KC and the Offensive game plan and calls

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
A bona fide KC complaint is that he calls games as if he always has the superior talent.

With the qb situation, no Duff and Carter potentially dinged up, will any modifications be made?

We need to get back to GS1 and early 2 (see Oh st game) where we tried different things, gave different looks, tried to trick the other side because of the talent differential. Since KC arrived that has all but stopped.

Time to run the ball often and throw in some trickery. Imagine an end around to Black??? We wasted completely that opportunity with Sheffield last year! Imagine him coming around and Raymond a possibility--D's would have to pause, but KC allowed FULL speed pursuit. Hopefully GS will mandate a change this week.

And if there was ever a time to start trying to block punts and run back kicks, this would be it.
 
Jan 10, 2026
803
711
93
5 yard out
Fly pattern
Same dive play to left or right

my defensive game plan meeting before playing Rutgers would be , team bowling event
Cover all Rutgers plays on 2 napkins while eating , head back to campus for weight training or treatment
 

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
8,810
4,932
66
A bona fide KC complaint is that he calls games as if he always has the superior talent.

With the qb situation, no Duff and Carter potentially dinged up, will any modifications be made?

We need to get back to GS1 and early 2 (see Oh st game) where we tried different things, gave different looks, tried to trick the other side because of the talent differential. Since KC arrived that has all but stopped.

Time to run the ball often and throw in some trickery. Imagine an end around to Black??? We wasted completely that opportunity with Sheffield last year! Imagine him coming around and Raymond a possibility--D's would have to pause, but KC allowed FULL speed pursuit. Hopefully GS will mandate a change this week.

And if there was ever a time to start trying to block punts and run back kicks, this would be it.
For the millionth time, it’s Schiano’s playbook. It’s his rules. He said so himself. Paraphrasing: we don’t try to trick people. We do what we do and it’s only about executing.

KC has absolutely no blame in this vanilla, predictable offense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU#1fan

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
For the millionth time, it’s Schiano’s playbook. It’s his rules. He said so himself. Paraphrasing: we don’t try to trick people. We do what we do and it’s only about executing.

KC has absolutely no blame in this vanilla, predictable offense.
You are in error hanging your hat on an off hand quote and not considering the actual facts. Look at the O before KC and after.

We get it you have an undying fixation on all things GS. It's really quite something to see the repetition day after day. Agree there is much to be unhappy about.

But if you don't see how much GS has deferred to KC you are willfully blinded by personal fixation. KC has had as much autonomy as any GS assistant ever. My take is that GS 2.0 has been too much deference and NOT enough micromanaging. (DID you see the Cigentti I get in at 5 and set all tones presser-is that a micromanaging problem---imagine some who dont like review of themselves will say so because they view micromanaging negatively. It's what you do with all that micro knowledge.

This is KC's baby and just look what he did at PSU and here-same. Same red zone issues, same general playcalling. Not all of us will let the personal animus get in the way of analysis. The facts are too clear. I hope KC is mandated to call it different this week, and not defer to him-and also in the future as his salary will likely not be eaten.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

B6510

Freshman
Jun 29, 2026
91
85
3
For the millionth time, it’s Schiano’s playbook. It’s his rules. He said so himself. Paraphrasing: we don’t try to trick people. We do what we do and it’s only about executing.

KC has absolutely no blame in this vanilla, predictable offense.
He’s paid 2 mil a year to be in charge of the offense. Agree it’s Schiano’s directive but still up to KC to make it work Motion and pocket movement aren't too risky. If he can’t get creative within the parameters given or can’t tell Schiano we need do this again at this team then he should quit and give back the $2 mil for a better coordinator.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,148
90,314
113
KC always looks uncomfortable, scared of his own shadow and/or like he just shat himself. Rarely see the guy smiling and at ease.
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
2 million and 30 plus years in and not at ease---Seems like he reached is MO and level years ago and has just been replicating it.

