1.65 multiplier to 2.5

Jul 3, 2025
800
770
93
I don’t see why this can’t be worked out with the SF on an individual team basis. Think about it, this 2.5 thing is all about eleven CCL teams that have pretty consistent playoff success. The two teams that are the most heavily favored to win it all every year, LA and MC, would not be affected by an increase in the multiplier. That leaves nine teams in the entire state, BR, Rita, JCA, Fenwick, Naz, Provi, SF, Montini and IC. All of these teams vary year to year and would be brought down by the SF which is similar to a 2.5 multiplier. As for the rest of the states privates, is there really a need to impose a 2.5 multiplier on the likes of NND, St Pats, Marmion, Wheaton Academy, B Mac Altof, ACC or Hope? I think not
Two "rest of state" programs likely "deserve" to be multiplied consistently and/or success factored... Newman and SHG. The rest are average programs 7 to 10 out of 10 years...

Alton and Ottawa Marquette
Decatur St. Teresa
RI Alleman
BCC
QND
PND
St. Bede
Routt

I think that's the rest of them... not a lot of success there outside of one off years and maybe DST and BCC who've had nice pockets of success. I think outside of DST only BCC and Alleman have even made it past the semi's... Maybe Routt did once... I'm not sure.
 

RobertS68

Redshirt
Oct 26, 2026
3
1
0
I'm a downstate public school guy. But can acknowledge this is a convoluted issue. I'm sure the IHSA doesn't want to split the private schools out into their own playoff unless they can figure out a way to put that $ in their own coffers.

But privates/non boundaried schools can & sometimes do have an advantage when they can go into a neighboring town to get a few highly skilled players. The trick is not all private schools do that.

One thought I have had is why couldn't this work sort of like the co-op enrollments work. I believe in a co-op, once you co-op you combine the 2 enrollments to form the total for IHSA purposes. Someone correct if I am wrong.

Assuming I am correct on the above, could not a similar logic be applied where the private gets a designated area within their boundaries to operate (3 miles, city limits, etc would need to be negotiated) but once that school picks up a player from "out of district" that schools enrollment is combined. This would effectively put the schools that bring in the most out of district players into a much higher classification than a similar sized school that doesn't get their QB from the next town down the road. Not perfect I am sure but it would have an element of flexibility to it based on how much a given school takes in from outside their boundaries.

And I know some could play chicanery with addresses to try to get around the rules but we all know there are public schools that do that today.

Just a thought I have had. No dog in the fight just a fan of high school football & basketball.
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
817
573
93
Two "rest of state" programs likely "deserve" to be multiplied consistently and/or success factored... Newman and SHG. The rest are average programs 7 to 10 out of 10 years...

Alton and Ottawa Marquette
Decatur St. Teresa
RI Alleman
BCC
QND
PND
St. Bede
Routt

I think that's the rest of them... not a lot of success there outside of one off years and maybe DST and BCC who've had nice pockets of success. I think outside of DST only BCC and Alleman have even made it past the semi's... Maybe Routt did once... I'm not sure.
I don’t think SHG or Newman should be multiplied either. They are constantly in the hunt and on par with teams when not multiplied.
 
Jul 3, 2025
800
770
93
I don’t think SHG or Newman should be multiplied either. They are constantly in the hunt and on par with teams when not multiplied.
Disagree. SHG has been in 4A four times including this year, so undetermined on that one, but 4 times since 8 class was brought on in 2001... twice they've gone to state, and a very good chance still they'll be back for a 3rd time in 4 tries in 4A... They've played for a state title 9 times since 2001... won 6 of them... only twice in 4A... one a title, one 2nd place... rest were 5A/6A...

And if you remove SHG and Newman from the equation... the rest of the "non-Chicagoland" private schools only account for 5 titles of the 15 won by that "downstate / non-Chicagoland" group. Newman and SHG have a combined 10 since 2001... Boylan 2, Althoff 1, BCC 1, St. Teresa 1.

257 combined playoff appearances since 2001 by the 15 schools I'm talking about here... 15 titles... 10 of them are those the two mentioned in your comment. Just saying...

I get what you're saying, but there's 2 dominant private schools outside that bubble... and they're Newman and SHG...
 
