It seems that the consensus is that Oklahoma State is the new rival…

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,588
4,723
113
Injuries and additions made things different. Wrestle that dual with the same line ups as the beginning of the year and the score isn't like yesterday.
Adding Jax is simply a reflection of OkieSt's recruiting and progression, and injuries towards the second half of the season seem to be part of the Iowa progression.
Considering the season doesn't happen in a vacuum and teams move through a season differently, the statement that without additions and injuries the match would have been different has nothing to do with reality.
Maybe Iowa finds 6 or 7 portal rentals that can help them compete next year, but by the end of season half or more will be not available. My take remains that the two programs are progressing in opposite directions.
 

mcpat

All-American
Mar 12, 2021
1,771
7,120
113
Threat - yes.

Rival - I think we have to see our rival more than just at NCAAs to call them that.

And while I do think Okie St is a legitimate threat going forward, it’s because of the resources and support for the program, not 2 recruiting classes. If history is our guide, a couple of the guys Askren listed won’t become AAs.
 

CTStall

Senior
Oct 24, 2020
279
707
93
Keep Taylor out from landing the best kids in Pennsylvania. Taylor has connections for Pennsylvania talent for probably 3 more years from when he was running M2. Forrest was a huge get for him. Iowa's last run was made possible by landing a couple of Pennsylvania kids. Virginia Tech is probably going to be top 5 in a year or 2 because of Pennsylvanian talent.
Looking at High School talent it appears Iowa has slipped compared to Ohio, California and Pennsylvania. I think that has hurt Iowa.
 
Last edited:

tullfan68

All-Conference
Jun 20, 2021
782
1,022
93
well PSU has so many number 1s the only way to catch then is to NIL all those guys and that's not happening!
 

NittanyChris

All-Conference
Dec 3, 2001
322
1,425
93
Agree or disagree?
Ok St WILL BE PSU's main rival in a couple of years. In order to be a true rival, an opponent must have a credible chance to defeat PSU and as it stands now by that definition, PSU has no rival. In 2028, it may be a different story and Ok St could rise to rival status at that time.
 

Cali_Nittany1

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2019
679
2,893
93
And in 2026 it's happening all over 🤷

As 83% of the natives are recognizing on HR, Iowa is paying the price for poor recruiting and subpar development. The portal is important to fill in gaps but the portal isn't going to fix where Iowa is at now.

Don't be MSU:
 

Sandy2176

Freshman
Nov 1, 2025
96
91
18
The other OSU may disagree, though.
Don't you have to wrestle them consistently to be a rival

Oklahoma State is a challenger, a main competitor but not a rival.
People are falling asleep on Perry. I really like him in this room
Heard Zack Seyko on on3 who I like some of the time, just keep saying for this and next 2 years nobody can catch us I think he should take a urine and blood test. After this year, for the next 4-5 years neck and neck.
 

Sandy2176

Freshman
Nov 1, 2025
96
91
18
I seem to recall similar statements about tOSU back around 2022 (?) with names like these on a roster that looked pretty formidable at the time:

Nic Bouzakis
Jesse Mendez
Nick Feldman
Seth Shumate
Luke Geog
Gavin Brown
Brendan McCrone
Sammy Sasso
Dylan D'Emilio
Paddy Gallagher
Carson Kharchla
Kaleb Romero

OKST’s recruiting looks great. It will be f*n to see how things develop. Maybe this will end up being like a new Sam’s Club going up across the street from Costco and they will eat into each other’s profits big time. Or, maybe the new construction will come with all the hype of a big warehouse store and end up being just another CVS. Too soon to know.
Very good point. I think 25-26-27 recruiting class are the real thing. They won't need to get transfers maybe 1 but all top recruits fit nicely right time right place. If PSU and old wrestle must see TV
 

Sandy2176

Freshman
Nov 1, 2025
96
91
18
That's actually a decent RTC roster. It's not enough and it took way too long to get there. But it's not bad.

The bigger problem is that they're all Hawk alums. Brands and Slumlord Bob pay big bucks to import varsity wrestlers, but import no RTC resident athletes. NLWC would still be very good but not nearly what it is without bringing in Snyder, Dake, Gilman, Rodriguez, Francisco, Gomez, Bekzod, Varner, etc.

And then Iowa isn't retaining all of their best wrestlers after graduation -- notably Kemerer, Woods, and Cassioppi.

Taylor within a year imported Zahid, RBY, and McKenna. Brands has different priorities.
Plus 3 more
 

amattaro

All-Conference
Sep 12, 2017
326
1,554
93
When Vega beats Mendez in Cleveland (I said it, go ahead and bookmark it), is that credit to DT or will Vega be declared an out-of-the-box stud?
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: TangSoo and Hlstone

The Pitchfork Rebel

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2021
575
1,345
93
When Vega beats Mendez in Cleveland (I said it, go ahead and bookmark it), is that credit to DT or will Vega be declared an out-of-the-box stud?

Shouldn't this post be under "What Are We Drinking Tonight".

He beat Echemendia 4-2 and pined and MD'd Hardy (who is always prone to the spectacular-good and bad)

Mendez majors him at least.

As much as I hate the Bugeyes, absent Mitchell and Barr, clearly Hodge material.
 

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,588
4,723
113
Don't you have to wrestle them consistently to be a rival

Oklahoma State is a challenger, a main competitor but not a rival.

