Now It's Official. 24 team playoff is here.

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,779
18,482
113
Conference championship games officially axed.

All you need to know about the 24-team CFP is this: ESPN, $1,7 billion
 

nlstanford

Joined Sep 9, 2002
Sep 9, 2002
333
869
73
24 team college football playoff is like high school playoffs now. 5 weeks of postseason lol.
It’s wild, right? Our local HS was one game short of the state championship a few years ago. I remember that we started going to playoff games right after Halloween, kept going through Thanksgiving, and were closing in on Christmas when the kids finally lost 😭

I remember thinking that it was like a second football season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sclawman77

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,779
18,482
113
Are we mathematically eliminated from the possibility this year?
Realistically, yes. Probably not mathematically. We aren't leapfrogging UK or Bama unless they each lose 2x more as they hold the head to head. A lot of other losses would have to happen.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,191
3,760
113
  • Like
Reactions: Traildust57

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,779
18,482
113
Since they already ruined college football with NIL and the portal, I guess they wanted to completely destroy it by rendering the regular season meaningless and making getting in the playoff nothing special.
Haven't you heard? It makes the regular season MORE meaningful b/c teams will be playing for seeding in the CFP
 

adcoop

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2004
2,025
1,899
113
Since they already ruined college football with NIL and the portal, I guess they wanted to completely destroy it by rendering the regular season meaningless and making getting in the playoff nothing special.
The regular season won't be meaningless. The last few playoff spots will be up for grabs just like it is now. You will have more teams with a chance and less quitting in the middle of the season. Only traditionalists care about the bowl games. So, you may as well lean into an expanded playoff. If you lived with 6-6 bowl teams all these years, you definitely can live with an 8-4 playoff team.
 

atl-cock

All-Conference
Jan 18, 2022
3,735
1,857
113
The regular season won't be meaningless. The last few playoff spots will be up for grabs just like it is now. You will have more teams with a chance and less quitting in the middle of the season. Only traditionalists care about the bowl games. So, you may as well lean into an expanded playoff. If you lived with 6-6 bowl teams all these years, you definitely can live with an 8-4 playoff team.
Would like to see the playoffs conducted independent of the bowls. Highest seed hosts up to the championship game, to be held at a neutral site.

Those bowls which survive can invite teams who lose in the early rounds of the playoffs.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,779
18,482
113
The regular season won't be meaningless. The last few playoff spots will be up for grabs just like it is now. You will have more teams with a chance and less quitting in the middle of the season. Only traditionalists care about the bowl games. So, you may as well lean into an expanded playoff.
Semantics. You can argue it doesn't make the regular season meaningless, but it unquestionably makes the regular season games far less meaningful. When you can easily absorb 3 losses and still be comfortably in and possibly in with even 4 losses, there's simply no way around diminished meaning. With the 24-team CFP there is no single compelling game for any team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KingWard

Lurker123

All-American
May 4, 2020
7,616
6,175
113
Semantics. You can argue it doesn't make the regular season meaningless, but it unquestionably makes the regular season games far less meaningful. When you can easily absorb 3 losses and still be comfortably in and possibly in with even 4 losses, there's simply no way around diminished meaning. With the 24-team CFP there is no single compelling game for any team.

In recent years, Miami/ND might have been an elimination game in the regular season.

This year? It didn't matter who win, they are both in.

I didn't look into it, but how badly hurt was the heisman hopeful at Miami? The wr? I wonder if he would have played if the playoffs weren't at 12?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blues man

bayrooster

All-American
Aug 21, 2003
15,747
8,148
113
Hopefully that means the end of conference championship games. It would be unfair to the teams playing to have to get beat up in an extra game that none of the other teams with playoff berths have to play.
 

adcoop

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2004
2,025
1,899
113
Semantics. You can argue it doesn't make the regular season meaningless, but it unquestionably makes the regular season games far less meaningful. When you can easily absorb 3 losses and still be comfortably in and possibly in with even 4 losses, there's simply no way around diminished meaning. With the 24-team CFP there is no single compelling game for any team.
The bowl era was a different time where you could schedule your way into the National Championship conversation. With the major conferences scheduling 9 conference games, I think 9-3 teams are playoff worthy especially if you account for midseason injuries. Imagine teams like an Oregon or Ohio State still having a chance with 3 or even 4 losses and they mess around and get their QBs back. Those type of teams become dangerous on the lower end of the bracket instead of just going to the Holiday Bowl at the end of the year. I won't be surprised if a 3 loss team goes on to win the tournament before long.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,917
9,019
113
The bowl era was a different time where you could schedule your way into the National Championship conversation. With the major conferences scheduling 9 conference games, I think 9-3 teams are playoff worthy especially if you account for midseason injuries. Imagine teams like an Oregon or Ohio State still having a chance with 3 or even 4 losses and they mess around and get their QBs back. Those type of teams become dangerous on the lower end of the bracket instead of just going to the Holiday Bowl at the end of the year. I won't be surprised if a 3 loss team goes on to win the tournament before long.
Competition involving "seasons" should systematically identify contenders by eliminating pretenders.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

