Ice Cream : your favorite

cr333

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
765
1,047
92
My favorite flavor is a really creamy dark chocolate. Although there are many ice cream shops and dairies, my favorite place to get a couple good scoops is at Kilwins. (For those not aware, Kilwins is a chain)
 

Aguia Vitoria

Sophomore
Jul 31, 2025
109
181
43
Häagen-Dazs Double Belgian Chocolate Chip, preferably in a waffle cone. Inject that stuff right into my veins.
 

ronjon

Senior
Aug 1, 2025
329
611
93
I rarely eat ice cream, generally prefer local dairy ice creams with whatever seasonal fruit is happening. If I go to the store, it must be Butter Pecan. I never go to buy it, but I always wind up leaving with it.
 

SmokePantsIC

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2025
418
1,428
93
I'm the type that's never had bad ice cream. I love everything from the high end nitrogen stuff to those little ice cream plastic cups with the cardboard top and wooden spoon.

With that said, Publix has some great seasonal flavors.

I ate a simple vanilla ice cream at a high end restaurant in Hawaii that may have been the best single scoop of ice cream I've ever had.

I love Kilwin's fudge, but I need to try their ice cream.

Ben and Jerry's on Franklin street got my business frequently during summer school. Mint Chocolate Cookie, Stores, and Cherry Garcia were go to's.

I've never had Haagen Dazs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PINEHEEL

UNCatTech

Redshirt
Aug 1, 2025
46
24
8
It's much easier for me to say what I don't like.

Ok, I'm done.

Though Strawberry is at the bottom of the list, unless maybe there's coconut and/or mayo flavors, they might be the only ice cream that I would not eat.
 

PINEHEEL

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2025
1,484
3,817
113
I also like pretty much every ice cream, but cookie dough is my favorite.

Blue Bell is the best commercially available brand of all flavors and there is no close second.
 

Chamtrain

All-Conference
Jan 9, 2011
1,040
2,920
113
For those of you who have never had it, Handels ice cream in Morrisville is the best ice cream shop I've ever been too. They have 10 + flavors that I'd rank above the best thing I'd get from Cold stone/Freddy's. Key Lime Pie, Monkey Business, Graham Central station, Pineapple upside down cake, any of their cheesecake varieties. If you are anywhere near RTP it's worth the trip.

My guilty pleasure is bubble gum ice cream from Yarboroughs in Sanford, hard to beat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SmokePantsIC

cr333

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
765
1,047
92
My wife was sold on Blue Bunny Peanut Butter Party. They stopped making it during the pandemic and I can't seem to find it in the stores since. Their website says they still make it.
 

Tar Heel

Sophomore
Jul 23, 2025
62
180
33
Some of the best ice cream I've had was a "Salted Sweet Corn" from a local place. Made with fresh, local sweet corn, It was fantastic the first year and just ok the next year likely based on the corn that season.

Also love a well done coffee ice cream, coffee and cream were made for each other.
 

PINEHEEL

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2025
1,484
3,817
113
For those of you who have never had it, Handels ice cream in Morrisville is the best ice cream shop I've ever been too. They have 10 + flavors that I'd rank above the best thing I'd get from Cold stone/Freddy's. Key Lime Pie, Monkey Business, Graham Central station, Pineapple upside down cake, any of their cheesecake varieties. If you are anywhere near RTP it's worth the trip.

My guilty pleasure is bubble gum ice cream from Yarboroughs in Sanford, hard to beat.

Handel's also has a spot in Southern Pines now.
 

2forheels

Junior
Aug 2, 2025
538
354
63
I'm all vanilla. lol You can add anything you want to vanilla to make it something else. I like plain vanilla at times, but love making various dishes at home using vanilla as the base. If I'm at an ice cream shop I generally try weird ice creams I've never had before.
 

2forheels

Junior
Aug 2, 2025
538
354
63
bryers vanilla

homemade blueberry
homemade peach

eta: Blue Bunny Peppermint
I used to love Bryer's vanilla but they have changed something in it. It's terrible to me now. I love any flavor of Turkey Hill. Very creamy and tasty, especially as it melts.
 

Heels68

Redshirt
Aug 1, 2025
39
22
8
The best vanilla ice cream is Haagen Dazs. Several steps above any other brand.

Same goes for Haagen Dazs strawberry. Their chocolate is good, but I think some others have a better chocolate.

d
 

Chamtrain

All-Conference
Jan 9, 2011
1,040
2,920
113
The best vanilla ice cream is Haagen Dazs. Several steps above any other brand.

Same goes for Haagen Dazs strawberry. Their chocolate is good, but I think some others have a better chocolate.

d

Turkey Hill French vanilla is really really good, will have to try Haagen Dazs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Heels68

MichelleHillison

All-American
Staff member
Jun 29, 2025
1,332
5,362
113
So making ice cream is one of my hobbies! I’m the dork with her own little labels even - I call them Michelle is Freezing, which is a family joke because I’m always hot.

