PSU QB Portal Options & $$$ to Spend

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
What are the projections for potential high end QBs that will be available in the portal?

I Iistened to Tengwall over the weekend and he thinks we need to get a bonafide starter at QB in the portal. He is concerned that Campbell will not want to guarantee the guy will be the starter in '27 and therefore no one of high quality will want that kind of situation. I hope that doesn't happen. We need to just make a decision that we need to start our roster overhaul with a top flight QB. We need to open up the wallet and pay about $4 million for a proven QB.

Manske is not our answer. Campbell has to know that if we are going to go from where we are now to a playoff team next year we need a really good QB, a trigger man for the offense who can win big games for us.

Grunk seems to be the one mentioned a lot. $4 million to get him maybe more. Is he worth it? Does he even want to come here?

Who else may come available?
 
  • Like
Reactions: LMTLION and Bosco2

TheWizardofCamelot

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2015
1,205
1,842
113
I've read a bunch that the staff is likely to kick the tires on Malik Washington from UMD. He has a ton of familiarity to the school because he visited so often in HS. He has shown a lot of promise at Maryland, there just isn't any talent around him.

Adam Breneman mentioned Michael Hawkins from WVU. He seems to be in a much more stable position than Washington. And I'd imagine WVU will try and keep him happy. Unless he wants a shot playing in prime time in the BIG or SEC?

Guys like Sagapolutele (Cal), Atkinson (Oregon St), and Lopez (Wake) are going to cost big bucks and have all the heavy hitters knocking on their door.

I can't see Grunk leaving Tech, especially to come back to PSU. Only way he leaves Obrien/Franklin is for the pros.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
I've read a bunch that the staff is likely to kick the tires on Malik Washington from UMD. He has a ton of familiarity to the school because he visited so often in HS. He has shown a lot of promise at Maryland, there just isn't any talent around him.

Adam Breneman mentioned Michael Hawkins from WVU. He seems to be in a much more stable position than Washington. And I'd imagine WVU will try and keep him happy. Unless he wants a shot playing in prime time in the BIG or SEC?

Guys like Sagapolutele (Cal), Atkinson (Oregon St), and Lopez (Wake) are going to cost big bucks and have all the heavy hitters knocking on their door.

I can't see Grunk leaving Tech, especially to come back to PSU. Only way he leaves Obrien/Franklin is for the pros.
How much will Washington cost? $4 million? How much would the Wake guy or Oregon State guy or Cal guy cost? We really can't get cheap at this position.
 

Grant Green

All-American
Jan 21, 2004
4,199
5,675
113
I've read a bunch that the staff is likely to kick the tires on Malik Washington from UMD. He has a ton of familiarity to the school because he visited so often in HS. He has shown a lot of promise at Maryland, there just isn't any talent around him.

Adam Breneman mentioned Michael Hawkins from WVU. He seems to be in a much more stable position than Washington. And I'd imagine WVU will try and keep him happy. Unless he wants a shot playing in prime time in the BIG or SEC?

Guys like Sagapolutele (Cal), Atkinson (Oregon St), and Lopez (Wake) are going to cost big bucks and have all the heavy hitters knocking on their door.

I can't see Grunk leaving Tech, especially to come back to PSU. Only way he leaves Obrien/Franklin is for the pros.
Atkinson is rumored to have just resigned with OR St for 2027
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
16,897
23,174
113
Maybe edit the subject line to “PSU portal possibilities, interest and $$$$.” We’d get more long-term traction on this subject and it’s gonna heat up soon. Basically everyone is in play if you offer them enough money. I hate the whole concept but it’s current interest, can’t fight City Hall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leo Ridens

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
Maybe edit the subject line to “PSU portal possibilities, interest and $$$$.” We’d get more long-term traction on this subject and it’s gonna heat up soon. Basically everyone is in play if you offer them enough money. I hate the whole concept but it’s current interest, can’t fight City Hall.
I just did. Thank you for the suggestion. My clever title was apparently not clever and not interesting to anyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LionJim

DaytonRickster

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
3,494
4,009
113
I've read a bunch that the staff is likely to kick the tires on Malik Washington from UMD. He has a ton of familiarity to the school because he visited so often in HS. He has shown a lot of promise at Maryland, there just isn't any talent around him.

