Ah. I don't even remember Finley so that tells you how good he actually was. Cobi was one of those players Americans loved to watch early, maybe as much for his style as his ability. I enjoy listening to him as an analyst now. He even admits he might not have made the USMNT if he were coming up now as the quality of players and depth the US now has is 10x what it was back in the 90s.
Im surprised to hear that you don't even remember him, he started 3 of the 4 USA matches at the 2010 World Cup in South Africa up top opposite of Jozy. He replaced CD9 on the roster, who was ten times the player.
Finley played at Oregon State and was drafted by LA Galaxy to replace Cobi Jones. He was later sold to Real Salt Lake when LA made Mexican acquisitions.
Bradley scrambled for anyone with speed to replace Charlie so short to the roster cut off and Finley had all the performance metrics, but none of the skill. It didn't matter, he stretched Turkey and caused Australia and Slovenia fits. But he go no where near the goal. He was the equivalent of a WR who runs 30 streaks to clear out space for the slot to make catches and tire out the CBs.
Nottingham Forest, which was in the Championship at the time, signed him on a free transfer. He was quickly dealt to a League Two side where he was comically the fastest player on the field, but simply could not dribble with the ball under any pressure. After about 6 games in League Two, he was returned and NF cut him and he came home to MLS.
He is the Skeets Nehmiah of MLS.