HCMR vs HCMR

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,549
4,811
113
Ferentz has 8 double digit seasons.

Iowa has 11 total.

Ferentz Is both somehow Their best coach ever, and yet Very Bo Pelini like minus the yelling. I'd say Iowa has settled, but no, that is their ceiling I imagine without a Curt Cignetti type hire, which I don't see happening.

And they still have had our number....
Ferentz is the winningest coach in B1G history

A good nugget for all the B1G fans who proudly root for this league around the clock
 

Jonesy5960

Heisman
Feb 1, 2023
5,656
11,536
113
Ferentz has 8 double digit seasons.

Iowa has 11 total.

Ferentz Is both somehow Their best coach ever, and yet Very Bo Pelini like minus the yelling. I'd say Iowa has settled, but no, that is their ceiling I imagine without a Curt Cignetti type hire, which I don't see happening.

And they still have had our number....
Ferentz has had a great run at Iowa and they've averaged over 9 wins per year over the past 10 years if you exclude the shortened covid season. They're not competing for championships, but the program is a model of consistency. As you said, that is the ceiling as it would be for 95% of the programs out there and only a small handful of programs have a better record over that timeframe, but it's also a high floor with only 2 losing seasons in 20 years. Still, there are a lot of Iowa fans who want more, because every fan wants more. They have only had Nebraska's number because they've been a much better program overall. They're 9-1 vs both Nebraska and Minnesota over that timeframe and Nebraska has only had 2 winning seasons over the last 10 years. A lot of teams have had their number.
 

singlet

Heisman
Dec 2, 2004
50,471
23,036
93
I don't get the genius angle on this post OP. The fact is Rhule drastically improved Temple and Baylor during those short stays and didn't stay to reap the benefit of improving his winning % over multiple seasons. Do you think his % would be higher if he'd stayed at Baylor for 10 years? I do. Will he improve Nebraska similarly? I don't know, but I know he's better than Mike Riley.
The mistake was anyone believing that he could do the same at Nebraska. This is Nebraska - the place where mediocre coaches come to die.
 

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,499
4,091
113
Ferentz is the winningest coach in B1G history

A good nugget for all the B1G fans who proudly root for this league around the clock
Ha! So sad!

Does he also have the most Big Ten losses?

He literally made that iowa head coaching gig a middle management job at Union Pacific. Just show up on time, don't miss work, always make sure to sing happy birthday when on of the "team" members gets a year older...basically just waiting for that magical day of retirement.

Then about 2 years after retirement, no one at Union Pacific even remembers that he worked there.
 

Wasker73

Senior
Sep 2, 2025
477
474
63
I don't get the genius angle on this post OP. The fact is Rhule drastically improved Temple and Baylor during those short stays and didn't stay to reap the benefit of improving his winning % over multiple seasons. Do you think his % would be higher if he'd stayed at Baylor for 10 years? I do. Will he improve Nebraska similarly? I don't know, but I know he's better than Mike Riley.
You are just guessing when it comes to thinking Rhule would have more wins under his belt if he would have stayed longer at Baylor. There is no way of proving it because he left. I think he is what his record shows he is. Hasn't disproved in Lincoln so far.

Let's get to the three seasons Matt Rhule hangs his hat on.

2015 Temple (his breakout year) 10-4 Lost to #9 Notre Dame, South Florida, #19 Houston (Conference Champ.) and Matt Campbell's Toledo (Bowl) Beat an unranked Penn State and #21 Memphis (all ranked opponents are listed)

2016 Temple 10-4 Lost to Army, Penn State and Memphis (all unranked) and the team lost to Wake Forest in a Bowl with Ed Foley coaching. Beat the only ranked team they played that year #19 Navy (conf. champ.)

2019 Baylor 11-3 Lost to the only ranked teams they played that year #10 OU in Waco, #6 OU, in OT (conf. champ.) and #5 Georgia (Bowl) Was the Big 12 down that year? I can't remember, but Texas and K State were both unranked when Baylor played them. Won two OT games in the regular season Texas Tech and TCU (I think this was a pretty good season and would be ecstatic with the same results. with the Huskers. Just wish I knew how good the Big12 was that year)

I think his record shows he has trouble beating ranking teams and he has done nothing to disprove this during his time with the Huskers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dylman
Aug 28, 2025
357
395
63
You are just guessing when it comes to thinking Rhule would have more wins under his belt if he would have stayed longer at Baylor. There is no way of proving it because he left. I think he is what his record shows he is. Hasn't disproved in Lincoln so far.

Let's get to the three seasons Matt Rhule hangs his hat on.

