ESPN arguing the case for teams getting in

MAKhawks

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2001
1,418
2,175
113
I knew expanding the CFP to 12 teams would solve everything.

Thank goodness there's no more whining.

There’s always going to be discussions (or whining) as to who should or shouldn’t be in the playoffs. It doesn’t matter if it’s a four team bracket, 12 team bracket, or 24 teams….. It’s a given and if you seriously thought a 12 team bracket would end that, that’s more on you than the ones discussing it. Basketball has 68 teams in the tournament and every year people still bring up the same arguments of who got left out and who shouldn’t be in.

I really don’t feel so bad for the 10th, 11th, or 12th best school being left out as opposed to the 5th or 6th best team being excluded. Especially when one of those teams refuse to join a conference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Unclesammy

rchawk

All-American
Oct 27, 2001
74,547
9,187
113
If you aren't among the consensus twelve best teams in the country it is hard to take seriously the argument "But we could have been national champs!"

It probably will move to 24 for the money. For the money, $$$, cash, pay, dinero. It won't be because we require 24 teams to determine which of them is the best in the country.
 
Feb 12, 2007
166
249
43
I believe Ole Piss should have dropped a few spots since they don't have their original coach. FSU got dinged for not having their starting qb and missed the 4-team playoff going 13-0 (whatever happened in their bowl game is irrelevant since so many starters opted out).
I view losing a head coach is just as important as losing your starting qb. They should have dropped to at least 8.
 

MeetTheFerentzes

All-Conference
Sep 6, 2022
2,038
3,941
113
FSU got dinged for not having their starting qb and missed the 4-team playoff going 13-0.
This is a common narrative, but also a myth. Alabama was ahead of Florida State in every possible metric at the end of the season, and anyone with eyeballs (including Michigan) knew that 'Bama was the better team. The QB injury made the decision easier for the Committee but it was still a pretty clear-cut decision. The ACC has since been in a free-fall.
 
Feb 12, 2007
166
249
43
This is a common narrative, but also a myth. Alabama was ahead of Florida State in every possible metric at the end of the season, and anyone with eyeballs (including Michigan) knew that 'Bama was the better team. The QB injury made the decision easier for the Committee but it was still a pretty clear-cut decision. The ACC has since been in a free-fall.
According to CFP website weekly ratings FSU was #4 on Nov 28. 5th on Dec 3.

https://collegefootballplayoff.com/sports/2023/11/1/wk-x-wk-rankings-2023.aspx
 

Kceasthawk@77

All-American
Feb 2, 2005
3,037
5,530
113
There’s always going to be discussions (or whining) as to who should or shouldn’t be in the playoffs. It doesn’t matter if it’s a four team bracket, 12 team bracket, or 24 teams….. It’s a given and if you seriously thought a 12 team bracket would end that, that’s more on you than the ones discussing it. Basketball has 68 teams in the tournament and every year people still bring up the same arguments of who got left out and who shouldn’t be in.

I really don’t feel so bad for the 10th, 11th, or 12th best school being left out as opposed to the 5th or 6th best team being excluded. Especially when one of those teams refuse to join a conference.
You realize he was being sarcastic, right?
 

AnonymousNolonger

All-Conference
Jul 4, 2025
950
1,813
93
Why? They have one close loss to the #2 team in the country. Should they be punished because they lost in the conference championship game instead of the regular season?
You’re right, If it had been Bama and Georgia in a 1 vs 2 championship game, you can bet your *** they wouldn’t have dropped the team that lost by 3 points.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ottumwan in tx
Jun 10, 2025
1,181
951
113
Why? They have one close loss to the #2 team in the country. Should they be punished because they lost in the conference championship game instead of the regular season?
Because it’s Indiana. Same problem
I had with Iowa losing to indiana
not buying the basketball school is #2 or #1 in the nation