Stop the Witch Hunts, Let People Enjoy A Good Offseason

Rick Honcho

All-Conference
Apr 19, 2011
1,537
1,553
103
Going to Final Fours are still special though. In 87 years of NCAA tournaments, we have only won the title 8 times and that’s considerably more than almost anyone. I think it’s fair to celebrate Final Fours rather than just titles. It’s why I’m happy we have the 1942, 1966, 1975, 1984, 1993, 1997, 2011, 2014 and 2015 banners up there as well. Those years weren’t failures — they were still great years. They weren’t ultimate but still deserve celebration IMO
Enjoying a grilled brat with a cold Pepsi at Churchill Downs on a nice day is really, really special, but nobody should hang a banner for that either.
 

Im The Village Idiot

All-American
Sep 7, 2025
2,622
6,514
113
Enjoying a grilled brat with a cold Pepsi at Churchill Downs on a nice day is really, really special, but nobody should hang a banner for that either.
It’s an opinion thing. And I respect yours.

For me, Final Fours are absolutely banner worthy.

If you get to a point where ONLY the titles matter, we aren’t the gold standard — UCLA is. We gotta remember who we are. We are the GOAT in college basketball because of the cumulative case. We have the titles, we have the wins, we have the final fours, we have the All-Americans, we have the NBA guys, we have the conference championships — it all matters here. And Final Fours are a huge part of Kentucky basketball history.
 

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
Good thing for UCONN that they gave Hurley some time or those championships would have never happened.

Oh but the goalposts will be moved to "your comparing Pope to Hurley, LOL" when that's not the point at all with the point being that NOBODY became a good coach at the warp speed that some want from Pope. They made up their mind on Pope the night he was hired, showing that they are nobody you'd ever take seriously about anything and just want to be fan under their rules. 🤡
Umm, Hurley had a pretty good resume prior to Uconn and took them over from Kevin Ollie who got Uconn on probation, including reduced scholarships. He had a conference championship, tournament championship and A-10 COY before going to Uconn.

Hurley had no NIL and no portal to rebuild with, yet, had Uconn back to the tournament in his 3rd year and a top 3 finish in the Big east by year 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
This is the bad thing about the internet. I know you wouldn’t play like you didn’t understand his point IRL. One of the nicest and smartest dudes I know yet when you show up on here you do stuff like this…

He isn’t arguing what Pope will or won’t be. He’s simply showing, with evidence, that it takes time for some coaches to develop. Pope is still pretty early in his coaching career — he could develop into the next Tom Crean, the next John Thompson III, the next Kelvin Sampson or anything else. That is factually apparent when you start looking at other greats’ careers. That doesn’t mean Paul is arguing such a thing has a high probability — he’s simply sharing to you why he’s looking for a greater sample size. Rather than understanding that, a couple of you will choose to simplify his points into a ridiculous strawman and how does that help? So you can ridicule him? Pope is the coach regardless and people have various logical reasons to support or doubt him. Personally, I’m still mostly in the middle but I understand where Paul is coming from. It’s actually pretty easy to see what he’s saying if you aren’t thinking about it like it’s Battlefield 6 with people on both sides of a war.
He's had 12 years. How much time do these things take?

When did providing facts become a strawman? Like, seriously, tell us!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RunninRichie
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
You are in essence, arguing Pope could be like legendary coaches, if we just give him some time. Despite nothing in his resume suggesting he is that.
The argument that has been made is that he can never be anything more than what his winning percentage has been to this point.

There was nothing in their resumes to suggest great accomplishments where coming until well into their careers in some cases. What he could possibly be and what he actually will be are two different things and only time will tell.

The point has always been that there are some great coaches who would have been fired by the criteria of those who insist Pope should have been fired already before they reached the heights that they did.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Agent Redbone

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
29,326
70,766
113
The argument that has been made is that he can never be anything more than what his winning percentage has been to this point.

There was nothing in their resumes to suggest great accomplishments where coming until well into their careers in some cases. What he could possibly be and what he actually will be are two different things and only time will tell.

The point has always been that there are some great coaches who would have been fired by the criteria of those who insist Pope should have already been fired already before they reached the heights that they did.
You keep acting like it's 1998 or 1986. It's 2026. Coaches have the transfer portal, warchests to buy players, and a booming international market. And to say "There was nothing in their resumes to suggest great accomplishments where coming until well into their careers in some cases", is hilarious, many coaches showed year on year improvement, or had some success, some were forced to do old-fashioned rebuilds. Due to a lack of a transfer portal/NIL. Which can skew results, that's why the Hurley argument is hilarious. The guy was a-10 COY and got Rhode Island to the NCAAT, before that he was a dominant high school coach. He had to rebuild Uconn who was on probation, with no portal. Pope coached at Utah Valley and BYU before UK, where he was pedestrian at best and he coached at those two for long enough, to have some type of success. He never won a conference or a conference tourney.
 
