Should the fed cut interest rates?

tarheelbybirth1

Heisman
Jul 4, 2025
6,254
17,873
113
IMO the U.S. spent twice what it should have on Covid. 90% were working but we gave them stimulus checks anyway. Many of the 10% that weren't working were getting paid more not to work. A lot of big and small companies + government agencies took advantage of handouts. I blame both sides.

There was a lot of money with pent up demand. Then when Biden was elected he handed out another $3.5 trillion. Of course that sped up the economy. It also ran up the debt and kicked off inflation.

Unlike you I don't think more government handouts is the best path to prosperity. I think government caused the financial crisis and much of today's affordability problem.

I'm not a big Trump fan. I think Iran was a big mistake. But people like you think that 100% of everything he does is evil (racist, misogynist, pedophile, Nazi). I don't think that way about any president. Of course I have opinions but I try to focus on data and facts. So when you say that 9% inflation under Biden wasn't his fault but Trump is destroying the country with 3% inflation I have trouble taking you seriously.
Where are you getting $3.5T? The American Rescue Plan was $1.9T... where does the other $1.6T come from? Are you lumping Infrastructure and CHIPS in with that?
 
Last edited:

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
AI is booming.
The markets are soaring into bubble territory.
The wealthy are raking it in.

What about the average American?
Define Average Americans. Do any of these apply?
  • No tax on tips (income limit)
  • No tax on OT (income limit )
  • $12k deduction to offset taxes on SS (income limit)
  • Higher Standard deduction
  • Higher child credit
Nominal wage growth:
2021 (inflation 7.0%)
2002 3.0% (inflation 6.5%)
2003 3.0% (inflation 3.4%)
2004 3.5% (inflation 2.9%)

2005 3.6% (inflation 2.7%)
2006 thru April 3.53% (inflation 3.8%)
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
based strictly on statistics the "average" American household should be doing OK...according to AI "The average U.S. household income is approximately $121,000, while the median U.S. household income is $83,730. The median is considered the more accurate benchmark of a typical household's earnings because it avoids being skewed by high-earning outliers"

Without question, there is a group of Americans that are having economic difficulties. Obviously, average won't/doesn't mean much in that discussion.

here's a breakdown of the "below average"
According to USAFacts data based on U.S. Census Bureau figures, household income groups are distributed as follows:
  • Less than \(\$35,000\): ~22% of households
  • \(\$35,000\) to \(\$49,999\): ~10% of households
  • \(\$50,000\) to \(\$99,999\): ~28% of households
  • \(\$100,000\) and over: ~41% of household
A household earning less than $35,000 - 22% of households - are in trouble
Think about that. 32% of all households earn less than $49,999. A person can get close to $40k + benefits to start with only a high school education and a work ethic. No experience necessary. That would be $80k for two income family. That seems like a pretty low bar but nearly a third fall below that amount.

FWIW I think those numbers are before transfer payments.
 

What Would Jesus Do?

All-American
Nov 28, 2010
36,269
5,727
113
based on this information, I don't know why everybody doesn't work to become a CEO...if they're interested in money.

I worked in industry for 20 years...negotiated for my salary and benefits...and you know, I never once worried about how much the CEO made. As long as he was doing his job, the company was growing, making money, and providing benefits to both employees and retirees, I was happy. Maybe I was wrong not to be concerned, but envy was not part of my makeup.
That perspective works if you only think about yourself and are doing fine.

You apparently had that luxury, as did I.

Others aren't so lucky - no matter how hard they work.

Envy isn't the issue. Compassion for others is the issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yoshi121374

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
Your answer embodies a point of view that I used to share. Namely "As long as I'm doing well, why should I have a problem with you doing even better?" But the discrepancies between the ordinary Joe and our plutocrats has become obscene. I asked Gemini a related question and got some interesting data.
.
.
.
The most consistent tracking of this data comes from the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), which measures the "realized compensation" (including salary, bonuses, and cashed-out stock options/awards) of CEOs at the 350 largest U.S. firms compared to a typical worker in their industry.
The baseline shifted over the last 60 to 75 years from a modest double-digit gap to a massive triple-digit chasm, peaking during stock market bubbles.