2015 Temple (his breakout year) 10-4 Lost to #9 Notre Dame, South Florida, #19 Houston (Conference Champ.) and Matt Campbell's Toledo (Bowl) Beat an unranked Penn State and #21 Memphis (all ranked opponents are listed)

2016 Temple 10-4 Lost to Army, Penn State and Memphis (all unranked) and the team lost to Wake Forest in a Bowl with Ed Foley coaching. Beat the only ranked team they played that year #19 Navy (conf. champ.)

2019 Baylor 11-3 Lost to the only ranked teams they played that year #10 OU in Waco, #6 OU, in OT (conf. champ.) and #5 Georgia (Bowl) Was the Big 12 down that year? I can't remember, but Texas and K State were both unranked when Baylor played them. Won two OT games in the regular season Texas Tech and TCU (I think this was a pretty good season and would be ecstatic with the same results. with the Huskers. Just wish I knew how good the Big12 was that year)

I think his record shows he has trouble beating ranking teams and he has done nothing to disprove this during his time with the Huskers.
When we hired Rhule, I dug into his 2019 season heavily and there were a ton of warning signs. My thread on the original rivals forum was not received well by the koolaid club, but it has been 100% true.

For one, the combined record of his opponents was sub .500, and he had multiple squeaker games against teams with losing records (triple OT against 7 loss TCU and 1 score wins against 9 loss Rice, 7 loss West Virginia)

That was an incredibly weak year for the Big 12, and is a total outlier on his resume.
 

God_zilla

Sophomore
Oct 19, 2025
110
115
43
When we hired Rhule, I dug into his 2019 season heavily and there were a ton of warning signs. My thread on the original rivals forum was not received well by the koolaid club, but it has been 100% true.

For one, the combined record of his opponents was sub .500, and he had multiple squeaker games against teams with losing records (triple OT against 7 loss TCU and 1 score wins against 9 loss Rice, 7 loss West Virginia)

That was an incredibly weak year for the Big 12, and is a total outlier on his resume.
Repost it now
 

JDD1959

Sophomore
Nov 28, 2016
255
140
43
Something we can agree on. The expectations for Matt aren’t as high as Dana
Agree. Dana seems to approach this job like a sugar addict who's been given the keys to the candy store or as a good friend said to me it's like he's playing with house money, have a little fun/see what happens, get paid, wash/rinse/repeat.
 

Walleye 1

All-Conference
Mar 7, 2021
4,964
1,798
113
Reefbreak GIF by ABC Network
 

orclover11

Senior
Dec 1, 2014
1,152
820
113
Rhule took over Frost's mess, Riley took over for teams that were winning 9 games a year.
I would get very happy if we could just return to the 9 wins seasons.
How many blowouts would Bo's teams had had in 2021? Frost's teams competed well with some very good teams. I appreciate Bo's ability to beat bad teams, and he did it well, but was equally horrible in games that mattered, if not worse than Frost, at least from an optics standpoint.
 

God_zilla

Sophomore
Oct 19, 2025
110
115
43
How many blowouts would Bo's teams had had in 2021? Frost's teams competed well with some very good teams. I appreciate Bo's ability to beat bad teams, and he did it well, but was equally horrible in games that mattered, if not worse than Frost, at least from an optics standpoint.
Bo never opted out of bowl games
 

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,499
4,091
113
"Games that mattered"
SOOOOO stupid.

You know why Bo had so many "games that mattered"
BECAUSE HE WON A LOT OF GAMES

I love that he beat back to back ranked Okie State and Mizzo but for some reason, those games don't matter.

Look how pissed so many NU fans are this week after losing to Minny...was that a "game that mattered"???
 

Zeke Husker

All-Conference
Aug 23, 2025
1,350
1,378
113
Revisionist history. Every knuckle dragging cleti member wanted Banker gone. The problem was the corresponding hire was worse. Just like when TO had drunken Moos hire Frost. Worst coach in program history
I’ll get scorched by some for saying this but TOs involvement with the program post 2010ish hasn’t been for the good. Hiring Bo was the last good move he made.
 
Aug 28, 2025
357
395
63
I’ll get scorched by some for saying this but TOs involvement with the program post 2010ish hasn’t been for the good. Hiring Bo was the last good move he made.
Couldn’t agree more.

Then his “well he was just unlucky” comments after Scott Frost flamed out were borderline retarded.

We’re seeing the same thing with Bob Stoops at OU
 

God_zilla

Sophomore
Oct 19, 2025
110
115
43
Couldn’t agree more.

