Forbes rates Seton Hall 2nd among NJ Private Colleges in Financial Health

Fishjam

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2016
886
3,135
93
....behind only Princeton who rates an A+ with their $36 Billion endowment.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/car...new-report-warns/ar-AA25RSz6?ocid=socialshare
  • Seton Hall University: B
  • Stevens Institute of Technology: B-
  • Monmouth University: B-
  • Georgian Court University: C+
  • Fairleigh Dickinson University: C-
Article lists 8 colleges in dire straits with a grade of D.
  • Saint Elizabeth University
  • Centenary University
  • Saint Peter’s University
  • Caldwell University
  • Drew University
  • Rider University
  • Felician University
  • Pillar College
 

BrklynGrad

Sophomore
Feb 1, 2026
205
128
43
Lumping St. Peter's, Drew, and Rider with rest of that group is bad news; so is FDU's C-.
 

JCB11

Redshirt
Jan 31, 2013
15
26
13
We’re entering a really precarious period for small private colleges that aren’t among the most elite in the country. The financial health of the university is key to surviving the storm. 3 or more of those D grade schools won’t exist 10 years from now.
 

PirateBlue08

Senior
Jul 25, 2025
767
733
93
Maybe we don’t need so many colleges. Let the chips fall where they may. If it doesn’t make sense as a business get rid of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bluebeard

PirateBlue08

Senior
Jul 25, 2025
767
733
93
If that was the case, then you'd get rid of all athletics.
Athletics is viewed from a marketing standpoint as being worthwhile as an overall business expense to the university. Although for state schools it seems to just be a drain for the taxpayers. I'd be ok with all of it going away to be honest. It's gone too far.
 

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,215
11,569
113
The US college model is a giant bubble long due to burst solely propped up by free money from government both in the form of grants as well as student loans that barely require you to have a pulse.
This! The university model is ready for a major disruption.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PirateBlue08

HallGuy2323

Senior
Jun 3, 2020
829
598
93
Maybe we don’t need so many colleges. Let the chips fall where they may. If it doesn’t make sense as a business get rid of it.
Agreed. But they’ll continue to get taxpayer bailouts because they’re “important to the economy of the area” or do fugazi mergers like NJCU/Kean.

There’s no reason to have this many colleges in a single state.
 

Halldan

All-American
Staff member
Jan 1, 2003
184,724
7,447
113
The Forbes 2026 College Financial Grades show the worst overall performance since the tracker began in 2013, with more than 25% of the 928 private colleges analyzed receiving a "D" grade. Nearly half of the institutions evaluated scored a "C" or worse, highlighting a massive financial divide in higher education. While elite, highly selective universities remain exceptionally strong, smaller private colleges with open admissions are struggling significantly due to a shrinking pool of high school graduates, dipping international enrollment, and aggressive tuition discounting. [1, 2, 3]

Summary of the 2026 Financial Health Grades
  • Over 25% of schools received a "D" grade.
  • Nearly 50% of schools scored a "C" or worse.
  • Only 11% of schools (more than 100 institutions) achieved a perfect "A+" grade.

Grading Criteria
Forbes updated its methodology to better capture true liquidity, scoring private, non-profit institutions with over 500 students across 10 main categories:

  • Endowment size and assets per student.
  • Liquidity measures, including a 3-year average of Unrestricted Net Assets Without Donor Restrictions (UNAEP) relative to operating expenses.
  • Core operating margins and primary reserve ratios.
  • Enrollment trends and admissions yield.
  • Tuition reliance and freshman financial aid metrics.

The Top Tier: Perfect "A+" Financial Health
Elite institutions backed by massive endowments dominate the top of the list, boasting maximum 4.50 GPAs. Examples include:
  • Ivy League Leaders: Harvard University, Brown University, Dartmouth College, and the University of Pennsylvania.
  • Elite Liberal Arts Colleges: Pomona College, Williams College, Amherst College, and Bowdoin College.
  • Major Research & Specialty Institutions: MIT, Stanford University, Duke University, University of Notre Dame, and The Juilliard School.

The Bottom Tier: Regional Crises
The report points out severe geographic clusters of financial distress. For example, in New Jersey, more than half of the state's four-year private colleges earned a "D" grade due to crashing enrollment and revenue shortfalls, prompting aggressive faculty cuts and land-sale considerations.
  • Distressed New Jersey Schools: Rider University, Drew University, Saint Peter's University, Caldwell University, Centenary University, Saint Elizabeth University, Felician University, and Pillar College.
 
Jun 3, 2001
311
441
63
The US college model is a giant bubble long due to burst solely propped up by free money from government both in the form of grants as well as student loans that barely require you to have a pulse.
you may have just hit on the one leverage point that hasn't been raised....you want colleges to "follow the rules"...put their grant funding at risk. you wont see the rampant skirting of the rules that we have seen constantly...
 
  • Like
Reactions: PirateBlue08

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,215
11,569
113
Enrollment cliff is just beginning. Number of 18yos will decline some 15% in next few years.
I think the projection is a decline will be for about 15-20 years before it turns about. Fewer kids and job shift (more trades or alternative models) is going to shake up the landscape. One school I was surprised that is also struggling is Syracuse.
 
