2 X and O criticisms I have

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
I preface this with....Huge Pike fan. He should have a statue outside RAC.

NOT A ROTATION AND LINEUP THREAD

1. On the last offensive possession you need to get a better shot. You have 2.1 seconds so you need the entry pass to be at least to half court. The inbounder shouldn't even bother throwing a pass a quarter of the way.

I use a screener allowing Cliff to catch the ball a little past half court and have a player screening away for Ron so Cliff has someone to pass to. Execution isn't that simple but it bets the odds of a half court heave going in. I'd think we have a play set up for that situation and it is a little better than Paul catching the ball at quarter court.

2. End of 1st half....You have 2 fouls to give up 4 with 12 seconds left and a full bench of players with zero fouls. I don't understand why we wouldn't foul twice and make Lafayette execute with 2 or 3 seconds left.
 

The RUT

Heisman
Oct 30, 2011
35,959
20,332
61
A statue? For what? Making the tournament? Lol…that’s another discussion.

The issue is that he doesn’t have an offense or set plays. I was all over this after the DePaul game, you can’t have a last second shot with 3 players standing around doing nothing. That’s not normal at this level.

We don’t run inbounds plays, and when the team is in a scoring drought we don’t have a scheme to fall back on for an open look.

This has been an issue for quite a few years. It hasn’t been a glaring issue for most because the team would get stops/transition buckets and would pull out wins so no one cared to actually look at the problems.

Now we lost 3 of our best defenders and we’re not getting stops or transition buckets. We’re relying on a half court offense that’s non existent because our staff refuses to implement set plays and a base half court offense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superfan01

goru7

All-American
Dec 12, 2005
6,490
7,820
113
I preface this with....Huge Pike fan. He should have a statue outside RAC.

NOT A ROTATION AND LINEUP THREAD

1. On the last offensive possession you need to get a better shot. You have 2.1 seconds so you need the entry pass to be at least to half court. The inbounder shouldn't even bother throwing a pass a quarter of the way.

I use a screener allowing Cliff to catch the ball a little past half court and have a player screening away for Ron so Cliff has someone to pass to. Execution isn't that simple but it bets the odds of a half court heave going in. I'd think we have a play set up for that situation and it is a little better than Paul catching the ball at quarter court.

2. End of 1st half....You have 2 fouls to give up 4 with 12 seconds left and a full bench of players with zero fouls. I don't understand why we wouldn't foul twice and make Lafayette execute with 2 or 3 seconds left.
Yes. Terrible with 2.1 left. You have to draw up a throw to just past half court and that should be enough time to catch , one pass to the wing , and shoot. Agreed that was horrible.
Yes, good point at the end of the half . But our defense for a good part of the night hustled , caused shot click violations , blocks , and turnovers.
The game was lost on the offensive end. How Ron wasn’t planted at the foul line all night for a shot or high low with Cliff was mind boggling. Then I think the players took turns taking wide open 3 point shots , with a lot of one and dones. The 29% overall shooting and 15% three point shooting on 26 attempts is almost impossible but I saw it with my own eyes. Pike gets the blame but I really have to include the players here. Even Jaden Jones couldn’t hit the right side of the barn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IL Lusciato

The RUT

Heisman
Oct 30, 2011
35,959
20,332
61
Btw it’s pretty standard for coaches at even the high school level to work on that exact scenario in practice.

It’s clear we do not.
 

Mr. Magoo1

Heisman
Nov 15, 2001
15,626
16,577
113
I preface this with....Huge Pike fan. He should have a statue outside RAC.

NOT A ROTATION AND LINEUP THREAD

1. On the last offensive possession you need to get a better shot. You have 2.1 seconds so you need the entry pass to be at least to half court. The inbounder shouldn't even bother throwing a pass a quarter of the way.

I use a screener allowing Cliff to catch the ball a little past half court and have a player screening away for Ron so Cliff has someone to pass to. Execution isn't that simple but it bets the odds of a half court heave going in. I'd think we have a play set up for that situation and it is a little better than Paul catching the ball at quarter court.

2. End of 1st half....You have 2 fouls to give up 4 with 12 seconds left and a full bench of players with zero fouls. I don't understand why we wouldn't foul twice and make Lafayette execute with 2 or 3 seconds left.
I thought we had another timeout. Why not throw the ball to half court and call it immediately on the catch?
 

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
8,805
4,931
66
am not going to criticize any option here. there was almost no chance of scoring no matter how you draw it up.

