Beamer vs Spurrier: first 72 games

Anon1742573506

Sophomore
Mar 21, 2025
132
101
28
No buts, its simply a fact.

Beamer compares favorably to Spurrier's worst years.
Not counting that last one. Seems a little unfair, the constant comparisons to Spurrier who is probably the best coach we will ever have. Are all NFL QBs compared to Brady? All scientists compared to Einstein? All linebackers compared to LT? If you're not the best ever then you're garbage. Ricky Bobby mentality.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Not counting that last one. Seems a little unfair, the constant comparisons to Spurrier who is probably the best coach we will ever have. Are all NFL QBs compared to Brady? All scientists compared to Einstein? All linebackers compared to LT? If you're not the best ever then you're garbage. Ricky Bobby mentality.

I think the opposite. Spurrier is one of the greatest all time coaches.

He also spent his first 5 or so years here floundering. It was either year 6 or 7 where he went to 9 wins, then 3 straight 11 wins.

The idea of this comparison is the same as when we made it with Muschamp and Spurrier. Compare them to Spurrier's worst run in his career, and we can make a good sounding posts about how Muschamp/Beamer are really closer to Spurrier's level than you'd think.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
I think the opposite. Spurrier is one of the greatest all time coaches.

He also spent his first 5 or so years here floundering. It was either year 6 or 7 where he went to 9 wins, then 3 straight 11 wins.

The idea of this comparison is the same as when we made it with Muschamp and Spurrier. Compare them to Spurrier's worst run in his career, and we can make a good sounding posts about how Muschamp/Beamer are really closer to Spurrier's level than you'd think.
I just think fans look at Spurrier only through the lens of those three 11 win seasons as if that is representative of his time here. He had more mediocre seasons than good seasons. Somehow fans only want to define him by those seasons and disregard the others as outliers when really the 11 win seasons were the outliers.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I just think fans look at Spurrier only through the lens of those three 11 win seasons as if that is representative of his time here. He had more mediocre seasons than good seasons. Somehow fans only want to define him by those seasons and disregard the others as outliers when really the 11 win seasons were the outliers.

Agree completely. What i usually assume is that when people make this comparison, rhey are going for something different. I usually think they are trying to fool people into thinking Muschamp/Beamer records are really close to Spurrier, who had that awesome run (and nevermind that the comparison doesn't include the good run years).

Its been used before to make people think those two are doing better than they really are. JMO
 

sclawman77

All-Conference
Jun 27, 2011
1,926
1,744
113
I just think fans look at Spurrier only through the lens of those three 11 win seasons as if that is representative of his time here. He had more mediocre seasons than good seasons. Somehow fans only want to define him by those seasons and disregard the others as outliers when really the 11 win seasons were the outliers.
Shane has done a solid job turning things around this season. No one can deny that. The numbers are comparable. But on the flip side you can't dismiss Spurrier's three consecutive 11 win seasons if you are going to compare another Carolina coach-and Shane has come nowhere close to that upper tier consistency over even consecutive seasons. He will get an opportunity though. And for people who say it's a different era, NIL, etc, then don't start comparing to Spurrier in the first place.
 

Deathstar

Senior
Sep 6, 2026
758
576
93
Spurrier coming out of retirement to take on the biggest coaching challenge in the world, and he turned it around until he didn’t. Beamer, nepo-baby coach who is living his dream job and holding on by a thread. It’s really apples and oranges. Spurrier had already been successful with a hall of fame career. Just padding his retirement accounts. Beamer has the advantage of NIL. I wonder what SOS could have done if he could purchased players?
 

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,264
2,086
113
We can squabble all we want to.

Bottom line: Beamer will have coached 6 seasons at the end of this year.
4 of them winning seasons.
2 of the 4 winning seasons had us right on the cusp of making the playoffs... 1 still pending....unlikely, but pending.
the 2 losing seasons actually were not that bad compared to the 0'fer season under Holtz.

That's good enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kidrobinski

sclawman77

All-Conference
Jun 27, 2011
1,926
1,744
113
We can squabble all we want to.

Bottom line: Beamer will have coached 6 seasons at the end of this year.
4 of them winning seasons.
2 of the 4 winning seasons had us right on the cusp of making the playoffs... 1 still pending....unlikely, but pending.
the 2 losing seasons actually were not that bad compared to the 0'fer season under Holtz.

That's good enough.
The '99 season was all on Fat Brad-not Lou. Yes, it was Lou's team but it was a complete rebuild. I don't think anyone is saying Shane hasn't done enough. It's a comparison to Spurrier.
 

