I picked Wilmington in OT if QB1 played RB and I'll give you my reason why. I'm guessing QB1 was a senior which means he was the QB on last year's playoff team as well? In a game of this magnitude, when the chips are down, it makes a difference who the voice/leader in the huddle is. First and goal 3 separate times and came away with no points? That's a tough pill for Seneca to swallow and I'm not taking anything away from the Wilmington D. Everybody in the state knows Reents always has a great defense.
Let me ask you this. Did QB2 make any big plays passing that made you go, "oh, that's why he's the guy now?"
On the other hand, if QB1 was so banged up he was playing tight end or say defense only, I would totally get it. But he was playing running back and Seneca is a running team. I think not playing him at QB was a mistake.