PSU QB Portal Options & $$$ to Spend

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
The quarterback market looks pretty damn pricey. I haven't seen this guy play, but he is making some serious bank.

Goodness gracious, it just gets worse and worse. That is a quarter of our total “payroll” allegedly, and we have too many needs elsewhere on the roster. If I’m Campbell, I bring a couple QBs with potential to compete with Manske and avoid the elite qb market.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catch1lion

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
Goodness gracious, it just gets worse and worse. That is a quarter of our total “payroll” allegedly, and we have too many needs elsewhere on the roster. If I’m Campbell, I bring a couple QBs with potential to compete with Manske and avoid the elite qb market.
Psu might as well start looking g for a new head coach. Campbell is not the guy.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: psu83

WVilleLion

All-Conference
Oct 13, 2021
812
1,147
93
who really gives a damn anymore? $7.5M for a QB at Miss St. 24 team playoff when about 12-16 teams, if not more, don’t belong. Surprised some of you still actually get worked up over a loss.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
Goodness gracious, it just gets worse and worse. That is a quarter of our total “payroll” allegedly, and we have too many needs elsewhere on the roster. If I’m Campbell, I bring a couple QBs with potential to compete with Manske and avoid the elite qb market.
We have to find the money. All the top teams have an excellent or very good QB. Look at OSU, lose their starter and they become imminently beatable. Doesn't matter if they have NFL receivers including the #1 pick or talent all over the field. You need the trigger man to make it all happen.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
We have to find the money. All the top teams have an excellent or very good QB. Look at OSU, lose their starter and they become imminently beatable. Doesn't matter if they have NFL receivers including the #1 pick or talent all over the field. You need the trigger man to make it all happen.
Absolutely, the QB is the most important position on the field, particularly if you want to win at all. You could make the argument that OSU neglected other areas of the roster, though. While it’s true they collapsed after the QB went down, they had issues before he went down, including a disappointing run game and some defensive issues as well. We’re obviously not going to win at all next year regardless who the QB is and we have a stud QB coming in the 2028 class. If I am Campbell, I’m building up the rest of the roster with depth and finding a good enough affordable QB to make us respectable in 2027 and 2028 so have the resources to build the program up to a 2029-2030 run. But who knows, it’s all speculation. Like you said, we do need to find more money. Not sure Krafty the clown is up for the challenge.
 

Rocco3

Junior
Mar 25, 2022
324
350
63
I realize we haven't seen much of Manske but what if he is really good.
I don't get just writing him off as some has done. The fact is we know more about his illness and operation than we have seen him on the field. We literally know little to nothing about his ability. He may be great we just don't know. Why he hasn't played may have more to do with not risking injury ahead of next year and allowing him to grow and learn than anything else given there is absolutely no one behind him.
 

Rocco3

Junior
Mar 25, 2022
324
350
63
You did not, Koby is not leaving. I would be absolutely shocked based on everything you hear about him. They are being very cautious bringing him back from whatever unknown injury he has.
IMO he's not ready to return and we may not see him until a bowl game. I don't see him leaving. In a way where NIL and potential theft of our best WR might be concerned it's better that he's not making a rep in Big 10 play and his NIL worth sky rockets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LMTLION

Steve JG

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2024
1,247
2,051
113
What are the projections for potential high end QBs that will be available in the portal?

I Iistened to Tengwall over the weekend and he thinks we need to get a bonafide starter at QB in the portal. He is concerned that Campbell will not want to guarantee the guy will be the starter in '27 and therefore no one of high quality will want that kind of situation. I hope that doesn't happen. We need to just make a decision that we need to start our roster overhaul with a top flight QB. We need to open up the wallet and pay about $4 million for a proven QB.

Manske is not our answer. Campbell has to know that if we are going to go from where we are now to a playoff team next year we need a really good QB, a trigger man for the offense who can win big games for us.

Grunk seems to be the one mentioned a lot. $4 million to get him maybe more. Is he worth it? Does he even want to come here?