Duke had the same 2.1 seconds in 1992 with two of the greatest college players ever and they pulled it off. Cliff ain't Laettner. I'm OK with the heave. It was already game-over barring a miracle shot.
 

cm_13

All-American
Aug 28, 2018
2,641
5,551
73
I preface this with....Huge Pike fan. He should have a statue outside RAC.

NOT A ROTATION AND LINEUP THREAD

1. On the last offensive possession you need to get a better shot. You have 2.1 seconds so you need the entry pass to be at least to half court. The inbounder shouldn't even bother throwing a pass a quarter of the way.

I use a screener allowing Cliff to catch the ball a little past half court and have a player screening away for Ron so Cliff has someone to pass to. Execution isn't that simple but it bets the odds of a half court heave going in. I'd think we have a play set up for that situation and it is a little better than Paul catching the ball at quarter court.

2. End of 1st half....You have 2 fouls to give up 4 with 12 seconds left and a full bench of players with zero fouls. I don't understand why we wouldn't foul twice and make Lafayette execute with 2 or 3 seconds left.
Even if for some reason you are going to go with a quarter court inbound, it should be to someone with better wheels than Paul.

The decision (or lack there of) to not use the fouls to give before the half was super frustrating.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
Even if for some reason you are going to go with a quarter court inbound, it should be to someone with better wheels than Paul.

The decision (or lack there of) to not use the fouls to give before the half was super frustrating.
3.5 seconds yes. 2.1 no
 

cm_13

All-American
Aug 28, 2018
2,641
5,551
73
3.5 seconds yes. 2.1 no
Oh I agree completely that with that amount of time the inbound pass needs to be further up the floor. I was more so saying even for the ill advised inbound play we did decide to run, it was the wrong guy receiving the pass.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
am not going to criticize any option here. there was almost no chance of scoring no matter how you draw it up.

Duke had the same 2.1 seconds in 1992 with two of the greatest college players ever and they pulled it off. Cliff ain't Laettner. I'm OK with the heave. It was already game-over barring a miracle shot.
Cant find the Yinka Dare play vs. RU anywhere
 

bethlehemfan

Heisman
Sep 6, 2003
15,466
17,050
113
I preface this with....Huge Pike fan. He should have a statue outside RAC.

NOT A ROTATION AND LINEUP THREAD

1. On the last offensive possession you need to get a better shot. You have 2.1 seconds so you need the entry pass to be at least to half court. The inbounder shouldn't even bother throwing a pass a quarter of the way.

I use a screener allowing Cliff to catch the ball a little past half court and have a player screening away for Ron so Cliff has someone to pass to. Execution isn't that simple but it bets the odds of a half court heave going in. I'd think we have a play set up for that situation and it is a little better than Paul catching the ball at quarter court.

2. End of 1st half....You have 2 fouls to give up 4 with 12 seconds left and a full bench of players with zero fouls. I don't understand why we wouldn't foul twice and make Lafayette execute with 2 or 3 seconds left.
I like the idea of tossing it up to cliff but would lean toward trying to get it to him near the foul line. 2.1 is not enough time for cliff to catch gather pass and someone else to shoot imo. He has to catch and shoot. In any event getting in at 3/4 quart has zero chance of success as you only have one dribble and need to heave.
 

Woody522

Junior
Dec 7, 2013
462
329
0
I preface this with....Huge Pike fan. He should have a statue outside RAC.

NOT A ROTATION AND LINEUP THREAD

1. On the last offensive possession you need to get a better shot. You have 2.1 seconds so you need the entry pass to be at least to half court. The inbounder shouldn't even bother throwing a pass a quarter of the way.

I use a screener allowing Cliff to catch the ball a little past half court and have a player screening away for Ron so Cliff has someone to pass to. Execution isn't that simple but it bets the odds of a half court heave going in. I'd think we have a play set up for that situation and it is a little better than Paul catching the ball at quarter court.

2. End of 1st half....You have 2 fouls to give up 4 with 12 seconds left and a full bench of players with zero fouls. I don't understand why we wouldn't foul twice and make Lafayette execute with 2 or 3 seconds left.
To be fair to pike he was trying to get cliff to back up but he lost his voice and his assistants just stood there in silence as he tried his hardest to get cliffs attention
 

Degaz-RU

Heisman
Dec 19, 2002
23,037
28,325
88
It was an inbounds play after a made FG, so our inbound guy could have run the baseline and/or passed it behind the end line. If it's me, I'm running back and forth and then PASSING it to another guy who is behind the end line on the other side of the court (away from coverage), then that guy heaves it to a "runner" down the sideline, who can then take a 35 foot shot.

