Who's stats are these? (Part II)

[Mr. Cook]

QB II Years 1-7

Yds/Season: 3,235
TDs /Season - 22
INTs/Season - 16
Rating - ~78.0

And compare to the former "QB B"

Years 1 - 7 for QB B
yds/season - 3563
tds/season - 24
ints/sesaon - 9
rating - 97.57

The fact that I've eliminated playoffs is a significant clue

 

[Dawgg]

whose*

 

[Maroon Eagle]

 

[Perd Hapley]

QB II Years 1-7

Yds/Season: 3,235
TDs /Season - 22
INTs/Season - 16
Rating - ~78.0

And compare to the former "QB B"

Years 1 - 7 for QB B
yds/season - 3563
tds/season - 24
ints/sesaon - 9
rating - 97.57

The fact that I've eliminated playoffs is a significant clue

So Dak is way better than Eli, a potential HOF QB according to some (not me)? I would agree.

 

[Mr. Cook]

So Dak is way better than Eli, a potential HOF QB according to some (not me)? I would agree.

Just facts. Take away from it what you will.

 

[Perd Hapley]

Just facts. Take away from it what you will.

I think most anyone could take that away from the simple eye test and career stats, but this only further backs it up.

 

[Mr. Cook]

I think most anyone could take that away from the simple eye test and career stats, but this only further backs it up.

Maybe playoff wins and SB titles matter, also. However, I'm also a believer that it takes a complete team to produce those. Others may disagree.

 

[Perd Hapley]

Maybe playoff wins and SB titles matter, also. However, I'm also a believer that it takes a complete team to produce those. Others may disagree.

Agree completely. Eli won a SB in a year where he threw 20 picks, because the Giants had a suffocating D that manhandled the greatest NFL offense of all time. To be fair, he had another title where he was more of the catalyst.