Jun 3, 2001
311
441
63
I think the projection is a decline will be for about 15-20 years before it turns about. Fewer kids and job shift (more trades or alternative models) is going to shake up the landscape. One school I was surprised that is also struggling is Syracuse.
AI is also affecting this. Careers in accounting, actuaries, consultants, lawyers, and more will all be (negatively) impacted by this…even if for now it is more projection then reality.
The” trades”, ie carpentry, plumbing, electrician, etc. are all insulated from AI.

it’s becoming a safer choice
 
  • Like
Reactions: TommyD82

Halldan

All-American
Staff member
Jan 1, 2003
184,724
7,447
113
College enrollment is declining primarily due to demographic shifts (fewer 18-year-olds), dropping confidence in degree value, rising tuition costs, and new technological alternatives that allow students to enter the workforce directly.

Key Reasons for the Decline
  • The Demographic "Cliff": There are simply fewer traditional-aged students. Birth rates dropped significantly during the 2008 Great Recession, resulting in a shrinking pool of high school graduates.
  • Changing Perceptions: Public confidence in the value of a bachelor's degree has dropped. Many Americans now cite rising tuition and high student debt as major deterrents.
  • Alternative Pathways: Major tech companies and employers have begun dropping degree requirements, enabling young adults to bypass college and learn via bootcamps or online alternatives. The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence has also encouraged more students to learn highly specialized skills quickly on their own.
  • Sector-Specific Drops: While highly competitive four-year universities and elite schools have maintained their numbers, regional colleges and community colleges have absorbed the brunt of these declines.
  • International Pipeline Strains: Tighter visa rules, immigration policy changes, and global political tensions have decreased the number of international students choosing U.S. colleges.

Impact and Regional Differences
Because there is a higher density of colleges in the Northeast and Midwest, areas like Bloomfield, NJ and the wider northeastern region are facing steeper enrollment challenges than the Sun Belt. Consequently, this "perfect storm" of challenges has forced many vulnerable, smaller colleges to merge or close entirely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Silkcity Pirate

Garyshu1971

Sophomore
Jul 13, 2025
76
141
32
We should all be pleased with the financial responsibility Seton Hall has shown. I’m not always happy with some of the goings on at SetonHall but the ability to increase enrollment and improve the academic status of those enrolled is astounding knowing what is going on all around the schools of New Jersey.
 

HallX2

Senior
Mar 25, 2005
2,667
865
73
We should all be pleased with the financial responsibility Seton Hall has shown. I’m not always happy with some of the goings on at SetonHall but the ability to increase enrollment and improve the academic status of those enrolled is astounding knowing what is going on all around the schools of New Jersey.
I’d feel better if we had an appropriate size endowment. FWIW, Hofstra’s is 3x our’s. That’s sad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Garyshu1971

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,215
11,569
113
Like most non-profits that struggle, there isn’t much pro-active thought on long term planning. Many of these schools know that the end is coming but they choose to fly the plane into the mountain.

Cabrini should have merged with Villanova 20 years ago, but waited until they had blown through their endowment and let the propane decay. Alumni and BOR’s can be unrealistic even when it’s plain as day. They would rather drain the endowment rather then let another organization spend it for selfish reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HallX2

HallX2

Senior
Mar 25, 2005
2,667
865
73
Like most non-profits that struggle, there isn’t much pro-active thought on long term planning. Many of these schools know that the end is coming but they choose to fly the plane into the mountain.

Cabrini should have merged with Villanova 20 years ago, but waited until they had blown through their endowment and let the propane decay. Alumni and BOR’s can be unrealistic even when it’s plain as day. They would rather drain the endowment rather then let another organization spend it for selfish reasons.
Let’s be honest most college Boards are filled with those who wrote checks and notwithstanding their largesse are neither effective nor visionary. We are no different.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
36,722
3,085
113
Odd that no one here seems to equate the ability to earn money with intelligence and common sense.
 

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
36,722
3,085
113
Do you think only people that go to college have both?
No. But I thought saying generous, rich people are not effective or visionary is not something that has any merit imo. Some do, sone dont.
 

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,215
11,569
113
No. But I thought saying generous, rich people are not effective or visionary is not something that has any merit imo. Some do, sone dont.
Didn’t say all, but non-profit boards can be insular.

I’ve seen it with hospital boards and other NP related Boards. Part of it has to do with the endowment remains going to a different organization. The colleges on that list should be having merger discussions now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HallX2

Seton75

All-Conference
Jun 3, 2001
36,722
3,085
113
Didn’t say all, but non-profit boards can be insular.

I’ve seen it with hospital boards and other NP related Boards. Part of it has to do with the endowment remains going to a different organization. The colleges on that list should be having merger discussions now.
I know nothing about our board and was simply responding to phrase in a post.
 

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,215
11,569
113
My view and it’s just mine is that few boards reflect the schools as meritocracies
They are businesses and they try to sustain themselves. Some don’t do a very good job of assessing the market and outside forces. SHU is doing better than small private universities.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Silkcity Pirate

HallX2

Senior
Mar 25, 2005
2,667
865
73
They are businesses and they try to sustain themselves. Some don’t do a very good job of assessing the market and outside forces. SHU is doing better than small private universities.
If so it’s more happenstance than real vision. I’d say the BOR has a history of dysfunction. Nyre, Marino and Leahy are prime examples.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TommyD82

HALL85

Heisman
Jul 5, 2001
30,215
11,569
113
If so it’s more happenstance than real vision. I’d say the BOR has a history of dysfunction. Nyre, Marino and Leahy are prime examples.
By better I mean they are surviving better than the ones ready to close. I agree the BOR has had too many black eyes and are always two steps behind other BE schools. Not the most engaging or inclusive group.