Power 4 vs. Group of Five

Hawkangler

All-Conference
Mar 16, 2014
1,890
4,227
113
Washington throttled Boise State last night. Starting see the impact of NIL and profit sharing playing out. Power Four teams poaching the best group of 5 players through the portal.
 

Palmerhawk

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
2,021
4,014
113
When did they start playing bowl games on the same day as Army Navy? What happened to the 15 extra practices?
Tradition in college football is back- burner now
With playoffs dominating next weekend it is crowding out some bowls

As for Washington, they are gonna be loaded next year and to me becomes our #2 toughest game out there next year behind only OSU and ahead of Michigan at ann arbor
Fish, UW coach May be in Mich next year and that would jumble the picture.
That QB for Wash is a potential Heisman guy next year.
I was thinking of going to Seattle for that game but not if we are big underdogs.
 

OnlyTheObscure

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
3,098
4,458
113
There's also a difference between the P2 & the Leftover2. This will continue to get worse as the NIL/profit sharing gap grows & players/coaches are promoted to the big leagues. Maybe ISMoo & the other rejects can move to FCS?
Why would they do that? Just spend less.
 

HawkinAZ

Sophomore
Aug 23, 2008
65
105
33
I believe with NIL the disparity will increase as several top G5 players transfer to P5 schools. But the disparity has always been there. I found this, between 2010 and 2020 the power 5 won 60.8% of the bowl games. And of course in these games you are not playing the top teams in the power 5 conferences. I believe when the Big was in the Holiday Bowl it was the Big #3 team against the WAC champion. Iowa was 2-0-1 in that bowl against WAC teams.

The overall records were worse as the Big won 84.7% against G5 from 2014-2020. Some of this disparity is likely do to Big teams being the home team in the vast majority of these games.
 

Burghawk87

All-Conference
Jan 5, 2023
800
1,426
93
Call me crazy but I don't think NIL is to blame for any of this so called disparity. Other than Indiana's meteoric rise, what has changed? The top teams are still the same, smaller conferences occasionally beat the big boys, and players are now paid both above and below the table. The biggest issue with traditional football is the wild west of the transfer portal.
 

DuddyB

All-Conference
Jul 14, 2022
1,614
2,800
113
Call me crazy but I don't think NIL is to blame for any of this so called disparity. Other than Indiana's meteoric rise, what has changed? The top teams are still the same, smaller conferences occasionally beat the big boys, and players are now paid both above and below the table. The biggest issue with traditional football is the wild west of the transfer portal.
I think the instances of the smaller conferences beating the big boys is going to greatly diminish, especially in the CFP. The rest of the bowls will be a wild card with all the opting out that goes on now.

For me, I’ll be greatly disappointed if Iowa doesn’t win 80% of the football CyHawk games going forward.
 

Hawktech

Senior
Dec 18, 2022
535
681
93
Those lost 15 practices will kill their chances at being competitive in 2026.

they are that important.
They are Very important... Ask ANY coach! It is like an extra spring practice season. The guys who have the best chance to be starters, and those in close competition, will get a lot of #1 snaps in the spring.

Side note - the rumor has it that Hank Brown has looked Very Good so far in these extra practices. Love that! A competitive race to be QB1 next season, and having multiple years in Lester's system, is incredibly beneficial vs a one-and-done... 🤩
 

Hawkfan_08*

All-American
Jul 2, 2025
3,249
8,728
113
Call me crazy but I don't think NIL is to blame for any of this so called disparity. Other than Indiana's meteoric rise, what has changed? The top teams are still the same, smaller conferences occasionally beat the big boys, and players are now paid both above and below the table. The biggest issue with traditional football is the wild west of the transfer portal.

Clemson sucks and the SEC isn't as good since they can't cheat by themselves anymore?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wobmam Rulez!

Wobmam Rulez!

All-American
Aug 4, 2025
3,676
5,813
113
Call me crazy but I don't think NIL is to blame for any of this so called disparity. Other than Indiana's meteoric rise, what has changed? The top teams are still the same, smaller conferences occasionally beat the big boys, and players are now paid both above and below the table. The biggest issue with traditional football is the wild west of the transfer portal.
True, to a point but dirty Nic retired because everyone can now have a bag man!
 
  • Like
Reactions: chuck285

OnlyTheObscure

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
3,098
4,458
113
Because eventually they won’t be able to compete with the P2 teams.
So? FCS is a money pit.

they can still make money and provide an environment that get alumni on campus.

you think they want to draw dick for fans and never be on TV?
 

OnlyTheObscure

All-Conference
Jul 3, 2025
3,098
4,458
113
They are Very important... Ask ANY coach! It is like an extra spring practice season. The guys who have the best chance to be starters, and those in close competition, will get a lot of #1 snaps in the spring.

Side note - the rumor has it that Hank Brown has looked Very Good so far in these extra practices. Love that! A competitive race to be QB1 next season, and having multiple years in Lester's system, is incredibly beneficial vs a one-and-done... 🤩
Your right. I always play golf awesome next June if I play a few rounds in December.

been practing since July but if they don’t practice in December they forget everything.

I assume we are all betting the under on Washington next year. They are screwed.

The band directors say they are much better in 2026 with the extra practices.