There's really no "good" scenarios with 2.1 seconds left, unless you're Joe Wieskamp catching a hail mary and taking a fall away turnaround heave from the corner that bounces off the side of the backboard into the net.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NiTeKnight

Scarlet Shack

Heisman
Feb 3, 2004
26,407
16,328
73
That was not a great play . The ball needs to travel to half court

Do something to Dare the refs to call a foul
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Btw it’s pretty standard for coaches at even the high school level to work on that exact scenario in practice.

It’s clear we do not.
Yes we should definitely spend lots of practice time on the 2.1 second drill so we can have a 0.3% chance of winning in this scenario instead of 0.2%.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Freddy Stubbs

The RUT

Heisman
Oct 30, 2011
35,959
20,332
61
Yes we should definitely spend lots of practice time on the 2.1 second drill so we can have a 0.3% chance of winning in this scenario instead of 0.2%.
Coaches work on it all the time. It’s often an end of practice type deal.
 

zappaa

Heisman
Jul 27, 2001
76,005
93,146
103
I don't care, what you're complaining about is ridiculous.
You can at least willfully attempt to heave the ball past mid-court, since that pass gives you the only chance you have to win.
Should have been discussed in the huddle as the one thing that must happen even if you never work on it in practice
 
Last edited:

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
You can at least willfully attempt to heave the ball past mid-court, since that pass gives you the only chance you have to win.
Should have been discussed in the huddle as the one thing that must happen even if you never work on it in practice
It's not that I don't agree with this, it's that doing this correctly has virtually no impact on your chance of winning the game which are extremely low at that point even with a perfect strategy. A coach should concentrate on not getting in that situation as opposed to a miniscule improvement on his chances once he does.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
You can at least willfully attempt to heave the ball past mid-court, since that pass gives you the only chance you have to win.
Should have been discussed in the huddle as the one thing that must happen even if you never work on it in practice
15 minutes during practice tops for 2-3 special situation plays. Rerun for 5 minutes once every few weeks. This is what happened in high school.

there is more time if you add in shoot around on game day that we never had in HS. Plenty of time on game day when you don’t want to do anything expending energy.

definitely don’t spend time on it over conditioning time!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The RUT

The RUT

Heisman
Oct 30, 2011
35,959
20,332
61
15 minutes during practice tops for 2-3 special situation plays. Rerun for 5 minutes once every few weeks. This is what happened in high school.

there is more time if you add in shoot around on game day that we never had in HS. Plenty of time on game day when you don’t want to do anything expending energy.

definitely don’t spend time on it over conditioning time!
Exactly.
 

RUSCFORMERLYRULOU

All-American
Nov 12, 2017
5,626
7,321
103
Pike is not a good x and o coach. Or a good recruiter. He can teach good defensive skills. He has shown the ability to develop players, but cannot sustain the development or worse, the players regress.
He is in short a high floor low ceiling coach. And we hit the ceiling the last two years. It is, most assuredly, going to get worse.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Pike is not a good x and o coach. Or a good recruiter. He can teach good defensive skills. He has shown the ability to develop players, but cannot sustain the development or worse, the players regress.
He is in short a high floor low ceiling coach. And we hit the ceiling the last two years. It is, most assuredly, going to get worse.
You’re an idiot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpwhite

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
Wow. How profound. I can only infer that you are thrilled wirh the season to date. G-d bless you this Thanksgiving Day, sir.
He shouldn’t call you an idiot, but your views are very short sighted. The lack of respect with what this man has done for the program by some is nuts. You don’t turn this program the way he has without doing a lot of things right.

This most likely will be a down year. I am extremely confident that he will right the ship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyC80

RUSCFORMERLYRULOU

All-American
Nov 12, 2017
5,626
7,321
103
He shouldn’t call you an idiot, but your views are very short sighted. The lack of respect with what this man has done for the program by some is nuts. You don’t turn this program the way he has without doing a lot of things right.

This most likely will be a down year. I am extremely confident that he will right the ship.
I’m a realist. He got us to the dance for two years even with our offensive flaws.
But:
1. His recruiting - with some exceptions - have been very, very questionable. This year, it’s exceptionally glaring- Reiber, Palmquist and Agee (it appears) are gonna be non contributors.
2. His substitution patterns and minutes distribution - even in the “good times-“ have been maddening and non sensical.
3. Relayed to 2- loyalty to players not deserving of playing time. Exhibit a - McConnell, who I think needs to ride the bench for a few games.
4. Assistant coach selections. Other than being names, what have Knight and Hobbs done lately? And we won’t even talk about the third asst wore since Jay young left.

