I would agree overall Iowa's transfers over the last 10 years have been an extremely net positive to the program - not only on the mat performance but also in the general sense. Lugo has carried the Hawkeye name back to Miami and looks to be doing really well. Eierman always felt like he should have been in Carver. Mikey C is the face of the program along with Drake and PK, Buchanan excelled and is excelling here. Parco, who didn't "work out" because of injury is in the area coaching, as mentioned DeSanto has grown leaps and bounds in black and gold, and so on. Teemer was also hurt, which just happens sometimes, and I don't think that is one that can be attributed to outdated training methods.
I think the transfer issue is coming down to 3 points: the failure of them this year, the number of them this year, and next, and the absolute need of them for next year because of failures in recruiting. Until this year, I would say Tom has done a spectular job with transfers, bringing in guys most would say are Hawkeyes through and through.