Why does Starkville hate Mississippi State?

Status
Not open for further replies.

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
My understanding is that you can’t just have an open container of anything, it has to be in a special cup provided by the business in order to comply. The intent is that you can bar hop without pouring your drink out when you leave IF you have it in one of those cups. The intent is not to just let people go crazy with their own alcohol they brought from the house. You’re not allowed to just roll up with a cooler, sit it on the curb, and start going to town.

If Starkville passed some laissez faire open container law that nobody else in the country was dumb enough to do, then yeah, they should probably address that. If its more like the law above, and they just aren’t enforcing it, then yeah, they should address that, too.

But, either way - it’s a huge stretch to say that either of those things was directly linked to a shooting. And I highly doubt anyone on here can point to hard evidence that any of these suspects were abusing the open container policy prior to acting out. People are going to go where the party is, regardless. If there is a harsh penalty on open container, they’ll just pour vodka in a Sprite bottle or whatever the 17 else makes sense and is difficult to enforce.

There’s no way to solve the problem without making the entire Cotton District less desirable for everyone.
The original intent for the open container law was awesome, and I liked it. BUT its had unintended consequences. People are showing up and not spending any money in the cotton district. That leads to problems. This weekend isn't the first time either.

I think a solution that will be tried going forward is to make the restaurants/bars use a certain type cup and thats what you have to drink out of.
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
10,709
7,421
113
There has to be a large, visible LE presence.

Was recently in Austin, their entertainment district is between the university and my hotel. They have a ton of cops out at night on foot patrolling the area. I felt completely safe.

Cops on foot in the district on weekend nights are what’s needed.
This is usually the answer when places rein it in, and still keep what they have. It's still a delicate balance to get it right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: greenbean.sixpack

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
I don't think that's true. Most people that you want there (i.e., paying patrons that will generally behave, or at least if they don't, will misbehave in general college kids being dumb ways, not shooting people ways) do not want to be around the type of crowd that is causing the issues. They will put up with some mild hassle if it means they don't have to worry about whether people are carrying guns or not. It's just a matter of having the will to fix it. Plenty of examples where areas get nicer when they just stop tolerating disorder and anti-social behaviors.
Its definitely not true.

You can easily enforce the current law and run off the pieces of $h1t.

And the loitering of people definitely lead to the problem we had this past weekend regardless if these morons want to believe it or not.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
Maybe I’ve missed a bunch of other problems in the CD. I remember a shooting a few years back but nothing since then. But I’m 40 and don’t have kids old enough yet to be in the CD. So, my only time in the CD these days is walking through after a game.

Im not saying we shouldn’t be concerned about what happened this weekend but it certainly seems like an outlier and not a regular occurrence.
Any time you have a large group of people congregating and drinking and doing drugs and not going into the businesses around them is going to lead to a problem.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
I can guarantee you that the open container law did not attract the people in question to the cotton district. I would put my life savings on it that they didn’t even know it exists.
Youd be wrong.

Why else are 2000 people showing up and never entering bars? Bc they are all outside the bars drinking for pennies on the dollar.
 

Maroon13

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2022
3,755
3,882
113
I remember way back in the day. We gathered at the Sonic. Wasn't long, Sonic and Columbus PD ran us off. So we went to the sunflower parking lot. Lots of kids hanging in the parking lot with their muscle cars. No open drinking, certainly no weed or shooting... but again CPD said, nope can't do that. Then we went to the field in the county. Lowndes County SD invited themselves to those parties.

So why can't SPD tell people that can't just stand in the middle of the street, drinking, smoking, fighting and shooting?

when I went to Austin tx, the area of 6th street that we visited, wasn't anyone standing in the street drinking and smoking. The bars were packed but nobody in the damn street.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
This is usually the answer when places rein it in, and still keep what they have. It's still a delicate balance to get it right.
No its not. The problem has been growing since football season of last year. Maybe before.

But as usual the mayor pretended it was fine. It wasn't and isn't.
 

615dawg

All-Conference
Jun 4, 2007
6,866
4,014
113
Some of you just think that people like me should not have any negative opinion of Mississippi State or Starkville. This board was created 23 years ago to give a place for non-sunshine opinion. And if you think me having a negative opinion of Starkville's leadership response to a shooting in the Cotton District or Mississippi State being dead last in the SEC academically, you will hate me in the fall during football season because I suspect I will have some very negative opinions about the crap that will be rolled out by High School Lebby.

Starkville has gotten better over the years, that's true - but there is still a disdain between the city and the university that ultimately hurts MSU. While it may be better than it was, it still needs improvement. And this is a prime example. Starkville should be doing everything they possibly can to make Starkville fun for 18-22 year old students, not pieces of **** from Columbus and West Point.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
I remember way back in the day. We gathered at the Sonic. Wasn't long, Sonic and Columbus PD ran us off. So we went to the sunflower parking lot. Lots of kids hanging in the parking lot with their muscle cars. No open drinking, certainly no weed or shooting... but again CPD said, nope can't do that. Then we went to the field in the county. Lowndes County SD invited themselves to those parties.