To repeat again the use or lack thereof of Sheffield last year was criminal--its the OC's job- if NEEDED -to convince the hc to use a weapon. I don't think he once tried to do that and is running his Minn PSU same game plan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScarletDave

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
8,810
4,932
66
You are in error hanging your hat on an off hand quote and not considering the actual facts. Look at the O before KC and after.

We get it you have an undying fixation on all things GS. It's really quite something to see the repetition day after day. Agree there is much to be unhappy about.

But if you don't see how much GS has deferred to KC you are willfully blinded by personal fixation. KC has had as much autonomy as any GS assistant ever. My take is that GS 2.0 has been too much deference and NOT enough micromanaging. (DID you see the Cigentti I get in at 5 and set all tones presser-is that a micromanaging problem---imagine some who dont like review of themselves will say so because they view micromanaging negatively. It's what you do with all that micro knowledge.

This is KC's baby and just look what he did at PSU and here-same. Same red zone issues, same general playcalling. Not all of us will let the personal animus get in the way of analysis. The facts are too clear. I hope KC is mandated to call it different this week, and not defer to him-and also in the future as his salary will likely not be eaten.
Nice try, but no. I’ll simplify: the team stinks. We agree on that. Schiano’s team. The team is 2-7. If what you say about it being KC’s offense and deferring to him were true, don’t you think Schiano would have him change the philosophy and make the offense more creative and less predictable?

Sean Gleeson’s offense was much more diverse. Schiano fired him. He broke the rules.

Your view makes no sense. Why wouldn’t Schiano change the offensive approach ? Only because it’s what he wants. Again, he sees it as an execution problem, not a strategy problem. He says it every week
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,707
151,547
113
KC runs the offense that Schiano dictates he run. Low risk, ball is the program offense. Punting is an acceptable outcome. We win the turnover battle we win that game.

Except that dumb philosophy has resulted in two blowouts and numerous loses.
 

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
You were almost there until this:

"Sean Gleeson’s offense was much more diverse. Schiano fired him. He broke the rules."

You evidently don't see the obvious contradiction and how it outs your whole MO.

You have repeatedly said everything is GS dictated all the time no questions asked. ON all topics this has been the response.

But now you admit the O pre KC was "much more diverse". Well who let it be diverse" for such a period of a body of work that one could see it was "much more diverse"? Thus, it is clear who's offense it was.

You have proven two points with your admission:
1 Just like it was Gleesons show, it is now KC's.
2 GS 2.0 has been too much deference and not enough micromanaging of coordinators.

An Gleeson was let go not because he was too diverse in his offense, but rather because his offense was not successful.

Hopefully this repeat mantra that GS controls all of KC and KC has no independent input can be put to bed finally. Put it with Justise Hairston is a fumbler and Townsend's missed catch would have won the wvu game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: redking

AdventureHasAName

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2022
1,991
2,113
113
I personally think we try to do too many things on offense. I'd love to see it be a lot less diverse. We don't have the personnel ($$$) to be even average at a couple different offensive styles. I'd welcome settling on one thing, acquiring talent for that single type of offense, and ditching all the other nonsense. If Schiano came out tomorrow and said, "Next year we are running the wishbone. And only the wishbone," I'd find it preferable to what we've had for the last 5 years. At least we'd know we can afford a top caliber wishbone quarterback.
 

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
8,810
4,932
66
You were almost there until this:

"Sean Gleeson’s offense was much more diverse. Schiano fired him. He broke the rules."

You evidently don't see the obvious contradiction and how it outs your whole MO.

You have repeatedly said everything is GS dictated all the time no questions asked. ON all topics this has been the response.

But now you admit the O pre KC was "much more diverse". Well who let it be diverse" for such a period of a body of work that one could see it was "much more diverse"? Thus, it is clear who's offense it was.

You have proven two points with your admission:
1 Just like it was Gleesons show, it is now KC's.
2 GS 2.0 has been too much deference and not enough micromanaging of coordinators.

