; they may not be a true national title contender right now, but they’re absolutely worthy of a CFP berth. It seems like the committee realized that this week, too.
Notre Dame
The Fighting Irish knew they needed to beat Miami to have a shot at making the CFP this year. And they did just that, catapulting them up to No. 5 and positioning them well with three games remaining on their schedule. The only question is whether Notre Dame could drop a game and still get in at 10-2 with one of the best wins in the country — I’d lean yes, because I don’t think this committee would drop ‘em more than six spots — but the safer move is just to win out and not have to worry about it. Leave no doubt, etc.
TIER II: WIN AND YOU’RE IN
Miami
The Hurricanes lost on the road to Notre Dame without their star receiver. The selection committee understands that, even if the rest of Miami’s schedule is a bit underwhelming. The same group of committee members viewed this team as worthy of the No. 1 ranking in their first set of rankings, so they obviously think highly of the Canes, even with a win over Wake Forest at home the highlight of their resume. Even after a six-spot drop, Miami should be totally fine, as long as it takes care of business down the stretch.
Indiana
The ninth-ranked Hoosiers are probably not very happy with the selection committee, especially after the group gave them credit for wins over teams with winning records a year ago and didn’t ding them too bad for their loss to Ohio State. Then, they got jumped by a bunch of teams that got quality wins, and Indiana dropped five spots. The good news is, if the Hoosiers just win out, they’re definitely in and likely much higher than No. 9. A win this weekend over USC would be their new best win (and first ranked win), plus whatever opportunity would come in the Big Ten championship game.
Texas
The Longhorns may have figured something out in the last couple of weeks, stringing three straight wins together in SEC play — which is no small feat in the league this year. Arch Manning hasn’t thrown any of those back-breaking fourth-quarter picks lately, and the defense has been its usual dominant self. Texas has weathered a number of injuries but seemingly stabilized itself and its season at the same time. If the Longhorns beat LSU in Death Valley this weekend, it’s smooth sailing from there.
Tennessee
I don’t know why the selection committee is ignoring the fact that Tennessee beat Alabama by 16 points in a football game less than a month ago. Maybe, if both teams continue to win out, the committee will put them close enough to one another in the rankings that they’ll have to be compared to each other, and the head-to-head result will come into play as a tiebreaker. (We can ask Notre Dame and Miami how that worked out.) But in the meantime, the committee is choosing to say it believes the Tide are significantly better than the Vols, which is … fine, I guess. Tennessee would also be fine if it just wins out. At the very least, it’d be in the same 8-seed-ish range it is now. At best, that head-to-head result would come into play and perhaps jump Tennessee up even higher.