OT: Myles Powell sues Seton Hall

Perricone7

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2015
1,509
2,137
113
It's hard to overstate the risk Powell is taking here. Even if his playing career flopped, he was a Seton Hall icon and extremely popular. Willard would have hired him as an assistant the second he quit playing. Now I have a hard time imagining any program will hire him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: silkcitypirate

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,208
17,015
113
Guess you forgot Brey sticking his nose into Rutgers affairs during the Mike Rice fiasco. He said shut down the program.

Hence the Mike Brey joke.
I think a close friend of his from NJ who was a ND fan was the one who asked for advise about what the RU MBB program should do , in which Brey then talked ****
 

RutgersLarry

Sophomore
May 31, 2004
602
166
0
He's a baller, I can't imagine he cant make some descent money going to europe for a few years... or will this scare off the teams there now?
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
"Lomurro said Seton Hall and other religiously chartered schools or organizations are normally protected from general negligence claims under state law.

"It is similar to someone getting hurt at a YMCA or a JCC during a camp program," Lomurro said. "If you are there receiving the benefit of the charity, you can’t turn around and sue the charity if you are hurt even if they may have been negligent.”"

So, since it's a religious institution, they have immunity against being sued for negligence? This argument should be an interesting tidbit on the recruiting trail for any program recruiting against the Big East, Boston College, Notre Dame, etc.
 

Russ Wood

Heisman
Oct 12, 2011
94,313
45,145
0
I think a close friend of his from NJ who was a ND fan was the one who asked for advise about what the RU MBB program should do , in which Brey then talked ****

Gov. Chris Christie called Notre Dame's Mike Brey for advice on Rutgers situation​

Apr 06, 2013

ATLANTA — As the situation at Rutgers began to escalate on Wednesday morning, one of Gov. Chris Christie's first phone calls to assess the problem was to Notre Dame men's basketball head coach Mike Brey.

"My phone rang two days ago at eight in the morning," Brey told the "John Feinstein Show" on CBS Radio Friday. "He was on his first family vacation (in a while) and he goes, 'I need to talk to you, I've got some video.' What he said was, 'Here's how I think this needs to be addressed.' And I said, 'You're right on.' Any logical person would say you have a mess to clean up there and obviously they're doing it."

Brey and Christie are close friends, dating to Brey's time as the head coach at Delaware where Christie is an alumnus. Last month at Madison Square Garden, Christie sat behind the Notre Dame bench during a game at the Big East Tournament.


Earlier this season when Rutgers traveled to South Bend, Ind., Christie was there as Notre Dame presented a check to New Jersey for Hurricane Sandy relief.


Brey also similarly condemned the actions by Rice on the show, saying it's "an extreme outlier" and that it was "sad to see."


The longtime Fighting Irish head coach also provided some advice for the school as it begins to embark on emerging from the scandal that has rocked Rutgers this week.


"They're such a lame-duck next year in that league (the American Athletic Conference)," Brey said. "Take your time with an AD and a coach. ... If you really have to bleed for a year going into this new league, the Big Ten, just shut it down an do it."

 
  • Like
Reactions: MADHAT1

batts

All-Conference
Jun 6, 2001
6,957
1,386
113
So, you and your friends are regulars then? 😉

"Lomurro said Seton Hall and other religiously chartered schools or organizations are normally protected from general negligence claims under state law.

"It is similar to someone getting hurt at a YMCA or a JCC during a camp program," Lomurro said. "If you are there receiving the benefit of the charity, you can’t turn around and sue the charity if you are hurt even if they may have been negligent.”"

So, since it's a religious institution, they have immunity against being sued for negligence? This argument should be an interesting tidbit on the recruiting trail for any program recruiting against the Big East, Boston College, Notre Dame, etc.
State schools also have a form of immunity under the State's Tort Claims Act: https://www.wongfleming.com/litigating-claims-against-public-entities/
 
  • Like
Reactions: silkcitypirate

mikewalsh

Redshirt
Jun 4, 2019
18
18
0
"Lomurro said Seton Hall and other religiously chartered schools or organizations are normally protected from general negligence claims under state law.