An Gleeson was let go not because he was too diverse in his offense, but rather because his offense was not successful.

Hopefully this repeat mantra that GS controls all of KC and KC has no independent input can be put to bed finally. Put it with Justise Hairston is a fumbler and Townsend's missed catch would have won the wvu game.
Meant it was more diverse at OK St. obviously don’t know what they agreed on in the hiring but Schiano didn’t allow on game day so he fired him. He also fired Craig Ver Steeg during 1.0 when things were actually (briefly) going well and hired McNulty (i think).

Point is, GS is a micromanager like no other. Nothing happens without his ok. When a problem persists it’s because he wont change the rules.

If Schiano didn’t agree with KC’s vanilla and stale playcalling, obviously he would make sure KC changed it. Can’t be any more obvious that’s what any HC would do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU on Manns Planet

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,148
90,314
113
The title of this thread rhymes with KC and the Sunshine Band:

KC's meeting room with the position coaches:

 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

Ru-baby

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2001
6,872
3,363
66
Meant it was more diverse at OK St. obviously don’t know what they agreed on in the hiring but Schiano didn’t allow on game day so he fired him.//////////////////////

So now there's a whole new bundle of contortions.

The story is that you were somehow referring to Gleeson at Ok state and not RU in this discussion of RU offenses?

And both he and KC ran the same GS offense at RU?

But somehow GS hired him and had to fire him because he didn't allow the diverse offense? (even though he was running GS' vanilla offense he somehow had to fire him??? Doing what he wants but had to fire him because he as diverse at OK state--holy moly)

Putting aside actually watching games during Gleesons tenure and the games during KC's, why not just say you hate GS and facts are irrelevant and be done with it rather than trying to either create facts or disregard them to justify a preordained conclusion. It would not get caught up in the factual based fball analysis.

Lastly, always interesting to see those who complain about "micromanaging" as with very few exceptions it is a big tell.
 

mynameisdick

Sophomore
Jan 28, 2004
96
143
33
A bona fide KC complaint is that he calls games as if he always has the superior talent.

With the qb situation, no Duff and Carter potentially dinged up, will any modifications be made?

We need to get back to GS1 and early 2 (see Oh st game) where we tried different things, gave different looks, tried to trick the other side because of the talent differential. Since KC arrived that has all but stopped.

Time to run the ball often and throw in some trickery. Imagine an end around to Black??? We wasted completely that opportunity with Sheffield last year! Imagine him coming around and Raymond a possibility--D's would have to pause, but KC allowed FULL speed pursuit. Hopefully GS will mandate a change this week.

And if there was ever a time to start trying to block punts and run back kicks, this would be it.
We have many problems. Offensive playcalling is not one of them. The banged up line and suraces extremely limited ability to process the game are brutal to work around. They’ve chosen bombs and body blows. It’s gotten us some results.
 

AdventureHasAName

All-Conference
Mar 1, 2022
1,991
2,113
113
HUH???!!! Sniffing glue again??!! What offense have you been watching lol!!!
The one where we are running the ball well, and then once a drive, we decide to run fake-RPO with the QB keeping the ball (which is ALWAYS a four yard loss) FUBARing the drive. The next drive, we're running four WRs. The drive after that? Two TEs.

I would be thrilled to run an I-formation only and have 20 plays in the playbook.
 

AreYouNUTS

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
126,526
61,847
113
The one where we are running the ball well, and then once a drive, we decide to run fake-RPO with the QB keeping the ball (which is ALWAYS a four yard loss) FUBARing the drive. The next drive, we're running four WRs. The drive after that? Two TEs.