Last edited:
Jul 3, 2025
800
770
93
This is for the 15 private schools outside of the general Chicagoland area...

Football
with the 2.5 multiplier... all but 3 teams (Routt, QND, Alton Marquette) would move up at least 1 class. 3 teams would see a 2 class jump (Newman, Lutheran, SHG)

In the major "other" sports... (Boys/Girls Basketball, Boys/Girls Soccer, Baseball, Softball, Girls Volleyball)
T
rophies earned since 2007, which I believe is when the 4 class system began...

Routt - 5 (1 state title baseball)
Ottawa Marquette - 6 (all baseball, 3 state titles)
Newman - 6 (state titles in Boys B-ball, Softball, Girls VB)
St. Teresa - 6 (4 trophies in Girls VB, 1 title each in GVB, Boys Soccer)
Rockford Lutheran - 7 (no state titles)
St. Bede - 2 (no state titles)
Alleman - 4 (no state titles)
Mater Dei - 13 (9 in Girls VB. 4 state titles in GVB, 1 title in Girls B-ball)
Althoff - 10 (1 state title each in Boys B-ball, Girls VB, Boys Soccer)
BCC - 13 (3 state titles, 1 each in Boys B-ball, Girls B-ball, Girls VB)
QND - 24 (16 combined in Girls B-ball and Girls Soccer. 14 state titles combined all sports listed)
Alton Marquette - 11 (3 state titles)
Boylan - 4 (all boys soccer, 2 state titles)
PND - 14 (9 in boys soccer, 4 state titles in boys soccer, 1 title in girls b-ball)
SHG - 9 (1 each state title in boys b-ball and baseball)
 

Colin2299

Senior
Aug 13, 2025
817
573
93
Disagree. SHG has been in 4A four times including this year, so undetermined on that one, but 4 times since 8 class was brought on in 2001... twice they've gone to state, and a very good chance still they'll be back for a 3rd time in 4 tries in 4A... They've played for a state title 9 times since 2001... won 6 of them... only twice in 4A... one a title, one 2nd place... rest were 5A/6A...

And if you remove SHG and Newman from the equation... the rest of the "non-Chicagoland" private schools only account for 5 titles of the 15 won by that "downstate / non-Chicagoland" group. Newman and SHG have a combined 10 since 2001... Boylan 2, Althoff 1, BCC 1, St. Teresa 1.

257 combined playoff appearances since 2001 by the 15 schools I'm talking about here... 15 titles... 10 of them are those the two mentioned in your comment. Just saying...

I get what you're saying, but there's 2 dominant private schools outside that bubble... and they're Newman and SHG...
Now provide the stats for both programs with out Coach Papoccia and Coach Leonard.
 

Anon232446

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2026
25
34
13
I think you’re on to something. A special 9A for any enrollment over, say, 7,000. Then we hang like an 8.0 multiplier on MC and LA only. Those two teams will play for the 9A title every year and the public’s get their shot at 8A😂
The semi-final between Mt. Carmel and Berwyn-Cicero Morton (7172 enrollment) would be must see TV! 🤣
 
  • Haha
Reactions: DirtySixThirty

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
719
361
51
The semi-final between Mt. Carmel and Berwyn-Cicero Morton (7172 enrollment) would be must see TV! 🤣
Darn! Then make it 8,000 and a multiplier of 9. In all seriousness, I think a misunderstood the reasoning behind the 2.5 when I suggested the SF instead. the issue they have with using only theSF is that, well, it requires success before it kicks in. The goal of a 2.5 is to eliminate any chance of success. In other words , they want these teams gone by the second round
 

Anon232446

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2026
25
34
13
Darn! Then make it 8,000 and a multiplier of 9. In all seriousness, I think a misunderstood the reasoning behind the 2.5 when I suggested the SF instead. the issue they have with using only theSF is that, well, it requires success before it kicks in. The goal of a 2.5 is to eliminate any chance of success. In other words , they want these teams gone by the second round
Why would big public schools vote for this? If you increase the multiplier now JCA, Naz, Fenwick, Provi, St Francis etc. are all 7A or 8A. Adding all those teams into those classes makes the path for a public school that much more difficult. Public schools have won 17 of the 24 8A championships since going to 8 classes and 15 of the 24 7A championships. This would just add so much more depth to those classes making the path to a championship that much harder.
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,168
4,579
113
Why would big public schools vote for this? If you increase the multiplier now JCA, Naz, Fenwick, Provi, St Francis etc. are all 7A or 8A. Adding all those teams into those classes makes the path for a public school that much more difficult. Public schools have won 17 of the 24 8A championships since going to 8 classes and 15 of the 24 7A championships. This would just add so much more depth to those classes making the path to a championship that much harder.
Again, it's for all sports, not just football. It may hinder large public schools in football, but benefit them in multiple other sports.
 