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,264
2,086
113
The '99 season was all on Fat Brad-not Lou. Yes, it was Lou's team but it was a complete rebuild. I don't think anyone is saying Shane hasn't done enough. It's a comparison to Spurrier.
100% agree. Wasn't trying to imply it was Lou's fault. It wasn't. I was just saying even Shane's losing seasons weren't as bad as that no win season.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
Yeah, but... 3,2,1
Yeah....how many games did Steve crap his clock management? Have only 10 men on the field? Would have lost if we take away the opposing team's penalities? The real travesty is now Shane Beamer is out of the Top 20 in hot seat rankings. We almost had a path to a firing, now we on a path to an extension.

What could have been.....
funny face lips GIF by Worcester Warriors
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Yeah....how many games did Steve crap his clock management? Have only 10 men on the field? Would have lost if we take away the opposing team's penalities? The real travesty is now Shane Beamer is out of the Top 20 in hot seat rankings. We almost had a path to a firing, now we on a path to an extension.

What could have been.....
funny face lips GIF by Worcester Warriors
Wins and losses are the bottom line. The bottom line is the bottom line.
 

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,264
2,086
113
Yeah....how many games did Steve crap his clock management? Have only 10 men on the field? Would have lost if we take away the opposing team's penalities? The real travesty is now Shane Beamer is out of the Top 20 in hot seat rankings. We almost had a path to a firing, now we on a path to an extension.

What could have been.....
funny face lips GIF by Worcester Warriors
Your words in the "A&M is not a good football team" thread:

"They've stepped up their run defense their last 2 games. Take away the big Sellers run, and we fared no better than 'Bama on the ground."

So, to be perfectly clear, it's ok when *YOU* want to play the "take away" game to make your point..... but when I do it, you wanna make fun.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Lurker123

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,264
2,086
113
Hopefully the new AD isn't as stupid as the last one, and locks us in to some unplayable buyout. Because i think we all know we'll swing back into "can we afford the buyout" talk again.
Speaking of the buyout and what we can't afford.....

Struck me as funny when we stormed the field against UT and ppl were saying there would be a $500K fine. Once the bill arrives we should sent it back with a "We can't afford it" note.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Gamecock Disciple

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Hopefully the new AD isn't as stupid as the last one, and locks us in to some unplayable buyout. Because i think we all know we'll swing back into "can we afford the buyout" talk again.
Think you're going to be disappointed Lurker. The extension will likely follow the original contract and industry norm. We get to 8 wins you're probably looking at a 2 year extension so the buyout will be larger next year than it is this year.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,874
3,739
113
Yeah, Spurrier's first 5 seasons had some exciting wins, but the records were just a hair above our historic norm. But afer the win over Clemson in 2009, I do specifically remember thinking that Gamecock Nation really needed that win. We had lost 4 of our last 5 games and I think the fanbase was feeling pretty beat down at that point. If 2010 had gone like the previous 5 years, I don't think it's a certainty Spurrier would have remained as our coach. Fortunately, that 2009 Clemson win was a down payment on the success of the next 4 seasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123
Aug 31, 2026
10
2
1
Spurrier coming out of retirement to take on the biggest coaching challenge in the world, and he turned it around until he didn’t. Beamer, nepo-baby coach who is living his dream job and holding on by a thread. It’s really apples and oranges. Spurrier had already been successful with a hall of fame career. Just padding his retirement accounts. Beamer has the advantage of NIL. I wonder what SOS could have done if he could purchased players?
When all is said and done Beamer will surpass spurrier in wins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,915
9,014
113
Spurrier: 40-32

Beamer: 39-33
When Spurrier came in as coach, the orange crush was still essentially the orange crush and Meyer came in at Florida the same year. They both first coached in 2005. Spurrier beat Florida and a Phil Fulmer Tennessee team that year, on the same night Peyton's number was retired. My memory is a little hoary-headed. Is that not correct?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gamecock Disciple

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
When Spurrier came in as coach, the orange crush was still essentially the orange crush and Meyer came in at Florida the same year. They both first coached in 2005. Spurrier beat Florida and a Phil Fulmer Tennessee team that year, on the same night Peyton's number was retired. My memory is a little hoary-headed. Is that not correct?
IIRC, we beat UT his first year, which coincided with the start of UT"s decline. The next year we beat them under SOS was Fulmer's last year. Those two seasons were the worst seasons they had under Fulmer. UF was good that first year, but not UF good....not nearly as good as they would be under Meyer. They had 3 conference losses.