The Historical Timeline​

Era / YearCEO-to-Worker Pay RatioThe Context
1950s–1960s21 to 1 (In 1965)Executives were paid primarily in salary and bonuses. Corporate culture and high marginal tax rates discouraged extreme pay disparities.
1970s31 to 1 (In 1978)The ratio stayed relatively flat through the mid-70s before beginning a slow crawl upward as the economy shifted.
1980s61 to 1 (In 1989)Deregulation and the introduction of heavy stock-option packages began widening the gap in earnest.
1990s121 to 1 (In 1995)This matches the "factor of 10" growth you heard about (going from roughly 30-to-1 in the 70s to over 300-to-1 by the end of the 90s).
2000366 to 1The peak of the Dot-Com bubble. Because CEO pay became tied directly to the stock market via options, soaring stocks meant astronomical payouts.
2021408 to 1A historic high, driven by the massive stock market surge during the pandemic recovery.
Recent (2024)281 to 1While down from the 2021 peak due to shifting stock values and changes in corporate payouts, it remains vastly higher than any pre-1990s era.

Sorting Out the "1,000 Times" Discrepancy​

When you hear a figure like "1,000 times difference" today, it usually stems from one of two specific scenarios rather than the broad macroeconomic average:
  • Individual Extremes: At specific massive corporations (like retail giants or tech firms with hundreds of thousands of low-wage part-time workers), the ratio frequently hits 1,000-to-1 or higher. For example, if a CEO pulls in $30 million mostly in stock and the median worker is a part-time retail employee making $30,000, the ratio is exactly 1,000-to-1.
  • The 1,000% Growth Stat: You might also be crossing wires with a frequently cited growth metric: between 1978 and recent years, top CEO compensation grew by roughly 1,094% (adjusted for inflation), while typical worker compensation grew by just 26%.
The trajectory shows that what was once a relatively tight relationship between executive and worker pay completely uncoupled once equity and stock grants became the primary vehicle for corporate leadership compensation.

Fresh data for 2025 and early 2026 has recently been compiled. Because companies report their executive pay for the previous year during spring proxy seasons, the figures for fiscal year 2025 have just crystallized, giving us a clear view of where things stand right now in 2026.
The numbers show that after a brief moderation in 2023 and 2024, CEO compensation experienced a massive surge in 2025, primarily driven by soaring stock awards linked to corporate investments in artificial intelligence and tech.
The gap has widened yet again, depending on which corporate index is measured.

1. The Broad S&P 500 Index (Associated Press/Equilar Study)​

This tracking covers the chief executives across the entire S&P 500.
  • Median CEO Pay (2025): $17.7 million, an increase of nearly 6% year-over-year.
  • Median Employee Pay (2025): $89,744, up 4.7% year-over-year.
  • The 2025 Pay Ratio: 200 to 1 > Note on this metric: This is a straight median-to-median comparison across the middle of the S&P 500. The analysts noted that across half of the companies surveyed, it would now take a typical employee 200 years to earn what their CEO makes in a single year.

2. The Mega-Cap Companies (The Equilar 100)​

When looking specifically at the early disclosures of the top 100 largest U.S. public companies by revenue (companies with at least $1 billion in revenue where executive pay is heavily stock-dependent), the spike was much more severe.
  • Median CEO Pay (2025): $29.4 million, which represents a massive 23.2% jump from the prior year.
  • Median Employee Pay (2025): $99,229, up roughly 10%.
  • The 2025 Pay Ratio: 341 to 1 (up from 300-to-1 the year before).

Key Drivers of the 2025/2026 Surge​

  • The Equity Spike: The median value of stock awards alone jumped 38.8% for mega-cap CEOs. Because boards heavily favor multi-year stock grants tied to performance milestones, the booming market valuation of these firms directly translated to larger realized packages.
  • An Rise in "Perks": Interestingly, executive perquisites (like security details and private travel) saw an unprecedented spike of 17.7% to 24% across various studies. Industry analysts attribute this sharp rise to boards heavily expanding corporate security budgets for top executives following high-profile security incidents late in the prior year.
While the broad macroeconomic numbers from groups like the Economic Policy Institute (which use a specific "realized compensation" formula for the top 350 firms) are still finalizing their long-term weighted averages for this exact moment, the corporate disclosures clear the air: the gap is aggressively expanding back toward its pandemic-era highs.
Who cares?

