All State Teams

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
Looking at the IHSFCA All State Teams, its the same nonsense as years past. Just glancing at 7A, there a 8 QBs listed between 1st team and Honorable Mention, but only 2 OL listed. Someone please make this make sense to me. How can you call it an all state "team" and have unequal representation like that? You'd think the members of the IHSFCA would have more common sense than this. What a joke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jha618

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
Could be wrong, but I think coaches have to nominate kids for all state teams and then it gets decided by the IHSFCA. So if coaches aren't nominating their OL then that's on them not IHSFCA.

Some coaches don't care and don't bother to nominate anyone, others nominate everyone, and some take it seriously.
 

K58W

Redshirt
Nov 25, 2025
55
30
18
That’s how I’ve always understood it too.

Would like to see how these QB’s play with a line that doesn’t care about them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OnVikings!

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
Could be wrong, but I think coaches have to nominate kids for all state teams and then it gets decided by the IHSFCA. So if coaches aren't nominating their OL then that's on them not IHSFCA.

Some coaches don't care and don't bother to nominate anyone, others nominate everyone, and some take it seriously.
I get it. I would just think that the IHSFCA could come up with a system that makes more sense than this.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: McCaravan

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
5,594
8,726
113
I think since Jordan Lynch had taken over at MC maybe 3 MC players have made this list. Now since occasionally an MC player pops up, like Roman Igwebuike this year, I know someone at MC is nominating players but who exactly selects them is unknown to me. How Marshaun Thorton isn't an All State WR is beyond me.
 
Last edited:

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
I get it. I would just think that the IHSFCA could come up with a system for that makes more sense than this.
Like what? It's not like the IHSFCA has the resources to see countless players and make accurate analysis to determine all state teams so they have to rely on coaches and some don't care at all and most don't take it seriously. So what's your solution?

I equate being selected all state to making the pro bowl, it's nice, but when you look into how it's determined there's very little effort behind it.
 

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
Like what? It's not like the IHSFCA has the resources to see countless players and make accurate analysis to determine all state teams so they have to rely on coaches and some don't care at all and most don't take it seriously. So what's your solution?

I equate being selected all state to making the pro bowl, it's nice, but when you look into how it's determined there's very little effort behind it.
I dunno... maybe have 22 pre determined position slots that you nominate players for that represent an actual football "team"? 25 if you include a K, P, and LS. That took me 30 seconds to come up with so I would think the IHSFCA could do better than me. Last I checked, even the pro bowl teams dont have 8 QBs and 2 OL.
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,199
4,599
113
I dunno... maybe have 22 pre determined position slots that you nominate players for that represent an actual football "team"? 25 if you include a K, P, and LS. That took me 30 seconds to come up with so I would think the IHSFCA could do better than me. Last I checked, even the pro bowl teams dont have 8 QBs and 2 OL.
For all we know that could exist now but coaches would still be responsible for nominating kids at those positions.
 

OnVikings!

Senior
Nov 15, 2024
364
562
87
For all we know that could exist now but coaches would still be responsible for nominating kids at those positions.
I would assume if there were 10 OL spots to be filled in 7A (5 first team, 5 HM) that more that 2 OL would have been nominated across all of 7A. So no, this system, or something similar, does not exist now.

Don’t call it an all state team if it’s nothing more that a statistic/popularity contest that relies on a coach’s willingness to nominate players. 8 QBs in comparison to 2 OL is laughable.
 

McCaravan

All-American
Feb 1, 2016
5,594
8,726
113
I like MOB's All State and POY selections in the Sun Times. I know it's only Chicagoland (for now) but at least it's off his knowledge of the players (I believe).
 
  • Like
Reactions: OnVikings!
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football Watch Live Tonight: WJOL Pigskin Preview
  2. 02 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 8A
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 7A
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 6A
  5. 05 Edgy Tim Football Video: EDGY Thoughts on Class 5A