"It is similar to someone getting hurt at a YMCA or a JCC during a camp program," Lomurro said. "If you are there receiving the benefit of the charity, you can’t turn around and sue the charity if you are hurt even if they may have been negligent.”"

So, since it's a religious institution, they have immunity against being sued for negligence? This argument should be an interesting tidbit on the recruiting trail for any program recruiting against the Big East, Boston College, Notre Dame, etc.
RIGHT??? As if a recruit gives a crap whether he can sue, or not. Who wants that type of player anyway?

For the record - SHU fans are not the least bit worried as to how this effects recruiting, it won't. Powell was never a contender to be drafted by an NBA team, his claims are preposterous. Powell is an afterthought to SHU fans and he has burned every bridge he had with the school and coaching staff.

Powell was always overly confident in his abilities as a professional player. Before the draft he went on a spending spree and most likely found himself deep in debt, and with a bruised ego. Some ambulance chasing lawyer convinced him that his payday would come from SHU. The same lawyer didn't have the acumen to know that he can't collect damages from a Catholic University.

Powell finds himself in a position where professional teams will not touch him and most NCAA teams won't hire him. Willard would have helped Powell had he come to him first, and Willard will likely help him when this is over.

Going forward, Mamu is the face of Seton Hall basketball, with Rhoden and Richmond close behind. Mamu will prove to be the steal of the NBA draft as he has a high basketball IQ and is a terrific ball handler for his size. Check out the Milwaukee Bucks Twitter feed and you'll see how the fans feel about Mamu. Recruits will be focused on how SHU got a 3 Star player and turned him into a pro, Powell - not so much.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
32,208
17,015
113
RIGHT??? As if a recruit gives a crap whether he can sue, or not. Who wants that type of player anyway?

For the record - SHU fans are not the least bit worried as to how this effects recruiting, it won't. Powell was never a contender to be drafted by an NBA team, his claims are preposterous. Powell is an afterthought to SHU fans and he has burned every bridge he had with the school and coaching staff.

Powell was always overly confident in his abilities as a professional player. Before the draft he went on a spending spree and most likely found himself deep in debt, and with a bruised ego. Some ambulance chasing lawyer convinced him that his payday would come from SHU. The same lawyer didn't have the acumen to know that he can't collect damages from a Catholic University.

Powell finds himself in a position where professional teams will not touch him and most NCAA teams won't hire him. Willard would have helped Powell had he come to him first, and Willard will likely help him when this is over.

Going forward, Mamu is the face of Seton Hall basketball, with Rhoden and Richmond close behind. Mamu will prove to be the steal of the NBA draft as he has a high basketball IQ and is a terrific ball handler for his size. Check out the Milwaukee Bucks Twitter feed and you'll see how the fans feel about Mamu. Recruits will be focused on how SHU got a 3 Star player .


and turned him into a pro, Powell - not so much.
Lots of accusations.
Can you provide spending spree proof and heavily in debt proof or just something you heard.
Not saying it wasn't so, a lot of athletes spend more then they should anticipating a big payout coming,. But charges like that should be backed up.

As for Lawyer knowing he can't collect, some have the acumen to know some ( Catholic or not) Schools don't want the limelight shined on them because of the things the case might bring out in the open they want hidden, so they will make a out of court settlement to keep those issues hidden.