Adam Breneman mentioned Michael Hawkins from WVU. He seems to be in a much more stable position than Washington. And I'd imagine WVU will try and keep him happy. Unless he wants a shot playing in prime time in the BIG or SEC?

Guys like Sagapolutele (Cal), Atkinson (Oregon St), and Lopez (Wake) are going to cost big bucks and have all the heavy hitters knocking on their door.

I can't see Grunk leaving Tech, especially to come back to PSU. Only way he leaves Obrien/Franklin is for the pros.
Atkinson (Oregon State QB) "resigned" today with them.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
This is pure speculation, but I wonder if they bring in Zollers, a PA kid, to compete with Manske. Missouri resigned their starting qb for 2027. Otherwise I think Malik Washington could be a target if we want a solid guaranteed starter that will not break the bank and has potential to succeed with a better team. I do not think Hawkins is the qb type they would want for this conference and as such probably not a target. He literally runs more often than he attempts passes. I hope we have higher aspirations than these QBs, but I am not sure what budget we will dedicate to the position.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Electric Lion

Efejle

All-Conference
Apr 30, 2023
1,425
2,813
113
What happened to his batman return post of Mid October? Oh wait...portal money was more important
 

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
543
929
93
Of course you go and spend all this money and when he has a career ending injury in the third game, you're right back where you started.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
Of course you go and spend all this money and when he has a career ending injury in the third game, you're right back where you started.
Yep, it’s insanity and it seems like even the best funded teams don’t have depth at the position. Look at OSU falling apart, at least partially due to losing their very expensive starting QB to injury and relying on a freshman backup. Is it worth us spending $4m+ for a bona fide starter or is it worth spending a lot less bringing in less proven / high potential guys to compete with Manske?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ram20 and Binder74

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,537
2,551
113
Yep, it’s insanity and it seems like even the best funded teams don’t have depth at the position. Look at OSU falling apart, at least partially due to losing their very expensive starting QB to injury and relying on a freshman backup. Is it worth us spending $4m+ for a bona fide starter or is it worth spending a lot less bringing in less proven / high potential guys to compete with Manske?
Both the Ole Miss and BC qbs came from D-2 schools in Michigan, Mestemaker played at North Texas State, and Iowa's qb last season came from one of the Dakota schools. There are a lot of good to really good qbs who are playing at lower level schools who definitely can play well at the Big 10 level. Regardless, PSU definitely must and will bring in a qb from the portal. God, even a program like UVA, which probably doesn't have as much NIL as PSU, has Pribula and the former Pitt starting qb as their qbs for this season, so there's no excuse for PSU not being able to attract a really competent qb at least to compete with Manske if not to win the job outright.
 

Binder74

Senior
Nov 1, 2021
543
929
93
Both the Ole Miss and BC qbs came from D-2 schools in Michigan, Mestemaker played at North Texas State, and Iowa's qb last season came from one of the Dakota schools. There are a lot of good to really good qbs who are playing at lower level schools who definitely can play well at the Big 10 level. Regardless, PSU definitely must and will bring in a qb from the portal. God, even a program like UVA, which probably doesn't have as much NIL as PSU, has Pribula and the former Pitt starting qb as their qbs for this season, so there's no excuse for PSU not being able to attract a really competent qb at least to compete with Manske if not to win the job outright.
I realize we haven't seen much of Manske but what if he is really good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Colt2169 and Rocco3

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,537
2,551
113
I realize we haven't seen much of Manske but what if he is really good.
Well, as we've seen with the OSU situation this season, you really need two qbs preferably with experience. The best case scenario is to have the situation that we had in 2024 with Allar and Pribula, or what Mizzou had last season when Pribula was able to step in for the starter who I believe went out for the season in the first game.
 

