SC Governor's Race Re: Ralph Norman

SlovenskoTiger

Heisman
Dec 19, 2015
5,125
13,826
113
If any one is considering voting for Ralph Norman, please reconsider. Myself and other constituents in his district sought his help with a stock matter over the course of three years. At first he helped, but then for no apparent reason and without explanation, he took the word of Biden appointee Gary Gensler over the FOIA's and other ironclad evidence that showed that the SEC and FINRA had broken their own rules. He had given his word that he was going to hold hearings and get answers multiple times, but he broke that promise and it flies in the face of everything that he purports to be on his campaign website. I get that sometimes a vote choice boils down to who is the least repugnant, but just wanted to make folks aware of Ralph's hypocrisy. Feel free to reach out for any additional details.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coldbud1994

coldbud1994

All-American
Jan 18, 2005
4,010
6,494
112
Thanks for the info. I'm considering Rom Reddy. Anyone have thoughts on him?

Edit: I live in Charleston and am well aware of his drama at his IOP house
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
If any one is considering voting for Ralph Norman, please reconsider. Myself and other constituents in his district sought his help with a stock matter over the course of three years. At first he helped, but then for no apparent reason and without explanation, he took the word of Biden appointee Gary Gensler over the FOIA's and other ironclad evidence that showed that the SEC and FINRA had broken their own rules. He had given his word that he was going to hold hearings and get answers multiple times, but he broke that promise and it flies in the face of everything that he purports to be on his campaign website. I get that sometimes a vote choice boils down to who is the least repugnant, but just wanted to make folks aware of Ralph's hypocrisy. Feel free to reach out for any additional details.
Care to add additional details on what rules you think the SEC and FINRA broke?
 

SlovenskoTiger

Heisman
Dec 19, 2015
5,125
13,826
113
Care to add additional details on what rules you think the SEC and FINRA broke?
FINRA rule 6490 and 6440, SEC did not exercise proper oversight of FINRA. Its a long story, but FINRA halted the stock with 2 days left of trading that should have happened and short shares never reconciled. There are people at certain brokerages that want to transfer their shares to the transfer agent but the brokerage told them they don't have enough shares to fulfill that request because of FINRA's halt. FINRA claimed that they did it because of settlement and clearing issues, but it was a self fulfilling prophecy because that's precisely what they caused.
1776193586670.png
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
FINRA rule 6490 and 6440, SEC did not exercise proper oversight of FINRA. Its a long story, but FINRA halted the stock with 2 days left of trading that should have happened and short shares never reconciled. There are people at certain brokerages that want to transfer their shares to the transfer agent but the brokerage told them they don't have enough shares to fulfill that request because of FINRA's halt. FINRA claimed that they did it because of settlement and clearing issues, but it was a self fulfilling prophecy because that's precisely what they caused.
View attachment 1256964
Very interesting. I've dealt with several different clearing issues over the years.

The image you posted is too small to read, i'd like to read it if you can make it bigger?
 

SlovenskoTiger

Heisman
Dec 19, 2015
5,125
13,826
113
Very interesting. I've dealt with several different clearing issues over the years.

The image you posted is too small to read, i'd like to read it if you can make it bigger?


This thread details, each of the emails in one of the FOIAs that we got. I don’t expect congressman Norman to have been an expert in all things securities, but he is on the financial services committee and he and his staffers were briefed over 30 times on the issue yet he continued to get basic stuff wrong. Tradestation was one of the brokers that told their customers in writing that they didn’t have shares to give their customers who had bought and that they wouldn’t until FINRA set a plan in motion to fix the mess. Are you in the financial industry? How did you see settlement issues resolved previously? Some shareholders even had a chance to meet with SEC commissioner Hester Peirce and even she said “we have no idea how to fix it” 😂😭
 
Last edited:

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113


This thread details, each of the emails in one of the foyers that we got. I don’t expect congressman Norman to have been an expert in all things securities, but he is on a financial services committee and he get his staffers were briefed over 30 times on the issue yet he continued to get basic stuff wrong. Tradestation was one of the brokers that told their customers in writing that they didn’t have shares to give their customers who had bought and that they wouldn’t until FINRA set a plan in motion to fix the mess. Are you in the financial industry? How did you see settlement issues resolved previously? Some shareholders even had a chance to meet with SEC commissioner Hester Peirce and even she said “we have no idea how to fix it” 😂😭

I am in the finance industry, been trading for almost 30 years. I am very familiar with the clearing process.