JCHillmen10

Junior
Jul 29, 2025
193
266
63
Again, it's for all sports, not just football. It may hinder large public schools in football, but benefit them in multiple other sports.
I don't think it benefits any public school traditionally in 7A/8A for football, 4A for the 4 class sports like basketball, or 3A for the 3 class sports like soccer. It just bumps more potentially competitive schools up into that class. Why does Lyons Township baseball want to add Naz baseball or St. Rita baseball to their postseason path? Why does Lockport soccer want to add DeLaSalle or Peoria Notre Dame to their postseason path?

This proposal is good for public schools in 1A-5A for football and for 1A and 2A schools in four class system sports.
 

Anon232446

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2026
25
34
13
I don't think it benefits any public school traditionally in 7A/8A for football, 4A for the 4 class sports like basketball, or 3A for the 3 class sports like soccer. It just bumps more schools up into that class. Why does Lyons Township baseball want to add Naz baseball or St. Rita baseball to their postseason path? Why does Lockport soccer want to add DeLaSalle or Peoria Notre Dame to their postseason path?

This proposal is good for public schools in 1A-5A for football and for 1A and 2A schools in four class system sports.
Exactly! Don't see how it could benefit a big school in any sport outside of a school that is on the low end of the higher class bubble getting bumped down into a lower class.

As already mentioned, this is also not good for non-boundary CPS schools. So a coalition of privates, big publics and CPS could take down this vote. However, apparently the IHSA can implement certain by laws without even putting them to a vote. Anyone know how that works?
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,168
4,579
113
I don't think it benefits any public school traditionally in 7A/8A for football, 4A for the 4 class sports like basketball, or 3A for the 3 class sports like soccer. It just bumps more schools up into that class. Why does Lyons Township baseball want to add Naz baseball to their postseason path? Why does Lockport soccer want to add DeLaSalle to their postseason path?

This proposal is good for public schools in 1A-5A and for 1A and 2A schools in a four class system.
Because you're cherry picking the best teams in each sport in your example. Naz baseball would move up a class, but so would schools like Carmel and Marmion and there's only 8 CCL teams that even field a boys soccer team
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,168
4,579
113
Exactly! Don't see how it could benefit a big school in any sport outside of a school that is on the low end of the higher class bubble getting bumped down into a lower class.

As already mentioned, this is also not good for non-boundary CPS schools. So a coalition of privates, big publics and CPS could take down this vote. However, apparently the IHSA can implement certain by laws without even putting them to a vote. Anyone know how that works?
It already passed once when it increased to 1.65.
 

Anon232446

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2026
25
34
13
It already passed once when it increased to 1.65.
And before it went into effect in 2005 the public schools were 8/8 in winning classes 7 and 8A in the 8 class system. So should big public schools not look at this, albeit a small simple size and maybe think it's not in their best interest?

Note: It's hard to see the impact in other sports because they did not go 4 classes until after this went into effect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4Afan

ramblinman reborn

Sophomore
Aug 15, 2025
184
192
43
But privates/non boundaried schools can & sometimes do have an advantage when they can go into a neighboring town to get a few highly skilled players. The trick is not all private schools do that.

It's a lot easier said than done for private schools to "get" players.

Assuming I am correct on the above, could not a similar logic be applied where the private gets a designated area within their boundaries to operate (3 miles, city limits, etc would need to be negotiated) but once that school picks up a player from "out of district" that schools enrollment is combined. This would effectively put the schools that bring in the most out of district players into a much higher classification than a similar sized school that doesn't get their QB from the next town down the road. Not perfect I am sure but it would have an element of flexibility to it based on how much a given school takes in from outside their boundaries.

You are looking at this completely through a public school lens when you try to apply the concept of a public school district to private schools.