Who else may come available?
Fickell had interesting and cogent take on QB situation in college football now, he said current appearance of parity is that QBs have sought opportunities to start. Basically any good, legit back up QB looking to be starter will portal cough, cough ahemanske cough and not stick around and wait their turn. Money and opportunity its trumps college/ team loyalty. So many teams have a starter but not much in way back up as a result.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
Absolutely, the QB is the most important position on the field, particularly if you want to win at all. You could make the argument that OSU neglected other areas of the roster, though. While it’s true they collapsed after the QB went down, they had issues before he went down, including a disappointing run game and some defensive issues as well. We’re obviously not going to win at all next year regardless who the QB is and we have a stud QB coming in the 2028 class. If I am Campbell, I’m building up the rest of the roster with depth and finding a good enough affordable QB to make us respectable in 2027 and 2028 so have the resources to build the program up to a 2029-2030 run. But who knows, it’s all speculation. Like you said, we do need to find more money. Not sure Krafty the clown is up for the challenge.
Is Campbell and his 2* gm up to the challenge?
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
Absolutely, the QB is the most important position on the field, particularly if you want to win at all. You could make the argument that OSU neglected other areas of the roster, though. While it’s true they collapsed after the QB went down, they had issues before he went down, including a disappointing run game and some defensive issues as well. We’re obviously not going to win at all next year regardless who the QB is and we have a stud QB coming in the 2028 class. If I am Campbell, I’m building up the rest of the roster with depth and finding a good enough affordable QB to make us respectable in 2027 and 2028 so have the resources to build the program up to a 2029-2030 run. But who knows, it’s all speculation. Like you said, we do need to find more money. Not sure Krafty the clown is up for the challenge.
Who was the most important player to Michigan when they won?
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
Fickell had interesting and cogent take on QB situation in college football now, he said current appearance of parity is that QBs have sought opportunities to start. Basically any good, legit back up QB looking to be starter will portal cough, cough ahemanske cough and not stick around and wait their turn. Money and opportunity its trumps college/ team loyalty. So many teams have a starter but not much in way back up as a result.
The number of qbs is about the same and the number of teams is about the same.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
Fair point, it is professional football. The ridiculous thing is with these escalating pay for play salaries, many of these guys who won't make an NFL roster will have banked $3 million, or $4 million or $5 million by the time they are 22 or 23. Nice way to get started in their life's work. Hopefully they don't blow it.

This is a self-destructive model - you really believe that all these Universities are going to continue to pay these types of sums to mercenaries that have nothing to do with their universities - merely wearing jerseys with the Universities' names on them like insanely expensive advertising? What exactly are the Universities gaining from all this ridiculousness???
 

Nits1989

All-Conference
Oct 29, 2021
1,490
2,129
113
There's going to have to be a cap on it, kind of like the NFL. It won't be able to continue functioning without one. It seems like its breaking down already. Ohio State is a good example. A couple years ago, they seemed unbeatable. Not anymore.
 

o_PSUALREADYKNOW

Sophomore
Mar 9, 2022
159
194
43
There's going to have to be a cap on it, kind of like the NFL. It won't be able to continue functioning without one. It seems like its breaking down already. Ohio State is a good example. A couple years ago, they seemed unbeatable. Not anymore.
You’re going to see a lot of parody and more difficulty remaining consistently dominant. Between capable players being poached, talented players being poached, and money being used to recruit talent-you’ll see teams like Northwestern, Indiana, UCLA, etc be competitive because they paid to bring in talented players. Traditional schools that had recruiting pedigree will lose that to an extent. You could spend $100 mill and their theoretically turn an Ivy League school into a championship contender. And that’s a really big problem for fans and programs. Because let’s face it-we don’t care about seeing a plethora of good football-we care about seeing our program win. And that’s going to happen less for everybody in time. If it is happening to OSU, it will happen to everyone. I mean heck-we wouldn’t score a point if Becht got injured. We don’t even have a back up.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
You’re going to see a lot of parody and more difficulty remaining consistently dominant. Between capable players being poached, talented players being poached, and money being used to recruit talent-you’ll see teams like Northwestern, Indiana, UCLA, etc be competitive because they paid to bring in talented players. Traditional schools that had recruiting pedigree will lose that to an extent. You could spend $100 mill and their theoretically turn an Ivy League school into a championship contender. And that’s a really big problem for fans and programs. Because let’s face it-we don’t care about seeing a plethora of good football-we care about seeing our program win. And that’s going to happen less for everybody in time. If it is happening to OSU, it will happen to everyone. I mean heck-we wouldn’t score a point if Becht got injured. We don’t even have a back up.
I agree to an extent, but I also believe that if the best teams are 9-3, there is more fanbase interest for the midlevel teams that are still in it much deeper into the season.
 

