So hard to peg a guy based on his HS videos. You can tell some thing, like throwing accuracy and overall athleticism, but other things just don't translate. For instance, I have no idea if the guys he was outmaneuvering or escaping simply weren't very athletic. I can't tell if the DBs he was passing over just lacked closing speed to pick off some of those passes. I can't tell if he always makes good decisions, or if a highlight reel doesn't include failures .
Not ragging on the Skipper, I've heard great things and like what I've seen. It's just hard to tell. I have to trust that the coaches have seen more than I (we) have. Then again, our fan base has been so spoiled the last 10 years that we have a large segment that whines about any QB even when they are breaking records and winning 10 games.
All that said, when a coach holds off on naming a starter, it seems to go against the upperclassmen more often than not.