We could give people a free place to live, free food, free utilities, etc and the wealth gap would remain. Do we owe people a minimum lifestyle or do we owe them at least 30%? of a CEO lifestyle?

Also, why are people so upset that the CEO of a Fortune 500 company makes $40 million per year but we aren't as upset that Taylor Swift, Beyonce, Tom Cruise, The Rock, etc make a whole lot more than most CEOs?
 

What Would Jesus Do?

All-American
Nov 28, 2010
36,269
5,727
113
They waited a year to hit and that was coincidentally when the straits were closed?
They take a while to implement.

They were erratic - as Trump jerked countries, markets and sectors for advantage (including personal advantage).

Some shippers and more importers absorbed the extra costs initially (and those who did now expect refunds).

Surely you don't think "They waited a year to hit and that was coincidentally when the straits were closed?" is an accurate characterization, or that your mocking formulation somehow proves tariffs weren't part of the problem.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
That perspective works if you only think about yourself and are doing fine.

You apparently had that luxury, as did I.

Others aren't so lucky - no matter how hard they work.

Envy isn't the issue. Compassion for others is the issue.
You're free to give away as much of your money as you want. Our government is broke and can't afford it.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
Then you're way short. You have to include the entire budgets that were passed.
Also add executive orders

President Biden’s Executive Actions Have Cost Taxpayers Over $2 Trillion | The U.S. House Committee on the Budget - House Budget Committee

The debt in 2020 was $26.95 trillion
The debt in 2024 was $35.46 trillion

Federal spending was $4.4 trillion in 2019 (pre covid)
Federal spending was $6.9 trillion in 2024 (post covid)
That's a 56% increase in 5 years with no covid in either year
 

AlexanderUrinis

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2025
2,247
4,134
113
IMO the U.S. spent twice what it should have on Covid. 90% were working but we gave them stimulus checks anyway. Many of the 10% that weren't working were getting paid more not to work. A lot of big and small companies + government agencies took advantage of handouts. I blame both sides.

There was a lot of money with pent up demand. Then when Biden was elected he handed out another $3.5 trillion. Of course that sped up the economy. It also ran up the debt and kicked off inflation.

Unlike you I don't think more government handouts is the best path to prosperity. I think government caused the financial crisis and much of today's affordability problem.

I'm not a big Trump fan. I think Iran was a big mistake. But people like you think that 100% of everything he does is evil (racist, misogynist, pedophile, Nazi). I don't think that way about any president. Of course I have opinions but I try to focus on data and facts. So when you say that 9% inflation under Biden wasn't his fault but Trump is destroying the country with 3% inflation I have trouble taking you seriously.
Please name some non-evil things he does, I am genuinely curious.
 

AlexanderUrinis

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2025
2,247
4,134
113
Geez, just what we need. Trump appointed fed chair redefining and changing how we calculate inflation. Entirely unnecessary.

I love the political bias in threads like these. All finger pointing to Biden/trump yet very little mention of the federal reserve. Both Biden and trump shoulder some of the blame for the inflation we saw in 21/22 but a bulk of it is on the federal reserve. Their balance sheet more than doubled in 2 years. 2021 was not Jerome Powell best year for job performance. Artificially keeping those rates low for far too long.
You have received one amen from the congregation.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
That perspective works if you only think about yourself and are doing fine.

You apparently had that luxury, as did I.

Others aren't so lucky - no matter how hard they work.

Envy isn't the issue. Compassion for others is the issue.
aren't the government safety net programs demonstrating compassion. Individuals like you and I can donate food to the food banks, money to red cross, samaritan's purse or other organizations.....Americans might be the most generous people on the planet...Think about yourself? who doesn't think about themselves ?

Is there a better way for us to show compassion than what we're doing. Do the people on the other side of the compassion have any responsibilities? We seem to spend a lot of time complaining about how much as CEO or high earners makes, but these are also the people who are funding the government..making donations..the evil head of the citadel organization made a $650million donation to a NY hospital...those things seem to get overlooked.

I personally donate a lot of money and am paying for college for my grandchildren...And, I pay very little attention to how much a CEO earns.

