Something I noticed about Popes first class

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
3,740
5,050
82
I don’t think he’s struggling that bad. He’s just a B+ level recruiter and he’s following the greatest recruiter of all-time. One of the top rated classes last year portal+high school and fans blame recruiting because Pope isn’t Cal.
He’s at UK my man. Not BYU. He’s an F recruiting at UK. The brand and the biggest payroll got THIS roster. B+? Jesus.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
3,740
5,050
82
Some fans are still waiting on another period like 1993-1998 and won’t be able to enjoy because of an unrealistic comparison.

Some fans are still waiting on another coach to recruit like John Calipari and won’t be able to enjoy because of an unrealistic comparison.

You won’t change Kentucky basketball by your disposition. But you can change what you get out of it by recognizing things for what they are. Calipari isn’t walking back through the door and neither is Rick. We best hope Mark Pope plays to his own strengths and succeeds here. Otherwise we all lose.
Sweet. Be happy with S16s. Meanwhile Duke and a few others have figured out how to be elite.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
3,740
5,050
82
It’s terrible. We are running out of time and won’t be able to field a team . Farrr Pope!

Let’s go for all the simple cliche low hanging fruit ones:

“We are Kentucky!”

“We ain’t got no recruits!”

“We lost over 10 games.”

“We didnt make the final four.”

If you want my real opinions about recruiting, I’ll gladly share but let’s be real, Richie — you don’t care. You want to dunk on Pope and that’s all it is for you. No conversation needed, you just want the pat on the back so here it is: Farrrr Pope!
To be fair, you just dunked on Pope. All those “cliches” are also truths.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
23,959
54,338
100
Here’s the deal. Pope is NOT gonna recruit to the level of Cal. Matter of fact, nobody we could ever bring to Lexington will now, or ever. Cal is only the best recruiter of all time.

Honestly, I don’t want a roster full of 5 star freshmen. All people did for the last several years of Cal was b1tch and complain that we had to rebuild an entire roster every season, because all of our players went to the draft. They claimed they wanted roster retention. Claimed they wanted experienced rosters. Now they b1tch because we aren’t landing those same 5 star freshmen. Idk, just wild.
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
3,740
5,050
82
Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t all three of said players make NBA rosters?! I know 2/3 did. Odd.
What does that have to do with recruiting guys from those schools? First year on the job. Before everyone realized he’s a poser.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
23,959
54,338
100
What does that have to do with recruiting guys from those schools? First year on the job. Before everyone realized he’s a poser.
The question you should be asking is, why do the school names matter? These guys went PRO, yet somehow, they weren’t good enough to be recruited by UK because they played at a mid major?! If anything, it says Pope saw something in these guys that most others didn’t. However, all three of those guys were of high interest to some of the best college basketball programs in the country. IIRC, Brea was down to us, UConn, the cheats and either KU or duke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HipTer

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
23,959
54,338
100
I’ll also add this. We beat EIGHT top 15 teams with that roster last year, which tied an all time record. All while battling multiple injuries ALL season. If that’s a “poser” then I wanna know what is authentic?!
 

Eagles_Ball_69

All-American
Dec 19, 2003
3,740
5,050
82
The question you should be asking is, why do the school names matter? These guys went PRO, yet somehow, they weren’t good enough to be recruited by UK because they played at a mid major?! If anything, it says Pope saw something in these guys that most others didn’t. However, all three of those guys were of high interest to some of the best college basketball programs in the country. IIRC, Brea was down to us, UConn, the cheats and either KU or duke.
Nobody said they weren’t good enough. Recruiting those guys to UK from those schools isn’t a flex. It’s what should happen if the UK coach wants them.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
23,959
54,338
100
Nobody said they weren’t good enough. Recruiting those guys to UK from those schools isn’t a flex. It’s what should happen if the UK coach wants them.
So, we should have taken a bunch of 4/5 star freshmen? Is that what you’re saying. What’s the argument here?!
 

mhs1964

Junior
Feb 8, 2018
299
317
58
I don’t think he’s struggling that bad. He’s just a B+ level recruiter and he’s following the greatest recruiter of all-time. One of the top rated classes last year portal+high school and fans blame recruiting because Pope isn’t Cal.
And while I thought it was time for Calipari to leave i suspected that all the voices purporting that they were finished with one and dones would start complaining if we only recruited three-four year projects. If you keep recruiting over the 2-3 year player they will leave for more playing time elsewhere. I still tend to go with talent approach but you can’t let Duke sign four of the top ten.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
23,959
54,338
100
And while I thought it was time for Calipari to leave i suspected that all the voices purporting that they were finished with one and dones would start complaining if we only recruited three-four year projects. If you keep recruiting over the 2-3 year player they will leave for more playing time elsewhere. I still tend to go with talent approach but you can’t let Duke sign four of the top ten.
I get it. However, they’re not gonna win a title with a bunch of freshmen. Unless they get an AD type of talent.
 

