Nebraska in contact with transfer

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
Language is foggy on that since they come from a program that fired a coach. I don’t think anyone that even showed up for a Fall practice with one school, should be able to play for a different team until the next season
why not?
 
  • Like
Reactions: WHCSC

Huskers+123

Sophomore
Dec 6, 2024
164
179
43
They cannot be immediately eligible. Once the season starts, you can not be on 2 rosters during the same season. Or else we could have played Williams Nwaneri in the bowl game.
NCAA rules usually require players to wait until the next season to compete unless they:
  • Are graduate transfers (with remaining eligibility).
  • Get a waiver (which is rare and requires extenuating circumstances).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4.6.3

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
Because I don’t think you should be able to practice with a team, get their playbook, calls, etc…. Then quit and go somewhere else that might pay them more just to have that information. It’s already changed enough, very quickly. Just my opinion.
happens exactly like this in every professional sport, which college football undeniably is
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuskerInCarolina

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
I figured this would be the retort, which I totally understand. Just don’t care for the idea in college…. At all. If they allow this, there should be a “trade deadline” before teams play a conference game.
this is already within a unique provision (coach fired portal window)

cc: @Huskers+123
 

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113
happens exactly like this in every professional sport, which college football undeniably is
It’s completey different .when a nfl or an nba coach gets fired a player cannot say I quit and go wherever he wants. All pro athletes have contracts and about the only time they change teams is a trade.once in a while a Baseball player is given his outright release and his is not in high demand because usually your career is done in most cases.
 

HuskerInCarolina

All-American
Dec 2, 2024
3,630
5,280
112
happens exactly like this in every professional sport, which college football undeniably is
It does. BUT it only happens when the player gets cut. If the Bengals fire Zac Taylor tomorrow, Joe Burrow can’t go sign with the Raiders on Monday.

i do agree though, if a player is in the portal they should be able to immediately play for the team they go to. AKA if a player is a free agent, they should be able to immediately play for the team they sign with.

With that, I don’t think players should be allowed to enter the portal because a coach was fired. They can enter after the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuskerO58

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113
It does. BUT it only happens when the player gets cut. If the Bengals fire Zac Taylor tomorrow, Joe Burrow can’t go sign with the Raiders on Monday.

i do agree though, if a player is in the portal they should be able to immediately play for the team they go to. AKA if a player is a free agent, they should be able to immediately play for the team they sign with.

With that, I don’t think players should be allowed to enter the portal because a coach was fired. They can enter after the season.
Ya it’s just different times. Coaches get fired every year and have been for years but in college until recently a coach ( Frost) always made it through the year Even if everyone knew they were getting axed ( Callahan and Riley) as Nebraska example.
 

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113
It does. BUT it only happens when the player gets cut. If the Bengals fire Zac Taylor tomorrow, Joe Burrow can’t go sign with the Raiders on Monday.

i do agree though, if a player is in the portal they should be able to immediately play for the team they go to. AKA if a player is a free agent, they should be able to immediately play for the team they sign with.

With that, I don’t think players should be allowed to enter the portal because a coach was fired. They can enter after the season.
I agree nobody should be able to enter the portal and jump in season. Now if and when the roster limits are set in stone that will end this possibility from happening.
 

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
It’s completey different .when a nfl or an nba coach gets fired a player cannot say I quit and go wherever he wants. All pro athletes have contracts and about the only time they change teams is a trade.once in a while a Baseball player is given his outright release and his is not in high demand because usually your career is done in most cases.
this is irrelevant because NFL or NBA players aren't limited to x years of eligibility like collegiate athletes are. thus, there should be much more urgency in college.

a player being within his rights to enter the portal when his coach is fired shouldn't then be penalized/forced to forfeit 20% of their eligibility for no good reason
 
Jul 10, 2008
3,728
720
112
this is irrelevant because NFL or NBA players aren't limited to x years of eligibility like collegiate athletes are. thus, there should be much more urgency in college.

a player being within his rights to enter the portal when his coach is fired shouldn't then be penalized/forced to forfeit 20% of their eligibility for no good reason
Can they not still play the remainder of the season at their current school?
 

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113

this is irrelevant because NFL or NBA players aren't limited to x years of eligibility like collegiate athletes are. thus, there should be much more urgency in college.

a player being within his rights to enter the portal when his coach is fired shouldn't then be penalized/forced to forfeit 20% of their eligibility for no good reason

this is irrelevant because NFL or NBA players aren't limited to x years of eligibility like collegiate athletes are. thus, there should be much more urgency in college.

a player being within his rights to enter the portal when his coach is fired shouldn't then be penalized/forced to forfeit 20% of their eligibility for no good reason
They have only played 3 games everyone who wants to transfer can opt out and take a redshirt year. Won’t lose any eligibility. And for those who already redshirted they can get a waiver they hand them out like candy.
 