I make a mean overloaded Andes peppermint candy Oreo with a mint base. around the holidays - think of that holiday shake at CFA but moar.

Another good one I male is biscoff crumbled cookies in a coffee ice cream - I do a coffee with dark chocolate chunks too that’s pretty good.

But my personal commercial favorites is Jeni’s Birthday cake and Jeni’s brown butter almond. And store gavorite - old school baskin robins chocolate chip.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3987.jpeg
    IMG_3987.jpeg
    569.3 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:

cr333

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
765
1,047
92
Michelle, you should never post something like that without an invitation to share in your hard work. Also, what type of ice cream maker do you use?
 
  • Love
Reactions: MichelleHillison

cr333

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
765
1,047
92
Some of the best ice cream I've had was a "Salted Sweet Corn" from a local place. Made with fresh, local sweet corn, It was fantastic the first year and just ok the next year likely based on the corn that season.

Also love a well done coffee ice cream, coffee and cream were made for each other.
A creamy coffee ice cream with hot fudge is pretty good too.
 
  • Love
Reactions: MichelleHillison

MichelleHillison

All-American
Staff member
Jun 29, 2025
1,332
5,362
113
Michelle, you should never post something like that without an invitation to share in your hard work. Also, what type of ice cream maker do you use?
Oh I'm always happy to share... sometimes I get neighborhood teenage boys asking for ice cream from my outside freezer, lol.

Honestly I just use the freezer bowl attachment to my Kitchen Aid mixer! I have two of the bowls that I keep out in my deep freeze in the garage. I have been considering a dedicated machine but I'm one of those people who loves tinkering with food but I have ADD so I'm always moving to the next thing before circling back. I've got a pizza oven for outside and it's still in the box... I got it last year for my birthday, which is this month so for a full year it's sat there in the box!! Which is a bad sign because I just bought a bunch of hydroponic stuff this weekend for growing herbs to use in my extraction and infusion machine.

However, I do covet the Lello Musso.
 

cr333

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
765
1,047
92
Oh I'm always happy to share... sometimes I get neighborhood teenage boys asking for ice cream from my outside freezer, lol.

Honestly I just use the freezer bowl attachment to my Kitchen Aid mixer! I have two of the bowls that I keep out in my deep freeze in the garage. I have been considering a dedicated machine but I'm one of those people who loves tinkering with food but I have ADD so I'm always moving to the next thing before circling back. I've got a pizza oven for outside and it's still in the box... I got it last year for my birthday, which is this month so for a full year it's sat there in the box!! Which is a bad sign because I just bought a bunch of hydroponic stuff this weekend for growing herbs to use in my extraction and infusion machine.

However, I do covet the Lello Musso.
Thanks for sharing. I'd love a lello musso as well but I use one so infrequently that it doesn't financially make sense for me. For you, it'd make a fine birthday gift!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MichelleHillison

PINEHEEL

All-Conference
Aug 1, 2025
1,484
3,817
113
Oh I'm always happy to share... sometimes I get neighborhood teenage boys asking for ice cream from my outside freezer, lol.

Honestly I just use the freezer bowl attachment to my Kitchen Aid mixer! I have two of the bowls that I keep out in my deep freeze in the garage. I have been considering a dedicated machine but I'm one of those people who loves tinkering with food but I have ADD so I'm always moving to the next thing before circling back. I've got a pizza oven for outside and it's still in the box... I got it last year for my birthday, which is this month so for a full year it's sat there in the box!! Which is a bad sign because I just bought a bunch of hydroponic stuff this weekend for growing herbs to use in my extraction and infusion machine.

However, I do covet the Lello Musso.

I had a great time this summer breaking out our old ice cream maker out of the attic. I'm talking about the kind with the small motor that spins in the bucket and needs constant ice and rock salt. I've never been able to get the same texture out of a Cusinart or other modern options that I do out of the original bucket.

I usually keep it pretty basic and go with vanilla or coffee, but I need to start expanding my horizons more. Adding biscoff to the coffee sounds like a brilliant idea.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MichelleHillison

cabmac

Senior
Jul 31, 2025
189
647
93
This thread takes me back some 60 years when my family had one of these motorized ice cream makers that relied on constant ice and rock salt. The only recipe my parents knew was for banana ice cream, which was not my favorite. Almost always involved some sort of big family get-together for a fish fry or bbq chicken served on our big picnic table outdoors.
I’d practically kill for a bowl of that banana ice cream today…
 

cr333

All-Conference
Jul 22, 2025
765
1,047
92
This thread takes me back some 60 years when my family had one of these motorized ice cream makers that relied on constant ice and rock salt. The only recipe my parents knew was for banana ice cream, which was not my favorite. Almost always involved some sort of big family get-together for a fish fry or bbq chicken served on our big picnic table outdoors.
I’d practically kill for a bowl of that banana ice cream today…
Those family get together were so much fun. It's a shame not many do them anymore. Great memories.