But, it didn't matter. Beating UF and UT at all, much less in the same season, made that 7-5 record feel like 12-0 to Gamecock fans.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
When all is said and done Beamer will surpass spurrier in wins.
Entirely possible. Let's face it, it's a pretty low bar.

He doesn't have to string together 11-win seasons. If he can win 8ish games a season, he'll pass SOS in 6 years or so. That's a big IF, though. SOS had a bunch of OK seasons sandwiching those 11-win seasons.
 

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
Entirely possible. Let's face it, it's a pretty low bar.

He doesn't have to string together 11-win seasons. If he can win 8ish games a season, he'll pass SOS in 6 years or so. That's a big IF, though. SOS had a bunch of OK seasons sandwiching those 11-win seasons.

Looked it up, he won 9 in his 6th year. (This year for beamer) then 11 three times, then 7, then 2.

Certainly possible, but that would mean we do this back and forth losing season, good season dance for 6 or so more years. yay
 

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,050
799
113
Agree completely. What i usually assume is that when people make this comparison, rhey are going for something different. I usually think they are trying to fool people into thinking Muschamp/Beamer records are really close to Spurrier, who had that awesome run (and nevermind that the comparison doesn't include the good run years).

Its been used before to make people think those two are doing better than they really are. JMO
What always gets left out too, is the programs they came into were totally different and how things happen. The records look very close obviously but those don't tell the whole story either. Spurrier often talked about changing the culture: competing in the SEC over beating Clemson as the big deal, the boring stadium, lack of donations to the school and athletic department, etc... He used to talk about our recruiting, a few years into it I remember him noting how "the LB's here are now beginning to look like the LB's at Georgia and Tennessee."

It took him longer than expected to get to the types of things we thought possible and/or potential with him here. 2007-09 had no shortage of stupid losses including some abysmal bowl games. But we all knew his background and there were things happening in those first 5 seasons leading one to think he'll get beyond this. The short of it is - he established a program that didn't exist before he came. One of the frustrations with Muschamp was he didn't capitalize on it. Beamer, has done better than Muschamp, but the way his seasons are playing out that same overall progress that existed under Spurrier is lacking at this point. So far Beamer's two best seasons - by record - have been followed by two losing seasons (IMO his best coaching job was his first season. We didn't have a QB and that idiot Satterfield was running the offense and they got to 7 wins). We've even seen some incredible wins and records but it hasn't translated to any sort of consistency from season to season, maybe that changes from 2026 to 2027. I'd like to think it can.
 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,771
1,542
113
So all Beamer has to do is keep pace with a legendary hof coach and have generational in-state talent fall in his lap while actually doing diddly in terms of real accomplishment and the fans will be happy. Lol. Or..

Miami is looking for fans! Any bandwagon fan can be a Cane, no commitment required! Guaranteed winning record in the ACC every season! Be happy all the time; how bout them Canes! Cool gear too! Giant road trip for all home games!
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,773
3,394
113
I would not put Beamer in Spurrier's class. In addition to the 3 consecutive Top 10 teams, other than that last season when he left in mid-season, Spurrier never had a losing season at Carolina. He was at Carolina around twice as many seasons as Beamer has. In 6 seasons, Beamer has had 2 losing seasons. OK so there were a few seasons here when the state had great high school talent. But, when some fans on this site were pushing for Beamer to be made Head Coach, they pointed to those recruiting classes, saying that Beamer is some extraordinary recruiter. You can't have it both ways.

I would be hesitant to extend Beamer's contract until he can produce consecutive good seasons. Up and down, up and down won't cut it. There's nothing personal about that; it's business. So Beamer might be upset over not getting an extension and raise. OK, then he can leave. If he is so good, then another school will hire him as Head Coach. I would be careful when deciding what to do with Beamer after this season. Some people like to somersault when crossing a street. I prefer to look both ways before crossing.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
I would not put Beamer in Spurrier's class. In addition to the 3 consecutive Top 10 teams, other than that last season when he left in mid-season, Spurrier never had a losing season at Carolina. He was at Carolina around twice as many seasons as Beamer has. In 6 seasons, Beamer has had 2 losing seasons. OK so there were a few seasons here when the state had great high school talent. But, when some fans on this site were pushing for Beamer to be made Head Coach, they pointed to those recruiting classes, saying that Beamer is some extraordinary recruiter. You can't have it both ways.

