OT/SIAP: Movie Geeks, James Gunn is out at DC Studios

Player2BNamedL8r

All-Conference
Jan 3, 2012
1,204
2,406
113
I’m glad he’s finishing the Sups sequel. I may be in the minority, but I really liked his reboot. To be fair, being a big fan of the character, I’ve typically been pretty okay with most of the iterations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
I’m glad he’s finishing the Sups sequel. I may be in the minority, but I really liked his reboot. To be fair, being a big fan of the character, I’ve typically been pretty okay with most of the iterations.

Loved Superman, Peacemaker, and Creature Commandos - all stuff Gunn wrote and or directed (Supergirl was okay - they had everything in place but story just didn’t work for me and Lobo was wildly misused) but he was in over his head when it came to actually running a studio. He should have never left Marvel and I hope he goes back. I’d give him GOTG and let them run wild…
 

Zenophile

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2001
1,501
4,658
113
I’m glad he’s finishing the Sups sequel. I may be in the minority, but I really liked his reboot. To be fair, being a big fan of the character, I’ve typically been pretty okay with most of the iterations.
Saw Superman. Suffice it to say I wasn’t so worried about him ruining the character as much as I was worried he was going to ruin all of cinema.
 

razpsu

Heisman
Jan 13, 2004
14,983
15,486
113
He made Superman with the dog? Omg that was not good. Then he made supergirl which until this day me or my kids have not watched. Oh and it’s free on tv. 🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: NOYDB and Zenophile

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
Loved Superman, Peacemaker, and Creature Commandos - all stuff Gunn wrote and or directed (Supergirl was okay - they had everything in place but story just didn’t work for me and Lobo was wildly misused) but he was in over his head when it came to actually running a studio. He should have never left Marvel and I hope he goes back. I’d give him GOTG and let them run wild…

Frankly, do not have a lot of trust/faith in Warner Brothers either to be honest. Gunn would do well to bail IMO. And I think he will given WB is now looking to severely cut/edit his Man of Tomorrow film....
 

Zenophile

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2001
1,501
4,658
113
DC needs to figure out what it wants to be and get comfortable in that lane. Its natural niche is as the darker, grittier, more adult alternative to the MCU. But there’s a difference between adult storytelling and simply trying to “appear adult.” Gratuitous profanity doesn’t make a script mature any more than gratuitous violence makes a story compelling. It’s the tone, themes, stakes & complexity that should distinguish DC from Marvel (not the number of F-bombs).
 

NedFromYork

Sophomore
Aug 29, 2001
106
111
43
I liked Black Adam and thought many of the other introduced superheroes were good. The first Wonderwoman was good, maybe the end was a little over the top, but good. Justice League had its moments. Outside of that pretty bad. They should just let the Marvell team run it.
 

WillyMO

Junior
Oct 28, 2021
160
256
43
I assume Clayface (a character 95% of the population has ever heard of) was his idea? If so he deserves to go. And Supergirl? Who's the audience for that? Who's next, Kiteman?
 

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,168
32,342
113
DC needs to figure out what it wants to be and get comfortable in that lane. Its natural niche is as the darker, grittier, more adult alternative to the MCU. But there’s a difference between adult storytelling and simply trying to “appear adult.” Gratuitous profanity doesn’t make a script mature any more than gratuitous violence makes a story compelling. It’s the tone, themes, stakes & complexity that should distinguish DC from Marvel (not the number of F-bombs).
That was one of my major issues the Green Lantern Series.
Just because you can doesn't mean you have to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewEra 2026

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
DC needs to figure out what it wants to be and get comfortable in that lane. Its natural niche is as the darker, grittier, more adult alternative to the MCU. But there’s a difference between adult storytelling and simply trying to “appear adult.” Gratuitous profanity doesn’t make a script mature any more than gratuitous violence makes a story compelling. It’s the tone, themes, stakes & complexity that should distinguish DC from Marvel (not the number of F-bombs).

Batman has generally done well - I liked the Nolan films and the new film with Pattinson was really good. The animated stuff - especially Harley Quinn on HBO - is great. Not sure if another season is coming but is/was a terrific series. Doom Patrol (HBO) and Sandman (Netflix) are amazing but kind of perfect where they ended (Penguin on HBO was really really good but has been dormant way too long and no idea if it’s returning…). Peacemaker on HBO is one of my favorite shows of the past decade but it takes way too long to come out and might be too quirky for most audiences. DC has always been the north star for edgy, adult stories and I’d love to see them lean into more of that (Vertigo could be an anthology? Swamp Thing, Hellblazer, Animal Man, Shade, etc). DC’s biggest problem is they have the big three then a bunch of heroes no one cares about. Lanterns hasn’t been renewed yet either. Gunn is a talented guy but he shouldn’t be in charge of a studio. He needs to go back to Marvel ASAP.