adcoop

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2004
2,025
1,899
113
Competition involving "seasons" should systematically identify contenders by eliminating pretenders.
To the contrary, the bowl system eliminated contenders by just rewarding winning. It didn't take who you played enough into account. It didn't take mid-season injury into account. It didn't take a coach making midseason adjustments and getting hot into account. You either kept a 0 on the right side of the ledger or you were out. Exciting in a way, but not really a good way to choose a champion. 24 teams is a little too many IMO, but if ESPN wants the content and is willing to pay for it, then you have a 24 team playoff.
 

RUMMENIGGE

Senior
Dec 14, 2016
1,399
939
113
Wait until you have coaches sitting starters in the Bama/Auburn, USC/Clemson, UM/OSU, etc games to rest them up for the playoffs.
Sounds like they will do away with conference championship games and if that is the case (with the exception of affirmative action Group of six team) each playoff team is guaranteed at least 13 days off before the playoffs starts so how much rest time (with the exception of injury prevention) do they need? Second no coach will rest players for the games that you listed. Resting players for the biggest regular season rival game is just asking to be on the hottest seat in the universe.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,779
18,482
113
Sounds like they will do away with conference championship games and if that is the case (with the exception of affirmative action Group of six team) each playoff team is guaranteed at least 13 days off before the playoffs starts so how much rest time (with the exception of injury prevention) do they need? Second no coach will rest players for the games that you listed. Resting players for the biggest regular season rival game is just asking to be on the hottest seat in the universe.

Mark it down. It, unfortunately, is the smart thing to do.
 

adcoop

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2004
2,025
1,899
113
But now what happens to conference play? What's the purpose of a conference if your only goal is to make the playoffs?
Can a team schedule a bunch of patsies and get in?
Conferences will still matter and be one of the metrics to get teams in. Also, OOC play will become important. An SEC team beating a BIG team or vice versa will be a metric as to what conference gets the most teams in. At the end of the day, the teams will have to play 12 regular season games. You want to win as many of those as you can to get the best position to make a run.
 

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
21,779
18,482
113
Mark it down. It, unfortunately, is the smart thing to do.

You will also have opt outs. If you're a first round draft pick playing on the #24 seeded team, are you going to play potentially 5 additional games and incur all that injury risk with no realistic shot at the title? Nope.
 

adcoop

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2004
2,025
1,899
113
Mark it down. It, unfortunately, is the smart thing to do.
The only way I see that happening is if you are undefeated, very unlikely with a 9 game conference schedule, and you go into your last game being guaranteed as the #1 seed. Too risky to be giving away games when seeding will still be in play.
 

