I Wasn't In Favor Of It

I4CtheFuture

All-Conference
Oct 5, 2024
2,266
2,095
113
Anything less is just a popularity contest. Let them play it out on the field. Absolutely.

Anything can happen. The ball bounces funny sometimes.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
If the already lengthy and intense college football season can't eliminate enough pretenders so that 24 teams deserve to play for the national championship, then the entire enterprise is competitively bankrupt.
 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,784
1,550
113
If the already lengthy and intense college football season can't eliminate enough pretenders so that 24 teams deserve to play for the national championship, then the entire enterprise is competitively bankrupt.
That wagon has BEEN left the smokehouse. If we’re just abandoning what we’ve known as college football then I welcome it; replacing the Acme Kotex Bowl with something meaningful is interesting with some meaning at least instead of just a tv screensaver. Plus I am hoping it will act to at least pare down the opt out crap so games are more representative of the teams.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,782
3,397
113
That wagon has BEEN left the smokehouse. If we’re just abandoning what we’ve known as college football then I welcome it; replacing the Acme Kotex Bowl with something meaningful is interesting with some meaning at least instead of just a tv screensaver. Plus I am hoping it will act to at least pare down the opt out crap so games are more representative of the teams.
I agree. The bowls are the equivalent to the NIT in basketball. They are meaningless.

I was in favor of expanding the playoffs to 16 and no more. But now that it's going to 24, I'm fine with that. Just enjoy it.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,173
3,741
113
ESPN wants NFL Jr. and they are going to get it.

My interest was already much lower than it had been, a 24 team playoff will make college football a complete joke.
 

SouthernBelly

Senior
Sep 16, 2024
1,053
800
113
That wagon has BEEN left the smokehouse. If we’re just abandoning what we’ve known as college football then I welcome it; replacing the Acme Kotex Bowl with something meaningful is interesting with some meaning at least instead of just a tv screensaver. Plus I am hoping it will act to at least pare down the opt out crap so games are more representative of the teams.
I think this is where I am at, strictly regarding the post-season. I used to really enjoy a solid New Year's Day, and maybe some of the days in immediate proximity, as well as catching whatever random bowl I could in the weeks leading up to it. Some of the formerly enjoyable aspects of the bowls was how they used to involve a variety of teams in matchups you otherwise would not have gotten, and the games mattered to the teams. But all that stuff has been gone for a while, so since its dead and not coming back let's at least see if a new format can breathe some life back into the post season that could still involve a variety of teams with intriguing matchups.
 

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
26,173
3,741
113
I think this is where I am at, strictly regarding the post-season. I used to really enjoy a solid New Year's Day, and maybe some of the days in immediate proximity, as well as catching whatever random bowl I could in the weeks leading up to it. Some of the formerly enjoyable aspects of the bowls was how they used to involve a variety of teams in matchups you otherwise would not have gotten, and the games mattered to the teams. But all that stuff has been gone for a while, so since its dead and not coming back let's at least see if a new format can breathe some life back into the post season that could still involve a variety of teams with intriguing matchups.
A lot of it is going to be the same matchups that would have happened in bowl games. The top 25 all played other ranked teams and the top 5 or 10 typically got matched up against each other in the NYD bowls. The difference now is going to be, the top 5 or so are going to have to play some lower ranked teams to get to the "big" game.
 

KingWard

All-American
Feb 15, 2022
8,916
9,016
113
That wagon has BEEN left the smokehouse. If we’re just abandoning what we’ve known as college football then I welcome it; replacing the Acme Kotex Bowl with something meaningful is interesting with some meaning at least instead of just a tv screensaver. Plus I am hoping it will act to at least pare down the opt out crap so games are more representative of the teams.
That might or might not happen, but that OUGHT to happen WITHOUT a playoff full of unworthy participants. What about, say, no one bowls without at least seven wins - or even eight? What about that? Problem instantly solved.
 

kidrobinski

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2004
1,784
1,550
113
That might or might not happen, but that OUGHT to happen WITHOUT a playoff full of unworthy participants. What about, say, no one bowls without at least seven wins - or even eight? What about that? Problem instantly solved.
I’m assuming it’s going to be top 24 by some consensus (which will entail some drama itself probably). If so, then if you’re top 24 I personally don’t really put a criterion on a static number; don’t care. If the blue bloods are that big and bad then the cream will rise to the top anyway. If not, then as Keanu Reeves says in The Replacements “chicks dig scars; glory lasts forever.”
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon808620

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
766
324
63
If the already lengthy and intense college football season can't eliminate enough pretenders so that 24 teams deserve to play for the national championship, then the entire enterprise is competitively bankrupt.

Sincerely,

Jeff Bezos
 

TheRoo

Joined Nov 3, 2021
Feb 6, 2022
766
324
63
The "best team" should not be afraid to play an extra game or two to determine that they are the best team.

As stated before, the entire best team concept is typically a folly anyway.

The only way that can be determined is if all of D1 played each other each year.

How many times have we seen the SEC declared to be the best league and house the best team --- yet the league's bowl record wasn't great at all?

So even if Bama wins the NC, were they really playing the toughest regular season schedule?

Totally subjective.
 

Uscg1984

All-Conference
Mar 9, 2006
2,876
3,742
113
So even if Bama wins the NC, were they really playing the toughest regular season schedule?

Totally subjective.
It wasn't entirely subjective. The NFL draft was a fairly objective measuring stick of the relative talent level of each conference and it usually wasn't close. However, that has shifted somewhat in recent years as NIL and the portal has spread the talent more evenly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheRoo

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,977
1,947
113
Hate it. 24 team brackets mean byes are awarded. The only advantage the teams should receive as a result of the regular season is seeding... not seeding, extra time to heal, prepare AND getting to be one game closer to the championship game.
 
Last edited:

Blues man

Joined Jul 1, 2009
Jan 22, 2022
1,977
1,947
113
How so? 24 teams, 12 games, no? What am I missing? Admittedly I’ve never paid much attention to the minutia and fine print of these type things.
That said, I wouldn't be opposed to 16. The math works. No advantages other than seeding. That would be too easy though and take some of the subjectivity out of it... which they seemingly don't want to do so they blew right by it like it is no option at all.
 
GamecockCentral

Latest

  1. 01 GamecockCentral Football Insider Report: CFP rankings, Sellers, and preparing for offseason
  2. 02 TheBigSpur Football Pat DiMarco calls South Carolina's effort at Arkansas one of the most disappointing he's seen
  3. 03 TheBigSpur Football South Carolina is No. 21 and that gives the Gamecocks a needed boost
  4. 04 GamecockCentral Football Three players to know from South Carolina's next opponent, the Georgia Bulldogs
  5. 05 GamecockCentral Basketball Three burning questions ahead of South Carolina's matchup with Elon