 

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,168
32,342
113
Batman has generally done well - I liked the Nolan films and the new film with Pattinson was really good. The animated stuff - especially Harley Quinn on HBO - is great. Not sure if another season is coming but is/was a terrific series. Doom Patrol (HBO) and Sandman (Netflix) are amazing but kind of perfect where they ended (Penguin on HBO was really really good but has been dormant way too long and no idea if it’s returning…). DC has always been the north star for edgy, adult stories and I’d love to see them lean into more of that (Vertigo could be an anthology? Swamp Thing, Hellblazer, Animal Man, Shade, etc). DC’s biggest problem is they have the big three then a bunch of heroes no one cares about. Lanterns hasn’t been renewed yet either. Gunn is a talented guy but he shouldn’t be in charge of a studio. He needs to go back to Marvel ASAP.


with all the remakes and reboots I wish someone would reboot SPAWN.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
with all the remakes and reboots I wish someone would reboot SPAWN.

Have heard this is in the works! Todd has been hinting at it on X from time to time. Animated series was excellent.

As an aside, Rob Liefeld has a great podcast (I don’t listen to it much anymore) on the craziness of the 90’s comic industry. He sounds like he’s coked up but has amazing stories about the business. He was and is a total fraud but still - had front row seats to all of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,168
32,342
113
Have heard this is in the works! Todd has been hinting at it on X from time to time. Animated series was excellent.

As an aside, Rob Liefeld has a great podcast (I don’t listen to it much anymore) on the craziness of the 90’s comic industry. He sounds like he’s coked up but has amazing stories about the business. He was and is a total fraud but still - had front row seats to all of it.
But please no Jamie Foxx. He's fine but there are enough unknown black actors that can play that part.
Hell I would rather have 59 year old Michael Jai White revise the roll than Foxx.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
But please no Jamie Foxx. He's fine but there are enough unknown black actors that can play that part.
Hell I would rather have 59 year old Michael Jai White revise the roll than Foxx.

Totally. Guy from Fallout would be wonderful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown

84lion

All-Conference
Oct 7, 2021
920
1,613
93
DC needs to figure out what it wants to be and get comfortable in that lane. Its natural niche is as the darker, grittier, more adult alternative to the MCU. But there’s a difference between adult storytelling and simply trying to “appear adult.” Gratuitous profanity doesn’t make a script mature any more than gratuitous violence makes a story compelling. It’s the tone, themes, stakes & complexity that should distinguish DC from Marvel (not the number of F-bombs).
I could not agree more. The one superhero film that not only worked with the profanity and bad attitude was Deadpool (possibly my favorite movie of the genre), and this worked (and was "necessary") because Deadpool was an anti-hero. Otherwise, the "tone, stakes, and complexity" were absolutely dead-on (no pun intended). Deadpool was never meant for small kids - it's really for older teens and up. And, the movie had a rollicking plot, and a really compelling love story (which, oddly, really "made" the film for me - it actually made it rather, well, wholesome, in my view). And, of course, Deadpool is part of the Marvel franchise. The DC stuff - well, let's just say that the original Suicide Squad was a bit over-the-top for me, started it and never finished, the original Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot) was OK, as was Aquaman, but everything else just never made it on my radar. I think I started watching Joker and again, didn't finish it. DC should take a sabbatical and re-watch Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy to understand how it's done right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bbrown

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,168
32,342
113
I could not agree more. The one superhero film that not only worked with the profanity and bad attitude was Deadpool (possibly my favorite movie of the genre), and this worked (and was "necessary") because Deadpool was an anti-hero. Otherwise, the "tone, stakes, and complexity" were absolutely dead-on (no pun intended). Deadpool was never meant for small kids - it's really for older teens and up. And, the movie had a rollicking plot, and a really compelling love story (which, oddly, really "made" the film for me - it actually made it rather, well, wholesome, in my view). And, of course, Deadpool is part of the Marvel franchise. The DC stuff - well, let's just say that the original Suicide Squad was a bit over-the-top for me, started it and never finished, the original Wonder Woman (Gal Gadot) was OK, as was Aquaman, but everything else just never made it on my radar. I think I started watching Joker and again, didn't finish it. DC should take a sabbatical and re-watch Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy to understand how it's done right.
I thought Jason Momoa was badly miscast. The guy from Smallville and Jack Reacher would have been better.
 