adcoop

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2004
2,025
1,899
113
You will also have opt outs. If you're a first round draft pick playing on the #24 seeded team, are you going to play potentially 5 additional games and incur all that injury risk with no realistic shot at the title? Nope.
You are making up unlikely scenarios now. A player on the #24 seeded team is only guaranteed one playoff game. One where he will most likely be excited to play. You win and that player is even more excited to play the next one.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,191
3,760
113
Sounds like they will do away with conference championship games and if that is the case (with the exception of affirmative action Group of six team) each playoff team is guaranteed at least 13 days off before the playoffs starts so how much rest time (with the exception of injury prevention) do they need? Second no coach will rest players for the games that you listed. Resting players for the biggest regular season rival game is just asking to be on the hottest seat in the universe.
A 10-1 Bama would definitely rest/protect starters in a game against a 6-5 Auburn at the end of the season. Rival games like SC/Clemson will mean much less if both teams are already in the playoff or if one is in and the other is definitely out. The only time rivalry games that are out of conference will have importance will be if both teams are already out of the playoff picture and bragging rights are what the game is about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,876
3,743
113
Realistically, yes. Probably not mathematically. We aren't leapfrogging UK or Bama unless they each lose 2x more as they hold the head to head. A lot of other losses would have to happen.
Well, one of the things that would have to happen is for a whole bunch of SEC teams to end up with 3 losses, so that the head-to-head data points are circular. There are currently 9 teams (not counting UGA) which could realistically end up with 3 losses. Obviously, with a number of games left to play, all 9 of those can't end up with three losses, but I was just wondering if we're actually mathematically eliminated. I doubt we are, but I imagine they are one-in-a-thousand odds.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,191
3,760
113
Conferences will still matter and be one of the metrics to get teams in. Also, OOC play will become important. An SEC team beating a BIG team or vice versa will be a metric as to what conference gets the most teams in. At the end of the day, the teams will have to play 12 regular season games. You want to win as many of those as you can to get the best position to make a run.
With 24 teams, conferences won't matter much at all unless there is a guarantee by the CFP that certain conferences get a minimum number of teams in. I imagine you are going to see 20 P4 teams and 4 G6 teams make up the field. The G6 teams will be there to throw a bone to the whiners who complain about the mid majors getting left out. They will be scrimmages for the P4 teams they face. Every five or six years, a G6 team will win and advance to the second round and the highlights of that game will be shown every year.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,876
3,743
113
Wait until you have coaches sitting starters in the Bama/Auburn, USC/Clemson, UM/OSU, etc games to rest them up for the playoffs.
If college football rivalries are going to continue to mean anything, I think they'll have to move them to earlier in the season. We've already seen an OSU/Michigan game played with diminished importance. The OSU fans I know wanted to fire Day after they lost to Michigan, but when they subsequently won the national title, a new paradigm emerged.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,191
3,760
113
Well, one of the things that would have to happen is for a whole bunch of SEC teams to end up with 3 losses, so that the head-to-head data points are circular. There are currently 9 teams (not counting UGA) which could realistically end up with 3 losses. Obviously, with a number of games left to play, all 9 of those can't end up with three losses, but I was just wondering if we're actually mathematically eliminated. I doubt we are, but I imagine they are one-in-a-thousand odds.
I guess if we win out and UGA loses to MO Saturday, they would have 3 SEC losses and we would win the head to head with them. Unlikely, but possible.
 

Harvard Gamecock

All-Conference
May 5, 2014
3,478
3,193
113
In recent years, Miami/ND might have been an elimination game in the regular season.

This year? It didn't matter who win, they are both in.

I didn't look into it, but how badly hurt was the heisman hopeful at Miami? The wr? I wonder if he would have played if the playoffs weren't at 12?
He had surgery on his ankle. Will be out minimum of 4 weeks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,876
3,743
113
I guess if we win out and UGA loses to MO Saturday, they would have 3 SEC losses and we would win the head to head with them. Unlikely, but possible.
Well, we don't need UGA to lose another game for us to make the SECCG. I was thinking more like UGA ends up being the only 2-loss team and then SC, OU, UK, and TN end up being the only 3-loss teams. There may be some other scenarios where we have a chance of getting into the game, but I'm not sure what the tie-breakers are.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,191
3,760
113
Well, we don't need UGA to lose another game for us to make the SECCG. I was thinking more like UGA ends up being the only 2-loss team and then SC, OU, UK, and TN end up being the only 3-loss teams. There may be some other scenarios where we have a chance of getting into the game, but I'm not sure what the tie-breakers are.
Bama, UK, Texas and TN all only have 2 losses right now. We are tied with Ole Miss. LSU, MO and OU with 3 losses. It would be hard for us to get in without UGA losing its last two SEC games (one of which is with us).
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
769
326
63
Seems like great news if you're a Gamecock Fan.

We'll never be in a situation where any game is meaningless and we won't be jockeying for the Cheez-it Bowl each year.

Personally, I was never a big fan of Conference Championship games anyway.

With this setup, all the "best team in the country" has to do is win one more game to prove it.
 

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,057
803
113
Maybe now we can finally go back yo 1-A & 1-AA. The acronym titles were always stupid and then senseless once 1A began using a playoff.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Basketball Immaturity comes to forefront in second-half near-disaster for South Carolina men's basketball
  2. 02 TheBigSpur Football Dylan Stewart's availability looms large as South Carolina's defense faces Georgia
  3. 03 GamecockCentral Football Comparing South Carolina's roster talent to this week's opponent, the Georgia Bulldogs
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Football South Carolina's turnover struggles and why there's belief it will improve: 'Any time it can rain'
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Basketball The 3-2-1: Three positives, two negatives, and one burning question from South Carolina basketball's win over Elon