Can we do more, sure we can...
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdgan

AlexanderUrinis

All-Conference
Feb 24, 2025
2,247
4,134
113
Also add executive orders

President Biden’s Executive Actions Have Cost Taxpayers Over $2 Trillion | The U.S. House Committee on the Budget - House Budget Committee

The debt in 2020 was $26.95 trillion
The debt in 2024 was $35.46 trillion

Federal spending was $4.4 trillion in 2019 (pre covid)
Federal spending was $6.9 trillion in 2024 (post covid)
That's a 56% increase in 5 years with no covid in either year
Did you actually read that garbage list? I don't think you are arguing in good faith here.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
Please name some non-evil things he does, I am genuinely curious.
Off the top of my head:

Closing the border
Stricter law enforcement
Insisting that our so called allies pay their fair share
Deregulation
Increased foreign investment
Helped stop a few wars

There are also lot of things I disagree with but I certainly don't consider them evil. No tax on tips, OT, & SS for low to mid income families and $1,000 accounts for newborns are examples. The same with Biden. I disagreed with $200 billion in student loan forgiveness. I thought that was bad policy but I don't consider it evil. I think all presidents have big egos and want to be remembered favorably. That doesn't mean you have to agree with their policies.

FWIW I think the Iran war was a big mistake. I think it was an especially dumb political thing to do it so close to the election. I also think Trump underestimated Iran's will. Weeks not months certainly hasn't worked out. I tend to look at things from a financial standpoint. I think our debt and deficit is so large that we simply can no longer afford to be the defender of the world. I completely understand that Iran is the world's largest state sponsor of terror and they clearly have nuclear ambitions. I also think that their first nuclear attack would be somewhere other than the USA. So if the rest of the world won't take action to stop them I don't think it's the USA's job to do it alone. Having said all of this I think Trump wants to be remembered as bringing peace to the middle east and this is a big first step. I disagree with what he's done but I don't consider it evil.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
aren't the government safety net programs demonstrating compassion. Individuals like you and I can donate food to the food banks, money to red cross, samaritan's purse or other organizations.....Americans might be the most generous people on the planet...Think about yourself? who doesn't think about themselves ?

Is there a better way for us to show compassion than what we're doing. Do the people on the other side of the compassion have any responsibilities? We seem to spend a lot of time complaining about how much as CEO or high earners makes, but these are also the people who are funding the government..making donations..the evil head of the citadel organization made a $650million donation to a NY hospital...those things seem to get overlooked.

I personally donate a lot of money and am paying for college for my grandchildren...And, I pay very little attention to how much a CEO earns.

Can we do more, sure we can...


I think the ultra wealthy should pay a little bit more in an effort to reduce the deficit, not to expand social welfare. Nearly 25% of Americans already receive social welfare and I think that leads to dependency. The amount that the USA spends on social welfare has never been higher but some think it's never enough.

I was in Pittsburgh this weekend and was reminded that Carnegie funded 2,500 libraries across the nation. This is the same guy who was accused of being a robber baron that screwed over society. I'm not a big fan of Bill Gates but I think his philanthropic endeavors are made with good intentions. My point is that rich people aren't inherently evil. Unfortunately politicians like to blame wealthy people for the struggles of others. It works because a lot of people are envious and it's easier to blame others for their own struggles..
 

What Would Jesus Do?

All-American
Nov 28, 2010
36,269
5,727
113
What new tax breaks did the plutocrats get?
Hey, Gemini. What tax breaks did plutocrats get from the Trump tax cuts? Asking for a friend.

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 introduced several key provisions that significantly lowered the tax burden on corporations and high-income earners. These include:
  • Corporate Tax Rate Reduction: The federal corporate income tax rate was permanently reduced from 35% to 21%.
  • Pass-Through Business Deduction (Section 199A): This allowed owners of pass-through entities (such as partnerships, S-corps, and sole proprietorships) to deduct up to 20% of their "qualified business income" from their taxes, effectively lowering their marginal tax rate compared to those earning traditional wages.
  • Estate Tax Threshold Increase: The amount of assets exempt from the estate tax was temporarily doubled—from $5 million per person to $10 million (indexed for inflation)—allowing significantly more wealth to be passed to heirs tax-free.
  • Individual Income Tax Brackets: The top marginal income tax rate was lowered from 39.6% to 37%, and the income thresholds for these brackets were adjusted.
  • Capital Gains Taxes: The tax structure remained favorable toward investment income, which makes up a larger share of income for the wealthiest taxpayers.
Reports and analyses from organizations like the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) have noted that while many taxpayers saw some reduction in their taxes, the largest absolute dollar savings and the greatest relative share of the benefits were concentrated among the highest income earners and business owners.