bbrown

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,168
32,342
113
He seems a little wimpy to be Spawn but that could have been his character. The guy from the not great HBO Watchmen series could be a fit.
Yea I didn't think he was big enough either but these actors can put on muscle like crazy now so maybe.
Yahya Abdul-Mateeen would be a good choice, certainly big enough. But he's doing a lot other stuff now. I thought he was very good in the Wonder Man series and I'm looking forward to his new By Any Means movie.
I was thinking the guy from Gangs of London...Sope Dirisu would be good and he's due for a breakout.
My off the wall pick is 50 Cent. 🤷‍♂️

​

 
Last edited:

PSU87

All-Conference
Jun 8, 2001
2,090
4,434
113
Obviously from my avatar, Im a Superman fan.

Superman 1 and 2 with Christopher Reeve will simply never, ever be topped. I would argue Superman 1 was not just the best Superman movie ever made, but the best Superhero movie ever made. And the scene where the world is introduced to Superman is quite possibly the best scene ever in Superhero movie.

That said, I thoroughly enjoyed the new Superman. Best Superman movie since Superman 2.

We got our truth justice and the American way "good" Superman back.

Superman returns....to whiny
Zach Snyder Superman...to dark. It might as well have been Batman.

I actually really liked Krypto.
 

Player2BNamedL8r

All-Conference
Jan 3, 2012
1,204
2,406
113
Obviously from my avatar, Im a Superman fan.

Superman 1 and 2 with Christopher Reeve will simply never, ever be topped. I would argue Superman 1 was not just the best Superman movie ever made, but the best Superhero movie ever made. And the scene where the world is introduced to Superman is quite possibly the best scene ever in Superhero movie.

That said, I thoroughly enjoyed the new Superman. Best Superman movie since Superman 2.

We got our truth justice and the American way "good" Superman back.

Superman returns....to whiny
Zach Snyder Superman...to dark. It might as well have been Batman.

I actually really liked Krypto.
Yeah, Sups is a tough character to fit into the typically grittier DC world. I liked the return of the boy scout as well and thought Corenswet was great for that version of the character. That said, I also found Snyder’s vision compelling and like many also thought Cavill was made for the role. For me, it always comes down to storytelling…the character is there for the taking, just give him a worthy script.
 

Zenophile

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2001
1,501
4,658
113
Yeah, Sups is a tough character to fit into the typically grittier DC world. I liked the return of the boy scout as well and thought Corenswet was great for that version of the character. That said, I also found Snyder’s vision compelling and like many also thought Cavill was made for the role. For me, it always comes down to storytelling…the character is there for the taking, just give him a worthy script.
+1. IMHO the kid did an amazing job despite the hot garbage movie that was going on around him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Player2BNamedL8r

Midnighter

Heisman
Jan 22, 2021
13,055
21,624
113
Yeah, Sups is a tough character to fit into the typically grittier DC world. I liked the return of the boy scout as well and thought Corenswet was great for that version of the character. That said, I also found Snyder’s vision compelling and like many also thought Cavill was made for the role. For me, it always comes down to storytelling…the character is there for the taking, just give him a worthy script.

Speaking of Cavill - no idea what Marvel is waiting for....

 

PSU87

All-Conference
Jun 8, 2001
2,090
4,434
113
Yeah, Sups is a tough character to fit into the typically grittier DC world. I liked the return of the boy scout as well and thought Corenswet was great for that version of the character. That said, I also found Snyder’s vision compelling and like many also thought Cavill was made for the role. For me, it always comes down to storytelling…the character is there for the taking, just give him a worthy script.
I did like Cavill as Superman very much
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State TE Benjamin Brahmer announces he'll return for the 2027 season
  2. 02 BWI Football Penn State Transfer Portal Preview: Four Potential Quarterback Targets to Know for 2027
  3. 03 BWI Football Trimmings: Penn State's Senior Day list and what we're hearing on those who could come back for 2027
  4. 04 BWI Basketball Penn State set to add international point guard Savo Drezgic
  5. 05 BWI Football Matt Campbell says Penn State became a real team, now wants to prove it for 60 minutes