Since you are a downstate guy, let's look at the example of Mater Dei in Breese. Mater Dei is a private school of 383 students that happens to be located in a district served by a 4A public school. For the sake of discussion, let's assume that Mater Dei has maybe 25% of its students residing in high school districts other than the one where Mater Dei happens to be located. Of those kids, let's assume that at least one of them plays football.

What do you want to do to Mater Dei now that they are enrolling at least one football player who lives in a public school district other the one where Mater Dei happens to be located? "Combine" their enrollment? Combine with what? Or do you mean multiply? Multiply them by a factor of what? 1.6? That's what we do now, and Mater Dei's multiplied enrollment of 544 puts them in 3A (where they lost their first playoff game this year to a public school). 2.5? That would bump them to 4A. So, let's assume you mean apply a multiplier of 2.5 to Mater Dei and bump them to 4A because they enroll football playing students (who may or may not be high impact players) from other districts than the one where Mater Dei happens to be located.

Let's look more closely at how Mater Dei has translated the ability to enroll football playing students outside the district where they are located into success on the football field. First of all, Mater Dei has never won a state championship in football. They have made the playoffs 30 times, where they have a record of 34-30. Successful? Yes, to the degree that a .531 winning percentage is considered successful. Extraordinarily successful? No. More recently, Mater Dei has qualified for the playoffs 6 times in the past 10 years where they have a record of 8-6 (.571 winning percentage). Four of their six losses have come at the hands of public schools.

The ability to enroll student athletes from out of town or out of district or whatever geographic limitation you think is appropriate does not necessarily translate into extraordinary athletic success.

Please explain why a school like Mater Dei needs to be multiplied in football.
 
Last edited:

JCHillmen10

Junior
Jul 29, 2025
193
266
63
Because you're cherry picking the best teams in each sport in your example. Naz baseball would move up a class, but so would schools like Carmel and Marmion and there's only 8 CCL teams that even field a boys soccer team
There are 24 CCL soccer teams. Three divisions of 8 teams each.


If Naz and Joliet Catholic bump up to 4A baseball, there would certainly be a few less competitive schools that would join them. But it is almost certain that the random lowest enrollment 4A public schools dropping down to 3A would have fewer state title contenders than the CCL schools bumping up because if there are 10 large 3A private schools that bump up, 3-5 of them are likely to be contenders to make a deep run. Of the 10 random public schools relegated down, there is very little chance 3-5 of them are contenders to make deep runs.
 

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,168
4,579
113
There are 24 CCL soccer teams. Three divisions of 8 teams each.


If Naz and Joliet Catholic bump up to 4A baseball, there would certainly be a few less competitive schools that would join them. But it is almost certain that the random lowest enrollment 4A public schools dropping down to 3A would have fewer state title contenders than the CCL schools bumping up because if there are 10 large 3A private schools that bump up, 3-5 of them are likely to be contenders to make a deep run. Of the 10 random public schools relegated down, there is very little chance 3-5 of them are contenders to make deep runs.
Intersting. IHSA only shows standings for 8 boys soccer teams.

 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
719
361
51
The ability to enroll student athletes from out of town or out of district or whatever geographic limitation you think is appropriate does not necessarily translate into extraordinary athletic success.
Correct. You could expand Viator’s radius to fifty miles with free busing and talented players are still going to go to places like Hersey, Fremd, Main S and LA
 
Jul 3, 2025
800
770
93
Now provide the stats for both programs with out Coach Papoccia and Coach Leonard.
Newman 2019... after a 5 year gap which happened twice during Papoccia's run.
Since 2003 SHG has never gone more than 4 years without a trip to state... this is year 4 for Allison... and easily, talent-wise, his best opportunity to go to state.

I mean, brother, I'm the first person to ask if you want negative feedback on John Allison at SHG... We can have that discussion if you'd like.
But in the end you need athletes... Allison will still get athletes handed to him. And in 4A, his only comp is Rochester, who has ran thru 4A for the better part of 15 years with few speed bumps slowing them down along the way. With smaller kids and less money than their private counterpart. Montini in 4A is similar... Althoff going to 1A consistently would produce the same... Allison gets the draw from a population of around 200,000... very few coaches outside the Chicago area get the same... Frank Lenti left CMC and the winning just kept happening... Providence, Loyola both have had multiple coaches go nuts and win titles...
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
I'm a downstate public school guy. But can acknowledge this is a convoluted issue. I'm sure the IHSA doesn't want to split the private schools out into their own playoff unless they can figure out a way to put that $ in their own coffers.

