Credit Card Surcharges

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
When and why did this become so commonplace?

I find this just as despicable a business practice as asking for tips for non-traditional services because you don’t want to pay your staff more. Credit card companies have always charged you fees, and you have always baked them into the price.

I’ve only noticed in the last 18-24 months that everyone is now charging fees. Very rarely does it make financial sense to use a credit card if you’re paying an extra 3%, but I also don’t want to carry a debit card around just to make their lives easier. I would pay cash, but I’m not going to give you money you may not report if you’re going to charge me extra for using a credit card.
 

2forheels

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2025
1,459
1,162
113
This morning I ordered several new eyeglasses. There was a $50 credit card surcharge. I told then I go to several businesses that write off the surcharge because they don't want to lose customers and they already charge more than enough for their goods anyway. I could have easily paid with my debit card but I walked out. This is a place I have done business with for over 30 years.

They called me and said they would waive the fee. I told them they could have done that in the store. I told them I'll think about it and call you tomorrow.

Of course I need the glasses and I will relent, but I'm trying to make a point to them.
 

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
This morning I ordered several new eyeglasses. There was a $50 credit card surcharge. I told then I go to several businesses that write off the surcharge because they don't want to lose customers and they already charge more than enough for their goods anyway. I could have easily paid with my debit card but I walked out. This is a place I have done business with for over 30 years.

They called me and said they would waive the fee. I told them they could have done that in the store. I told them I'll think about it and call you tomorrow.

Of course I need the glasses and I will relent, but I'm trying to make a point to them.

Good for you walking out on them!

The experience that lead me to make the post was a $95 surcharge on a dental surgery this morning. I didn’t have my debit card on me or even think much about it until it was too late, but I think I was in shock that a professional business would throw that on such a large bill.

If you’re a mom and pop restaurant or business I don’t agree with it, but I’m at least empathetic to your situation. This felt icky. It was a periodontal specialist, so it’s not like I’m price shopping for the best deal. I drove 90 minutes each way because that’s who my dentist referred me to.

A business makes a choice on whether to accept credit cards of not. If you’re going to, bake it into your pricing. It’s part of your overhead. Do you itemize all of your expenses and offer your customers a la carte pricing on them, or is that just for credit card fees and employee wages?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2forheels

Heel Alum

Senior
Jul 23, 2025
634
788
93
Good for you walking out on them!

The experience that lead me to make the post was a $95 surcharge on a dental surgery this morning. I didn’t have my debit card on me or even think much about it until it was too late, but I think I was in shock that a professional business would throw that on such a large bill.

If you’re a mom and pop restaurant or business I don’t agree with it, but I’m at least empathetic to your situation. This felt icky. It was a periodontal specialist, so it’s not like I’m price shopping for the best deal. I drove 90 minutes each way because that’s who my dentist referred me to.

A business makes a choice on whether to accept credit cards of not. If you’re going to, bake it into your pricing. It’s part of your overhead. Do you itemize all of your expenses and offer your customers a la carte pricing on them, or is that just for credit card fees and employee wages?
complete garbage fee and you should be miffed
 
  • Like
Reactions: PINEHEEL

kc_heel

Redshirt
Jul 31, 2025
5
3
3
You see it a lot more now because the credit card companies had policies against charging extra fees until a couple of years ago. Once they started allowing it, a ton of businesses started charging. I don' t do it at my stores I have but it has been tempting since it has become so commonplace.

I average around $1500 a month in CC fees and unfortunately I can't just increase prices across the board to cover. The majority of what I collect in the stores every month is the NC sales tax on high end phones. Not like I can increase the sales tax. So it is just a cost I absorb every month.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mpaer and 1992Heel

SomeBeach1

Redshirt
Aug 11, 2025
35
30
18
You see it a lot more now because the credit card companies had policies against charging extra fees until a couple of years ago. Once they started allowing it, a ton of businesses started charging. I don' t do it at my stores I have but it has been tempting since it has become so commonplace.

