OT: Guitar / Guitarist Appreciation Thread

jerseybird

Senior
Jul 31, 2001
653
727
93
I liked some Hendrix back in the day but forgot about him decades ago. I consider him a great but not a best player. I'm not big fan of technical players (Buckethead sometimes) and Hendrix was one of those experimental types from the 60s drug era. He had that hippie look/vibe and he got a lot of mileage out of that (and dying young). SRV is another great player I have no interest in listening to. BB King a one hit wonder imo. Eddie V - no interest. I think I like David Gilmour the best.

I just listened to "Changes" with Hendrix and Buddy Miles. The first YouTube comment was "His music heals the souls. It puts me in a trance-like state!! Thank you, Hendrix!" Typical Hendrix hippie fan with the trance imo
"BB King a one hit wonder imo."

BB King was one of the most influential blues guitarists of his generation. The three "Kings" provided a huge foundation for some of the most prominent guitar players of our time.
 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,509
3,903
73
"BB King a one hit wonder imo."

BB King was one of the most influential blues guitarists of his generation. The three "Kings" provided a huge foundation for some of the most prominent guitar players of our time.

Indeed. Many of the guitarists very high up on that list , especially from the ‘60s and ‘70s were heavily influenced by the “three Kings”, Albert, Freddie and especially BB King. BB was one of the very first guitarists to mix major and minor pentatonic scales into his soloing. BB had a jazz influence in his playing, he was a big fan of French Gypsy jazz guitarist Django Reinhardt. Hendrix, Clapton, Page, Beck, Allman etc all fans and influenced by BB.
 
Jan 12, 2015
38,910
38,988
113
Rolling Stone has come out with another one of their guitar lists. This one is their top 100 guitar solos of all time. Their lists have been controversial and often criticized. There are some great solos listed here and some not so great. I don’t necessarily agree with the rankings. Of course it’s all subjective and fodder for debate. For me, I would’ve like to see many more blues and jazz guitar solos. This is mostly rock with some electric blues players included:

Another site another list--this includes live clips.
Top 10 Guitar Solos Of All Time | Watch
Everyone's got an opinion lol... personally I prefer Brian May's solo in We Will Rock You over Bohemian Rhapsody.
The 50 greatest solos of all time: 10-1 - The 50 greatest guitar solos of all time - Page 5 | Guitar World
  • 10. "Crazy Train" – Ozzy Osbourne (Guitarist: Randy Rhoads, 1980)
  • 9. "Beat It" – Michael Jackson (Guitarist: Eddie Van Halen, 1982)
  • 8. "Free Bird" – Lynyrd Skynyrd (Guitarist: Allen Collins, 1974)
  • 7. "Sultans Of Swing" – Dire Straits (Guitarist: Mark Knopfler, 1977)
  • 6. "Sweet Child O’ Mine" – Guns N’ Roses (Guitarist: Slash, 1988)
  • 5. "Hotel California" – Eagles (Guitarists: Don Felder & Joe Walsh, 1977)
  • 4. "Stairway To Heaven" – Led Zeppelin (Guitarist: Jimmy Page, 1971)
  • 3. "Comfortably Numb" – Pink Floyd (Guitarist: David Gilmour, 1979)
  • 2. "Eruption" – Van Halen (Guitarist: Eddie Van Halen, 1978)
  • 1. "Bohemian Rhapsody" – Queen (Guitarist: Brian May, 1975)
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,748
19,037
113
Everyone's got an opinion lol... personally I prefer Brian May's solo in We Will Rock You over Bohemian Rhapsody.
The 50 greatest solos of all time: 10-1 - The 50 greatest guitar solos of all time - Page 5 | Guitar World
  • 10. "Crazy Train" – Ozzy Osbourne (Guitarist: Randy Rhoads, 1980)
  • 9. "Beat It" – Michael Jackson (Guitarist: Eddie Van Halen, 1982)
  • 8. "Free Bird" – Lynyrd Skynyrd (Guitarist: Allen Collins, 1974)
  • 7. "Sultans Of Swing" – Dire Straits (Guitarist: Mark Knopfler, 1977)
  • 6. "Sweet Child O’ Mine" – Guns N’ Roses (Guitarist: Slash, 1988)
  • 5. "Hotel California" – Eagles (Guitarists: Don Felder & Joe Walsh, 1977)
  • 4. "Stairway To Heaven" – Led Zeppelin (Guitarist: Jimmy Page, 1971)
  • 3. "Comfortably Numb" – Pink Floyd (Guitarist: David Gilmour, 1979)
  • 2. "Eruption" – Van Halen (Guitarist: Eddie Van Halen, 1978)
  • 1. "Bohemian Rhapsody" – Queen (Guitarist: Brian May, 1975)

