Will do. I'll check the numbers and anything he links once I finish reading the thread.
Now pulling the embedded tweets he's citing.
I read all 76 posts across both pages, plus the 24 X posts embedded in the thread and the four image attachments, and checked the main claims against reporting.
Overall: 3/10. TigerGrowls posted 31 of the 76 posts, mostly reposted X posts, and nobody engaged with the actual numbers until late on page 2.
Do the claims hold up?
Mostly no. Some of the raw numbers are real, but none of them show fraud.
The point that undercuts the fraud theory most is never mentioned in the thread: Abbott said he congratulated Democrat Gina Hinojosa on her win, and he did it "after looking at all the details of every county in the entire state." The Republican incumbent, in a state where his own party runs the elections, looked at the county data and conceded. hopefultiger13 was the only one who even came close to making this point.
"Presidential-level turnout" / "lines should've been around the block" (Ward, Montoya, Becker, MAGA Voice). False. Some 9.8 million Texans voted, the most in a Texas midterm since at least 1970, but turnout failed to set a record. 51.6% of registered voters cast ballots, beating 2022 but short of 2018's 53%. Turnout in 2024 was 61.2%. The raw totals are big because a record 19 million Texans were registered. In the words of the Texas Politics Project's research director, the win came from a national wave, not record turnout. A bigger Democratic share of a bigger electorate is all it takes.
Abbott "got more votes than any Republican gubernatorial candidate in Texas history" (the opening post, quoting Ward). False, and the thread disproves it: Montoya's post (#28) cites Abbott's 4.66M peak in 2018, and MAGA Voice's post (#37) shows 2018 at 4.6M vs. 2026 at 4.5M. TigerGrowls posted both without noticing they contradict his opening post.
Kyle Becker's "I was at a Collin County polling place, nothing unusual" (#35). This one is actually
consistent with the data, which is the funny part. Collin County turnout fell 3 points, from 61% in 2018 to 58% in 2026, and Montgomery County fell 4 points. The surge was somewhere else: turnout jumped more than 8 points in the state's 16 border counties compared with 2022. Becker watched the one kind of county that
didn't surge and assumed it was the whole state.
"All 254 counties shifted blue, impossible" (The SCIF, AustinConserve). That's what a wave election looks like. The Tribune found that compared with 2022, turnout and Democratic margins were higher in every kind of area: urban, suburban, exurban, rural and border. The opposite happened for years without anyone calling it fraud: 216 of the state's 254 counties have moved toward Republicans on average each cycle since 2016. The border swing is enormous but well documented. In Starr County, which is 96 percent Hispanic, Trump took 57 percent, and this year Talarico got more than 75 percent. That's yoshi's Latino point with numbers attached.
"97 counties have more voters than adult citizens" / Kevin Bass's "More votes than voters" (#71). Misleading, and Bass misstates his own source. The claim is about
registrations, not votes cast. One analysis found that inactive records explain most of the "overage," and active voters equal only 83.6 percent of adult citizens statewide in Texas. In the Texas counties on the viral map, each county's suspense list was larger than its posted "overage." Collin County, one of the counties in the claim, had 58% turnout. More votes than registered voters didn't happen anywhere.
Talarico's early votes topped Paxton's total (the image TigerGrowls posted with "Insane if true"). True: 4,397,474 early vs. 4,249,373 total. But that isn't strange in Texas, where most people vote early: more than 7.7 million voted early, beating the 2018 record. Most of the 9.8M votes were cast early, so a winning candidate's early votes beating the loser's total is just a 12-point win.
Bass: "polls had him up 2–3, he won by 14" (#32). The polling miss was real, but he inflated the margin. Talarico went in with a narrow polling lead and won by an unexpectedly large 12 points. A big polling miss in a wave year is not evidence of fraud.
Ericka Lomick won after suspending her campaign (MJTruthUltra, #59). True, but it's the opposite of suspicious. Her name stayed on the ballot because the deadline to remove it had passed, and she got about 51 percent. In a wave, people vote the party line without knowing who's on the ballot. If anything, that proves straight-ticket voting, not cheating.
"Why would voters pick Republicans for state races and Democrats for federal ones?" (JKash, #34). The state senate is half-cycled and gerrymandered, and ticket-splitting is normal. Jfcarter3 answered it in one line from personal experience.