s1uggo72

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
7,550
6,010
113
Both the Ole Miss and BC qbs came from D-2 schools in Michigan, Mestemaker played at North Texas State, and Iowa's qb last season came from one of the Dakota schools. There are a lot of good to really good qbs who are playing at lower level schools who definitely can play well at the Big 10 level. Regardless, PSU definitely must and will bring in a qb from the portal. God, even a program like UVA, which probably doesn't have as much NIL as PSU, has Pribula and the former Pitt starting qb as their qbs for this season, so there's no excuse for PSU not being able to attract a really competent qb at least to compete with Manske if not to win the job outright.
watching MACtion last nigh, the kid from Miami of Ohio looked good as he was just thrown into the game, Bellasari was 8/15 99 yds and ran some. He came into the game down 17-7 Miami won 34-17. He looked good.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
Both the Ole Miss and BC qbs came from D-2 schools in Michigan, Mestemaker played at North Texas State, and Iowa's qb last season came from one of the Dakota schools. There are a lot of good to really good qbs who are playing at lower level schools who definitely can play well at the Big 10 level. Regardless, PSU definitely must and will bring in a qb from the portal. God, even a program like UVA, which probably doesn't have as much NIL as PSU, has Pribula and the former Pitt starting qb as their qbs for this season, so there's no excuse for PSU not being able to attract a really competent qb at least to compete with Manske if not to win the job outright.
I wish we knew via conference play if Manske has potential or not. We do not even see him in garbage time in conference play. Either he is really good and they do not want a qb controversy or he is just really bad. We definitely need a qb. But we also need other very expensive starters from the portal like an edge, DT, and lb . It would be great if Manske has potential and we can bring in a lower cost qb to compete with him so we can properly upgrade the defense. A really good edge can go for a mill. We need one. If we can get pressure next year on the QB with that amazing secondary, we can be a force in the conference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catch1lion

Electric Lion

Freshman
Nov 7, 2021
55
64
18
Yep, it’s insanity and it seems like even the best funded teams don’t have depth at the position. Look at OSU falling apart, at least partially due to losing their very expensive starting QB to injury and relying on a freshman backup. Is it worth us spending $4m+ for a bona fide starter or is it worth spending a lot less bringing in less proven / high potential guys to compete with Manske?
Falling apart at QB for another reason. Two very highly recruited guys didn't pan out, Air Noland and Tavion St. Clair.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LMTLION

PSUFTG

All-Conference
Nov 1, 2021
2,865
4,090
113
If PSU is going to be competitive next year ("competitive" = capable of beating good teams) 1/2 of their 2027 two-deep will need to be adds from the portal. There just are not more than 22 kids on the current roster - even if PSU doesn't lose much in the portal - that are talented and capable enough to be "two-deep" guys on a competitive roster.

That is a hell of a lot of guys they will need to bring in.

On the plus side, there are not more than a fistful of guys on the current roster that will have a significant market value (who they will have to pay much to in order to retain) - so nearly all of their "talent acquisition budget" will be available to use for portal kids.

For whatever reasons (and likely not all within their control) Campbell et al really screwed the pooch with talent acquisition in Year 1 (I think any reasonable, non-delusional person realizes that).

This year is going to be a critical one in that regard, and the results will likely be something fairly used to assess this staff (more so than last year's debacle). It will be interesting - in a sad and perverse way, in this era of WTF-do-you-even-call-it "college" sports - to see how it plays out.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
If PSU is going to be competitive next year ("competitive" = capable of beating good teams) 1/2 of their 2027 two-deep will need to be adds from the portal. There just are not more than 22 kids on the current roster - even if PSU doesn't lose much in the portal - that are talented and capable enough to be "two-deep" guys on a competitive roster.

That is a hell of a lot of guys they will need to bring in.

On the plus side, there are not more than a fistful of guys on the current roster that will have a significant market value (who they will have to pay much to in order to retain) - so nearly all of their "talent acquisition budget" will be available to use for portal kids.