I would be thrilled to run an I-formation only and have 20 plays in the playbook.
Dude, we literally have one of the smallest playbooks in the entire nation. We are, no lie, dead last #138 when it comes to putting players in pre-snap motion. You can call 80% of our plays from the stands lol
 

Bueller

Senior
Nov 28, 2025
869
715
93


That Boise v Oklahoma games was one of the best I ever saw. The Statue of Liberty play was just one of the fancy plays. 22 points in final 86 seconds on creative plays. The game was from same season as Pandemonium in Piscataway. When I see Schiano all locked-up in his head over turnovers and "safety" I think of this Boise v Oklahoma game and Coach Peterson. That guy knew how to coach. He did a good interview about it

 
Last edited:

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
For the millionth time, it’s Schiano’s playbook. It’s his rules. He said so himself. Paraphrasing: we don’t try to trick people. We do what we do and it’s only about executing.

KC has absolutely no blame in this vanilla, predictable offense.
Yes and yes, 90%. It’s KC’s plays but built around a ‘no risk’ manifesto.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
You are in error hanging your hat on an off hand quote and not considering the actual facts. Look at the O before KC and after.

We get it you have an undying fixation on all things GS. It's really quite something to see the repetition day after day. Agree there is much to be unhappy about.

But if you don't see how much GS has deferred to KC you are willfully blinded by personal fixation. KC has had as much autonomy as any GS assistant ever. My take is that GS 2.0 has been too much deference and NOT enough micromanaging. (DID you see the Cigentti I get in at 5 and set all tones presser-is that a micromanaging problem---imagine some who dont like review of themselves will say so because they view micromanaging negatively. It's what you do with all that micro knowledge.

This is KC's baby and just look what he did at PSU and here-same. Same red zone issues, same general playcalling. Not all of us will let the personal animus get in the way of analysis. The facts are too clear. I hope KC is mandated to call it different this week, and not defer to him-and also in the future as his salary will likely not be eaten.
Yes, the head coach SHOULD control his program. There is no argument there but then this means that the outcomes are not 100% fault of the coordinators. This means that a bad head coach will often have poor results that often the coordinators get scape goated for. See Kirk 1.0 at Rutgers who was vilified but proved afterward that by no means was that mess in 2010 all his doing.

Somebody at Minny came up with a game plan that beat PSU by using 6 OL on something like 30% of the snaps. Now maybe it wasn’t KC but maybe it was. Do you know that it wasn’t?
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
He’s paid 2 mil a year to be in charge of the offense. Agree it’s Schiano’s directive but still up to KC to make it work Motion and pocket movement aren't too risky. If he can’t get creative within the parameters given or can’t tell Schiano we need do this again at this team then he should quit and give back the $2 mil for a better coordinator.
You have this backward I think. People don’t want to work for Schiano. Schiano had to court KC for a long time to get him to agree to come and had to over pay him to get him….the ‘Schiano tax’. Rutgers needed him more than he needed Rutgers.

KC is an older guy and I’m sure told Greg that he’ll do what Greg wants him to do at this salary level and is beyond the point in his career where he feels like battling. Remember that Schiano already scape goated KC after the 2010 season…..gee, and I wonder why we had to over pay him the second time!
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
Nice try, but no. I’ll simplify: the team stinks. We agree on that. Schiano’s team. The team is 2-7. If what you say about it being KC’s offense and deferring to him were true, don’t you think Schiano would have him change the philosophy and make the offense more creative and less predictable?

Sean Gleeson’s offense was much more diverse. Schiano fired him. He broke the rules.

Your view makes no sense. Why wouldn’t Schiano change the offensive approach ? Only because it’s what he wants. Again, he sees it as an execution problem, not a strategy problem. He says it every week
Scapegoating KC 1.0 who has a terribly weak roster to work with in 2010.

Screaming at SG during a game and firing him mid season.

Hmmm, and we wonder why we have to over pay for coaches?
 

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
7,836
9,074
113
You have this backward I think. People don’t want to work for Schiano. Schiano had to court KC for a long time to get him to agree to come and had to over pay him to get him….the ‘Schiano tax’. Rutgers needed him more than he needed Rutgers.