That being said, i don't know much about this situation. At first glance, it was a very risky trade. You were dealing with OTC securities with pending corporate action. All traders know that trades come with all kinds of risk. That includes government risk, settlement risk etc.

This is not a clear cut situation, even to someone like myself who is intimately familiar with the clearing process.

Id keep fighting if I were you, but I can't say I'm surprised a congressman is not sticking his neck out for you.

I'd be interested to hear more about how you got yourself in that situation?
 

SlovenskoTiger

Heisman
Dec 19, 2015
5,125
13,826
113
I am in the finance industry, been trading for almost 30 years. I am very familiar with the clearing process.

That being said, i don't know much about this situation. At first glance, it was a very risky trade. You were dealing with OTC securities with pending corporate action. All traders know that trades come with all kinds of risk. That includes government risk, settlement risk etc.

This is not a clear cut situation, even to someone like myself who is intimately familiar with the clearing process.

Id keep fighting if I were you, but I can't say I'm surprised a congressman is not sticking his neck out for you.

I'd be interested to hear more about how you got yourself in that situation?
So it’s a pretty tangled web, which unfortunately has made it so difficult to get help/answers/media attention :/. Originally I had not invested in an OTC stock 😂, I had invested in the NASDAQ listed stock TRCH which was doing a reverse merger with a Canadian materials company called Metamaterials in 2021. As a part of this merger, those who held TRCH would receive a series A preferred share representing the oil and gas assets post merger until such time as they were sold and we were given dividends, or until it was spun off. They were never meant to be traded. Come October 2021, six months after the merger, the pref A shares started trading on the OTC as MMTLP and had 2014 information listed about the officers and financials of the company on OTC markets website. We’ve since learned a market maker exemption was used for the first trades but we’ve never found out specifically who and FINRA and SEC won’t tell us. It trades for about a year right in the $1-2 range until Meta announces they’re going to spin it off in Dec 2022 into a private oil and gas company next bridge hydrocarbons with no ex date, end of trading 12th would be the last day of trading with 14th being the t+2 settlement date.

FINRA dragged their feet forever in approving the corporate action, and came to find out later from the former CEO had actually dictated to the company what the language of the corporate action would be(against their own rules). Which makes it all the more dubious that they claimed on the morning of the 9th of December that they were issuing a U3 halt citing settlement and clearance issues. Their own Uniform Practice Code committee had the authority and ability to have declared the corporate action deficient but they never did. So after that halt on the 9th, everything has just been locked in limbo for the last three years. FINRA admitted in an FAQ that there were at least 2.56 million short shares still outstanding, but the number is vastly higher because as they admitted as well, they don’t have a view into overseas holdings and that 2.56 number is only self reported.

Needless to say, we shareholders were all shell shocked as we expected a reconciling of the shares to occur on the 9th and 12th trading days and instead we were all just locked in limbo indefinitely. We received a FOIA in April of 2023 showing that the SEC and FINRA knew there had been a problem all the way back to November of 2021 but yet let MMTLP go through all it did with no action. We took to making a concerted push to get Congress to do something about it and had a decent bit of success in getting 74 reps to sign an open letter and two senators to send a letter to the SEC and FINRA asking for detailed answers to a long list of questions about what happened. Unfortunately they just responded late with recycled FAQs that we had already poked a plethora of holes in.

I was able to get a FOIA showing emails between Norman’s staffer and the SEC where there came a point where the SEC gave them an off ramp on something related but ultimate unrelated to what we were aggrieved about and has refused to listen to any further evidence since that point. Extremely frustrating and I plan to try and convince as many as I can to vote for anyone but Norman due to the shameful way he office acted.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
So it’s a pretty tangled web, which unfortunately has made it so difficult to get help/answers/media attention :/. Originally I had not invested in an OTC stock 😂, I had invested in the NASDAQ listed stock TRCH which was doing a reverse merger with a Canadian materials company called Metamaterials in 2021. As a part of this merger, those who held TRCH would receive a series A preferred share representing the oil and gas assets post merger until such time as they were sold and we were given dividends, or until it was spun off. They were never meant to be traded. Come October 2021, six months after the merger, the pref A shares started trading on the OTC as MMTLP and had 2014 information listed about the officers and financials of the company on OTC markets website. We’ve since learned a market maker exemption was used for the first trades but we’ve never found out specifically who and FINRA and SEC won’t tell us. It trades for about a year right in the $1-2 range until Meta announces they’re going to spin it off in Dec 2022 into a private oil and gas company next bridge hydrocarbons with no ex date, end of trading 12th would be the last day of trading with 14th being the t+2 settlement date.