As for Sandro Mamukelashvili ??
Mamu was the 54th overall pick,
He signed a two way contract, not a regular guaranteed contract that would be at full rookie scale.
That's not the type one would brag about being the face ( best program has to offer) but something to point out about being able to be drafted , in which most college players do not accomplish.
This was said about Mamu:
Defense is another question mark. Milwaukee will definitely have to hide him when he’s on the floor and sandwich him between other elite defenders.
But his offensive skills were praised , so he was a good gamble for the Bucks at #54.
He did make 3rd team all Rookie in the NBA's Summer League

But this thread is about Powell and would like to see the proff showing why you claim he's heavenly in dept .
As for Pro teams not wanting a part of him
The Knicks signed him to their G-League Westchester Knicks and Myles averaged 17.8 points, 4.0 assists and 3.3 rebounds

The latest development, former Seton Hall women’s basketball player Jasmine Smith who played the past two seasons with the Pirates has filed a lawsuit against Seton Hall
for telling her she had a bone bruise but a recent MRI disclosed more damage than that and it will cost her this season at Loyola Marymount ( transferred from the Hall as a grad student) and hurts her chances of playing professionally later on.
Looks like it;s not just Myles complaining and Myles might not have been drafted, but the Knicks didn't take the hands off approach you implied
 

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
RIGHT??? As if a recruit gives a crap whether he can sue, or not. Who wants that type of player anyway?

For the record - SHU fans are not the least bit worried as to how this effects recruiting, it won't. Powell was never a contender to be drafted by an NBA team, his claims are preposterous. Powell is an afterthought to SHU fans and he has burned every bridge he had with the school and coaching staff.

Powell was always overly confident in his abilities as a professional player. Before the draft he went on a spending spree and most likely found himself deep in debt, and with a bruised ego. Some ambulance chasing lawyer convinced him that his payday would come from SHU. The same lawyer didn't have the acumen to know that he can't collect damages from a Catholic University.

Powell finds himself in a position where professional teams will not touch him and most NCAA teams won't hire him. Willard would have helped Powell had he come to him first, and Willard will likely help him when this is over.

Going forward, Mamu is the face of Seton Hall basketball, with Rhoden and Richmond close behind. Mamu will prove to be the steal of the NBA draft as he has a high basketball IQ and is a terrific ball handler for his size. Check out the Milwaukee Bucks Twitter feed and you'll see how the fans feel about Mamu. Recruits will be focused on how SHU got a 3 Star player and turned him into a pro, Powell - not so much.

The inference was that SHU is arguing that they have no legal accountability for negligence (nor does any Catholic university), and can't be held responsible for acting in the university's best interests over the player's best interest. They are saying they have legal cover to send someone back out to play even if the risks to a player's long term health should keep them off the court.

As batts posted above, though, public universities enjoy a similar sort of protection, which makes that moot anyway.

It remains to be seen what these suits will do with regard to recruiting, though.
 

RutgHoops

Heisman
Aug 14, 2008
9,259
12,463
102
Former SHU Women's basketball player Jasmine Smith joins the Powell suit.

"In an amended complaint to Powell's lawsuit filed Tuesday, Jasmine Smith alleges team staff told her she had suffered a bone bruise during practice in the fall of 2020. She alleges she was cleared to play and played the rest of the season despite suffering knee pain and swelling.

After Smith graduated from Seton Hall and sought to use a final year of basketball eligibility at Loyola Marymount, an MRI showed more extensive damage that forced her to undergo surgery and will require a second procedure, the lawsuit claims."

https://www.espn.com/womens-college...player-jasmine-smith-added-lawsuit-seton-hall
 

hinson32

All-American
Jul 29, 2005
7,986
6,315
57
RIGHT??? As if a recruit gives a crap whether he can sue, or not. Who wants that type of player anyway?

For the record - SHU fans are not the least bit worried as to how this effects recruiting, it won't. Powell was never a contender to be drafted by an NBA team, his claims are preposterous. Powell is an afterthought to SHU fans and he has burned every bridge he had with the school and coaching staff.

Powell was always overly confident in his abilities as a professional player. Before the draft he went on a spending spree and most likely found himself deep in debt, and with a bruised ego. Some ambulance chasing lawyer convinced him that his payday would come from SHU. The same lawyer didn't have the acumen to know that he can't collect damages from a Catholic University.

Powell finds himself in a position where professional teams will not touch him and most NCAA teams won't hire him. Willard would have helped Powell had he come to him first, and Willard will likely help him when this is over.