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
They have only played 3 games everyone who wants to transfer can opt out and take a redshirt year. Won’t lose any eligibility. And for those who already redshirted they can get a waiver they hand them out like candy.
losing a redshirt year is losing a year

a materially punitive punishment for no good reason
 

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
They don’t lose eligibility which was your argument.
yes, they do.

losing a redshirt year is effectively losing a year a player can play college football due to circumstances completely out of their control that the NCAA have already deemed impactful enough to open up a brand new transfer exception.

makes no sense. players who transfer after their coach is fired should be immediately eligible to play at their next school.

I am very open to hearing coherent arguments to the contrary.
 

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113
yes, they do.

losing a redshirt year is effectively losing a year a player can play college football due to circumstances completely out of their control that the NCAA have already deemed impactful enough to open up a brand new transfer exception.

makes no sense. players who transfer after their coach is fired should be immediately eligible to play at their next school.

I am very open to hearing coherent arguments to the contrary.
You have players in their 6 th year all over the place because of the new “rules “ in place. Players have no issues on eligibility anymore. If you are a stud and going to the nfl it won’t matter you are not in College for the duration anyway. That being said if the rules allow it go for it . I just don’t think we need college kids changing teams in season and have my solutions on why they wouldn’t have to .
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4.6.3

broken record

Senior
Jul 9, 2025
284
456
63
NCAA rules usually require players to wait until the next season to compete unless they:
  • Are graduate transfers (with remaining eligibility).
  • Get a waiver (which is rare and requires extenuating circumstances).

It does. BUT it only happens when the player gets cut. If the Bengals fire Zac Taylor tomorrow, Joe Burrow can’t go sign with the Raiders on Monday.

i do agree though, if a player is in the portal they should be able to immediately play for the team they go to. AKA if a player is a free agent, they should be able to immediately play for the team they sign with.

With that, I don’t think players should be allowed to enter the portal because a coach was fired. They can enter after the season.
Nico I will enter the portal unless he's an idiot. It would be insane if he could play this year on another squad and not sit out. By the time we play UCLA they will be a hollowed out shell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HuskerInCarolina
Aug 18, 2016
16,628
10,904
113
yes, they do.

losing a redshirt year is effectively losing a year a player can play college football due to circumstances completely out of their control that the NCAA have already deemed impactful enough to open up a brand new transfer exception.

makes no sense. players who transfer after their coach is fired should be immediately eligible to play at their next school.

I am very open to hearing coherent arguments to the contrary.
They chose to go to Virginia Tech or UCLA where they were having not so great seasons and for coaches that had little or no head coaching experience. Going to that school was completely within their control, they could have left before the season, again within their control.
 
Aug 18, 2016
16,628
10,904
113
Nico I will enter the portal unless he's an idiot. It would be insane if he could play this year on another squad and not sit out. By the time we play UCLA they will be a hollowed out shell.
Nico already used his redshirt season, his first at Tennessee. Regardless as to when he leaves, now or in January, this season will be one of his 4 seasons of eligibility.
 

Arf_man

Junior
May 30, 2022
147
213
43
losing a redshirt year is losing a year

a materially punitive punishment for no good reason
I think playing so poorly is a reflection of the players as well as the coaches. To be that bad at U.C.L.A the players have to take some responsibility. Finish the year out at your current school and be better. Maybe try harder and don't get your coach fired three games into the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dylman and Laner2

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113
They'd have to redshirt at current school i believe. Might be wrong
Ya who knows with the NCAA losing all control. But I would believe it would be not right for a player to leave UCLA ( enter portal fired coach) and play for a different college in the same season.
 

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
Ya who knows with the NCAA losing all control. But I would believe it would be not right for a player to leave UCLA ( enter portal fired coach) and play for a different college in the same season.
Makes no sense

have yet to hear a good reason as to why a player can’t be immediately eligible when transferring after their coach is fired
 
  • Like
Reactions: Husker06

Big bo fan

All-American
Jan 8, 2019
19,119
6,388
113
Makes no sense

have yet to hear a good reason as to why a player can’t be immediately eligible when transferring after their coach is fired
This kids are still college students.you can’t just enroll mid semester at the University because you want to start your education because it’s a good time. You have to wait for semester. Why should an athlete be able to do it ?
 

king_kong__

All-Conference
Nov 3, 2021
3,538
4,792
113
This kids are still college students.you can’t just enroll mid semester at the University because you want to start your education because it’s a good time. You have to wait for semester. Why should an athlete be able to do it ?

Because it's too late to register for classes at the school they would be transferring to.
School?

Adorable
 
Aug 18, 2016
16,628
10,904
113
I am not sure he has done enough to get a combine invite. They have only invited around 15 the last couple of years. Sitting on your *** while others are improving their stock, doesn't seem like the best of moves to me. Especially after making a bonehead move in the off season.
He could just bow out now and get ready for the combine and draft.