So why can't SPD tell people that can't just stand in the middle of the street, drinking, smoking, fighting and shooting?

when I went to Austin tx, the area of 6th street that we visited, wasn't anyone standing in the street drinking and smoking. The bars were packed but nobody in the damn street.
They can do all of this. They just don't for some reason.

There was a GD person riding around on a horse in the cotton district this weekend. He wasn't parking it and going in to the OK corral either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13
Jun 4, 2025
136
262
63
Youd be wrong.

Why else are 2000 people showing up and never entering bars? Bc they are all outside the bars drinking for pennies on the dollar.
The loitering and drinking in the parking lot was happening at the sprint mart by the highlands and at the sprint mart by Harvey’s too. They certainly don’t have open container laws. I promise you that’s not in the thought process
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
The loitering and drinking in the parking lot was happening at the sprint mart by the highlands and at the sprint mart by Harvey’s too. They certainly don’t have open container laws. I promise you that’s not in the thought process
I promise you it is.

And lets say its not. Then arrest everyone standing around for loitering and open containers.
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
10,709
7,421
113
I promise you it is.

And lets say its not. Then arrest everyone standing around for loitering and open containers.
Basically what you want to do is to do away the entertainment district. That's a legit opinion but say so. That was the way it was for decades.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
14,621
5,099
113
I can guarantee you that the open container law did not attract the people in question to the cotton district. I would put my life savings on it that they didn’t even know it exists.
That's possible, but even if it's true, that doesn't mean the open container law didn't help create a problem. Social behavior of groups can be unpredictable and small changes can shift the equilibrium a good bit. Before allowing any open containers on the street, there was basically no reason to come hang out in the District outside of the bars and so nobody did (granted I have huge gaps in experience here). You'd pass people walking to and from a place, and maybe stop for a minute or two, but you wouldn't spend twenty mintues hanging outside while people nursed drinks before going to the next place. Once there are some people hanging out outside, even if it's generally just groups finishing a drink, then it becomes more attractive to some people to come and hang out on the street and not spend any money. And for a while, every additional person that comes to hang out and not spend money makes it more attractive to the next person that wants to do that.

Early on when the dynamic was ramping up, it probably could have been shut down just by cracking down on anybody hanging out without a go cup. It's possible that now that it's a relatively established practice, it may take something more.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
There’s no need in changing the open container law, I really enjoy getting a draft beer from boardtown and walking to the stadium. All that needs to be done is enforce the loitering laws that are already in place.
I don't want to change it either but if that works i'm all in favor of sacrificing a small thing to get rid of the mess that was this weekend.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
Basically what you want to do is to do away the entertainment district. That's a legit opinion but say so. That was the way it was for decades.
No I want to get rid of pieces of $h1t in the entertainment district. Thats easy to do.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
That's possible, but even if it's true, that doesn't mean the open container law didn't help create a problem. Social behavior of groups can be unpredictable and small changes can shift the equilibrium a good bit. Before allowing any open containers on the street, there was basically no reason to come hang out in the District outside of the bars and so nobody did (granted I have huge gaps in experience here). You'd pass people walking to and from a place, and maybe stop for a minute or two, but you wouldn't spend twenty mintues hanging outside while people nursed drinks before going to the next place. Once there are some people hanging out outside, even if it's generally just groups finishing a drink, then it becomes more attractive to some people to come and hang out on the street and not spend any money. And for a while, every additional person that comes to hang out and not spend money makes it more attractive to the next person that wants to do that.

Early on when the dynamic was ramping up, it probably could have been shut down just by cracking down on anybody hanging out without a go cup. It's possible that now that it's a relatively established practice, it may take something more.
spot on and you could see this problem growing.

Happened exactly as you said.
Started small and then grew into a club outside the club.
 

She Mate Me

Heisman
Dec 7, 2008
13,577
12,134
113
The original intent for the open container law was awesome, and I liked it. BUT its had unintended consequences. People are showing up and not spending any money in the cotton district. That leads to problems. This weekend isn't the first time either.

I think a solution that will be tried going forward is to make the restaurants/bars use a certain type cup and thats what you have to drink out of.

Maybe the city could just have a mowed field outside the city limits. On big weekends just advertise it as free party central, byoc (bring your own Courvoisier).

If you don't want to partake of the District establishments just hit the hayfields.

Let them shoot each other to their hearts content.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
Yeah, Austin LE dealt with that crazyass mass shooter quickly a few weeks back. That could have been much worse. They were ready.

Maybe the city could just have a mowed field outside the city limits. On big weekends just advertise it as free party central, byoc (bring your own Courvoisier).

If you don't want to partake of the District establishments just hit the hayfields.