FINRA dragged their feet forever in approving the corporate action, and came to find out later from the former CEO had actually dictated to the company what the language of the corporate action would be(against their own rules). Which makes it all the more dubious that they claimed on the morning of the 9th of December that they were issuing a U3 halt citing settlement and clearance issues. Their own Uniform Practice Code committee had the authority and ability to have declared the corporate action deficient but they never did. So after that halt on the 9th, everything has just been locked in limbo for the last three years. FINRA admitted in an FAQ that there were at least 2.56 million short shares still outstanding, but the number is vastly higher because as they admitted as well, they don’t have a view into overseas holdings and that 2.56 number is only self reported.

Needless to say, we shareholders were all shell shocked as we expected a reconciling of the shares to occur on the 9th and 12th trading days and instead we were all just locked in limbo indefinitely. We received a FOIA in April of 2023 showing that the SEC and FINRA knew there had been a problem all the way back to November of 2021 but yet let MMTLP go through all it did with no action. We took to making a concerted push to get Congress to do something about it and had a decent bit of success in getting 74 reps to sign an open letter and two senators to send a letter to the SEC and FINRA asking for detailed answers to a long list of questions about what happened. Unfortunately they just responded late with recycled FAQs that we had already poked a plethora of holes in.

I was able to get a FOIA showing emails between Norman’s staffer and the SEC where there came a point where the SEC gave them an off ramp on something related but ultimate unrelated to what we were aggrieved about and has refused to listen to any further evidence since that point. Extremely frustrating and I plan to try and convince as many as I can to vote for anyone but Norman due to the shameful way he office acted.

Do you not have any legal recourse? A class action suit? I wonder if SIPC or something similar would be of use?
 

SlovenskoTiger

Heisman
Dec 19, 2015
5,125
13,826
113
Do you not have any legal recourse? A class action suit? I wonder if SIPC or something similar would be of use?
There have been a few tries, but unfortunately FINRA has a lot of built in immunity that Congress gave them when they were created. All the lawsuits against them have failed on that so far. The brokerages have rules written into their user agreeements when you sign up for them that force you into arbitration if you have any disputes, and FINRA run the arbitrations…a few have gone down that path only to find out that the FINRA arbitrators stack the deck and prevent discovery, and in one case against an actual lawyer, ignored or shot down any motions that he brought so he ended up backing out of the arbitration process when it became clear he risked just getting back the final closing price for his shares and setting a precedent for everyone else. The majority of people still active and paying attention want a market based reconciliation process to close out the shorts. Thankfully the company is still kicking and is working towards a resolution, but it has been a slow slow process with the SEC still attempting to be a roadblock
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
There have been a few tries, but unfortunately FINRA has a lot of built in immunity that Congress gave them when they were created. All the lawsuits against them have failed on that so far. The brokerages have rules written into their user agreeements when you sign up for them that force you into arbitration if you have any disputes, and FINRA run the arbitrations…a few have gone down that path only to find out that the FINRA arbitrators stack the deck and prevent discovery, and in one case against an actual lawyer, ignored or shot down any motions that he brought so he ended up backing out of the arbitration process when it became clear he risked just getting back the final closing price for his shares and setting a precedent for everyone else. The majority of people still active and paying attention want a market based reconciliation process to close out the shorts. Thankfully the company is still kicking and is working towards a resolution, but it has been a slow slow process with the SEC still attempting to be a roadblock


In trying to look at your case objectively. You obviously want to talk about it because you are here posting about it. I don’t hold back on my feelings to be nice, im going to shoot you straight.

You say “ They were never meant to be traded” and then go on to say they were traded.

If one knew they were not supposed to be traded, then why were they being traded?

What market maker exemption was given and why? I was a derivatives market maker for 15+ years.


I must also state my opinion, that a congressperson should be no where near this highly complex issue.

As a trader, the market comes with all kinds of risk. Political risk, Intrest rate risk, clearing risk, geopolitical risk, currency risk, that all goes into the pricing of an asset. You knew the risks going in.

As someone who has been fined by Finra and someone who has had a multi million dollar winning trade cancelled by Finra, i can unequivocally say a politician has no business in your issue. You need a lawyer.

Your ire towards Ralph Norman, whom I have no opinion of one way or another, is misplaced in my opinion. Lawyers are your friend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SlovenskoTiger

coldbud1994

All-American
Jan 18, 2005
4,010
6,494
112
I'm hopeful that Jermaine Johnson will get the Dem nomination.

