As a lifelong Reds fan, I think it’s time….

Vek96

All-American
Jul 4, 2025
2,818
5,973
113
I stopped paying attention after Jr retired or left. Until there is a mechanism for real competition in MLB, there is not much point to follow. Some mid market teams sneak in every once in a while but they are managed completely differently than the Red machine
Yep. Owners have to demand a salary cap like the NFL, NBA, and NHL has. And if it means the players sit out for years until giving in, so be it. It has to be done.
 

berniecarbo

Heisman
Apr 29, 2020
5,188
29,426
113
Co pilot says Reds are 20th in team salary. My Cards are 24th. Fans called our last GM Moron. Owner DeWitt is called Dimwit and fans think his interest is in Ball Park Village, not the team. He did hire Claire Bloom for the rebuild though, so we are hoping.
 
  • Like
Reactions: *Fox2Monk*

Im The Village Idiot

All-American
Sep 7, 2025
2,027
5,066
113
Don’t worry OP. You may get your wish eventually. Castellini has already threatened it before. I’m sure everyone will be happier when you go from having a low-hope baseball franchise with 162 games of middling to bad content to having zero hope and 0 games of any content to watch at all. Reds fans will celebrate when the franchise is archived into the annals of history and lost in the sands of time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKortho

Vek96

All-American
Jul 4, 2025
2,818
5,973
113
Elly brought me back in but it's demoralizing seeing us waste him. He is probably just counting the days until he can leave for the Dodgers or Yankees.
Elly strikes out too much and never hits good pitching. He also led the league in errors last season. He’s not stealing bases this year nearly as much as he had in his first couple of years, which is what made him stand out. I love his attitude and enthusiasm, but honestly, they can lose the same without him.

The biggest problem is Greene and Lodolo are rarely healthy. The Reds hitters strikeout at an alarming rate. Their batting averages are almost always near the bottom of the league. Francona is atrocious. He makes Bell look like a genius. He never tries to manufacture a run. He pulls pitchers after ridiculously low pitch totals. He’s so effing awful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerMoving
Jun 23, 2026
209
501
63
Co pilot says Reds are 20th in team salary. My Cards are 24th. Fans called our last GM Moron. Owner DeWitt is called Dimwit and fans think his interest is in Ball Park Village, not the team. He did hire Claire Bloom for the rebuild though, so we are hoping.
It’s not just the investment in player salaries. Teams like the Dodgers and Brewers invest heavily in player development. That’s why the Dodgers have so many prospects in the top 100.
 
Jun 23, 2026
209
501
63
…..they just cease to exist. Perhaps the worst run Franchise in sports history. An absolute total failure.
So what are your thoughts on trading Greene? I'm kinda indifferent.

On one hand you can fill the many holes your team has and you still have some decent pitchers on staff. Greene is either injury prone or doing load management to save his arm for his next team. He frustrates me more than excites me at this point.

On the other hand, prospects are never a sure thing. We got a haul for Castillo and haven't been able to develop them. And trading a top tier player with a controllable contract for top prospects hoping to get a top tier player with a controllable contract doesn't seem to make a lot of since.
 
  • Like
Reactions: *Fox2Monk*

Son_Of_Saul

Hall of Famer
Dec 7, 2007
45,764
101,289
113
…..they just cease to exist. Perhaps the worst run Franchise in sports history. An absolute total failure.
As a White Sox fan I'd like to nominate a contender for that role. We have 3rd smallest payroll in baseball, which amounts to about $44 million less than the Reds. Under Jerry Reinsdorf, there has been nothing but retool after retool after retool. Reinsdorf was the leader of the pack back in 1994's baseball strike, orchestrating a strike when the White Sox had one of the best rosters in its history. He torpedoed his own team essentially. Not only that, but he's the same moron that chose Jerry Krause over Phil Jackson and Michael Jordan going for a 7th title in the late 1990s.

Yeah, I think you've got some competition in terms of bad ownership.
 