Zuma75

All-Conference
Mar 19, 2017
863
1,194
93
Here’s the deal. Pope is NOT gonna recruit to the level of Cal. Matter of fact, nobody we could ever bring to Lexington will now, or ever. Cal is only the best recruiter of all time.

Honestly, I don’t want a roster full of 5 star freshmen. All people did for the last several years of Cal was b1tch and complain that we had to rebuild an entire roster every season, because all of our players went to the draft. They claimed they wanted roster retention. Claimed they wanted experienced rosters. Now they b1tch because we aren’t landing those same 5 star freshmen. Idk, just wild.
It’s like Cal used to say about 3-point shooting: Pope don’t have to get ALL of his top targets. He just can’t MISS ‘em all.

Forget year 1, they were all gone when he took the job. But year 2 he missed ‘em all. And so far in year 3, he’s missed ‘em all in the HS class.

Good news is, he still has chance for Year 3.
 
Jul 30, 2024
5,747
10,879
113
And while I thought it was time for Calipari to leave i suspected that all the voices purporting that they were finished with one and dones would start complaining if we only recruited three-four year projects. If you keep recruiting over the 2-3 year player they will leave for more playing time elsewhere. I still tend to go with talent approach but you can’t let Duke sign four of the top ten.
I think the disconnect between me and a lot of the other fans on this topic is about what’s realistic and what isn’t. College recruiting isn’t the same as it was for Kentucky in the early Cal era. Duke is dominating everyone in recruiting and it isn’t close — even Calipari couldn’t keep up. We have to find our own competitive advantage and that’s what I believe Pope is trying to do. I don’t see any of the familiar favorite names getting the bevy of recruits most fans want. Oats? Nope. Beard? Absolutely not. Who you bringing in? You want Sean Miller or Jai Lucas? We have to adjust to the current landscape and know where we can win and where we can’t. If you aren’t going to collect talent, you have to prioritize fit and continuity. You’ll undermine that easily by going after the “best available player” all the time. I wish we could win a national title every year, have the top high school recruiting class, the top portal class and go 40-0 each year but that’s not how it works. I believe I’m looking at things from an honest and consistent perspective and I know the “recruit doomers” believe they are as well — I just disagree.
 

Cowtown Cat

Heisman
Aug 23, 2015
23,959
54,338
100
I think the disconnect between me and a lot of the other fans on this topic is about what’s realistic and what isn’t. College recruiting isn’t the same as it was for Kentucky in the early Cal era. Duke is dominating everyone in recruiting and it isn’t close — even Calipari couldn’t keep up. We have to find our own competitive advantage and that’s what I believe Pope is trying to do. I don’t see any of the familiar favorite names getting the bevy of recruits most fans want. Oats? Nope. Beard? Absolutely not. Who you bringing in? You want Sean Miller or Jai Lucas? We have to adjust to the current landscape and know where we can win and where we can’t. If you aren’t going to collect talent, you have to prioritize fit and continuity. You’ll undermine that easily by going after the “best available player” all the time. I wish we could win a national title every year, have the top high school recruiting class, the top portal class and go 40-0 each year but that’s not how it works. I believe I’m looking at things from an honest and consistent perspective and I know the “recruit doomers” believe they are as well — I just disagree.
Exactly! There’s soooooo many programs winning at an elite level that don’t even sign any top HS players. Also, there’s a transfer portal now. Coaches don’t have to exclusively recruit HS players.
 

HipTer

Senior
Apr 11, 2012
957
641
93
Here’s the deal. Pope is NOT gonna recruit to the level of Cal. Matter of fact, nobody we could ever bring to Lexington will now, or ever. Cal is only the best recruiter of all time.