For whatever reasons (and likely not all within their control) Campbell et al really screwed the pooch with talent acquisition in Year 1 (I think any reasonable, non-delusional person realizes that).

This year is going to be a critical one in that regard, and the results will likely be something fairly used to assess this staff (more so than last year's debacle). It will be interesting - in a sad and perverse way, in this era of WTF-do-you-even-call-it "college" sports - to see how it plays out.
Other than figuring out QB and assuming Koby and Zay Robinson are back, I think the offense is OK, particularly as the OL seems fairly solid. In my opinion, the defense front 7 (or 6) is where we have by far the most issues with the 2 deep and almost needs to be rebuilt from scratch in the portal. That’s where we will spend a ton of freaking money.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheWizardofCamelot

Efejle

All-Conference
Apr 30, 2023
1,425
2,813
113
You did not, Koby is not leaving. I would be absolutely shocked based on everything you hear about him. They are being very cautious bringing him back from whatever unknown injury he has.
You mean the unknown injury that they expected him back for the Michigan game from? That one? Ok
 

Efejle

All-Conference
Apr 30, 2023
1,425
2,813
113
Other than figuring out QB and assuming Koby and Zay Robinson are back, I think the offense is OK, particularly as the OL seems fairly solid. In my opinion, the defense front 7 (or 6) is where we have by far the most issues with the 2 deep and almost needs to be rebuilt from scratch in the portal. That’s where we will spend a ton of freaking money.
Zay Robinson? 😂
1 catch per game Zay? 😂.

They need two wide receivers and a quarterback at the absolute minimum. Howard is gone.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
2,250
4,408
112
Zay Robinson? 😂
1 catch per game Zay? 😂.

They need two wide receivers and a quarterback at the absolute minimum. Howard is gone.
We will have to bookmark this thread for January and refer back to it. 😉
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
Well, as we've seen with the OSU situation this season, you really need two qbs preferably with experience. The best case scenario is to have the situation that we had in 2024 with Allar and Pribula, or what Mizzou had last season when Pribula was able to step in for the starter who I believe went out for the season in the first game.
I agree that it would be great to have the starter and a competent backup but how do we pull it off? There is the issue of we have two guys who we "like" but don't "love". Does that mean we really don't have a guy? Remember, we don't have talent all over the field so I think we need a game changer or close to it. Not a Manske level guy.

Nevertheless, let's go with the 2 QBs at a Manske level scenario. Is that $2 million a piece? Manske will want a pay raise if he knows he has at least a 50 50 shot to start next year. What level guy transfers here to an average B10 team and has to compete and could possibly waste a year as a backup? Do we spend $1.5 million on a back-up?

College football is so crazy that it seems itis difficult to have a clear #1 guy without a backup who is either; 1) Just not very good; or 2) a true freshman.
 

BCS PSU

All-Conference
Jun 2, 2001
1,537
2,551
113
I agree that it would be great to have the starter and a competent backup but how do we pull it off? There is the issue of we have two guys who we "like" but don't "love". Does that mean we really don't have a guy? Remember, we don't have talent all over the field so I think we need a game changer or close to it. Not a Manske level guy.

Nevertheless, let's go with the 2 QBs at a Manske level scenario. Is that $2 million a piece? Manske will want a pay raise if he knows he has at least a 50 50 shot to start next year. What level guy transfers here to an average B10 team and has to compete and could possibly waste a year as a backup? Do we spend $1.5 million on a back-up?

College football is so crazy that it seems itis difficult to have a clear #1 guy without a backup who is either; 1) Just not very good; or 2) a true freshman.
The answers to your questions are above my knowledge. However, if programs like Pitt and UVA are able to field teams with backups who respctively have played in the SEC and was a starter at Pitt, then it shouldn't be a problem for a program like PSU to be able to do the same. Whether they're any good is another story.
 

