The bold part is only part of it. My broader point is the elimination of a lifetime of medical costs for the deported individual. So we pay for preventative care and avoid an ER visit - super. But then we're paying for that person's healthcare for decades longer, including as they age and incur more expensive costs. And we're doing it for ALL illegals, not just the small % that require a preventable ER visit.
And our friends at ChatGPT suggest a moderate taxpayer cost (Medicaid reimbursement) for a moderate severity infection ER visit:
Putting it all together, for a typical treat-and-release ER visit for an infection (moderate severity):
- Total cost (hospital’s billed or “allowed” amount) might be in the neighborhood of $1,500-$3,000 (higher if many diagnostics or complexity).
- What Medicaid might reimburse might end up closer to $400-$800 (or even less), depending on state, whether it's under managed care or FFS, and what services are included.
And just lol at your first point. What other country do you suggest a Mexican or Venuzuelan or whatever would go to for free healthcare? Are they boarding a flight to Europe instead of walking across the border?Of course healthcare in the US is an incentive to come here.
You can lol at my first point but you are going to make yourself look foolish. Mexico has free healthcare and everyone has access. It also globally ranks near or better than the US. So thinking Mexicans will come here because “hey, I can finally get that physical therapy appointment”, instead of earning significantly more money (minimum wage is below $2/hr) is just nonsensical. It makes me wonder if you have any concept of what life is like in other countries. Costa Rica has excellent health care btw., and they aren’t going there.
To address the top part of your response, let’s look at this from the standpoint of an illegal immigrant. They are almost exclusively working hourly minimum wage jobs. If they don’t work, they don’t get paid. Do you think they will go to the doctor for a common cold - hell no. They won’t go for the flu, and instead will show up and work because that is why they traveled hundreds of miles through some pretty awful conditions. They will utilize our health care at a much lower rate (and data shows that it’s well under half of what Americans use).
The final point in your flawed argument that I’ll address is that you make the argument as if a hospital or doctors office is the only place where illegal immigrants can be detained. We have a massive budget for ICE and won’t have millions of illegal immigrants going to routine doctors visits. They can find them at many other places. They won’t be here for a lifetime to rack up those bills.
I am open minded and will happily reconsider my stance, but you have to provide something factual and relevant to this debate.
Last edited: