Fc 25 greatest college football coaches of all timr

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
9,183
4,797
113
JMO
Cignetti shouldn't be ranked yet
Smart's too low
Bo and Holtz being ranked is crazy IMO
I get Eddie Robinson but it wasn't at the highest level
Urban's too low
Joe was better than Switzer and Bowden
They got 1-2 right though--kudos for that--I don't see a valid argument against either
 

Blair10

All-Conference
Dec 30, 2002
2,164
4,610
113
Whoever wrote this article clearly did not study their history.

How in the world can a top 25 list be compiled without the legendary Hall of Famer Bob Devaney who coached the powerful Nebraska Cornhuskers to dominance in the early 1970s.

This omission means the authors have no credibility.
 

psuro

Heisman
Aug 24, 2001
9,923
21,800
113
Legacy is a messy concept with so many legendary college football figures, perhaps none more so than Paterno. He was fired midway through the 2011 season at the age of 84, in connection to the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal that played out within the Penn State community, after a report conducted by former FBI director Louis Freeh determined that Paterno was among the prominent school officials who “failed to protect against a child sexual predator harming children for over a decade.”

And this is why Joe is not ranked any higher.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUFBFAN and Bob78

razpsu

Heisman
Jan 13, 2004
14,973
15,466
113
Legacy is a messy concept with so many legendary college football figures, perhaps none more so than Paterno. He was fired midway through the 2011 season at the age of 84, in connection to the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal that played out within the Penn State community, after a report conducted by former FBI director Louis Freeh determined that Paterno was among the prominent school officials who “failed to protect against a child sexual predator harming children for over a decade.”

And this is why Joe is not ranked any higher.
And that quote is complete bs.
 

razpsu

Heisman
Jan 13, 2004
14,973
15,466
113
Joe at 12 is about right. His low number of conference and national titles through 46 years of coaching is why he is not any higher.
Now I know you are a troll. Played for 4 national championships, had 4 other undefeated seasons and then when they did join big he had 3 conf titles and possibly a 4th in his last year. Most bowl wins in history, was the only coach to win all major bowls, oh and holds the record for most wins ever.

but you keep being you.
 
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
Now I know you are a troll. Played for 4 national championships, had 4 other undefeated seasons and then when they did join big he had 3 conf titles and possibly a 4th in his last year. Most bowl wins in history, was the only coach to win all major bowls, oh and holds the record for most wins ever.

but you keep being you.
His numbers don't even put him in the top 5. Switzer had more success in a third of the time. Two natties in 46 years is not impressive when compared to others.
 

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,048
21,605
113
Saban's average recruiting class ranking over 16 years was 1.6 (including 13 #1 classes). Best in the country by a mile.

Derrick Henry as a senior in HS....

 
  • Like
Reactions: LMTLION

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
16,854
23,139
113
Saban's average recruiting class ranking over 16 years was 1.6 (including 13 #1 classes). Best in the country by a mile.

Derrick Henry as a senior in HS....

Not a level playing field. And maybe this is the wrong way to look at things but if we’re gonna say Coach X was the best CFB coach ever one would expect that those skills would translate to the NFL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_PSUALREADYKNOW
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
You do realize PSU was an independent when Joe was in his prime, right?
Of course I do. He and Switzer coached the same number of years as members of a conference. Joe's success for that period is rather lackluster when comparing the numbers between the 2. This list uses numbers for comparison and Joe falls way short.

Titles have significant meaning. Joe has much fewer than most on the list. That is why 12th on the list is about right, although it might be a bit high.
 
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
Not a level playing field. And maybe this is the wrong way to look at things but if we’re gonna say Coach X was the best CFB coach ever one would expect that those skills would translate to the NFL.
Nice try but no. Look at the title - it says "College". Not a level playing field? LOL
 

razpsu

Heisman
Jan 13, 2004
14,973
15,466
113
His numbers don't even put him in the top 5. Switzer had more success in a third of the time. Two natties in 46 years is not impressive when compared to others.
That is because Paterno was cignetti. Only he didn’t have the playoff to prove himself. So Penn state was put on the back burner because people considered eastern football a joke. So what did Joe do, became ad and made the toughest schedule in football. Only team to win a natty with the number 1 ranked schedule. Then in 1994, new to the big. Everyone in big country “voted”, couldn’t play it on the field, against the newcomer to the big. What is ironic is that the big was irrelevant for 25 years before psu came in
 

JerseyLion

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2001
1,185
2,348
113
Of course I do. He and Switzer coached the same number of years as members of a conference. Joe's success for that period is rather lackluster when comparing the numbers between the 2. This list uses numbers for comparison and Joe falls way short.

Titles have significant meaning. Joe has much fewer than most on the list. That is why 12th on the list is about right, although it might be a bit high.
If I am following your logic, we can only measure Joe's success during his tenure in the Big 10? OK, Barry imposter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_PSUALREADYKNOW
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
If I am following your logic, we can only measure Joe's success during his tenure in the Big 10? OK, Barry imposter.
Not what I said.

Look at the bottom line numbers and it is obvious he doesn't have the success necessary to be ranked any higher. He had the same number of years in a conference as Switzer with much less success. Low number of titles there.

Then look at natties. He had 2 in 46 years. Being close does not count. Low number of titles there.

Joe was a good coach and won the most games over his 46 year career. That isn't the only criteria.

I didn't make the list but for the most part I agree with it. It reflects what people think that aren't drinking the PSU koolaid.
 

slwlion

Junior
Oct 14, 2021
141
219
42
Legacy is a messy concept with so many legendary college football figures, perhaps none more so than Paterno. He was fired midway through the 2011 season at the age of 84, in connection to the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal that played out within the Penn State community, after a report conducted by former FBI director Louis Freeh determined that Paterno was among the prominent school officials who “failed to protect against a child sexual predator harming children for over a decade.”

And this is why Joe is not ranked any higher.
Amen !
 
May 11, 2016
448
262
63
Yeah, He just beat them all in Bowl games.
I seem to remember a couple of Sugar bowls where this was not the case. He never beat the Bear.

You should be pleased he is #12 on the list. His ranking will continue to fall in the future as coaches like Smart and Cig continue to improve their numbers.
 

slwlion

Junior
Oct 14, 2021
141
219
42
I seem to remember a couple of Sugar bowls where this was not the case. He never beat the Bear.

You should be pleased he is #12 on the list. His ranking will continue to fall in the future as coaches like Smart and Cig continue to improve their numbers.
Can't argue that. Still it's cherry picking.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Wrestling Penn State wrestling beats Oklahoma 41-0 to earn its first shut out of the year: Recap
  2. 02 BWI Basketball Penn State basketball cruises past New Haven behind complete effort
  3. 03 Rivals Football Recruiting Penn State offer puts Nittany Lions in strong position with DB Carlos Gordon
  4. 04 BWI Football Penn State notebook: Carson Hansen’s big night, Alex Manske’s opportunity and more
  5. 05 BWI Wrestling How to watch, follow, Penn State wrestling at Oklahoma on Sunday: New start time and streaming info, probable lineups, more