But privates/non boundaried schools can & sometimes do have an advantage when they can go into a neighboring town to get a few highly skilled players. The trick is not all private schools do that.

One thought I have had is why couldn't this work sort of like the co-op enrollments work. I believe in a co-op, once you co-op you combine the 2 enrollments to form the total for IHSA purposes. Someone correct if I am wrong.

Assuming I am correct on the above, could not a similar logic be applied where the private gets a designated area within their boundaries to operate (3 miles, city limits, etc would need to be negotiated) but once that school picks up a player from "out of district" that schools enrollment is combined. This would effectively put the schools that bring in the most out of district players into a much higher classification than a similar sized school that doesn't get their QB from the next town down the road. Not perfect I am sure but it would have an element of flexibility to it based on how much a given school takes in from outside their boundaries.
They do have a designated area to compete in athletics, 30 miles. All private schools attract kids from 5, 10, 15, 20, 30 or more miles away, athletes or mathletes or just students.
 
Last edited:

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,272
2,608
93
I don’t see why this can’t be worked out with the SF on an individual team basis. Think about it, this 2.5 thing is all about eleven CCL teams that have pretty consistent playoff success. The two teams that are the most heavily favored to win it all every year, LA and MC, would not be affected by an increase in the multiplier. That leaves nine teams in the entire state, BR, Rita, JCA, Fenwick, Naz, Provi, SF, Montini and IC. All of these teams vary year to year and would be brought down by the SF which is similar to a 2.5 multiplier. As for the rest of the states privates, is there really a need to impose a 2.5 multiplier on the likes of NND, St Pats, Marmion, Wheaton Academy, B Mac Altof, ACC or Hope? I think not
You are ONLY looking at football and this is way bigger than football.

Here is my question to CCL Guys. If its only 11 teams creating the issue, why can't the leaders force those teams to petition up and play teams that are more like them. If those teams you mentioned were 6A and above in football at 3A/4A in other sports, you would get these type of proposals.
 

ramblinman reborn

Sophomore
Aug 15, 2025
184
192
43
You are ONLY looking at football and this is way bigger than football.

Here is my question to CCL Guys. If its only 11 teams creating the issue, why can't the leaders force those teams to petition up and play teams that are more like them. If those teams you mentioned were 6A and above in football at 3A/4A in other sports, you would get these type of proposals.
Here is my question for you: Why can't a school like Fenwick be allowed to win a state title once in a while without being penalized for it?
 

LHSTigers94

All-Conference
Oct 25, 2004
3,272
2,608
93
It's a lot easier said than done for private schools to "get" players.



You are looking at this completely through a public school lens when you try to apply the concept of a public school district to private schools.

Since you are a downstate guy, let's look at the example of Mater Dei in Breese. Mater Dei is a private school of 383 students that happens to be located in a district served by a 4A public school. For the sake of discussion, let's assume that Mater Dei has maybe 25% of its students residing in high school districts other than the one where Mater Dei happens to be located. Of those kids, let's assume that at least one of them plays football.

What do you want to do to Mater Dei now that they are enrolling at least one football player who lives in a public school district other the one where Mater Dei happens to be located? "Combine" their enrollment? Combine with what? Or do you mean multiply? Multiply them by a factor of what? 1.6? That's what we do now, and Mater Dei's multiplied enrollment of 544 puts them in 3A (where they lost their first playoff game this year to a public school). 2.5? That would bump them to 4A. So, let's assume you mean apply a multiplier of 2.5 to Mater Dei and bump them to 4A because they enroll football playing students (who may or may not be high impact players) from other districts than the one where Mater Dei happens to be located.

Let's look more closely at how Mater Dei has translated the ability to enroll football playing students outside the district where they are located into success on the football field. First of all, Mater Dei has never won a state championship in football. They have made the playoffs 30 times, where they have a record of 34-30. Successful? Yes, to the degree that a .531 winning percentage is considered successful. Extraordinarily successful? No. More recently, Mater Dei has qualified for the playoffs 6 times in the past 10 years where they have a record of 8-6 (.571 winning percentage). Four of their six losses have come at the hands of public schools.