Having seen it live at MSG almost exactly 57 years ago, I insist that "Voodoo Child - Slight Return" (Hendrix) makes the Top 5.
 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,509
3,903
73
Charlie Christian should be on any best solo list and more people should be aware of him. Christian was one of the first electric guitar players to elevate the instrument to a soloing entity. Christian contracted TB in 1939 and died at age 25 in 1942. This was recorded in 1941 at Minton’s Playhouse in Harlem, NYC. Some great soloing on “Swing To Bop”:

 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,201
8,026
113
Scrolling through the list, I have to say I am surprised to see AC DC, Megadeth, Girlschool, Pantera, Judas Priest, Iron Maiden, Ozzy.

But then they have to throw in some of their kitschy craap: Sleater Kinney, Jimmy
Eat World, The Knack, Helium.

The top 20 is a joke.. Funkadelic???

No Scorpions or Michael Schenker? Jeff Beck on list once with multiple Beatles entries?

Harumph!!
Well, they did say that Jeff Beck could have had 100 entries. He certainly should have been on there more than once. I don't have a problem with Funkadelic. Maggot Brain has been covered by bands in multiple genres. Even some of the alternative bands that their edgelord critics worship have covered it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,201
8,026
113
Having seen it live at MSG almost exactly 57 years ago, I insist that "Voodoo Child - Slight Return" (Hendrix) makes the Top 5.
Hendrix, like Beck, could have had 100 entries. Machine Gun from the Fillmore East in 1970 is an all time great solo, as is Voodoo Child (Slight Return).
 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,509
3,903
73
One player who I did not see on any of these guitar lists (unless I missed it) and who absolutely belongs is Brian Setzer from the Stray Cats . A great and underrated player. Here he is with Jeff Beck playing in the “rockabilly” style that he is known for:

 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,938
86,944
113
One player who I did not see on any of these guitar lists (unless I missed it) and who absolutely belongs is Brian Setzer from the Stray Cats . A great and underrated player. Here he is with Jeff Beck playing in the “rockabilly” style that he is known for:


All three original members on tour this summer!
Aug 15 Atlantic City
August 16 Morristown

They're gonna Rock Those Towns inside and out!!

 
  • Like
Reactions: RUGuitarMan1

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
336
307
63
"BB King a one hit wonder imo."

BB King was one of the most influential blues guitarists of his generation. The three "Kings" provided a huge foundation for some of the most prominent guitar players of our time.

I don't listen to guitarists for "influence'. Every time I hear BB King at a gig (who I like) he's playing "The Thrill is Gone." I know Blue Öyster Cult had more songs than "Don't Feat the Reaper" but the other stuff is forgotten.

Plus in BBs case I don't like those kind of "woe-is-me" type` blues. I never liked old jazz either. Skiffle, Leadbelly, Bluegrass, honky tonk, juke joint music is not for me even though I dont blame others if they like it. I like some old folk like Rhiannon Giddens performs


 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,509
3,903
73
I don't listen to guitarists for "influence'. Every time I hear BB King at a gig (who I like) he's playing "The Thrill is Gone." I know Blue Öyster Cult had more songs than "Don't Feat the Reaper" but the other stuff is forgotten.