KC is an older guy and I’m sure told Greg that he’ll do what Greg wants him to do at this salary level and is beyond the point in his career where he feels like battling. Remember that Schiano already scape goated KC after the 2010 season…..gee, and I wonder why we had to over pay him the second time!
Exactly how it happened. Rumor was Schiano upped the salary 3 separate times to get Kirk to the banks. All while getting denied by multiple other OC candidates in the process.
 

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
You were almost there until this:

"Sean Gleeson’s offense was much more diverse. Schiano fired him. He broke the rules."

You evidently don't see the obvious contradiction and how it outs your whole MO.

You have repeatedly said everything is GS dictated all the time no questions asked. ON all topics this has been the response.

But now you admit the O pre KC was "much more diverse". Well who let it be diverse" for such a period of a body of work that one could see it was "much more diverse"? Thus, it is clear who's offense it was.

You have proven two points with your admission:
1 Just like it was Gleesons show, it is now KC's.
2 GS 2.0 has been too much deference and not enough micromanaging of coordinators.

An Gleeson was let go not because he was too diverse in his offense, but rather because his offense was not successful.

Hopefully this repeat mantra that GS controls all of KC and KC has no independent input can be put to bed finally. Put it with Justise Hairston is a fumbler and Townsend's missed catch would have won the wvu game.
He fired KC 1.0 and, paraphrasing, said that we tried to go to an offense we didn’t fully understand and needed to revert back. In other words, he wasn’t comfortable with the spread offense after trying it.

He tried AGAIN to do something more dynamic with Gleason but could not deal with this more diverse offensive style and IRONICALLY went back to the last guy he fired who nowadays runs something closer to what Schiano is comfortable with.

Both KC and SG would go on to have better success elsewhere. SG’s offense is averaging 31 PPG and 415 yards per game this year at K State. THEY are not the problems. The common theme is Schiano associated with the failures, not the OCs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wagram97

RU on Manns Planet

All-Conference
Mar 23, 2025
3,678
4,041
108
You were almost there until this:

"Sean Gleeson’s offense was much more diverse. Schiano fired him. He broke the rules."

You evidently don't see the obvious contradiction and how it outs your whole MO.

You have repeatedly said everything is GS dictated all the time no questions asked. ON all topics this has been the response.

But now you admit the O pre KC was "much more diverse". Well who let it be diverse" for such a period of a body of work that one could see it was "much more diverse"? Thus, it is clear who's offense it was.

You have proven two points with your admission:
1 Just like it was Gleesons show, it is now KC's.
2 GS 2.0 has been too much deference and not enough micromanaging of coordinators.

An Gleeson was let go not because he was too diverse in his offense, but rather because his offense was not successful.

Hopefully this repeat mantra that GS controls all of KC and KC has no independent input can be put to bed finally. Put it with Justise Hairston is a fumbler and Townsend's missed catch would have won the wvu game.
He fired KC 1.0 and, paraphrasing, said that we tried to go to an offense we didn’t fully understand and needed to revert back. In other words, he wasn’t comfortable with the spread offense.

He tried AGAIN to deviate with Gleason and could not

Both KC ans SG would go on to have better success elsewhere.

The common theme is Schiano and Rutgers associated with the failures, not the OCs.
Dude, we literally have one of the smallest playbooks in the entire nation. We are, no lie, dead last #138 when it comes to putting players in pre-snap motion. You can call 80% of our plays from the stands lol
There is no scenario on earth where Schiano hasn’t influenced this. None.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AreYouNUTS
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report The Knight Report - Ask The Experts Chat: November 18th Edition
  2. 02 The Knight Report Wrestling Rutgers Wrestlers in the latest InterMat Rankings - Week Three
  3. 03 The Knight Report Basketball How to watch Rutgers / Notre Dame; Pregame Info, More: Gameday Central
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's Houston Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball falls to No. 8 Houston in Players Era 8 opener