I could go on.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
He shouldn’t call you an idiot
Should I not? To be fair I certainly don’t extend him the civility I would to someone in real life, but on the other hand I would not associate or converse with someone as annoying as him in real life unless absolutely necessary.

I mean “idiot” is absolutely the most charitable interpretation of this guy; the alternative is just that he is an ******* who intentionally pisses people off. People like him and kyk make this forum completely unreadable with their constant “look at me” ******** and if there was any moderation here at all he would’ve been banned a long time ago.
 

RUSCFORMERLYRULOU

All-American
Nov 12, 2017
5,626
7,321
103
You are very stupid.
Should I not? To be fair I certainly don’t extend him the civility I would to someone in real life, but on the other hand I would not associate or converse with someone as annoying as him in real life unless absolutely necessary.

I mean “idiot” is absolutely the most charitable interpretation of this guy; the alternative is just that he is an ******* who intentionally pisses people off. People like him and kyk make this forum completely unreadable with their constant “look at me” ******** and if there was any moderation here at all he would’ve been banned a long time ago
 

The RUT

Heisman
Oct 30, 2011
35,959
20,332
61
He shouldn’t call you an idiot, but your views are very short sighted. The lack of respect with what this man has done for the program by some is nuts. You don’t turn this program the way he has without doing a lot of things right.

This most likely will be a down year. I am extremely confident that he will right the ship.
He had the players bought in at one point to be about pure effort on the defensive end.

Honestly when you do that you give yourself a chance to win games.

He actually preached a similar attitude to Schiano, which is why you saw improvement from his teams right away.

The issue is that Schiano improved on recruiting over time, Pike truly hasn’t. And I don’t really care what people say, you cannot sustain success without being successful on the recruiting trail.

It’s a major issue and it’s not going to solve itself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freddy Stubbs

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
I’m a realist. He got us to the dance for two years even with our offensive flaws.
But:
1. His recruiting - with some exceptions - have been very, very questionable. This year, it’s exceptionally glaring- Reiber, Palmquist and Agee (it appears) are gonna be non contributors.
2. His substitution patterns and minutes distribution - even in the “good times-“ have been maddening and non sensical.
3. Relayed to 2- loyalty to players not deserving of playing time. Exhibit a - McConnell, who I think needs to ride the bench for a few games.
4. Assistant coach selections. Other than being names, what have Knight and Hobbs done lately? And we won’t even talk about the third asst wore since Jay young left.

I could go on.
If you are a realist you would understand and appreciate how hard it is to succeed at Rutgers. You would respect the fact that Pike knows Rutgers role in college basketball scene and recruit a certain type of player. You would also realize no one is going to bat 1.000 recruiting.

I think you need to find a team like Duke to root for. What you expect is way way way a mismatch to what one should expect here.
 

RUSCFORMERLYRULOU

All-American
Nov 12, 2017
5,626
7,321
103
This is just corculae
If you are a realist you would understand and appreciate how hard it is to succeed at Rutgers. You would respect the fact that Pike knows Rutgers role in college basketball scene and recruit a certain type of player. You would also realize no one is going to bat 1.000 recruiting.

I think you need to find a team like Duke to root for. What you expect is way way way a mismatch to what one should expect here.
I will never, never fall victim to low expectations. Otherwise, we should be in the Patriot league. I still believe in the old adage that we are the sleeping giant. I’m a realist with Pike, but I still believe in RU long term with the right people in place.
 

BigRnj

All-American
Nov 20, 2012
5,034
6,809
63
He shouldn’t call you an idiot, but your views are very short sighted. The lack of respect with what this man has done for the program by some is nuts. You don’t turn this program the way he has without doing a lot of things right.

This most likely will be a down year. I am extremely confident that he will right the ship.
I agree with you about Pike, but that guy is an idiot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fluoxetine
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football PFF Grades + Snap Counts versus Nebraska
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers vs Penn State odds: Point spread released on Scarlet Knights, Nittany Lions
  3. 03 The Knight Report Football Every throw from Rutgers Football Quarterbacks versus Nebraska
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Nebraska Cornhuskers Edition - TKR Pod
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Nebraska Postgame Press Conference