I average around $1500 a month in CC fees and unfortunately I can't just increase prices across the board to cover. The majority of what I collect in the stores every month is the NC sales tax on high end phones. Not like I can increase the sales tax. So it is just a cost I absorb every month.
That's a tough model. Just remember that not paying NC that sales tax you collected is embezzling
 

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
I understand and mostly agree, but if the company bakes it into their price, isn't the resulting cost the same?

Definitely, but IMO it's much more offensive and sleazy to itemize it out like it's a separate tax you have no control over. Credit cards are mutually beneficial for the seller and the consumer. A surcharge makes it very clear that you're not willing to share the expense, but have no problem reaping your share of the benefits.

Advantages for the seller:

- You don't have to handle cash, checks, etc. It's a true nuisance that costs time and more money than the cc companies charge you in fees.
- It makes accounting easier
- Improved cash flow
- Less debt collection. Debt or insufficient funds becomes the CC company's problem; not yours.

Businesses have no problem accepting the benefits of allowing their customers to pay for goods with cards, but now they're transparently passing all of the costs onto the consumer?
 
Last edited:

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
You see it a lot more now because the credit card companies had policies against charging extra fees until a couple of years ago. Once they started allowing it, a ton of businesses started charging. I don' t do it at my stores I have but it has been tempting since it has become so commonplace.

I average around $1500 a month in CC fees and unfortunately I can't just increase prices across the board to cover. The majority of what I collect in the stores every month is the NC sales tax on high end phones. Not like I can increase the sales tax. So it is just a cost I absorb every month.

So what will happen when consumers aren't willing to pay those fees any longer? I don't mind paying in cash, but I'm not going to do it for a business that is charging credit card fees. I'm going to make damn sure they have to deal with a paper trail if they're putting me through the inconvenience.

I guess my bigger question is, isn't it a threat to credit card companies if businesses continue to charge consumers for it? I love my credit card benefits, but they're not worth a 3% tax on everything I buy with it.

When I go to this periodontist for my follow-up appointment, I'm tempted to roll in there with a bunch of rolled coins. Spend the time dealing with that if you're going to charge me 3% extra for your medical services if I do you the favor of paying with a card.
 
  • Love
Reactions: mpaer

mpaer

All-American
Jul 1, 2025
3,987
5,318
113
I pay cash at such restaurants I pay cash at DMV I gladly pay the Voluntary upcharge for things like on line Carolina Giving .If Amazon etc does it I have not noticed-but would not make the purchase if they do
I remember 25 years ago my church paid around $50,000 for Debit/Credit fees😒
 

mpaer

All-American
Jul 1, 2025
3,987
5,318
113
Years ago my BIL had a small store/electronics shop
End of each day he would "account for" checks, credit cards etc
And pocket the cash
Yes there was a Deevorce
 
Last edited:

FreeLunch

All-Conference
Jul 30, 2025
1,487
1,686
113
On the one hand ...........

VISA and Mastercard have something of an oligopoly on credit cards / credit card transaction processing. This allows them to have rather extraordinary profit margins.

Here are the percentages from the table below:

VISA ....................... 61%
Mastercard ......... 26%
Amex .................... 11%
Discover ................ 2%


1792658569230.png



VISA and Mastercard appear to be unusually profitable businesses. Their profit margins are in 45% - 50% range. And this is Net Profit to the Shareholders ... not just something like Operating Margin or Gross Margin.

Additionally, VISA's return on equity (last year) was 60%. While Mastercard's ROE was north of 200%.




VISA profit margin trend

1792658982685.png


Mastercard profit margin trend

1792659045472.png
 
Last edited:

FreeLunch

All-Conference
Jul 30, 2025
1,487
1,686
113
On the other hand ............


There are no free lunches ************.

There are only lunches that are paid for in some obvious, direct way .... or .... lunches that are paid for in some hidden way ..... perhaps by other people.



There is a cost to processing the exchange of money when you buy something ..... regardless of how you do that.

The questions are ..........

a) What are these costs ? What might be the most efficient way to pay for something ?


b) Who bears this cost ? And remember the concept of 'tax incidence' -- who appears to pay a 'tax' or other cost may be different from who is actually bearing the economic burden of paying that cost.

