We're not going to Mars

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
We have everything we need on earth. Air, water, plant and animal life. Life outside of earth would be hell with death highly probable in the short term. Do you consider that it would be extremely expensive to mine on other planets? It would result in billions of $$ lost. And you could find the workers. Miners don't want to rest in their protected quarters and read. They want to go hunting and fishing. They want to be with their families.
I'm just thinking of the natural progression of the human species. We're eventually going to outgrow our planet and sap it of all its finite resources. I think it's a net positive to try and focus on space exploration and other planetary colonization. It's also not a coincidence that some of our most impactful scientific/medical discoveries came due to space exploration funding during the space race.
 

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
I'm just thinking of the natural progression of the human species. We're eventually going to outgrow our planet and sap it of all its finite resources. I think it's a net positive to try and focus on space exploration and other planetary colonization. It's also not a coincidence that some of our most impactful scientific/medical discoveries came due to space exploration funding during the space race.
WE are long past where "impactful scientific/medical discoveries" are coming from NASA. It was handed over to the private sector and the results have been spectacular.

Regarding humans, I am sure we only have about 100 years. By which time oil and many other minerals will be exhausted. I am at peace recognizing the truth. We will not have enough oil to even wage war. Fusion will not work either to save us on the energy front. The physics (and history) say it won't work.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TigerGrowls

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
WE are long past where "impactful scientific/medical discoveries" are coming from NASA. It was handed over to the private sector and the results have been spectacular.

Regarding humans, I am sure we only have about 100 years. By which time oil and many other minerals will be exhausted. I am at peace recognizing the truth. We will not have enough oil to even wage war. Fusion will not work either to save us on the energy front. The physics (and history) say it won't work.
I suppose I'm just not as cynical as you are
 

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
Odd thread is odd …

Space exploration is one of the few things that everyone everywhere could/should rally around and unify on. Curing cancer would be another ….

Today … we need more of these things, not less.
So let's concentrate on things consider more possible. Not just throwing stuff against the wall. Like you say. Let's all rally for space exploration $$ used instead for law/drug enforcement.
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,362
28,922
103
So let's concentrate on things consider more possible. Not just throwing stuff against the wall. Like you say. Let's all rally for space exploration $$ used instead for law/drug enforcement.
The foundation of science is built on “throwing stuff against the wall”.

and I would also say if “we” (the collective we) only considered things that were “possible”, we’d still be wearing animal skins and living in caves.

Don’t necessarily disagree with you on funding on law/drug enforcement…. Just think of all countries …. Shoot … if just the G8 prioritized exploration instead of military funding and waging endless wars …. what could “we” accomplish???? Gene Rodenberry’s dream ….
 

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
The foundation of science is built on “throwing stuff against the wall”.

and I would also say if “we” (the collective we) only considered things that were “possible”, we’d still be wearing animal skins and living in caves. (Think "need")

Don’t necessarily disagree with you on funding on law/drug enforcement…. Just think of all countries …. Shoot … if just the G8 prioritized exploration instead of military funding and waging endless wars …. what could “we” accomplish???? Gene Rodenberry’s dream …. (We could accomplish waste and death)
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
I'm not cynical. I know the history. The fact is we will never go to Mars.
How old are you? You really think we will NEVER get there? I am 47 and I think it will happen in my lifetime. I think it happens in the next 25 years which would be the expected lifespan for someone like me.


Just to name a few things that came from NASA looking to explore space.

Water purification systems
Corldess power tools
Memory foam
CMOS image sensors (digital photography, motion sensors)

The list could go on for quite a while. All of these items make human lives more comfortable. Seems like a worthy cause to me.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
The foundation of science is built on “throwing stuff against the wall”.

and I would also say if “we” (the collective we) only considered things that were “possible”, we’d still be wearing animal skins and living in caves.

Don’t necessarily disagree with you on funding on law/drug enforcement…. Just think of all countries …. Shoot … if just the G8 prioritized exploration instead of military funding and waging endless wars …. what could “we” accomplish???? Gene Rodenberry’s dream ….
Correct.

Step one of the scientific method "Formulate a hypothesis" .... aka throwing **** against a wall :)
 

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
How old are you? You really think we will NEVER get there? I am 47 and I think it will happen in my lifetime. I think it happens in the next 25 years which would be the expected lifespan for someone like me.


Just to name a few things that came from NASA looking to explore space.

Water purification systems
Corldess power tools
Memory foam
CMOS image sensors (digital photography, motion sensors)

The list could go on for quite a while. All of these items make human lives more comfortable. Seems like a worthy cause to me.
I'm 69. You were not even born when Apollo 17 landed on the moon in 1972.

Explain to us all why none of the things you mentioned would not have been invented anyway. ???
 

WapPride

All-American
Mar 17, 2021
3,977
6,344
0
The foundation of science is built on “throwing stuff against the wall”.

and I would also say if “we” (the collective we) only considered things that were “possible”, we’d still be wearing animal skins and living in caves.