Additionally, recent legislative efforts and tax policy discussions in 2025 and 2026 have often built upon or extended these 2017 frameworks, with some analyses suggesting that newer policies (often referred to in current political discourse as the "Big Beautiful Bill" or "Megabill") continue to provide significant tax relief to the top 1% of earners while shifting the fiscal burden through other economic adjustments.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
Hey, Gemini. What tax breaks did plutocrats get from the Trump tax cuts? Asking for a friend.

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 introduced several key provisions that significantly lowered the tax burden on corporations and high-income earners. These include:
  • Corporate Tax Rate Reduction: The federal corporate income tax rate was permanently reduced from 35% to 21%.
  • Pass-Through Business Deduction (Section 199A): This allowed owners of pass-through entities (such as partnerships, S-corps, and sole proprietorships) to deduct up to 20% of their "qualified business income" from their taxes, effectively lowering their marginal tax rate compared to those earning traditional wages.
  • Estate Tax Threshold Increase: The amount of assets exempt from the estate tax was temporarily doubled—from $5 million per person to $10 million (indexed for inflation)—allowing significantly more wealth to be passed to heirs tax-free.
  • Individual Income Tax Brackets: The top marginal income tax rate was lowered from 39.6% to 37%, and the income thresholds for these brackets were adjusted.
  • Capital Gains Taxes: The tax structure remained favorable toward investment income, which makes up a larger share of income for the wealthiest taxpayers.
Reports and analyses from organizations like the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) have noted that while many taxpayers saw some reduction in their taxes, the largest absolute dollar savings and the greatest relative share of the benefits were concentrated among the highest income earners and business owners.

Additionally, recent legislative efforts and tax policy discussions in 2025 and 2026 have often built upon or extended these 2017 frameworks, with some analyses suggesting that newer policies (often referred to in current political discourse as the "Big Beautiful Bill" or "Megabill") continue to provide significant tax relief to the top 1% of earners while shifting the fiscal burden through other economic adjustments.
That was 2017 and has nothing to do with the BBB.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
I think the ultra wealthy should pay a little bit more in an effort to reduce the deficit, not to expand social welfare. Nearly 25% of Americans already receive social welfare and I think that leads to dependency. The amount that the USA spends on social welfare has never been higher but some think it's never enough.

I was in Pittsburgh this weekend and was reminded that Carnegie funded 2,500 libraries across the nation. This is the same guy who was accused of being a robber baron that screwed over society. I'm not a big fan of Bill Gates but I think his philanthropic endeavors are made with good intentions. My point is that rich people aren't inherently evil. Unfortunately politicians like to blame wealthy people for the struggles of others. It works because a lot of people are envious and it's easier to blame others for their own struggles..
I have no argument with anything you posted. And, IMO, most of the ultra wealthy would not be objectionable to paying a higher tax rate if they felt the money was being used wisely. But just creating a longer 'deficit tail" by increasing existing programs or adding new ones just doesn't make sound financial sense..IMO
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdgan

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
Two things:

1) Read the last paragraph of the post for the new stuff. Less detailed because, you know, newer.

2) You're giving Trump a pass for his earlier bad acts?
  • I always thought it was a bad idea to lower the top rate from 39.6% to 37%. One reason is that we need the revenue. The other reason is that dems would cry "tax cuts for the rich". Just a bad political decision IMO.
  • Half the country pays zero or negative income taxes so by definition any tax cut favors "the rich". Does that mean taxes always have to go up?
  • Democrats shat all over the 2017 bill but I said from day one democrats would never fully repeal it even if they were in charge. There is no way they would lower the standard deduction and child credit while increasing rates on the middle class. The only thing they would do is raise the top rate and maybe lower the estate tax exemption.
  • The same thing is now true for no tax on tips, no tax on OT and no tax on SS. Democrats wouldn't dare get rid of those things. Blaming the top 1%-5% for the country's problems might be effective politics but blaming half the population is a loser.
I didn't give Trump a pass for anything. I'm just telling it like it is. I think the top rate should be higher but increasing it won't lower housing costs, healthcare costs, or grocery prices.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
Hey, Gemini. What tax breaks did plutocrats get from the Trump tax cuts? Asking for a friend.