Heard Zack Seyko on on3 who I like some of the time, just keep saying for this and next 2 years nobody can catch us I think he should take a urine and blood test. After this year, for the next 4-5 years neck and neck.
No, 2028 is not neck and neck.
2029 is the first year that Okie State may be a real threat, but we won't have any idea if that is a true assessment until we get into the 2028-29 season.
Not matter what Okie St throws out there, assuming both programs stay healthy PSU's lineup should look something like
Luke
Ono
Blaze
Desmond, Perry or someone better
Kasak
Duke
James, Henckel or Cunningham
Rocco
Barr
Mirasola

Now there is a possibility one or more could ORS, as a few Cowboys could also.

If both can put their best lineups on the mat there isn't much Oklahoma State can with the above lineup.
 

Random4598375

All-Conference
Jan 10, 2020
599
1,723
93
No, 2028 is not neck and neck.
2029 is the first year that Okie State may be a real threat, but we won't have any idea if that is a true assessment until we get into the 2028-29 season.
Not matter what Okie St throws out there, assuming both programs stay healthy PSU's lineup should look something like
Luke
Ono
Blaze
Desmond, Perry or someone better
Kasak
Duke
James, Henckel or Cunningham
Rocco
Barr
Mirasola

Now there is a possibility one or more could ORS, as a few Cowboys could also.

If both can put their best lineups on the mat there isn't much Oklahoma State can with the above lineup.
It depends on how you define "threat". If that means at least a 50% chance (or even 40%) to actually beat PSU and win it all, then, no, it's still a little early for that. But, by 2028, they will be head and shoulders above everyone else in the field and will push PSU to be their best to win it all, and the days of the 100 point margin will be long gone (and the margin from 2nd to 3rd will be significantly bigger than 1st to 2nd).
 

Psalm 1 guy

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2019
1,158
4,434
113
I sometimes think that when wrestling fans are discussing years or wrestling seasons, not everyone uses the same definition. For instance, some may refer to the 2028-2029 season as 2028, but others as 2029 since that is when the NCAA tournament occurs and what year will be recorded for team and individual champions. For clarity, I try to always use this format; e.g. 2028-29 season.
 

Goggles Paisano

All-Conference
Feb 6, 2018
774
2,007
93
Yep, and by the end of the year one had taken a giant step forward and the other seemed to not have. One will continue to progress while the other will continue to not.
Iowa Minus Endene, Ferrari and Keuter, no matter their limitations, didn't help either, while OSU gained Jax.

I am not so sure the gap was narrowed by development or the lack thereof. Mostly by personnel IMO.
 

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,588
4,723
113
It depends on how you define "threat". If that means at least a 50% chance (or even 40%) to actually beat PSU and win it all, then, no, it's still a little early for that. But, by 2028, they will be head and shoulders above everyone else in the field and will push PSU to be their best to win it all, and the days of the 100 point margin will be long gone (and the margin from 2nd to 3rd will be significantly bigger than 1st to 2nd).
Now that is an accurate description. I can see Okie State making a serious run at 140 points. The distance between first and second will still be greater than the distance between second and third.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dogwelder

RoarLions1

Senior
May 11, 2012
97
638
83
Oklahoma State is rebuilding the once-proud program the right way. Tons of solid recruits that are freshmen this year, and a solid class coming next season. Developing those kids and keeping them for four years of eligibility will surely pay dividends, while using the portal only when a gap is projected until they can build bench strength. Even then, coaches won't say no to a guy that can help the program. Sound familiar? Another very proud school has taken a different approach and it does not appear to be working out.

Too many unknowns to talk three years or more out, but there is enough evidence that the Cowboys are starting their charge. Penn State's firepower for the next two years might (or should I use a stronger word?) be too much to overcome, but I'm excited to see what happens those two years and beyond.

Roster size limits and the amount of talent available each year suggests that there should and could be more parity if blue-chippers congregate at one school. we're starting to see it at Okie State. What about Virginia Tech? Ohio State? Others? All good for college wrestling.
 

Nitlion1986

All-Conference
Apr 13, 2024
1,588
4,723
113
Oklahoma State is rebuilding the once-proud program the right way. Tons of solid recruits that are freshmen this year, and a solid class coming next season. Developing those kids and keeping them for four years of eligibility will surely pay dividends, while using the portal only when a gap is projected until they can build bench strength. Even then, coaches won't say no to a guy that can help the program. Sound familiar? Another very proud school has taken a different approach and it does not appear to be working out.

Too many unknowns to talk three years or more out, but there is enough evidence that the Cowboys are starting their charge. Penn State's firepower for the next two years might (or should I use a stronger word?) be too much to overcome, but I'm excited to see what happens those two years and beyond.

Roster size limits and the amount of talent available each year suggests that there should and could be more parity if blue-chippers congregate at one school. we're starting to see it at Okie State. What about Virginia Tech? Ohio State? Others? All good for college wrestling.
It is good to see you posting.
 

Lil Nicky Scarfo

All-Conference
Jul 1, 2025
1,347
3,855
113
Now that is an accurate description. I can see Okie State making a serious run at 140 points. The distance between first and second will still be greater than the distance between second and third.
Just reflexively, I see them at about 110-120. 140 is a tough ask with several holes and half a lineup that doesn’t get bonus
 

bdoncsecz

Sophomore
Feb 12, 2022
72
109
33
Not so sure Okie St is rebuilding the "right way", as in Cael might disagree. But I get your point