Plus in BBs case I don't like those kind of "woe-is-me" type` blues. I never liked old jazz either. Skiffle, Leadbelly, Bluegrass, honky tonk, juke joint music is not for me even though I dont blame others if they like it. I like some old folk like Rhiannon Giddens performs




Giddens is fabulous, her music is a mix of blues and bluegrass. As you know, blues , bluegrass, country and folk music are all interconnected. Traditional bluegrass is a mixture of blues, jazz and folk music. As for BB King , of course he played “The Thrill is Gone”. It’s like The Stones playing “Satisfaction” or The Eagles playing “Take It Easy”. Check at his album “Live At The Regal” from 1965. Some great playing and singing. Not all his stuff or blues is “woe is me”. People that don’t listen much to blues think that. There is a lot of humor, self awareness, the need for love and dignity in it. It’s a very unpretentious music and has- to use a popular phrase- “ authenticity” to it. It reflects life experience . Besides all that, it sounds really good.
 

Bueller

Junior
Nov 28, 2025
336
307
63
Giddens is fabulous, her music is a mix of blues and bluegrass. As you know, blues , bluegrass, country and folk music are all interconnected. Traditional bluegrass is a mixture of blues, jazz and folk music. As for BB King , of course he played “The Thrill is Gone”. It’s like The Stones playing “Satisfaction” or The Eagles playing “Take It Easy”. Check at his album “Live At The Regal” from 1965. Some great playing and singing. Not all his stuff or blues is “woe is me”. People that don’t listen much to blues think that. There is a lot of humor, self awareness, the need for love and dignity in it. It’s a very unpretentious music and has- to use a popular phrase- “ authenticity” to it. It reflects life experience . Besides all that, it sounds really good.

I think Joe Bonamassa is one of the better guitarists around but he's one of those players that likes blues because its more challenging. I've noticed a lot of off players like blues because its fun and challenging for them to play. But I cant listen to Joe much. A blues guitarist I like is Roy Buchanan . I like his Wayfaring Pilgrim a lot but not so much his "Sweet Dreams" that seems to get the most acclaim. I've seen guitarists work their pots as they play but not like Buchanan. The way he bends and uses tone and volume swells at the same time is more impressive than any shredding (which I hate)




 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,201
8,026
113
I think Joe Bonamassa is one of the better guitarists around but he's one of those players that likes blues because its more challenging. I've noticed a lot of off players like blues because its fun and challenging for them to play. But I cant listen to Joe much. A blues guitarist I like is Roy Buchanan . I like his Wayfaring Pilgrim a lot but not so much his "Sweet Dreams" that seems to get the most acclaim. I've seen guitarists work their pots as they play but not like Buchanan. The way he bends and uses tone and volume swells at the same time is more impressive than any shredding (which I hate)





Buchanan was a legendary player. The ultimate guitarist's guitarist. Jeff Beck's Cause We've Ended As Lovers was a tribute to him. Very influential. Saw him live at RU in the mid '80s. He was incredible.
 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,509
3,903
73
My favorite musician today and for quite some time is Derek Trucks. Not only for his talent but the type of person he is. He is very grounded, knowledgeable and respectful of the great music and musicians that came before him. Here is a clip of him with accolades from BB King and John Mayer. The key to playing blues well is understanding the rhythm and using great phrasing and the right note selection when improvising. Here Trucks plays an incredibly emotive short solo, the note selection and emphasis is just about perfect over the chord progression:

 
  • Like
Reactions: Kbe4

Whoshesir

Redshirt
Jul 5, 2025
6
2
3
Most underrated and underappreciated guitarist of all time: Terry Kath

When someone asks me about favorite guitarists, I mention Kath. I am always astounded that most have no idea who he is.

He was a superb vocalist as well.
Live version of 25 or 6 to 4 at Tanglewood in 1970 speaks volumes about his insane guitar mastery. Hendrix revered Terry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PiscatawayMike

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,938
86,944
113
I've never seen the tuners/pegs on the downside (?) of the headstock before. Is this common, a preference of Nuno or something else?
That is one his custom guitars. He has several electric guitars for sale, and all of them are made that way.

Many consider Nuno as one of the heirs to Eddie Van Halen's throne as the greatest living guitarist. He is a very humble and cool guy. Have seen Extreme twice, and they are fantastic live.