Then his “well he was just unlucky” comments after Scott Frost flamed out were borderline retarded.

We’re seeing the same thing with Bob Stoops at OU
What should TO be doing? He tried to tell Rhule to run the ball but Matt won’t listen
 
  • Haha
Reactions: 4.6.3

4.6.3

Senior
Jun 4, 2022
917
997
93
Not the first or the last time he told people in North stadium he would do it. He’s not a saint, no matter what people want to make excuses for. Legendary coach, horrid administrator. It doesn’t take many actual AD contacts (when you work with them) to talk about these things…. But believe what you want. I loved his comments at the time, he did it because he didn’t like not having a say. He’s human. Most of us would also be pissed. It’s really not that big of a stretch to believe, but you do you
 

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,387
12,801
78
Sometimes, with legends, it is best to keep them around and pretend to listen to them...
And Tom admitted several times after Bo was fired that hiring Bo was a mistake. Bo didn’t have the mental make up to be the head coach at a major P4 program with all the BS that goes with it. He failed a Youngstown as well IMO largely because of his disdain for recruiting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Man Woman & Child

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,499
4,091
113
And Tom admitted several times after Bo was fired that hiring Bo was a mistake. Bo didn’t have the mental make up to be the head coach at a major P4 program with all the BS that goes with it. He failed a Youngstown as well IMO largely because of his disdain for recruiting.
But he was a HC at a major P4 program for a long time and had a very good record. So it appears Tom was wrong.
 

God_zilla

Sophomore
Oct 19, 2025
110
115
43
Not the first or the last time he told people in North stadium he would do it. He’s not a saint, no matter what people want to make excuses for. Legendary coach, horrid administrator. It doesn’t take many actual AD contacts (when you work with them) to talk about these things…. But believe what you want. I loved his comments at the time, he did it because he didn’t like not having a say. He’s human. Most of us would also be pissed. It’s really not that big of a stretch to believe, but you do you
He was doing it to raise money
 

dinglefritz

Heisman
Jan 14, 2011
51,387
12,801
78
But he was a HC at a major P4 program for a long time and had a very good record. So it appears Tom was wrong.
Just saw the replay of the Hail Mary game against Northwestern. He had Abdullah, Westercamp, Armstrong etc. It took a Hail Mary to beat a crappy Northwestern team in our house…. Ameer was a beast in that game. Avery Moss had an interception for a TD in that game. We had just lost to Minnesota. Wisconsin just scored again on a jet sweep.

Tom made that comment IMO based on things other than Bo’s overall record. I supported Bo for a long time. Frankly I think they could have promoted Beck and had similar results at that point in time.
 

SuperBigFan69

All-Conference
Apr 17, 2021
4,499
4,091
113
Just saw the replay of the Hail Mary game against Northwestern. He had Abdullah, Westercamp, Armstrong etc. It took a Hail Mary to beat a crappy Northwestern team in our house…. Ameer was a beast in that game. Avery Moss had an interception for a TD in that game. We had just lost to Minnesota. Wisconsin just scored again on a jet sweep.

Tom made that comment IMO based on things other than Bo’s overall record. I supported Bo for a long time. Frankly I think they could have promoted Beck and had similar results at that point in time.
So now, if I understand this correctly.

We are now discussing the very good players that Bo had (and recruited) and how he won a lot of games...

But TO is still saying that Bo should not have been a P4 coach? Good lord.
 

orclover11

Senior
Dec 1, 2014
1,152
820
113
Bo never opted out of bowl games
Bo > Frost but I don't like the narrative that Rhule has had it so much harder than any other coach. If he doesn't hire Satt and Foley he could have had a 10-11 win team last year. He was basically handed the best recruit in Nebraska history out of luck and nepotism and to his credit, Tony was a great hire, who had some good dlineman who they inherited from Frost. Rhule had a chance at Nebraska for a few moments, up until he hired Satterfield. From that moment on, it was just a slow bleed for the fan base until Rhule is eventually fired.
 

Huskers+123

Sophomore
Dec 6, 2024
164
179
43
Bo > Frost but I don't like the narrative that Rhule has had it so much harder than any other coach. If he doesn't hire Satt and Foley he could have had a 10-11 win team last year. He was basically handed the best recruit in Nebraska history out of luck and nepotism and to his credit, Tony was a great hire, who had some good dlineman who they inherited from Frost. Rhule had a chance at Nebraska for a few moments, up until he hired Satterfield. From that moment on, it was just a slow bleed for the fan base until Rhule is eventually fired.
Who is saying Rhule had it harder than any other coaches?