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
I'm asking a serious question. Nobody real shills this hard, or you're getting a big payday.
That's even funnier. Being reasonable about the situation is not shilling. I have never made a prediction that greatness is on the horizon. I'm saying none of us have a crystal ball into the future and any suggestion that the past in this case proves greater success going forward to be an impossibility is stupid.
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
29,326
70,766
113
That's even funnier. Being reasonable about the situation is not shilling. I have never made a prediction that greatness is on the horizon. I'm saying none of us have a crystal ball into the future and any suggestion that the past in this case proves greater success going forward to be an impossibility is stupid.
You're not being reasonable. You're hoping/coping.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cattorney

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
29,326
70,766
113
I'm just stating things that are utterly factual and you can't handle it because you are over the top negative and I'm not playing along.
I'm not negative, I was a Pope fan, I just am rational and change my views when evidence is brought. I saw Pope's poor recruiting, PR blunders, and his issues getting his team to play defense and with effort for 2 halves. And I realized he's way too green/not qualified for this job. Which, honestly, everyone knew it the night he was hired. We just all collectively coped. You wanna keep coping that Pope could be Coach K if we just give him some time, go ahead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cattorney
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
I'm not negative, I was a Pope fan, I just am rational and change my views when evidence is brought. I saw Pope's poor recruiting, PR blunders, and his issues getting his team to play defense and with effort for 2 halves. And I realized he's way too green/not qualified for this job. Which, honestly, everyone knew it the night he was hired. We just all collectively coped. You wanna keep coping that Pope could be Coach K if we just give him some time, go ahead.
If your contention is he is too green then you should be able to concede that he could improve with more experience in this job. Are you still contending that his recruiting is an issue that prevents improvement in results at this point in time?

Did you not think he showed any promise season one even with inheriting an empty roster in mid April and dealing with an unusual amount of key injuries?
 

RunninRichie

Heisman
Sep 5, 2019
29,326
70,766
113
If your contention is he is too green then you should be able to concede that he could improve with more experience in this job. Are you still contending that his recruiting is an issue that prevents improvement in results at this point in time?
Once again, he coached at two places for 9 years before he got the UK job. I am not in the business of letting under qualified coaches, waste seasons to "get experience" at UK. Uconn and Duke are on our heels, and could catch us or get very close to our title lead. UNC could be good again if Malone pans out. Kansas is only a few games behind our all-time wins lead. The time to win is now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cattorney
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
Once again, he coached at two places for 9 years before he got the UK job. I am not in the business of letting under qualified coaches, waste seasons to "get experience" at UK. Uconn and Duke are on our heels, and could catch us or get very close to our title lead. UNC could be good again if Malone pans out. Kansas is only a few games behind our all-time wins lead. The time to win is now.
You just said he was too green. You need to make up your mind as to what makes you so negative. You act like we are guaranteed huge success immediately if we just run off or fire another coach in just over two years time and that is objectively just another gamble. There are no guarantees that you get someone who out does what Pope may well accomplish going forward.
 

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
That's even funnier. Being reasonable about the situation is not shilling. I have never made a prediction that greatness is on the horizon. I'm saying none of us have a crystal ball into the future and any suggestion that the past in this case proves greater success going forward to be an impossibility is stupid.
Reasonable? You've been comparing Pope to legends. Pope has 0 conference championships, 0 tournament championships, 1 sw16, and only 4 NCAA appearances in 11 years. In the last 5 years he's lost 63 games. He's got a 55% SEC win%.
 

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
If your contention is he is too green then you should be able to concede that he could improve with more experience in this job. Are you still contending that his recruiting is an issue that prevents improvement in results at this point in time?

Did you not think he showed any promise season one even with inheriting an empty roster in mid April and dealing with an unusual amount of key injuries?
No. Under qualified people rarely become qualified just by doing it more. Particularly when they are just simply inadequate at it. Such as Pope. And UK basketball certainly isn't a job where we just say "aw shucks, you just need more time so we will give it to you cause you try real hard." That is literally why you start at smaller schools to gain experience so you don't have to learn here.

9 years elsewhere and he couldn't learn? Why will he now?

Only someone wanting to see UK regress would advocate for "they just need more time and maybe they'll get better"
 
Last edited:

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
You just said he was too green. You need to make up your mind as to what makes you so negative. You act like we are guaranteed huge success immediately if we just run off or fire another coach in just over two years time and that is objectively just another gamble. There are no guarantees that you get someone who out does what Pope may well accomplish going forward.
Did he change that stance or something?

Considering the portal and NIL, it's very easy to have instant success. Watch Michigan at all last year? Didn't Cal just win the SEC in year 2 at Arky?

We're in year 3 and our coach is in the hot seat. That should probably tell you what you need to know.
 
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
Reasonable? You've been comparing Pope to legends. Pope has 0 conference championships, 0 tournament championships, 1 sw16, and only 4 NCAA appearances in 11 years. In the last 5 years he's lost 63 games. He's got a 55% SEC win%.
How many times must something be explained to you before you comprehend it? The comparison was strictly what they did in their first two seasons (the amount of time Pope has been here) at the school they won a title and then upon request their previous stops were added.
Over the top negative. Facts are negative now?
I have no clue how you considered this clever or believed it made any sort of point.
 