The ability to enroll student athletes from out of town or out of district or whatever geographic limitation you think is appropriate does not necessarily translate into extraordinary athletic success.

Please explain why a school like Mater Dei needs to be multiplied in football.
Why don't they? If they want better success, improve on coaching and train better right? I

It's not designed to win, its designed to be competitive. 500 winning percentage proves that its competitive for them.
 

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
You are ONLY looking at football and this is way bigger than football.

Here is my question to CCL Guys. If its only 11 teams creating the issue, why can't the leaders force those teams to petition up and play teams that are more like them. If those teams you mentioned were 6A and above in football at 3A/4A in other sports, you would get these type of proposals.
Agree this is more than football but since this is a football board I will focus on football but your point is valid.

LA and MC should petition up to DI? They are pretty much excluded from this conversation for right now.
Rita already petitions up. I am also excluding them since they petition up and are a very good 7A team but do not see them as being an issue team/program for this conversation, no offense to Rita they are playing 2 classes, if I am correct, above there actual class.

That leaves 8 teams.
BR - I guess they could petition to 8A. Won last year and could be back to get SC'd up to 8A. BR with 2 titles and 2nd place finishes in their history.
JCA - They are up in 6A and we see how that is going. They will be in 5A next year.
Naz - they are up in 6A, lost in semifinals last year, TBD this year.
Fenwick - Won 6A last year, solid this year and won 5A in 2021. Are they really a problem?
Providence - 2nd place last year and favorite this year, won 4A a few years back with that weird multiplier year. They will most likely be up in 6A next year.
SF - won 5A for the second championship ever. Good chance to get to champ game, would put them in 6A next year. Had some good close games against public schools last year on way to championship.
Montini - pretty average few years before Abrams. If they make champ game they will be 5A next year but could also lose to a public school in R2. I would expect them to be good but not last two years good.
IC - Lost in Quarters last year, good chance to win 3A and will be very good next year. Have a generational talent, son of a coach on staff.

With that said 5A is the class that is weird. I can see private schools bouncing back and forth from 5 to 6 and dominating 5A.
So out of the 8 above, who are the teams that are causing the big issues? Other than 8A a team can only dominate for 2 years before getting bumped up. I guess I am not sure why Saint Francis should have requested to play up after winning their second championship in the schools history. If they get to championship game this year they get bumped, doesn't that solve it?
 
Last edited:

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
Why don't they? If they want better success, improve on coaching and train better right? I

It's not designed to win, its designed to be competitive. 500 winning percentage proves that its competitive for them.
Isn't that the point of all of this, for teams to be in a class they are competitive in? You want to move the dominate ones up not the ones that are competative.
 

HRCJRHRCJR

Redshirt
Oct 28, 2025
37
35
18

4Afan

All-Conference
Sep 15, 2001
5,168
4,579
113

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
That was pointed out. Odd that the IHSA only shows 8.

They have these schools in East Suburban Catholic Conference but that is only 15.

 

Anon232446

Redshirt
Sep 30, 2026
25
34
13
Agree this is more than football but since this is a football board I will focus on football but your point is valid.

LA and MC should petition up to DI? They are pretty much excluded from this conversation for right now.
Rita already petitions up. I am also excluding them since they petition up and are a very good 7A team but do not see them as being an issue team/program for this conversation, no offense to Rita they are playing 2 classes, if I am correct, above there actual class.

That leaves 8 teams.
BR - I guess they could petition to 8A. Won last year and could be back to get SC'd up to 8A. BR with 2 titles and 2nd place finishes in their history.
JCA - They are up in 6A and we see how that is going. They will be in 5A next year.
Naz - they are up in 6A, lost in semifinals last year, TBD this year.
Fenwick - Won 6A last year, solid this year and won 5A in 2021. Are they really a problem?
Providence - 2nd place last year and favorite this year, won 4A a few years back with that weird multiplier year. They will most likely be up in 6A next year.
SF - won 5A for the second championship ever. Good chance to get to champ game, would put them in 6A next year. Had some good close games against public schools last year on way to championship.
Montini - pretty average few years before Abrams. If they make champ game they will be 5A next year but could also lose to a public school in R2. I would expect them to be good but not last two years good.
IC - Lost in Quarters last year, good chance to win 3A and will be very good next year. Have a generational talent, son of a coach on staff.