Last edited:

rick64

Heisman
Jan 25, 2007
25,039
34,861
113
I'm not paying for MLB or whatever it is to get to watch them. Reds are so poorly run. They obviously are really serious about winning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: *Fox2Monk*

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
46,997
85,908
113
…..they just cease to exist. Perhaps the worst run Franchise in sports history. An absolute total failure.
They have one of if not the cheapest owners in all of pro sports. They need to sell them to a group who wants to compete.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UKortho

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
46,997
85,908
113
Yep. Owners have to demand a salary cap like the NFL, NBA, and NHL has. And if it means the players sit out for years until giving in, so be it. It has to be done.
Agreed, this is the season to do it. The owners better lock in and get a cap done. The Dodgers will never cease to be a World Series contender ever without one. They will literally buy the best team yearly no matter the cost, and they have a deep farm system. It’s not even close to fair.
 

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
46,997
85,908
113
Elly strikes out too much and never hits good pitching. He also led the league in errors last season. He’s not stealing bases this year nearly as much as he had in his first couple of years, which is what made him stand out. I love his attitude and enthusiasm, but honestly, they can lose the same without him.

The biggest problem is Greene and Lodolo are rarely healthy. The Reds hitters strikeout at an alarming rate. Their batting averages are almost always near the bottom of the league. Francona is atrocious. He makes Bell look like a genius. He never tries to manufacture a run. He pulls pitchers after ridiculously low pitch totals. He’s so effing awful.
Batting averages across the league are atrocious anymore. Very few .300 hitters this day and age.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: chroix

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
46,997
85,908
113
As a White Sox fan I'd like to nominate a contender for that role. We have 3rd smallest payroll in baseball, which amounts to about $44 million less than the Reds. Under Jerry Reinsdorf, there has been nothing but retool after retool after retool. Reinsdorf was the leader of the pack back in 1994's baseball strike, orchestrating a strike when the White Sox had one of the best rosters in its history. He torpedoed his own team essentially. Not only that, but he's the same moron that chose Jerry Krause over Phil Jackson and Michael Jordan going for a 7th title in the late 1990s.

Yeah, I think you've got some competition in turns of bad ownership.
Yeah he’s absolutely awful. I hate that man for ruining my childhood Bulls. He has ran the White Sox so so so bad. Outside like 3 good years.
 

chroix

Heisman
Jul 22, 2013
10,650
26,924
113
I stopped tracking them because I was worried I was a jinx but I'm glad to see it's one of you all.

Seriously though, has there been a worse city for pro sports fans over the span of the last 30 years?
 
Jun 23, 2026
209
501
63
Batting averages across the league are atrocious anymore. Very few .300 hitters this day and age.
Maybe I'm too old school but the new metrics on which the measure a good player seem like hogwash. You telling me a guy batting 300 isn't as valuable as a guy with a good slugging pct?

It seems like to me that bombs would count for more runs if you had guys that could hit in front of them.
 

vhcat1970

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
3,500
2,598
113
I know something's wrong with me, but I'm more into the Reds this year than any in the last 5+. Record every game & FF thru them till they score. Before I didn't even do that.
 

vhcat1970

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2025
3,500
2,598
113
Still remember their late 50s D lineup with Bailey C, Klu 1B, Temple 2B, Freese (sometimes) 3B, McMillan SS, Robinson LF, Bell CF, Post RF.
 

Anon794131

Redshirt
Jul 10, 2026
9
4
0
We attend a game or 2 during the Dodger series in Cincy. Spouse is a born Dodger fans. The Great American Ball Park is a decent baseball stadium. It's not unusual for Dodger fans to nearly equal Reds fans at those games. Stunning how well Dodger fans travel. Of course, every Japanese or Japanese American fan within hundreds of miles attend or more Dodgers games. Literally, Japanese fans from Japan travel to Dodgers games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: *Fox2Monk*

berniecarbo

Heisman
Apr 29, 2020
5,188
29,426
113
Agreed, this is the season to do it. The owners better lock in and get a cap done. The Dodgers will never cease to be a World Series contender ever without one. They will literally buy the best team yearly no matter the cost, and they have a deep farm system. It’s not even close to fair.
Agreed. Branch Ricky when he worked for the Cards was the first to be smart enough to set up their own farm system. Before that minor league teams were independently owned and MLB teams had to buy players from them. The richest teams got the best players. The Cards set up their own minor league teams and the system was working great as the Cards became consistent contenders. Commissioner Landis said this gave the Cards an unfair advantage and made the Cards release a number of players so other teams could sign them. The current Dodger situation is an unfair advantage if you want real competition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: *Fox2Monk*

BigBluePap

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2024
738
1,454
88
one of my brother in laws and I are amongst the dwindling number of remaining hardcore baseball fans since the 60s. We’ve seen so many of the greatest of the greatest … at all levels I believe baseball interest is at the lowest level in my life, and I truly don’t understand how these salaries are afforded in the long term. But I digress …

I’ve been thru the Marge Schott years (she was quite the personality). I don’t begrudge the Dodgers or the Yankees … overcoming those odds are part of the lure. There are “small” market teams that manage to compete, and to start the season we were not far off IMO. I’m not surprised at Geno’s season, but can any of us remember who we got when we first let him go??? I can’t 😳 I think we got pretty good starters right now when healthy in Homer, Chase, Drew, and hopefully Nick. For those of us who do still follow baseball, we know they have to improve hitting … by a lot!!! And we need (hopefully 2) a closer. It’s apparently not happening this year. 3 more days to the trade deadline. I’ve no confidence the Reds will do anything to help this season or next … I think you have to at least listen to offers for Elly …

now, for the baseball fan part … this has been an absolute great season!!! A lot going on and time for teams to fish or cut bait!!! How about Cal Raleigh??? Talk about hitting heights and then the depths …and Aaron Judge starts the season just killing it, and now hasn’t played in months … batting averages are down … we really got a lot of great pitchers out there right now … Misiorowski Cease, Skenes, Sale, so many others, including my boy Chase Burns!!! And for us fans, we have and are witnessing one of the most unique talents in MLB history with ShoheI … hell, him alone kinda makes you like the dodgers 😂
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: *Fox2Monk*

*Fox2Monk*

Heisman
Jun 10, 2009
46,997
85,908
113
one of my brother in laws and I are amongst the dwindling number of remaining hardcore baseball fans since the 60s. We’ve seen so many of the greatest of the greatest … at all levels I believe baseball interest is at the lowest level in my life, and I truly don’t understand how these salaries are afforded in the long term. But I digress …

I’ve been thru the Marge Schott years (she was quite the personality). I don’t begrudge the Dodgers or the Yankees … overcoming those odds are part of the lure. There are “small” market teams that manage to compete, and to start the season we were not far off IMO. I’m not surprised at Geno’s season, but can any of us remember who we got when we first let him go??? I can’t 😳 I think we got pretty good starters right now when healthy in Homer, Chase, Drew, and hopefully Nick. For those of us who do still follow baseball, we know they have to improve hitting … by a lot!!! And we need (hopefully 2) a closer. It’s apparently not happening this year. 3 more days to the trade deadline. I’ve no confidence the Reds will do anything to help this season or next … I think you have to at least listen to offers for Elly …

now, for the baseball fan part … this has been an absolute great season!!! A lot going on and time for teams to fish or cut bait!!! How about Cal Raleigh??? Talk about hitting heights and then the depths …and Aaron Judge starts the season just killing it, and now hasn’t played in months … batting averages are down … we really got a lot of great pitchers out there right now … Misiorowski Cease, Skenes, Sale, so many others, including my boy Chase Burns!!! And for us fans, we have and are witnessing one of the most unique talents in MLB history with ShoheI … hell, him alone kinda makes you like the dodgers 😂
Pitching is ridiculous now with velocity, I don’t see how these guys arms hold up long term.
 
  • Like
Reactions: berniecarbo
KSR

Latest

  1. 01 KSR Auburn star transfer Keyshawn Hall hears from Kentucky
  2. 02 KSR KSR Rapid Reaction: La Familia falls in TBT Championship heartbreaker
  3. 03 KSR Don't count out Willie Cauley-Stein making another run in TBT...
  4. 04 KSR La Familia falls to Davis Steel 67-59 in TBT championship
  5. 05 KSR LIVE BLOG: La Familia vs. Davis Steel, TBT Championship