I would be hesitant to extend Beamer's contract until he can produce consecutive good seasons. Up and down, up and down won't cut it. There's nothing personal about that; it's business. So Beamer might be upset over not getting an extension and raise. OK, then he can leave. If he is so good, then another school will hire him as Head Coach. I would be careful when deciding what to do with Beamer after this season. Some people like to somersault when crossing a street. I prefer to look both ways before crossing.

Your mind lives in a different era Stock.
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
Loved the Spurrier era but he had it much easier than Beamer and has said as much.

Spurrier dealt with an overall weak SEC East while Beamer has dealt with Top 5 regular season schedules with the new alignment.

If you're going to make comparisons, then you must do it based around recruiting classes which were more similar before the 11-2 strech when Spurrier pushed into the Top 5/10.

Pony for Beamer and Company to get some Top 5/10 recruiting classes in this NIL era and let's see what he can do with them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
763
318
63
What always gets left out too, is the programs they came into were totally different and how things happen. The records look very close obviously but those don't tell the whole story either. Spurrier often talked about changing the culture: competing in the SEC over beating Clemson as the big deal, the boring stadium, lack of donations to the school and athletic department, etc... He used to talk about our recruiting, a few years into it I remember him noting how "the LB's here are now beginning to look like the LB's at Georgia and Tennessee."

It took him longer than expected to get to the types of things we thought possible and/or potential with him here. 2007-09 had no shortage of stupid losses including some abysmal bowl games. But we all knew his background and there were things happening in those first 5 seasons leading one to think he'll get beyond this. The short of it is - he established a program that didn't exist before he came. One of the frustrations with Muschamp was he didn't capitalize on it. Beamer, has done better than Muschamp, but the way his seasons are playing out that same overall progress that existed under Spurrier is lacking at this point. So far Beamer's two best seasons - by record - have been followed by two losing seasons (IMO his best coaching job was his first season. We didn't have a QB and that idiot Satterfield was running the offense and they got to 7 wins). We've even seen some incredible wins and records but it hasn't translated to any sort of consistency from season to season, maybe that changes from 2026 to 2027. I'd like to think it can.

The issue is that the classic 4-year player system is gone with the portal.

Role players come and go at will for teams in our position.

BAMA and UGA can still secure their 4 and 5-star players in high school and pay for them to stick around for the entire stint.

We don't have that level of talent on our team nor the finances to keep everyone there.

And we are playing tougher schedules than Spurrier did too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JimmyMcK

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,740
18,444
113
Loved the Spurrier era but he had it much easier than Beamer and has said as much.

Spurrier dealt with an overall weak SEC East while Beamer has dealt with Top 5 regular season schedules with the new alignment.

If you're going to make comparisons, then you must do it based around recruiting classes which were more similar before the 11-2 strech when Spurrier pushed into the Top 5/10.

Pony for Beamer and Company to get some Top 5/10 recruiting classes in this NIL era and let's see what he can do with them.
It's been a different beast entirely with the portal and roster turnover.

It's not at all comparable to the 4-year player system. Back then you were worried a guy might go pro after 3 years and miss the 4th, lol. Now there's no guarantee they won't check out midseason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,603
6,148
113
I would not put Beamer in Spurrier's class.

Of course not. Beamer hasn't achieved what Spurrier has here, much less titles at the other stops he made.

Beamer's career will NEVER be what Steve's was, except they both coached here.

People arguing that Beamer is as good as Spurrier are trolling and gaslighting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

Swifty

Junior
Jan 21, 2022
404
338
53
Being as good as Spurrier and having the same amount of success as Spurrier at the same position over the same amount of time are completely separate things. Nobody is saying Beamer is as good as Spurrier. Spurrier is a HOFer, a Heisman winner, truly a living legend. It still took him six seasons to have a successful one.
 

Go Gamecocks

All-Conference
Jan 19, 2021
1,884
1,558
113
It still took him six seasons to have a successful one.

I contend that his 2nd season ('06 @ 8-5) was successful. We had some glaring personnel weaknesses, but that team closed with 3 straight wins including beating the favored taters. It not how you start, but how you finish.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Details you may have missed: South Carolina vs. Arkansas
  2. 02 GamecockCentral Football Insider Mailbag Vol. 12: Briles and Sellers, what's next for South Carolina
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina remains in College Football Playoff rankings after Arkansas loss
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball Photos: Gamecocks roll past FGCU in home opener
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Womens Basketball South Carolina women's basketball: Rapid Reaction - FGCU