ApexLion

Heisman
Nov 1, 2021
6,611
11,130
113
You mean the unknown injury that they expected him back for the Michigan game from? That one? Ok
He got hurt his this past weekend. He's been running for weeks. Unfortunately, he may have issues again.
 

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
If PSU is going to be competitive next year ("competitive" = capable of beating good teams) 1/2 of their 2027 two-deep will need to be adds from the portal. There just are not more than 22 kids on the current roster - even if PSU doesn't lose much in the portal - that are talented and capable enough to be "two-deep" guys on a competitive roster.

That is a hell of a lot of guys they will need to bring in.

On the plus side, there are not more than a fistful of guys on the current roster that will have a significant market value (who they will have to pay much to in order to retain) - so nearly all of their "talent acquisition budget" will be available to use for portal kids.

For whatever reasons (and likely not all within their control) Campbell et al really screwed the pooch with talent acquisition in Year 1 (I think any reasonable, non-delusional person realizes that).

This year is going to be a critical one in that regard, and the results will likely be something fairly used to assess this staff (more so than last year's debacle). It will be interesting - in a sad and perverse way, in this era of WTF-do-you-even-call-it "college" sports - to see how it plays out.
Yes, Campbell and staff better start rehearsing the "We really appreciate all the hard work and dedication you put into the program but your services are no longer required" talk with many guys.

This is professional football and we have a budget. We need the deadweight to move on so we can reallocate their NIL to players with a pulse.
The answers to your questions are above my knowledge. However, if programs like Pitt and UVA are able to field teams with backups who respctively have played in the SEC and was a starter at Pitt, then it shouldn't be a problem for a program like PSU to be able to do the same. Whether they're any good is another story.
Both Pribula and the Pitt guy are not significantly different from a Becht caliber. Decent but not going to get us into the playoff next year. If Campbell doesn't want to be on the hot seat come next off season we need a big upgrade at QB. If that means we are left with a weak backup then take the risk.
 

Catch1lion

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
4,535
7,624
113
The quarterback market looks pretty damn pricey. I haven't seen this guy play, but he is making some serious bank.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

JoePaMajorCFBrecord409Ws

All-Conference
Jun 26, 2025
1,368
1,354
113
I agree that it would be great to have the starter and a competent backup but how do we pull it off? There is the issue of we have two guys who we "like" but don't "love". Does that mean we really don't have a guy? Remember, we don't have talent all over the field so I think we need a game changer or close to it. Not a Manske level guy.

Nevertheless, let's go with the 2 QBs at a Manske level scenario. Is that $2 million a piece? Manske will want a pay raise if he knows he has at least a 50 50 shot to start next year. What level guy transfers here to an average B10 team and has to compete and could possibly waste a year as a backup? Do we spend $1.5 million on a back-up?

College football is so crazy that it seems itis difficult to have a clear #1 guy without a backup who is either; 1) Just not very good; or 2) a true freshman.

"College Football"..... LMAO. Professional Football with universities' names on the jerseys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkiSkiSki

PSUForever

All-Conference
Feb 17, 2007
2,192
2,231
113
"College Football"..... LMAO. Professional Football with universities' names on the jerseys.
Fair point, it is professional football. The ridiculous thing is with these escalating pay for play salaries, many of these guys who won't make an NFL roster will have banked $3 million, or $4 million or $5 million by the time they are 22 or 23. Nice way to get started in their life's work. Hopefully they don't blow it.
 
BWI

Latest

  1. 01 BWI Football Penn State's Audavion Collins on his final season: 'Don't second-guess yourself'
  2. 02 BWI Football Matt Campbell on Penn State's turnaround, Senior Day and two key return announcements
  3. 03 BWI Recruiting Three 2028 Rivals300 prospects confirmed for Penn State's home finale
  4. 04 BWI Football Ben Brahmer and Kooper Ebel returning to Penn State will help 'start to accelerate a little bit of that planning' for the 2027 season
  5. 05 BWI Football Penn State injury updates: Did Carson Hansen practice on Wednesday? Latest on Caleb Bacon, Jahmir Joseph