His solo on Rise is mesmerizing- using one of his custom made guitars:

 
  • Like
Reactions: RUGuitarMan1

29PAS

All-Conference
Sep 21, 2001
3,489
1,405
113
That is one his custom guitars. He has several electric guitars for sale, and all of them are made that way.

Many consider Nuno as one of the heirs to Eddie Van Halen's throne as the greatest living guitarist. He is a very humble and cool guy. Have seen Extreme twice, and they are fantastic live.

His solo on Rise is mesmerizing- using one of his custom made guitars:


Thanks. Maybe I'll buy one and then play better. If only............
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
88,938
86,944
113
Thanks. Maybe I'll buy one and then play better. If only............
Soooo, I bought a cheap guitar (against the OP's advice going cheap), a small ORANGE brand amp and a "fuzz" pedal. I have played it definitely less than 5 times. I also purchased Rick Beato's video/online course on how to play guitar. Never logged on or took a lesson. Years ago, I took bass lessons--I may revert to that, as I was reading an article/interview on Keanu Reeves and why he gravitated towards bass versus six string. He said he always liked the low end, and I am much the same way, and I find myself focused more on rhythm sections while watching live music. I asked my better half for a bass guitar and drum set for my upcoming birthday. . . . 😂
 
Last edited:

phs73rc77gsm83

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2011
3,085
3,894
83
Soooo, I bought a cheap guitar (against the OP's advice going cheap), a small ORANGE brand amp and a "fuzz" pedal. I have played it definitely less than 5 times. I also purchased Rick Beato's video/online course on how to play guitar. Never logged on or took a lesson. Years ago, I took bass lessons--I may revert to that, as I was reading an article/interview on Keanu Reeves and why he gravitated towards bass versus six string. He said he always liked the low end, and I am much the same way, and I find myself focused more on rhythm sections while watching live music. I asked my better half for a bass guitar and drum set for my upcoming birthday. . . . 😂
What worked for me with guitar over the years was to find a balance between playing songs and learning theory. That balance has shifted back and forth over the years but generally leaned more towards playing songs. If I had had to play scales and study theory 100% of the time I wouldn’t have stayed with it.
 

RUGuitarMan1

All-Conference
Apr 5, 2021
2,509
3,903
73
What worked for me with guitar over the years was to find a balance between playing songs and learning theory. That balance has shifted back and forth over the years but generally leaned more towards playing songs. If I had had to play scales and study theory 100% of the time I wouldn’t have stayed with it.

My journey on the instrument is very similar. I’m completely self taught. Initially I bought a fairly cheap acoustic guitar and a few music books on chords, scales, theory and songs. I committed to learning on the acoustic for 2 years before buying any electric stuff. I’m glad I did, was able to strengthen my hands and fingers. I’ve gone through stages of trying to learn some theory, chords and then scales. I think the thing that has helped me most is learning songs. Trying to get the rhythm down and then the melody. I usually work on parts of songs and will practice on usually 2 songs at the same time and go over both for weeks. Having fun and gravitating toward the sounds that inspire you is important to keep interested in my opinion.
 

phs73rc77gsm83

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2011
3,085
3,894
83
My journey on the instrument is very similar. I’m completely self taught. Initially I bought a fairly cheap acoustic guitar and a few music books on chords, scales, theory and songs. I committed to learning on the acoustic for 2 years before buying any electric stuff. I’m glad I did, was able to strengthen my hands and fingers. I’ve gone through stages of trying to learn some theory, chords and then scales. I think the thing that has helped me most is learning songs. Trying to get the rhythm down and then the melody. I usually work on parts of songs and will practice on usually 2 songs at the same time and go over both for weeks. Having fun and gravitating toward the sounds that inspire you is important to keep interested in my opinion.
Your last sentence says it all!!!, at least for me. I got my first guitar from a friend for $14 and the John Barleycorn Must Die album. Horrible guitar… A friend taught me three cords and then went off to Vietnam in 1970. lots of selt teaching over the decades. It’s been a wonderful journey. For me, there is nothing better than learning a song you love and nailing it.