Let them shoot each other to their hearts content.
We could only hope.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
14,621
5,099
113
By themselves on the streets?
Yes. All you really need is a place with generally decent people with good foot traffic and they will be safe. Hell, I think that would have been true in most places in our major cities until the most recent defund the police insanity. NYC, Boston, Seattle, Chicago off the top of my head I have been to and been places where I wouldn't have thought anything about a 21 year old walking for an errand from 10:00 to midnight.
 

tired

All-Conference
Sep 16, 2013
3,455
1,113
113
I have 2 at State & I stay here half the time. I never really feel unsafe but I can see what's coming if it's not dealt with appropriately & swiftly.

My boys have left the CD early due to issues arising within a certain culture. There are so many arrestable offenses that occur there it's laughable to me when I here, "what can we do"
 

She Mate Me

Heisman
Dec 7, 2008
13,577
12,134
113
I have 2 at State & I stay here half the time. I never really feel unsafe but I can see what's coming if it's not dealt with appropriately & swiftly.

My boys have left the CD early due to issues arising within a certain culture. There are so many arrestable offenses that occur there it's laughable to me when I here, "what can we do"

It ain't rocket surgery and the ones acting like it is are just being willfully obtuse.

Increase law enforcement in the areas where the "problem" individuals congregate and arrest every obvious offense you see. Their presence will reduce organically.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
19,125
2,161
113
Even back to the 90s when I was there, the city despised the university and its students. They like athletics and the draw, but they hate students.

And this was incredibly tone deaf



The videos in Heisman Candidate JK Costello's post in the attachment are very telling. Are those college students or outside thugs?

As someone else posted yesterday - I'd be reluctant to allow my kid to go to Starkville nor would I recommend it to anyone else. The last video looked like professional wrestling, except beating with a folding chair was real.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
4,394
3,064
113
I have 2 at State & I stay here half the time. I never really feel unsafe but I can see what's coming if it's not dealt with appropriately & swiftly.

My boys have left the CD early due to issues arising within a certain culture. There are so many arrestable offenses that occur there it's laughable to me when I here, "what can we do"
Yep. Really easy to fix.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
19,125
2,161
113
On topic - when I was there from '65-70, it seemed that Starkville didn't want the school around, even though it's the main reason for the town's existence.
 

johnson86-1

All-American
Aug 22, 2012
14,621
5,099
113
Ok, how? How are you going to identify those people?
Easy start would be to stop and frisk everybody around an area that smells like weed. But I'd also bet police could identify the likely problems just on looks alone. It's not like most antisocial people don't basically advertise it by the way they dress and act. You see either of these guys, you watch him like a hawk and stop him if he creates probable cause and just generally make him uncomfortable. Worst case scenario you've annoyed somebody that was just going to slightly degrade the experience without actually committing a crime other than possibly loitering. Best case scenario you snag somebody with a gun or encourage somebody with a gun to not come back. That seems like a decent enough tradeoff.

1777323550862.png

1777323535203.png
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
10,709
7,421
113
Get rid of anyone loitering outside a bar and not going in.

Can you read? are you that 17ing dumb?
Ok, so you just basically ended the entertainment district and turned back the clock a couple of decades. As I said, why don't yo just say that. It's a legit opinion. Let's be clear about what you just called for. The only legit reason for being outside a premises is walking to and from your car or home. That isn't a legit entertainment district.
 

L4Dawg

All-American
Oct 27, 2016
10,709
7,421
113
Easy start would be to stop and frisk everybody around an area that smells like weed. But I'd also bet police could identify the likely problems just on looks alone. It's not like most antisocial people don't basically advertise it by the way they dress and act. You see either of these guys, you watch him like a hawk and stop him if he creates probable cause and just generally make him uncomfortable. Worst case scenario you've annoyed somebody that was just going to slightly degrade the experience without actually committing a crime other than possibly loitering. Best case scenario you snag somebody with a gun or encourage somebody with a gun to not come back. That seems like a decent enough tradeoff.

View attachment 1273442

View attachment 1273440
Looks? You gonna pony up when the city loses every single case and lawsuit over it? That is exactly what would happen.
 

Perd Hapley

All-American
Sep 30, 2022
6,021
7,104
113
The original intent for the open container law was awesome, and I liked it. BUT its had unintended consequences. People are showing up and not spending any money in the cotton district. That leads to problems. This weekend isn't the first time either.

I think a solution that will be tried going forward is to make the restaurants/bars use a certain type cup and thats what you have to drink out of.
So, say that I park my car in the Cotton District, get out of my car with an unopened bottle of Jack Daniels, walk over to the sidewalk in front of Two Brothers, and just crack it open and start sipping it right there.

Am I in compliance with the current open container law, or am I not?

I honestly don’t know the answer to this question.
 
Nov 16, 2005
28,080
21,664
113
This is usually the answer when places rein it in, and still keep what they have. It's still a delicate balance to get it right.
But that’s all we are saying. Holy shít. No one is bashing Starkville but simply pointing out that this doesn’t need to get out of control.
 
  • Like
Reactions: paindonthurt
Status
Not open for further replies.