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
This is a self-destructive model - you really believe that all these Universities are going to continue to pay these types of sums to mercenaries that have nothing to do with their universities - merely wearing jerseys with the Universities' names on them like insanely expensive advertising? What exactly are the Universities gaining from all this ridiculousness???

You’re going to see a lot of parody and more difficulty remaining consistently dominant. Between capable players being poached, talented players being poached, and money being used to recruit talent-you’ll see teams like Northwestern, Indiana, UCLA, etc be competitive because they paid to bring in talented players. Traditional schools that had recruiting pedigree will lose that to an extent. You could spend $100 mill and their theoretically turn an Ivy League school into a championship contender. And that’s a really big problem for fans and programs. Because let’s face it-we don’t care about seeing a plethora of good football-we care about seeing our program win. And that’s going to happen less for everybody in time. If it is happening to OSU, it will happen to everyone. I mean heck-we wouldn’t score a point if Becht got injured. We don’t even have a back up.

There is a huge (and bad) assumption intrinsic to your post.... - namely that the Non-Revenue Sharing Portion of these "$100 million" roster payments will remain "unregulated" by the NCAA and the CSC (the College Sports Commission). This is a very bad assumption given the pending Federal Legislation regarding this matter (and it is the Federal Government that regulates and makes the laws regarding "Interstate Commerce" and Prollegiate Football definitely falls within the "Interstate Commerce" authority. The pending legislation specifies what qualifies for the Non-Revenue Sharing portion at the CSC and if payments are not qualified (or ruled unqualified by the CSC) the athletes receiving the $$$ will be ineligible. Additionally, Universities are not permitted to have any control over (or anything to do with) the Non-Revenue Sharing Portion of NIL payments.
 

op2

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
12,260
2,081
103
Fair point, it is professional football. The ridiculous thing is with these escalating pay for play salaries, many of these guys who won't make an NFL roster will have banked $3 million, or $4 million or $5 million by the time they are 22 or 23. Nice way to get started in their life's work. Hopefully they don't blow it.
I think the time is coming when there’s a backlash and people start saying, why are our universities, whose purpose is supposedly to educate the public, running pro sports franchises?

Is this legal? Can universities run any kind of business or any kind of organized activity so long as it is under the guise of a nonprofit, and the people performing the activity are technically college students at the university?

Pick any activity or business you see outside of a university. And then imagine a university running it except that the people involved are technically college students. Is that okay?
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_PSUALREADYKNOW

Bosco2

Sophomore
Jul 27, 2026
78
125
33
I think the time is coming when there’s a backlash and people start saying, why are our universities, whose purpose is supposedly to educate the public, running pro sports franchises?

Is this legal? Can universities run any kind of business or any kind of organized activity so long as it is under the guise of a nonprofit, and the people performing the activity are technically college students at the university?

Pick any activity or business you see outside of a university. And then imagine a university running it except that the people involved are technically college students. Is that okay?
Apparently they can do all these things as long as one activist judge says so.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

op2

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
12,260
2,081
103
Fair point, it is professional football. The ridiculous thing is with these escalating pay for play salaries, many of these guys who won't make an NFL roster will have banked $3 million, or $4 million or $5 million by the time they are 22 or 23. Nice way to get started in their life's work. Hopefully they don't blow it.
Considering that the number of players that end up making good money in the NFL is much smaller than the number making good money in college, what we’ll see is people making enough money to last them for life, if they’re wise by playing college football and then not playing in the pros at all. Of course, one cavaet is that young men age 18 to 22 typically aren’t very wise With money.

Also, consider if you’re a good young athlete and also intellectually inclined. In the past, you were incentivized to take both football and school, seriously. But now, unless you think you’re good enough to make the NFL, you are incentivized to slack on your school and put all your effort into football because that’s where the money lies. And then after your college football career is over and there’s no NFL you’re going to, then you can go to college for real with plenty of money to buyan education if you like. That’s what the incentives are.