Going forward, Mamu is the face of Seton Hall basketball, with Rhoden and Richmond close behind. Mamu will prove to be the steal of the NBA draft as he has a high basketball IQ and is a terrific ball handler for his size. Check out the Milwaukee Bucks Twitter feed and you'll see how the fans feel about Mamu. Recruits will be focused on how SHU got a 3 Star player and turned him into a pro, Powell - not so much.
Boy, you are better than Baghdad Bob.
 

NightKnight

All-Conference
Jul 21, 2008
3,295
1,750
68
Yeah. “Who wants that type of player anyway?” If you’ve never been around a recruiting dinner table on an in-home visit let me give you a little idea of how it goes…
Hey recruit’s mom. I know you guys are looking at Seton Hall too. That’s alright. That makes sense. They’ve had some pretty good players over the years, but there’s something I think you should know - something I’d want my son (or “little brother” for younger asst coach) to know. You probably heard Myles Powell is suing them for purposefully giving him bad medical advice to play when he should have been on the sideline healing. Myles is the best player they’ve had there in the whole of (recruits name’s) life…and that’s how they treated him. Now I just heard that Jasmine Smith who played on the women’s team is saying pretty much the same thing. I guarantee you this: If Myles Powell went to College Name he’d be healthy and cashing NBA checks today instead of limping and hoping to catch on the a G league or some foreign country for short money and no insurance and no pension.

Look, if was just one kid you could chalk it up to a mistake by a coach and a doctor, but two …at the same time. That really makes you wonder. Doesn’t it? [Sales guys love asking questions where the answer is YES] I know it wouldn’t have at College Name because we have our priorities in order. I know Coach wouldn’t take a short cut with your son’s health on the line. I know our medical staff wouldn’t go along with it if he did. It wouldn’t happen at College Name because our medical staff is expert on just the kind of knee, ankle, back, concussion injuries that will hit every AND I DO MEAN EVERY player that plays four years. Their medical staff is three guys in the back pocket of their coach. Ours is 17 guys sworn by their Hippocratic oath to put health first [Doesn’t even have to be exactly true. Just has to be kind of true].
Frankly, they pretty much have to take short cuts. There total athletic budget is $26mil. Sound like a lot? I think Recruit can sign for $26mil in his rookie contract. College Name’s athletic budget is over $100mil. It doesn’t guarantee success but it does mean we don’t skimp and we’ve got over sight in place to make sure we’re doing things right. I’m going to come right out and say it ‘cause I know you’re thinking it. If they’re not taking proper care of athlete’s bodies what would make you think they’re taking care of their education. We’ve got an academic support staff that is four times their size. We’ve got twice as many majors to choose from and four times the number of courses. We will find the right match for Recruit even when those needs change over time.

Everyone says, “Don’t worry. Don’t worry. Things will work out.” Well I say WORRY. You love this kid and he is the sparkle in your eye. I can see it. You only get one chance to get this right. Would be great to say sign this paper and your worries will be over, but I suspect you will be worrying about Recruit his whole life. Be easier if he wasn’t so damn handsome. So, you worry about girls and in a couple of years whether the Lamborghini or the Maserati has the best airbag system. Sign here tonight and we will worry about his player development, his health and his education together. I absolutely promise it is a decision you will not regret and you will tell your grandchildren about this night. C’mon [grab mom’s hand and recruit’s hand] Recruit grab your mom’s hand. Let’s commit to each other right here tonight and get the big bright future started right here right now. [ABC –Always Be Closing]
 

greenknight

Heisman
Sep 1, 2001
20,898
12,756
113
So am I reading this right. He was not good enough to make NBA team yet played G-League. How did injury affect his inability to make the big show. It sounds like his lack of height predetermined his inability to make the NBA not his knee injury. Sour grapes and looking to make a score possibly
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Albany Press Conference
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball topples Albany with dominant second half
  3. 03 The Knight Report Three-Star DL Jeremiah Joseph decommits from Rutgers Football
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Men's Soccer earns NCAA Tournament berth for first time since 2022
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football versus Michigan State Game Time Announced