The teams that have won the natties recently did so due to solid QB play. OSU was plenty physical, especially on defense in 25. Their QB was sub par. He was the difference between their 24 natty and losing to Indiana and Miami this year. And if "physical" is the difference between winning and losing, why didn't Indiana have more OL drafted this year? Their QB was number one and they had two WRs and a TE drafted. Cignetti obviously doesn't know what he is doing.
.
OSU got beat up by Indiana and Miami, is what I saw.
Indiana was clearly the most physical team in the playoffs. Iowa was able to give them their toughest game of season by beating them up a little bit.
It's great to be both physical and have good qb play. Both are important.
But Iowa will always be built upon physicality. Most programs would kill to have what Iowa has. It should be something fans are ecstatic about.
But again, they have to make the passing game more important than it actually is. That way, at least in their minds, they are able to justify the highest level of negativity in the community having come during a peak period of winning.
The narrative that Iowa is a passing game away from the playoffs is drastically too simple. For one thing, many of the same people pushing this narrative are the same people that will try to convince you Iowa was good enough to be in the playoffs last season. But also, if a 12 team playoff had existed the past couple decades, Iowa would have made or barely missed out on the playoffs many times. And, as we know, people have been bitching about the passing game for decades.
Iowa will make the playoffs when they play good enough football to do so. There's a high chance that the passing game won't be good enough for many fans when that does take place. Then they will morph the narrative into, "Iowa can't win a national championship without a better passing game."
An absolute gift, of decades of good football, has passed before the eyes of many, without them having a clue of just how special what they were watching actually was