So - for instance - if the merchant charges an explicit credit card surcharge, it might look like the customers are paying this cost. But to the extent this apparently additional cost drives away business from the merchant .. (ie., reduces Demand) -- the merchant's income will decline.



1) If'n the merchant "eats" the cost associated with credit card fees -- those costs are just buried in the price of the goods and services you buy from the merchant. So you're still paying these costs in some way. You just don't see it explicitly. Though we should also note that it's likely a portion of this cost may come out of the profit earned by the merchant.


2) If you pay by cash -- I would suspect that's a far less efficient -- a more costly way for both the customer and the merchant and a bank -- to transact a payment.

Customers (all of us) would have to constantly go through the hassle of getting the cash. (Time is money.)

And then the merchant and the bank have deal with processing and accounting for, etc. all this cash. That would have to be a much less efficient process than computers magically crediting and debiting credit card accounts.


3) Ditto, if you pay by check -- then somebody has to process all these checks. That's not free.



Remember -- one of the reasons merchants are willing to accept credit cards is that -- profits of VISA and Mastercard notwithstanding -- it's still a relatively efficient way for customers to pay for stuff and it facilitates greater spending. Customers don't need to carry all this cash all the time and / or they don't have to have the money to pay for everything sitting in their checking account all the time.

If'n we could somehow break up the oligopoly we see in the credit card industry perhaps more competition would lower credit card fees. Offhand, I'm not sure how we would do that. And I'm not positive fragmenting that business would make it more efficient or exactly how that would work ...... ie., would every merchant now have to deal with 10 different credit card processors ????




******** Except for the Grace of God ....... consumer surplus ...... producer surplus ..... and .... arguably, diversification of investment portfolios.
 
Last edited:

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
Relevant tweet about the psychological effect on consumers. The juice isn't worth the squeeze for businesses; they're just not smart enough to realize it yet.



re: airbnb discourse

in college I worked as a server at an upscale steakhouse. we had a few different steak sauces that were made from scratch daily. they were expensive to make, and less than half of the customers that ordered steak wanted sauce, so the restaurant charged $3 for it

we got complaints constantly. just at my own tables, half a dozen times a week I'd get complaints about being "nickel and dimed" for $3 of sauce on a $70 steak. a few times a month someone would mention it in an angry online review, or ask to speak to a manager and demand that it be removed from the bill because "who the hell charges for condiments?"

after several years of this, finally management had enough. they raised the price of every steak by $3, and now complimentary sauce was included with each steak on request. want to hazard a guess about how many customers complained about the $3 price increase on steak? essentially zero.

it was great, from the restaurants perspective! no more complaints, and instead of making $3 on 40% of steak orderers, they made $3 on all of them. and the customers were much happier, despite this deal being absolutely, unequivocally worse for them.

consumers are not rational agents from microeconomics textbooks. very often the *feeling* of what they're being charged for matters way more than the absolute value of what they're being charged. I think that's more or less what happening with airbnb. people don't want to be charged a cleaning fee and then also told they have to clean, even if in the counterfactual world the additional cleaning fee is more than they'd be willing to pay someone to do the required cleaning. a $100 cleaning fee *feels* better than a $50 cleaning fee + "load the dishwasher and take the trash out to the dumpster", even though most people would not pay $50 to not have to do that.
 
Last edited:

unctarheel1984

All-American
Aug 15, 2002
10,090
7,768
101
A business makes a choice on whether to accept credit cards of not. If you’re going to, bake it into your pricing. It’s part of your overhead. Do you itemize all of your expenses and offer your customers a la carte pricing on them, or is that just for credit card fees and employee wages?
I agree with this, but you and I both understand the actual costs to us are identical. Its just an optics thing. Whether the cost is $1,000 + $30 fee or $1,030, its the same money. As to why the practice is becoming more commonplace to the point of being almost universal, I don't know, but its where we are. You can decide to pay cash, but then you won't get those airline points or whatever the perk is.