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) of 2017 introduced several key provisions that significantly lowered the tax burden on corporations and high-income earners. These include:
  • Corporate Tax Rate Reduction: The federal corporate income tax rate was permanently reduced from 35% to 21%.
  • Pass-Through Business Deduction (Section 199A): This allowed owners of pass-through entities (such as partnerships, S-corps, and sole proprietorships) to deduct up to 20% of their "qualified business income" from their taxes, effectively lowering their marginal tax rate compared to those earning traditional wages.
  • Estate Tax Threshold Increase: The amount of assets exempt from the estate tax was temporarily doubled—from $5 million per person to $10 million (indexed for inflation)—allowing significantly more wealth to be passed to heirs tax-free.
  • Individual Income Tax Brackets: The top marginal income tax rate was lowered from 39.6% to 37%, and the income thresholds for these brackets were adjusted.
  • Capital Gains Taxes: The tax structure remained favorable toward investment income, which makes up a larger share of income for the wealthiest taxpayers.
Reports and analyses from organizations like the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) have noted that while many taxpayers saw some reduction in their taxes, the largest absolute dollar savings and the greatest relative share of the benefits were concentrated among the highest income earners and business owners.

Additionally, recent legislative efforts and tax policy discussions in 2025 and 2026 have often built upon or extended these 2017 frameworks, with some analyses suggesting that newer policies (often referred to in current political discourse as the "Big Beautiful Bill" or "Megabill") continue to provide significant tax relief to the top 1% of earners while shifting the fiscal burden through other economic adjustments.
not sure of gemini's political leanings, but the part on capital gains taxes doesn't track with one of the major complaints of a lot of folks on the board. These seem to believe that a major shortcoming of our system is that billionaires borrow against their assets in order to avoid paying taxes. If that's the case, these rich folks would be paying very little income tax as the amount of the loans aren't taxed, and the capital gains are not taxed until realized.
 

What Would Jesus Do?

All-American
Nov 28, 2010
36,269
5,727
113
  • I always thought it was a bad idea to lower the top rate from 39.6% to 37%. One reason is that we need the revenue. The other reason is that dems would cry "tax cuts for the rich". Just a bad political decision IMO.
  • Half the country pays zero or negative income taxes so by definition any tax cut favors "the rich". Does that mean taxes always have to go up?
  • Democrats shat all over the 2017 bill but I said from day one democrats would never fully repeal it even if they were in charge. There is no way they would lower the standard deduction and child credit while increasing rates on the middle class. The only thing they would do is raise the top rate and maybe lower the estate tax exemption.
  • The same thing is now true for no tax on tips, no tax on OT and no tax on SS. Democrats wouldn't dare get rid of those things. Blaming the top 1%-5% for the country's problems might be effective politics but blaming half the population is a loser.
I didn't give Trump a pass for anything. I'm just telling it like it is. I think the top rate should be higher but increasing it won't lower housing costs, healthcare costs, or grocery prices.
You make mostly good points.

To answer your "Does that mean taxes always have to go up?" question: if we plan to pay the bills without worsening the debt and the already-exorbitant interest we are paying on it, then yes. Not always, but certainly now.

Do you have a better idea? Keep in mind that future cuts do not pay current bills.
 

Palmerhawk

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
2,653
5,196
113
not sure of gemini's political leanings, but the part on capital gains taxes doesn't track with one of the major complaints of a lot of folks on the board. These seem to believe that a major shortcoming of our system is that billionaires borrow against their assets in order to avoid paying taxes. If that's the case, these rich folks would be paying very little income tax as the amount of the loans aren't taxed, and the capital gains are not taxed until realized.
By not making changes in capital gains rate or treatment( private equity) along with stepped up basis for heirs the tax law favored wealthy and encouraged the tax avoidance tactic you described.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
not sure of gemini's political leanings, but the part on capital gains taxes doesn't track with one of the major complaints of a lot of folks on the board. These seem to believe that a major shortcoming of our system is that billionaires borrow against their assets in order to avoid paying taxes. If that's the case, these rich folks would be paying very little income tax as the amount of the loans aren't taxed, and the capital gains are not taxed until realized.
I don't think there's as much borrowing against assets as you do. Let's say you have $10 billion in assets. A mansion might cost $40 million. Yachts and cars might be another $40 million. Let's round up to $100 million total. Why would they borrow $10 billion when they want to spend $100 million?