Don’t necessarily disagree with you on funding on law/drug enforcement…. Just think of all countries …. Shoot … if just the G8 prioritized exploration instead of military funding and waging endless wars …. what could “we” accomplish???? Gene Rodenberry’s dream ….
Reminds me of Carl Sagan talking about Reagan’s Star Wars initiative wrt infant mortality in the US.

Incredibly depressing when you think about it, though. (Assuming you don’t have to worry about bad actors), imagine flipping the defense budget and NASAs budget and all the amazing things we could probably accomplish wrt interstellar travel and planetary colonization
 

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
Reminds me of Carl Sagan talking about Reagan’s Star Wars initiative wrt infant mortality in the US.

Incredibly depressing when you think about it, though. (Assuming you don’t have to worry about bad actors), imagine flipping the defense budget and NASAs budget and all the amazing things we could probably accomplish wrt interstellar travel and planetary colonization
We would never send humans no matter if we spent the yearly U.S. budget. The truth is the opposite of depressing.
 

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
Because the space programs were government run and not privately run? No because space is an inherently dangerous place. And Mars is 7 months away each way. And because there is no value in space.

Seen what SpaceX is doing lately? Blue origin making a stab at it too. Leave SpaceX for transporting satillites etc.
 

fatpiggy

Heisman
Aug 18, 2002
28,022
27,023
113
There is no value in space?

SpaceX is the largest private company in the world. Seems like a lot of people disagree with you.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: DW4_2016

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
There is no value in space?

SpaceX is the largest private company in the world. Seems like a lot of people disagree with you.
No because we need a lot of earth orbit satellites for commerce, defense, etc. No one will ever make money from Mars. Few will try.
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,362
28,922
103
Reminds me of Carl Sagan talking about Reagan’s Star Wars initiative wrt infant mortality in the US.

Incredibly depressing when you think about it, though. (Assuming you don’t have to worry about bad actors), imagine flipping the defense budget and NASAs budget and all the amazing things we could probably accomplish wrt interstellar travel and planetary colonization
On this we agree 100%.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WapPride

catch54

Senior
Feb 5, 2003
30,345
664
113
WE are long past where "impactful scientific/medical discoveries" are coming from NASA. It was handed over to the private sector and the results have been spectacular.

Regarding humans, I am sure we only have about 100 years. By which time oil and many other minerals will be exhausted. I am at peace recognizing the truth. We will not have enough oil to even wage war. Fusion will not work either to save us on the energy front. The physics (and history) say it won't work.
TigerGrowls needs to explain why he is laughing. ??
 

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,776
22,027
113
Terraforming Mars, sending people to mars, is pretty cool. But is a complete waste of time if we cannot live together on this planet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dadar

Dadar

All-Conference
Dec 21, 2003
5,201
3,976
113
Terraforming Mars, sending people to mars, is pretty cool. But is a complete waste of time if we cannot live together on this planet.

Agree, if we don't soon work together for the planet we are living on Mars may be a respite from an uninhabitable planet
 

LafayetteBear

Heisman
Nov 30, 2009
35,393
10,823
113
I just love this thread. Some tigers never change their spots, and Catch is one of them.

For Clemson alums who have posted here for sometime (and therefore did not know), Catch is one of many people who used to post on Penn State's politics Board. I did not realize he had come over here to post after the Penn State politics board went away, but it is hardly surprising that he commenced this thread.

Catch is, as his posts in this thread indicate, adamantly opposed to space exploration and considers it a ginormous waste of time, effort and money. He is firmly dedicated to that view, and posted regularly on the subject when we were over on the Penn State politics board. Trying to change his view on that subject is a waste of time.
 

firegiver

Heisman
Sep 10, 2007
74,776
22,027
113
Everything I read recently is that spacex has **** the bed in regards to going to the moon. We ain't going to mars anytime soon
 
Sep 1, 2022
272
252
63
Musks mission in life it to go to Mars.

Space Xs commercial LEO ventures will fund it. I think we go but doubt colonization happens in our lifetime. Biblically speaking its not in prophecy and we crap the bed here until Christ returns to reign for 1000 years and then the judgment. So I lean against colonization happening. But we should try.

As for value? Well there is a ton of 3He up there on the moon that can be used for Fusion reactors here on earth. One shuttles worth could power the planet for years. Fusion would lead to the creation of cheaply powered hydrogen fueled vehicles. Regular nukes could be doing that now if we get over the phobia of nuke power.

Using conventional fission reactors the cost in a gallon of gas equivalent for hydrogen ranges wildly from $1 to $3.83. This based on the efficient of the reactor and its type. Fusion could make it pennies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatpiggy

tigres88

All-American
Aug 7, 2022
3,684
9,349
113
Biblically speaking its not in prophecy and we crap the bed here until Christ returns to reign for 1000 years and then the judgment. So I lean against colonization happening. But we should try.
I can't believe you actually posted this seriously. Wow
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Dabo Swinney and the scrutiny from within
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football The day after for Clemson Football
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Football Pearman, Denson lead Clemson past Duke in upset win
  4. 04 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson upends double-digit favorite Duke 20-10
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Clemson - Duke Postgame Notes