I used to have a firm rule that I would not use a credit card at a local mom & pop business because it hurt them paying the fees. I always paid cash. Not so much a concern these days.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mpaer

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
I agree with this, but you and I both understand the actual costs to us are identical. Its just an optics thing. Whether the cost is $1,000 + $30 fee or $1,030, its the same money. As to why the practice is becoming more commonplace to the point of being almost universal, I don't know, but its where we are. You can decide to pay cash, but then you won't get those airline points or whatever the perk is.

I used to have a firm rule that I would not use a credit card at a local mom & pop business because it hurt them paying the fees. I always paid cash. Not so much a concern these days.

Yeah, it's just like the tweet I posted above yours mentioned with the restaurant example. Emotionally, I'd rather feel like I'm paying an all-inclusive price instead of getting nickel and dimed on everything. Particularly with credit cards, because it benefits the merchant more than it does me. The irony is they would be making more money if they calculated for that surcharge in their pricing, because just like the steak sauce in the example above, everyone is paying for it even if they don't all use it.

I also don't mind paying the 3% (which is effectively 1% since I get ~2% rewards back) for small purchases, but this one in particular irked me because it was a professional medical office with a $3500 bill. Just a scummy business practice to add a credit card tax on a bill that large when your Periodontists are making $500K+.

As a consumer, it annoys me. As a business owner, it offends me because it's a terrible business practice that hurts both you and your customer.
 
Last edited:

unctarheel1984

All-American
Aug 15, 2002
10,090
7,768
101
Yeah, it's just like the tweet I posted above yours mentioned with the restaurant example. Emotionally, I'd rather feel like I'm paying an all-inclusive price instead of getting nickel and dimed on everything. Particularly with credit cards, because it benefits the merchant more than it does me.

I also don't mind paying the 3% (which is effectively 1% since I get ~2% rewards back) for small purchases, but this one in particular irked me because it was a professional medical office with a $3500 bill. Just a scummy business practice to add a credit card tax on a bill that large when your Periodontists are making $500K+.
My dentist (whom I love) insists on charging $3 more than the insurance reimbursement for twice yearly cleanings. It’s drives me a little nutty to get a bill for $3.
 

PINEHEEL

All-American
Aug 1, 2025
2,499
7,043
113
My dentist (whom I love) insists on charging $3 more than the insurance reimbursement for twice yearly cleanings. It’s drives me a little nutty to get a bill for $3.

Is that just a coincidence? I don't carry dental insurance so don't know much about it. Is his pricing the same for all patients but everyone's insurer may reimburse a different amount and yours just happens to be $3 short?

I'm having my own private war with Labcorp that they know nothing about. They've been trying to collect on a bill of less than $2 for six months now. It was the difference for reimbursement on some routine bloodwork at my physical, but I'm going to make them spend $20 on postage and mailings for bothering me about such a trivial amount in the first place. I pay BCBSNC over $25K a year for my family of four. Labcorp can take their complaints up with them since they're in bed together anyway.
 

unctarheel1984

All-American
Aug 15, 2002
10,090
7,768
101
I don’t know how much other insurers reimburse and my suspicion is that at least part of the reason they charge a few dollars more is to drive up over time the “reasonable and customary charge” standard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PINEHEEL

mpaer

All-American
Jul 1, 2025
3,987
5,318
113
My Mobile Phone carrier is Verizon
I have a 3 year contract The bill varies every month-like 12 cents sometimes , but it varies And it is not minutes/data used-I have a much bigger limit on that than I ever use
I am to lazy to figure it out, but just for grins I think I will start trying to figure it out
 
Inside Carolina

Latest

  1. 01 Inside Carolina Basketball Jason Capel Reflects on UNC Past Ahead of Friday's Return to Chapel Hill on the Mic
  2. 02 Inside Carolina Football Updated Intel from Carolina Football Practice
  3. 03 Inside Carolina Basketball What We've Learned From the Cameron Fens Eligibility Ruling
  4. 04 Inside Carolina Football Jason's Keys for UNC at Virginia: 'This is the Game to Blitz'
  5. 05 Inside Carolina Football When Numbers Lie: What the Box Score Misses About UNC and Virginia