With that said 5A is the class that is weird. I can see private schools bouncing back and forth from 5 to 6 and dominating 5A.
So out of the 8 above, who are the teams that are causing the big issues? Other than 8A a team can only dominate for 2 years before getting bumped up. I guess I am not sure why Saint Francis should have requested to play up after winning their second championship in the schools history. If they get to championship game this year they get bumped, doesn't that solve it?
20/24 5A championships since going to 8 classes have been won by a private school! I think a part of the issue is teams bouncing down a class after showing they can succeed in a higher class. Let's say Naz makes the semis this year and loses, next year they are back in 5A despite the fact they made the semis two years in a row in 6A. You point out JCA, but by all accounts from JCA followers the last 2 years teams have not been typical JCA teams. If they were in 5A the last two years they would be competing for titles. Teams shouldn't be winning or competing for titles in down years. That's a clear indication they are in the wrong class. I think 6A is perfectly fine for JCA and they will handle themselves quite well once their strong freshmen class becomes Jrs and Srs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: USD24

SiuCubFan8

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2007
6,683
4,419
113
20/24 5A championships since going to 8 classes have been won by a private school! I think a part of the issue is teams bouncing down a class after showing they can succeed in a higher class. Let's say Naz makes the semis this year and loses, next year they are back in 5A despite the fact they made the semis two years in a row in 6A. You point out JCA, but by all accounts from JCA followers the last 2 years teams have not been typical JCA teams. If they were in 5A the last two years they would be competing for titles. Teams shouldn't be winning or competing for titles in down years. That's a clear indication they are in the wrong class. I think 6A is perfectly fine for JCA and they will handle themselves quite well once their strong freshmen class becomes Jrs and Srs.

Again I said 5A is a weird one. And with PR and C-G being not as good as they have been over 10 years hurts. The public schools in 5A are not that good when you strip out those two historically strong teams. I know C-G had been 6A and is now in 5A. Heck one of the public champions in 5A was from Rochester who isn't landing in 5A anymore. 5A just seems like a class that sets up for private schools to have success in for multitude of reasons. But is that a reason to enact a 2.5 multiplier? I don't know.
 
Last edited:
Jul 3, 2025
800
770
93
So now privates can't win regionals? How the... First it was titles... then it was "we (the public schools) would rather them not make the semi's either"

Now we skipping to regionals? 🤷‍♂️ What's the end result for you? Publics show up in the correct uniform and they win?
 

CCL65

Junior
Oct 28, 2015
719
361
51
Again I said 5A is a weird one. And with PR and C-G being not as good as they have been over 10 years hurts. The public schools in 5A are not that good when you strip out those two historically strong teams. I know C-G had been 6A and is now in 5A. Heck one of the public champions in 5A was from Rochester who isn't landing in 5A anymore. 5A just seems like a class that sets up for private schools to have success in for multitude of reasons. But is that a reason to enact a 2.5 multiplier? I don't know.
And this should be the last year for a couple for SF or PC or maybe both
 

ramblinman reborn

Sophomore
Aug 15, 2025
184
192
43
Why don't they? If they want better success, improve on coaching and train better right? I

It's not designed to win, its designed to be competitive. 500 winning percentage proves that its competitive for them.
So, Mater Dei, we are going to move you up to 3A, where you will be "competitive," but we won't let you have a shot at winning your first football title ever in the class where most schools with your actual enrollment are playing. Move along now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roamin' Catholic
Edgy Tim

Latest

  1. 01 Edgy Tim Football FREE Video 2A: Wilmington 49 Peotone 27
  2. 02 The Wolverine Football Recruiting From The Road: Intel on Michigan's top Chicagoland recruits
  3. 03 Edgy Tim Football Video 8A: Mount Carmel 21 LW East 16
  4. 04 Edgy Tim Football Week 14 EDGYTIM Chicagoland Top 30
  5. 05 SpartanMag Football Michigan State HC Pat Fitzgerald gives health update on Alessio Milivojevic