Galveston, Paxton 52–46, "a county that actually counted its votes" (#68). I couldn't confirm that number. Even if it's right, it hurts him: Galveston is a deep-red county, so Paxton winning it by only 6 would itself be a big blue swing.
The rest: the posts from Lara Logan ("Stolen election. Whether anyone gets to prove it or not…"), Wayne Allyn Root, Jim Verdi ("no one knew Hinojosa") and HOTROD are pure assertion with no data to check. One research group tracking these claims named The SCIF, an X account that has posted many election denialist claims this cycle, and MJTruthUltra specifically. TigerGrowls posted both several times.
Best
hopefultiger13 (2 posts): the best post in the thread. He pointed out that Republicans run Texas elections and drew the maps. So either Democrats didn't cheat, or they did and Trump's people were too incompetent to stop it in their most important state. That trap is unanswerable, and TigerGrowls didn't try.
dpic73 (14 posts): did the most actual rebutting. He brought in the Rehmet/Tarrant County special election as an early warning sign, the Pudge post showing 2018 turnout was 177% of 2014 (so a big jump isn't unprecedented), and the Ossoff/Cooper comparison. He also wrote the best one-line summary of the thread: TG's evidence amounts to a lot of people voting for candidates he didn't like. Knocks:
- He pasted a Grok answer as a source.
- He oversold the national picture with "same in every single state."
- Several of his posts were gif-only filler.
Jfcarter3 and Aardvark86. Jfcarter3 split his own ticket in SC, which answers the JKash post outright. Aardvark86's brother-in-law's joke ("regime change in a heavily armed, oil-rich country… unfortunately it was Texas") was the funniest thing in the thread.
yoshi121374 (7 posts): right on the substance, sloppy on tone. The point that attacking Latinos drives Latinos to vote against you is backed by the border numbers. He also caught TigerGrowls liking Scrubby's "sus" post right after saying he "hasn't claimed fraud yet." But the "touch you in your no-no place" line was crude and cheap.
Worst
TigerGrowls (31 posts, 41% of the thread): the worst poster, by a lot.
- He passes off other people's posts as his own words. Posts #0, #28, #35, #37 and #69 are X text pasted with no attribution and an embed underneath. That's how ClemsonInAtlanta ended up mocking "his" Collin County poll-watching story, which was actually Kyle Becker's. The "retard numbers" line in the opening post is also Ward's text, but TG posted it as his own.
- He moves the goalposts. He says "Haven't claimed it yet" in post #6, then "I do suspect fraud" in #9, then "This story will have legs."
- He hides behind JAQing. "I'm just putting info out for people to see. I'm not worried about being seen as wrong." He never responded to a single rebuttal, whether hopefultiger13's, dpic's or the Pudge numbers. He just posted the next X screenshot.
- His insults have no argument behind them: "dark blue kool-aid drinker," "5th grade level math like Jethro Bodine."
- He doesn't read his own sources. He posted Abbott's 2018 peak twice while defending a claim that 2026 was Abbott's record.
- Small credit: "Insane if true" and "let's see if they come out with evidence" at least gesture at needing proof, and he admitted the anti-MAGA Red State Movers post was funny.
ClemsonCO14, firegiver, Ghee Buttersnaps 2, fskillet: pure noise. "Election conspiracy pacifier," "COPE!!!", "these pussies won't riot," "MAGA tears." Between them that's six posts and zero content.
LafayetteBear (2 posts). "Repugnicants" and "MAGAts" are lazy. He asked the right question ("so what's your point?") but botched it: Beto ran in 2022, not 2024.
Scrubby (2 posts). He cosigned "pretty sus at face value," made a board-bet joke, and added nothing else.
Moogy (6 posts)
The language went too far. "Chinese troll bot" is an accusation with nothing behind it. "Seek treatment," "mentally disturbed," "romanticizes serial killers" and "work during the daytime" are cheap shots that make it easy for TG to dismiss the whole post. That needed toning down.
But his core point holds, and this thread is the proof. TG accepts weak evidence, never updates, and falls back on "I disagree" once he's out of arguments. Moogy predicted "I know, I know… you disagree," and TG answered "Yes I do Moogy" in the very next post. Calling out the welched board bet is fair game too. He doesn't belong on the worst list for being harsh toward someone who earned it.