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
No. Under qualified people rarely become qualified just by doing it more. Particularly when they are just simply inadequate at it. Such as Pope. And UK basketball certainly isn't a job where we just say "aw shucks, you just need more time so we will give it to you cause you try real hard." That is literally why you start at smaller schools to gain experience so you don't have to learn here.

9 years elsewhere and he couldn't learn? Why will he now?

Only someone wanting to see UK regress would advocate for "they just need more time and maybe they'll get better"
Now you are just pretending like this has not been explained to you on several pages of this thread already. Your buddy is the one that said he was still green not me.
 
Aug 23, 2024
3,040
6,524
113
Did he change that stance or something?

Considering the portal and NIL, it's very easy to have instant success. Watch Michigan at all last year? Didn't Cal just win the SEC in year 2 at Arky?

We're in year 3 and our coach is in the hot seat. That should probably tell you what you need to know.
Everyone has the portal and NIL now. Giving an example of a couple teams that have had success especially when one of them stole most of our roster and has barely outdone us means nothing. We haven't even started year three yet and how hot his seat truly is is just a matter of a guess and opinion.

You claim you would have been fine with K after three years at Duke going 38-47 and yet clamor to fire a guy for going 46-26 in two seasons despite a difficult roster situation from the beginning, the two most difficult schedules in school history and dealing with extreme injury issues. That is neither logical nor reasonable.

I'll go ahead put you on ignore now as continuing this is pointless. No matter how well something is explained or demonstrated by stats and records for you you just continue with your agenda and nothing is changing that.

You'll probably just continue this foolishness with yet another Leadbelly sock account anyway.
 
Last edited:

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
How many times must something be explained to you before you comprehend it? The comparison was strictly what they did in their first two seasons (the amount of time Pope has been here) at the school they won a title and then upon request their previous stops were added.

I have no clue how you considered this clever or believed it made any sort of point.
But this is Pope's 12th season, not his 2nd. Why are we only looking at 2 years? Are we just pretending the other 9 don't exists. All of the guys you listed, sans Calhoun had already accomplished more than Pope prior to their big program higher. With the exception of the couple that started at that level and win big quick.

It is the point!
 

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
Now you are just pretending like this has not been explained to you on several pages of this thread already. Your buddy is the one that said he was still green not me.
Lol, it hasn't been. Just saying it has doesn't make it so.

He is green at winning. He is experiences as God awful as a HC.
 

Cattorney

Junior
Dec 2, 2024
457
390
63
Everyone has the portal and NIL now. Giving an example of a couple teams that have had success especially when one of them stole most of our roster and has barely outdone us means nothing. We haven't even started year three yet and how hot his seat truly is is just a matter of a guess and opinion.

You claim you would have been fine with K after three years at Duke going 38-47 and yet clamor to fire a guy for going 46-26 in two seasons despite a difficult roster situation from the beginning and dealing with extreme injury issues. That is neither logical nor reasonable.

I'll go ahead put you on ignore now as continuing this is pointless. No matter how well something is explained or demonstrated by stats and records for you you just continue with your agenda and nothing is changing that.

You'll probably just continue this foolishness with yet another Leadbelly sock account anyway.
Barely out done us? He beat the **** out of us in rupp when we were favored pretty big. Went to the same sw 16 yr one and then won the SEC tour year 2. That's a hell of a lot better.

We haven't Come close to winning the SEC.

Not a guess or opinion, it's been reported and even you know it, Mark.

He built the roster. That's his problem. Stop relying on players with injury issues out of desperation. Recruit usable backups. All teams deal with injuries. It's not an excuse anymore.

But you've explained nothing and ignoring me just proves you're unable to.

Aww, the ole you're someone else post. Love it!
 

Starrcade

Senior
Jun 4, 2026
438
725
93
Umm, Hurley had a pretty good resume prior to Uconn and took them over from Kevin Ollie who got Uconn on probation, including reduced scholarships. He had a conference championship, tournament championship and A-10 COY before going to Uconn.

Hurley had no NIL and no portal to rebuild with, yet, had Uconn back to the tournament in his 3rd year and a top 3 finish in the Big east by year 3.
Nice try. By Richie’s very own definition, Hurley would have been fired and run out of town after year two. No debate.
 
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Football Will Stein likes how Kentucky has responded to Alabama loss: "No Poor Me's"
  2. 02 KSR Football Will Stein wants Kentucky's offense to be more aggressive in hunt for explosive plays
  3. 03 KSR Women's Basketball Clara Strack is stepping out of her comfort zone to help Kentucky WBB reach its potential
  4. 04 KSR Football Mi’Quise Humphrey-Grace’s Pick-Six was 'one of the coolest moments' of Will Stein’s career
  5. 05 KSR Basketball Recruiting LOOK: Lewis Uvwo rocks Kentucky blue on official visit to Lexington