Recruiting hits (misses) keep on coming

18IsTheMan

Heisman
Oct 1, 2014
19,572
16,441
113
Recruiting is very generic now and the school name has no value. Minds are easily changed by the $$$ and they may not know where they signed until their ''handler'' tells them.
Agree to an extent. I wouldn't say school name has no value. Bama or Texas is still going to open a lot more doors than South Carolina. In general, though, yeah you are seeing talent more spread around b/c of NIL.
 

PrestonyteParrot

All-Conference
May 28, 2024
2,861
2,819
113
Agree to an extent. I wouldn't say school name has no value. Bama or Texas is still going to open a lot more doors than South Carolina. In general, though, yeah you are seeing talent more spread around b/c of NIL.
Certainly, when I say school name has no value I'm saying recruiting is no longer institutional but financial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18IsTheMan

Piscis

All-Conference
Nov 30, 2001
25,131
2,689
113
Agreed. This is a Gamecocks sports forum, but the thoughts I post here account for > 0.1% of what concerns me in life. It seems foolish to say that for the entire history of college football, fans were allowed to care about recruiting but now that we have NIL you aren't allowed to care or voice an opinion unless you contribute to NIL.

I suspect I'd be allowed to care if I had an overall positive opinion of our recruiting. As always, on all aspects of team, I call it like it I see it. When we do good things, I comment on it. When we do bad things, I comment on it.

As it stand with recruiting, we haven't had anything but bad to comment on in a while. A quick perusal would show I have said many positive things on recruiting in the past.
Some here see this as a "happy thoughts only" zone. I live my life in the world of reality and honesty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 18IsTheMan

RL09

Senior
Dec 29, 2025
681
794
93
Agreed. This is a Gamecocks sports forum, but the thoughts I post here account for > 0.1% of what concerns me in life. It seems foolish to say that for the entire history of college football, fans were allowed to care about recruiting but now that we have NIL you aren't allowed to care or voice an opinion unless you contribute to NIL.

I suspect I'd be allowed to care if I had an overall positive opinion of our recruiting. As always, on all aspects of team, I call it like it I see it. When we do good things, I comment on it. When we do bad things, I comment on it.

As it stand with recruiting, we haven't had anything but bad to comment on in a while. A quick perusal would show I have said many positive things on recruiting in the past.
not sure I would say recruiting has been all bad, did we not just receive a commitment from a 4 star DB?
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,533
3,172
113
No worries. I remember Mrs Satterfield bragging about paying $30 or so at one time. She has more than made up for anyone here who wishes to give to other charities. :)
I wonder if Mrs. Satterfield is here under another handle? That said, I have not detected anyone posting here with such obnoxiousness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker123

Cackmandu

Senior
Mar 26, 2006
1,052
780
113
For the record, I'll never contribute a nickel to NIL. I'm a diehard Carolina Gamecock but it has gotten way out of control. I have 3 grandchildren, that's where I invest my money.
Really sad it all comes down to money! We don’t have the big donors to compete with the top 10 programs or top 20 either. I just can’t see giving my hard earned money to a system where coaches and kids can come and go as they please. It’s definitely for the rich and famous or people that just aren’t seeing it as I do!
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,533
3,172
113
Really sad it all comes down to money! We don’t have the big donors to compete with the top 10 programs or top 20 either. I just can’t see giving my hard earned money to a system where coaches and kids can come and go as they please. It’s definitely for the rich and famous or people that just aren’t seeing it as I do!
I don't understand how any fan of any university can feel good donating to NIL, knowing that players bought for next season may be gone for the following season. What's the point? So, you have one great season. You will have to give about the same amount for the next season, and the next, and the next, etc. Is winning THAT important? I could have understood adding a reasonable small amount to players' scholarships, room/board, books. But the amounts through NIL is ridiculous in my opinion. Yes, coaches get paid and get paid more than they should. But at least coaches have finished their educations, married and have families to support. The players are just kids. The nomadness of college athletics has taken the fun and enjoyment out of the games. I can watch the NFL if I want to watch professional athletics. I might feel differently if I was a college athlete. But I'm just a fan. This "here today, gone tomorrow" players is not appealing. I think it's unhealthy for and detrimental to college athletics.
 

Gr8spur

Joined Sep 16, 2003
Sep 16, 2003
532
1,189
93
How about a school (any school) go totally divergent! Hear me out. They say NO to NIL. Zip, zilch, not a penny! They recruit only players who wish to play simply for a scholarship and the love of the game. They make it a matter of pride. Wear it like a badge. A working man’s team. Even if they never made it to a bowl game, that’s a team I could get behind and become a fan of. Yes, I ended that sentence with a preposition.
Also add a coaching staff who accepted salaries in line with the school’s faculty. I would love following such a team. And I bet I’m not the only one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gamecock stock

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,533
3,172
113
I just wonder when are high school players going to want to get paid? The high schools make a lot of money from fans attending games.
 

Cackmandu

Senior
Mar 26, 2006
1,052
780
113
I just wonder when are high school players going to want to get paid? The high schools make a lot of money from fans attending games.
I would bet it’s already happening! There are a lot of high school players transfering, that has to be expensive for some of these kids to travel farther and or move your family!
 

gamecock stock

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2022
3,533
3,172
113
Stock, didn't some Texas HS QB make $1,000,000.00 his senior year?
I think so. That's inflation for you.

Speaking of inflation, just an aside: my wife was in Washington all last week for the DAR Continental Congress. One drink of Bourbon and Pepsi cost her $31.00. She and the other girls complained to the bartender about the cost. He said that it does include the tip. Whoopee dip. smh
 

Forkcock

All-Conference
Feb 11, 2006
1,633
1,735
113
I think so. That's inflation for you.

Speaking of inflation, just an aside: my wife was in Washington all last week for the DAR Continental Congress. One drink of Bourbon and Pepsi cost her $31.00. She and the other girls complained to the bartender about the cost. He said that it does include the tip. Whoopee dip. smh

😬
 

PrestonyteParrot

All-Conference
May 28, 2024
2,861
2,819
113
I think so. That's inflation for you.

Speaking of inflation, just an aside: my wife was in Washington all last week for the DAR Continental Congress. One drink of Bourbon and Pepsi cost her $31.00. She and the other girls complained to the bartender about the cost. He said that it does include the tip. Whoopee dip. smh
That establishment obviously assumes everyone is a government employee on the dole or on an expense account.