@coldbud1994 I'm not sure of your political leanings, but Reddy is a dyed in the wool Maga. Big contributions to Trump.
Yeah I know Reddy is pretty hardcore maga. He also hosted a dinner for Ron Desantis at his home on IOP and raised millions.

I'm probably what would be considered a Reagan Republican. I voted for Dubya but also voted for Clinton. I don't think I would vote for Reddy but I'm so tired of the SC good old boy politics crap. Its why SC lags behind so many States.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chumpsky
Nov 19, 2016
8,376
10,573
113
Yeah I know Reddy is pretty hardcore maga. He also hosted a dinner for Ron Desantis at his home on IOP and raised millions.

I'm probably what would be considered a Reagan Republican. I voted for Dubya but also voted for Clinton. I don't think I would vote for Reddy but I'm so tired of the SC good old boy politics crap.

“ Its why SC lags behind so many States.”
🤣
 

coldbud1994

All-American
Jan 18, 2005
4,010
6,494
112
“ Its why SC lags behind so many States.”
🤣

People move here for good weather and its cheap relative to many places in the Country. . SC has a poor public education system overall (many good schools), high poverty rates, high obesity rates, high infant death rates and lower life expectancy. Its a welfare State and has to be supported by the Federal Government (SC receives $1.67 in Federal money for every $1.00 it sends in taxes).

I love it but lets not pretend SC does not need a lot of improvement.
 
Nov 19, 2016
8,376
10,573
113
People move here for good weather and its cheap relative to many places in the Country. . SC has a poor public education system overall (many good schools), high poverty rates, high obesity rates, high infant death rates and lower life expectancy. Its a welfare State and has to be supported by the Federal Government (SC receives $1.67 in Federal money for every $1.00 it sends in taxes).

I love it but lets not pretend SC does not need a lot of improvement.
“ high poverty rates, high obesity rates, high infant death rates and lower life expectancy.”
lol
You do realize SC isn’t top 5 in any of these, right?!? I think obesity may be the only one where we fall in the top 10
 

Chumpsky

All-American
Oct 19, 2025
3,680
5,614
113
To any of my fellow leftists who live here, please don't get conned by Mullins McLeod. Dude is an absolute clown. You'd literally be better off with me as governor.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
People move here for good weather and its cheap relative to many places in the Country. . SC has a poor public education system overall (many good schools), high poverty rates, high obesity rates, high infant death rates and lower life expectancy. Its a welfare State and has to be supported by the Federal Government (SC receives $1.67 in Federal money for every $1.00 it sends in taxes).

I love it but lets not pretend SC does not need a lot of improvement.
It's always good to strive for improvement. But SC is doing a lot of things very well.

There is a reason there is an influx of people moving to the state. It's not just the weather. And many of the people move to Charleston, which ain't cheap, so I'm not buying that explanation either.

In addition to good weather, we have a very friendly business climate. We get lots of tourism. We are a friendly, family-oriented people. We are centrally located. Our rights are respected by the government. Our schools do leave room for improvement, but I don't think they are as bad as some make them out to be. We have great Universities.

Obesity - you are correct. We can work on that as a state.

Overall, I give SC an A+. Not many other places I would want to live right now. I think that sentiment is reflected in the population trends of the nation.
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,291
13,232
113
It's always good to strive for improvement. But SC is doing a lot of things very well.

There is a reason there is an influx of people moving to the state. It's not just the weather. And many of the people move to Charleston, which ain't cheap, so I'm not buying that explanation either.

In addition to good weather, we have a very friendly business climate. We get lots of tourism. We are a friendly, family-oriented people. We are centrally located. Our rights are respected by the government. Our schools do leave room for improvement, but I don't think they are as bad as some make them out to be. We have great Universities.

Obesity - you are correct. We can work on that as a state.

Overall, I give SC an A+. Not many other places I would want to live right now. I think that sentiment is reflected in the population trends of the nation.

Since I live in SC Lowcountry I am seeing a huge and when I say HUGE IT IS HUGE movement of well heeled wealthy people moving into the urban and rural areas. Seeing a lot of money buying large tracts of land and all kinds of stuff going on out of sight.

Thats just my take

Being an old fart there’s not much runway left for me

But got my kids and grands looking at golden group for SC
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson's defense looking for one more stop
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Dabo Swinney and the scrutiny from within
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football The day after for Clemson Football
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Pearman, Denson lead Clemson past Duke in upset win
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson upends double-digit favorite Duke 20-10