Lastly, at some point, the public is going to say, these guys are making all this money playing football at a public university, which is on my land and using my resources. Where is my cut?
 
  • Like
Reactions: o_PSUALREADYKNOW

psu0408

All-Conference
Oct 28, 2004
501
1,309
83
At some point, the NFL will be impacted by poor player development. Good college QBs who bounce around to 2-4 schools chasing money don’t get the development they need to become immediate contributors in the NFL. Economically, unless you’re getting a first or second round grade, you’re better off making $3m plus in college than declaring early.
 

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
543
929
93
I think the time is coming when there’s a backlash and people start saying, why are our universities, whose purpose is supposedly to educate the public, running pro sports franchises?

Is this legal? Can universities run any kind of business or any kind of organized activity so long as it is under the guise of a nonprofit, and the people performing the activity are technically college students at the university?

Pick any activity or business you see outside of a university. And then imagine a university running it except that the people involved are technically college students. Is that okay?
Like the creamery?
 
  • Like
Reactions: barry j fenchak

KC-KS-Lion

Freshman
Oct 10, 2005
1,945
66
48
I think the time is coming when there’s a backlash and people start saying, why are our universities, whose purpose is supposedly to educate the public, running pro sports franchises?

Is this legal? Can universities run any kind of business or any kind of organized activity so long as it is under the guise of a nonprofit, and the people performing the activity are technically college students at the university?

Pick any activity or business you see outside of a university. And then imagine a university running it except that the people involved are technically college students. Is that okay?
I think what you will see with QBs not projected as top-tier NFL prospect either because of their measurables or performance, is to stay as long as possible in college to max out NIL dollars...I'm looking at last year's Vandy QB, as well as this year's Utah and Arizona QBs...the injured Miss State QB may also be in this catagory.

My understanding is the pending congressional regulation may limit the number of moves, which I think makes sense, one and a conditional second (for cases like a change of coaching staff) make sense to me.
 

o_PSUALREADYKNOW

Sophomore
Mar 9, 2022
159
194
43
At some point, the NFL will be impacted by poor player development. Good college QBs who bounce around to 2-4 schools chasing money don’t get the development they need to become immediate contributors in the NFL. Economically, unless you’re getting a first or second round grade, you’re better off making $3m plus in college than declaring early.
I think we’re already seeing that with the QB play overall in NFL? Maybe someone who in more of an expert can talk on this aspect.
 

WVilleLion

All-Conference
Oct 13, 2021
812
1,147
93
MSST should tell that QB no thanks. Not that great and unless they are going to buy him the other pieces he needs they are going to be mid at best next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bison13

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
We have to find the money. All the top teams have an excellent or very good QB. Look at OSU, lose their starter and they become imminently beatable. Doesn't matter if they have NFL receivers including the #1 pick or talent all over the field. You need the trigger man to make it all happen.

We don't have the money and we won't have it.


Need tofind the right system.

Who was the best player on michigan when they won? It wasn't the qb. It was the RB!!

PSU struggles to recruit /develop qbs and wrs. Ironic since the masses then have a plan to build around a qb.


Psu usually has very good rbs and TEs. Build around a RB.
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
Absolutely, the QB is the most important position on the field, particularly if you want to win at all. You could make the argument that OSU neglected other areas of the roster, though. While it’s true they collapsed after the QB went down, they had issues before he went down, including a disappointing run game and some defensive issues as well. We’re obviously not going to win at all next year regardless who the QB is and we have a stud QB coming in the 2028 class. If I am Campbell, I’m building up the rest of the roster with depth and finding a good enough affordable QB to make us respectable in 2027 and 2028 so have the resources to build the program up to a 2029-2030 run. But who knows, it’s all speculation. Like you said, we do need to find more money. Not sure Krafty the clown is up for the challenge.
Who was Michigan's most important player when they won?
 

rigi19041

Junior
Apr 1, 2026
543
274
63
I did a search of top qbs that might hit the portal. Marcus stokes name comes up. SI suggests osu should go after him.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph