OT: Top 10 Rock Band List

Jan 12, 2015
39,195
39,261
113
Here ya go:

Kool & The Gang
Public Enemy
Depeche Mode
The Supremes
The O'Jays
ABBA
Gladys Knight & The Pips
Beastie Boys
Bee Gees
Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five



104.3 K-Rock will be running a top American RnR song list for our 250th 4th of July Celebration ...so no Brits!

Here's a couple interesting lists in the lead-up:
Top 50 American Rock Songs
The most famous band of all time from every state
BeeGees, Depeche Mode and ABBA aren't American bands! #MakeAmericanMusicGreatAgain
 
Last edited:

hoquat63

All-Conference
Mar 17, 2005
9,151
4,445
45
A lot depends on your age: grew up in the 50’s/60’s. Almost nobody who played from mid. 79’s on wouldn’t make my list.
Bands I still listen to in no particular order :
Animals, Cream, Big Brother, Kinks, Zombies, Lovin Spoonful, Zombies, Hendrix Experience, Greatful Dead, Lenard Skynard, are 9 that pop to mind.
 

24Babybull

Senior
Oct 15, 2006
1,054
447
83
The Rolling Stones: Mick Taylor Era 1969-74 is my favorite. Pretty much after Some Girls 1978 was their last good Album...imo
 

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,568
38,329
113
Agree with Van Halen - can’t believe I forgot them in my list.
I love Eddie's story of his guitar playing on "Beat It" for Michael Jackson - Says Jackson approached him about it but Van Halen had a rule that they did not do side gigs. But he said that all of the other members were out of town- so, he figured, "who is even going to know I played on this kids record" and he insisted that he would not be credited and that they couldn't tell his bandmates.
 
Jan 12, 2015
39,195
39,261
113

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,533
3,955
73
I'm still trying to work on a Top 10 (or so) American Rock Songs list. Honestly I could have 6-8 Aerosmith +VH and a couple Hendrix songs on my faves, but I'm hoping to come up with a less top-heavy list.

I can appreciate the interest and sentiment, but how can anyone come up with a top 10 or even top 50 song list? Even if it’s limited to American artists ? It’s the land of rock and roll and I doubt I could get out of the first decade of rock music (1954-1964) without naming 100 songs which could be interchanged depending on my mood or what day it was.
 
Jan 12, 2015
39,195
39,261
113
I can appreciate the interest and sentiment, but how can anyone come up with a top 10 or even top 50 song list? Even if it’s limited to American artists ? It’s the land of rock and roll and I doubt I could get out of the first decade of rock music (1954-1964) without naming 100 songs which could be interchanged depending on my mood or what day it was.
Yeh I get it--just spitballin'. While I definitely respect the first decade American rock &roll musicians (Elvis, Chuck Berry, Haley & the Comets, Little Richard, etc.), I'm more of a heavier rock fan so my favorites will start with Hendrix to Aerosmith, Van Halen, Pearl Jam, Lynyrd Skynyrd, TheDoors, along with Tom Petty, some Eagles, some Springsteen, REM, Boston, The Cars, Steely Dan, Talking Heads, and others of course.

I'm still messing around with my list, but I can confidently reveal my #1 American Rock song right now...drum roll...
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUGuitarMan1

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
413
350
63
Solid list, but I agree the Beatles don't qualify as Rock. U2 is another band that doesn't get mentioned enough on these lists.
The Beatles are weird to classify - I just see them as the most British (thus eccentric - like Sargent Pepper) of pop-rock. "Helter Skelter" is certainly rockish in the head banging way
 

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
413
350
63
Not really its old music

New rock is dead. Rock will never ever have the influence in mainstream it did from the 50s until the advent of the smartphone

The global push in music ended it

Youngs have been going retro and rediscovering 80s/90s/00s. The popular era now in music, fashion etc is Y2K (the 90s-mid aughts). For awhile US kids had to watch S Korean Music and TV because US was mostly trash (I write that as "Supergirl" becomes latest is bomb. Even PC games have been crashing like never before)


Why are Gen Zers so obsessed with the 2000s, a decade they barely knew?

The decade’s aesthetic is permeating everything from fashion and music to television

"Being cool in the early 2020s is all about embracing the fashion and pop culture of that much-idealised era.

Since the pandemic, Generation Z (people born between 1995 and 2010) has nurtured a fascination for a specific decade, the 2000s. On TikTok, the "Y2K" hashtag has racked up some five billion views and counting.

 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
49,473
60,766
113
The Beatles are weird to classify - I just see them as the most British (thus eccentric - like Sargent Pepper) of pop-rock.

I tend to classify them by the time period in which they emerged. Going back 60+ years, what they played was definitely rock, with much of their music based on some of the rock 'n roll pioneers that came before them. Their heyday in the US was from 1964-1969, I feel like their sound transitioned through that timeline as the whole concept of rock transitioned. When you compare their catalog from back then against much more modern rock songs, of course it sounds different, more "poppy" if you will, but you could say the same about a lot of rock pioneers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUGuitarMan1

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
413
350
63
I tend to classify them by the time period in which they emerged. Going back 60+ years, what they played was definitely rock, with much of their music based on some of the rock 'n roll pioneers that came before them. Their heyday in the US was from 1964-1969, I feel like their sound transitioned through that timeline as the whole concept of rock transitioned. When you compare their catalog from back then against much more modern rock songs, of course it sounds different, more "poppy" if you will, but you could say the same about a lot of rock pioneers.

I can see pop type stuff like "Hold Your Hand" as rockish but things like "Elenore Rigby, Yellow Submarine and Rocky Racoon, When I'm 64" are just British Pop to me. "In My Life" has harpsichord lol. Google AI says "'Eleanor Rigby' is not a traditional rock song. It defies easy genre classification and is widely recognized as a baroque pop or chamber pop masterpiece." I never even heard of baroque pop

I've never been a big Beatles fan (they were mostly before my time) but I always appreciated their eccentric originality. I recall from music history classes that the Beatles used Gregorian chant modes like Phrygian. For me the Beatles are to music what Monty Python is to comedy. Its kinda crazy that a band that did "Yesterday" inspired Charles Manson with "Helter Skelter." That's a heck of a range
 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,533
3,955
73
I can see pop type stuff like "Hold Your Hand" as rockish but things like "Elenore Rigby, Yellow Submarine and Rocky Racoon, When I'm 64" are just British Pop to me. "In My Life" has harpsichord lol. Google AI says "'Eleanor Rigby' is not a traditional rock song. It defies easy genre classification and is widely recognized as a baroque pop or chamber pop masterpiece." I never even heard of baroque pop

I've never been a big Beatles fan (they were mostly before my time) but I always appreciated their eccentric originality. I recall from music history classes that the Beatles used Gregorian chant modes like Phrygian. For me the Beatles are to music what Monty Python is to comedy. Its kinda crazy that a band that did "Yesterday" inspired Charles Manson with "Helter Skelter." That's a heck of a range

Both the “Rubber Soul” album in 1965 and “Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band” album in 1967 are very much groundbreaking albums. Not just having many great songs lyrically but sonically they were game changing. Without question they are “rock” albums.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kbe4

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,826
19,109
113
Both the “Rubber Soul” album in 1965 and “Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band” album in 1967 are very much groundbreaking albums. Not just having many great songs lyrically but sonically they were game changing. Without question they are “rock” albums.

Filling my distributive course requirements with a classical music course in the early 70's the teacher was a concert level pianist. One day he was asked if like the Beethoven piano concertos would any of today's rock be around in 170 years. His answer "Sgt. Peppers"
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUGuitarMan1

yesrutgers01

Heisman
Nov 9, 2008
122,568
38,329
113
One of my favorite all time bands- I wouldn't consider them a rock band but they have so many songs people recognize as soon as they hear them but never know the name of the band -Zebra
 
Jan 12, 2015
39,195
39,261
113
Very cool American rock n' roll trivia with our 250th right around the corner. One of my top Tom Petty songs to boot.
1976 rock classic, reimagined 48 years later, became a Fourth of July anthem
Few songs evoke the spirit of America quite like "American Girl."

When Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers released the track on their 1976 self-titled debut album, its ringing guitars, driving rhythm and uplifting energy immediately set it apart.

Although it wasn't a major hit upon its initial release, the song steadily grew into one of Petty's signature recordings and a staple of classic rock radio. Nearly four decades later, it found a fresh audience when country star Dierks Bentley reimagined it for a new generation.

The song helped introduce one of rock's greatest storytellers.

Written by Petty, "American Girl" tells the story of a young woman longing for something bigger just beyond the horizon. While many listeners have interpreted the lyrics in different ways over the years, Petty consistently rejected urban legends surrounding the song, explaining that it was simply about hope, possibility and youthful dreams.

Although it peaked outside the upper reaches of the charts, "American Girl" became one of those rare songs whose legacy far exceeded its original commercial performance. It evolved into a concert favorite, a classic rock radio staple and one of the recordings most closely associated with Petty's career.

"American Girl" was recorded on July 4, 1976, the exact date of America's bicentennial. It was only fitting, as its distinctly American imagery also made it a natural fit for patriotic celebrations. Over the decades, "American Girl" has become a familiar soundtrack for Fourth of July barbecues, fireworks displays, road trips and summer gatherings, earning a reputation as one of rock's unofficial Independence Day anthems.

Petty, who died in 2017, continued playing the song throughout the rest of his touring career.
 

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
413
350
63


Difference between rock and heavy metal? I know FBI, DoD, CIA and such use heavy metal on prisoners, for standoffs etc. I know bands like Slipknot have talented players (like deceased drummer Joey Jordison) but I can't really listen to them or anyone from that style. Only shredder I can listen to is Buckethead and he uses it as an element of the music and not just a stunt
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
33,546
49,107
113
Probably a matter of personal preference, but I think Queen is always overrated in these lists.
I think Nirvana is while Queen is underrated. Queen introduced things never seen before and things that now are copied.
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
33,546
49,107
113
Here ya go:

Kool & The Gang
Public Enemy
Depeche Mode
The Supremes
The O'Jays
ABBA
Gladys Knight & The Pips
Beastie Boys
Bee Gees
Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five

Hey, they're all in the Rock 'N' Roll Hall of Fame, so they should be Top 10, right?
I do love motown!
 