Honestly, I don’t want a roster full of 5 star freshmen. All people did for the last several years of Cal was b1tch and complain that we had to rebuild an entire roster every season, because all of our players went to the draft. They claimed they wanted roster retention. Claimed they wanted experienced rosters. Now they b1tch because we aren’t landing those same 5 star freshmen. Idk, just wild.
Pope has no recruits at this point so I can understand some giving him an F for recruiting this season to this point. But I’m not going to judge recruiting by how many OAD freshmen any coach signs. I’ll judge it by how his recruits impact winning.

With high school recruits that’s often not a one year assessment and depends on a coach’s ability see what a kid can become in the future and size up a kid to determine his chances of keeping him long enough to see that development bear winning fruit. Portal recruiting is more important for immediate results, so personally I would judge that aspect of recruiting more on what you got from a guy in year one – especially a senior transfer.
 

davtay

All-Conference
Dec 31, 2002
1,263
1,211
113
Imagine being a season ticket holder and wanting Pope to fail instead of enjoying every minute of it. Wild.....and sad.
Pretty sure that was the guy on here one night GUARANTEEING that Cade Cunningham was coming. Had sources and everything. So....
 

Woodrow24

Heisman
Dec 21, 2015
6,310
15,309
78
Exactly! There’s soooooo many programs winning at an elite level that don’t even sign any top HS players. Also, there’s a transfer portal now. Coaches don’t have to exclusively recruit HS players.
I think some got so used to getting 5 stars with Cal that it’s become expected to keep happening. I admit I worry over recruiting but you’re absolutely right. You can build good teams without top high school players.
 

Monday Nitro

All-American
Jul 3, 2025
4,034
6,880
112
Pretty sure that was the guy on here one night GUARANTEEING that Cade Cunningham was coming. Had sources and everything. So....
I don’t doubt it as he was the one that said he knew insiders and that Cal was 100% gone (well before he left. ) He had this place on edge for weeks and then vanished for a while after he was wrong, finally came back and proceeded to attack anyone that called him out. Disgraceful. Im not perfect at all, but I dont pull people’s legs and find sick humor in it. Elaborate troll job? ✅✅
 

Anon1759768907

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2025
2,282
3,691
113
I think some got so used to getting 5 stars with Cal that it’s become expected to keep happening. I admit I worry over recruiting but you’re absolutely right. You can build good teams without top high school players.
every top team has a. elite coaching, b. elite recruits or both

uconn - coaching
houston, arizona- both
duke- recruits
 

Woodrow24

Heisman
Dec 21, 2015
6,310
15,309
78
every top team has a. elite coaching, b. elite recruits or both

uconn - coaching
houston, arizona- both
duke- recruits
It’s not impossible to build good teams without top high school players. I hope we get a top high school player but if we don’t I’m not going to freak out if we get a top portal class including since we should have more guys returning than we normally have next year.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Cowtown Cat

jc2010

All-Conference
May 13, 2008
4,593
4,369
62
This is largely because 20 years ago recruits still cared about the program and its tradition. That is all completely meaningless in 2026. They just don't care about tradition or titles won before they were born. There's a reason our only two highly ranked recruits are Kentucky kids. Because for recruits from anywhere else the word Kentucky means nothing more than the word Alabama.

It's about the coach and NIL nowadays. Program tradition is no longer a recruiting tool. In 1998 the Kentucky brand could make a guy like Tubby a good recruiter, but in 2026 it can't.
Adolph Rupp came to UK and started winning basketball games. He got the University to invest in the basketball program when most schools weren't. When recruits came to UK they saw better facilities and that everything was first class for the basketball team. Basketball players were big men on campus. At most other schools basketball was an afterthought. Kentucky was one of the few "names" when it came to basketball. Things have changed, there is a lot of money in basketball and everyone is chasing it. Pedigree doesn't matter, $$$$ do. Agents are controlling decisions making every school a contender for players. How much money, will I be featured etc. etc. Everybody's got money, everybody's got facilities.
 
Jul 6, 2025
2,140
6,462
113
He got a bunch of guys with outlier attributes

Koby- Incredible shooter upoer 99 percentile

Amari- Best passing big in cbb

Lamont- Toughness/Nose for the ball

That team's talent level was criminally underrated. Brea or amari would by far be the most talented player on this year's team. They were just underrated because of the elite one and done guys we were used to.

I think Pope is a good coach. Not great, but good. He desperately needs help managing the roster. He gets that under control, he might have something.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Cowtown Cat