Assume that $10 million has a cost basis of $1 billion. The $9 billion gain would be taxed at 23.8% (fed only) or $2.1 billion. Borrowing $10 billion at 5% interest for 20 years would be $10 billion in interest. It would be much better to pay the tax.

Bottom line is that they most likely only borrow a relatively small percent of their net worth and even then only if it's just a short term need. The bigger concern is that they have large ownership stakes in companies that they never intend to sell. That's why democrats want a wealth tax.
 

bdgan

All-American
Oct 12, 2021
5,734
5,565
113
You make mostly good points.

To answer your "Does that mean taxes always have to go up?" question: if we plan to pay the bills without worsening the debt and the already-exorbitant interest we are paying on it, then yes. Not always, but certainly now.

Do you have a better idea? Keep in mind that future cuts do not pay current bills.
The right answer is to cut spending but that won't happen. The deficit is far too large and we can't even agree on the easy stuff. Look at things like PBS. That was created when we had 3 TV stations and no internet but it was like we're destroying the country. Or requiring able bodied working age people without dependents to work 20 hours per week in order to remain qualified for benefits. You would have thought we were executing tens of millions of people.

Now let's look at taxes. The country collects $5 trillion but spends $7 trillion. That means we would have to increase taxes by 40% to eliminate the deficit. We can argue about who has to pay but for the same of argument let's say across the board. 40% more income taxes, 40% more SS taxes, 40% more Medicare taxes, 40% more tax on corporations, and 40% more tax on estates. Can you even imagine what that would do to the economy and people's lives?

Biden proposed increasing the top rate back to 39.6% + adding a 1% wealth tax. He said it would generate $500 billion over 10 years ($50 billion per year). If he was correct it might have lowered the deficit from $2 trillion to $1.95 trillion. That's something but not even close to what's necessary.

Elections will come and go. Taxes on the rich and corporations will go up a bit under democrats but they will spend every bit of that tax increase on new programs. Promising free stuff is how politicians get elected.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,677
6,987
113
I don't think there's as much borrowing against assets as you do. Let's say you have $10 billion in assets. A mansion might cost $40 million. Yachts and cars might be another $40 million. Let's round up to $100 million total. Why would they borrow $10 billion when they want to spend $100 million?

Assume that $10 million has a cost basis of $1 billion. The $9 billion gain would be taxed at 23.8% (fed only) or $2.1 billion. Borrowing $10 billion at 5% interest for 20 years would be $10 billion in interest. It would be much better to pay the tax.

Bottom line is that they most likely only borrow a relatively small percent of their net worth and even then only if it's just a short term need. The bigger concern is that they have large ownership stakes in companies that they never intend to sell. That's why democrats want a wealth tax.
I don't think there's much borrowing either. I just pointed out that argument has been used on the board as a basis for changing tax laws so the billionaires will pay more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bdgan

Hawkedup

All-American
Jul 8, 2025
3,324
7,499
113
Your months are off. I got a 2.375 fixed 30 in Dec of 19
Not saying you didn’t but you either bought a brand new house, bought the rate down bigly or slept with the old loan officer. Rates averaged 3.8% in December 2019
 

WDDT

Heisman
Jan 3, 2023
12,893
13,180
113
Not saying you didn’t but you either bought a brand new house, bought the rate down bigly or slept with the old loan officer. Rates averaged 3.8% in December 2019
He is my BIL but there really wasnt anything super crazy about the deal. No points bought.

*** and we closed in Dec so the rate would have been locked before that fwiw.
 
Last edited:

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,772
22,015
113
Its pretty elementary how and why the FED controls interest rates the way it does. Its a simple formula and one of the variables is inflation rate. The inflation rate is too high currently to lower the interest rate. So no, they shouldn't do that. Its simple and objective and has 'proven' the value of the Fed as an institution. Its one of the few good objective arguments for the organizations existence. There are several objective ones for its dismantling IMO.

Fun side note: Without the Tarrif wars we might have been in a spot by now with inflation to lower interest rates.
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Evening Clemson Football Insider
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Clemson Football Insider
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Basketball Thursday Dillon Hunter Update
  5. 05 On3 Football House working on small revisions of Protect College Sports Act before vote