Jan 12, 2015
39,195
39,261
113
Yeh I get it--just spitballin'. While I definitely respect the first decade American rock &roll musicians (Elvis, Chuck Berry, Haley & the Comets, Little Richard, etc.), I'm more of a heavier rock fan so my favorites will start with Hendrix to Aerosmith, Van Halen, Pearl Jam, Lynyrd Skynyrd, TheDoors, along with Tom Petty, some Eagles, some Springsteen, REM, Boston, The Cars, Steely Dan, Talking Heads, and others of course.

I'm still messing around with my list, but I can confidently reveal my #1 American Rock song right now...drum roll...

Probably 50 more songs could have been added to my list, but it was tough enough trying not to be too top-heavy. Plus I got tired of flipping the coin on so many lol...Happy 250th America! #USA! #USA! #USA!

Top 10 American Rock Songs
Dream On-Aerosmith
Everybody Wants Some-Van Halen
Voodoo Child-Jimi Hendrix
Dissident-Pearl Jam
Sweet Emotion-Aerosmith
Little Guitars-Van Halen
Bye Bye Love-The Cars
Sweet Home Alabama-Lyrnyrd Skynyrd
Psycho Killer-Talking Heads
Touch Me-The Doors

Very Honorable Mentions (alphabetical order):
And The Cradle Will Rock-Van Halen
Are You Experienced-Jimi Hendrix
Born To Run-Bruce Springsteen
EvenFlow-Pearl Jam
Go Your Own Way-Fleetwood Mac
Last Child-Aerosmith
Life In The Fast Lane-Eagles
Only The Young-Journey
Refugee-Tom Petty
Sweet Child of Mine-Guns N Roses
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC93

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
23,722
12,411
113
Probably 50 more songs could have been added to my list, but it was tough enough trying not to be too top-heavy. Plus I got tired of flipping the coin on so many lol...Happy 250th America! #USA! #USA! #USA!

Top 10 American Rock Songs
Dream On-Aerosmith
Everybody Wants Some-Van Halen
Voodoo Child-Jimi Hendrix
Dissident-Pearl Jam
Sweet Emotion-Aerosmith
Little Guitars-Van Halen
Bye Bye Love-The Cars
Sweet Home Alabama-Lyrnyrd Skynyrd
Psycho Killer-Talking Heads
Touch Me-The Doors

Very Honorable Mentions (alphabetical order):
And The Cradle Will Rock-Van Halen
Are You Experienced-Jimi Hendrix
Born To Run-Bruce Springsteen
EvenFlow-Pearl Jam
Go Your Own Way-Fleetwood Mac
Last Child-Aerosmith
Life In The Fast Lane-Eagles
Only The Young-Journey
Refugee-Tom Petty
Sweet Child of Mine-Guns N Roses
No Led Zeppelin?
 
Jan 12, 2015
39,195
39,261
113
No Led Zeppelin?
All-American Rock Songs only, motivated by K-Rock's countdown re: #America250. I'll probably expand MY list; I realize I didn't do justice to a lot of great American RnR with only a 20 count! Some one-off songs like Brandy (by RU/New Brunswick's own band Looking Glass) deserve high recognition.

America turns 250, and Q104.3 is celebrating with the 250 greatest All-American rock songs of all time.
Q104.3 - New York's Rock
 
  • Like
Reactions: RAC93

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
49,473
60,766
113
Probably 50 more songs could have been added to my list, but it was tough enough trying not to be too top-heavy. Plus I got tired of flipping the coin on so many lol...Happy 250th America! #USA! #USA! #USA!

Top 10 American Rock Songs
Dream On-Aerosmith
Everybody Wants Some-Van Halen
Voodoo Child-Jimi Hendrix
Dissident-Pearl Jam
Sweet Emotion-Aerosmith
Little Guitars-Van Halen
Bye Bye Love-The Cars
Sweet Home Alabama-Lyrnyrd Skynyrd
Psycho Killer-Talking Heads
Touch Me-The Doors

Very Honorable Mentions (alphabetical order):
And The Cradle Will Rock-Van Halen
Are You Experienced-Jimi Hendrix
Born To Run-Bruce Springsteen
EvenFlow-Pearl Jam
Go Your Own Way-Fleetwood Mac
Last Child-Aerosmith
Life In The Fast Lane-Eagles
Only The Young-Journey
Refugee-Tom Petty
Sweet Child of Mine-Guns N Roses

I am absolutely shocked you didn't include this one:

 

hoquat63

All-Conference
Mar 17, 2005
9,151
4,445
45
According to a Family Feud poll from a couple of years ago:
Beatles
Stones
ACDC
Led Zeppelin
Aerosmith
Kiss
Metallica
Only 8 listed
 

RU#1fan

Heisman
Mar 7, 2003
23,722
12,411
113
His list was American songs, I was going to rip into it as well but re-read and caught that it was a list of songs from American bands. When I went back, it’s a good list, 3 songs from Van Halen is a bit much but Eddie was an amazing guitarist.
My bad.