The Difference in that Game is Basically Luck in 3-Point Shooting

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Said absolutely no one. Now you're just flailing.

If there is no random variation in three point shots, why is no one capable of a percentage even approaching 100 when wide open?

If Caleb McConnell gets three wide open looks, hits two and misses one, what variable under the control of Caleb McConnell do you think is the difference between the shots?
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
If Jacob Young misses two free throws in the first half and makes two in the second half, must he have improved his free throw shooting at halftime? Or is there maybe an element of... randomness ?
 

Westcoast

All-American
Nov 14, 2001
22,416
5,976
113
"Infinitely"

34.3% vs 30.1%. On 22 attempts per game (what Wisconsin took today) that is 0.924 more makes.
I'm including FT shooting in the "infinitely better" description.

There's just no comparison to Wisconsin's shooting and ours. We're awful. They are not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rubjk

RW90

All-American
Feb 2, 2002
8,422
7,702
113
If there is no random variation in three point shots, why is no one capable of a percentage even approaching 100 when wide open?

If Caleb McConnell gets three wide open looks, hits two and misses one, what variable under the control of Caleb McConnell do you think is the difference between the shots?
Again with the 100%? Its a losers game to say we lost because they shot above their average. The game is played on the court not Stratomatic gameboards. Usually the most talented teams wins.
 

rubjk

All-American
Dec 16, 2013
2,352
5,114
113
If Jacob Young misses two free throws in the first half and makes two in the second half, must he have improved his free throw shooting at halftime? Or is there maybe an element of... randomness ?
That’s why you look at averages per game and not shot to shot.
 

rubjk

All-American
Dec 16, 2013
2,352
5,114
113
3 pointers may have more randomness than free throws, but a 35% team is still going to shoot that +\- 5% most games with a game here or there a bigger outlier. A better shooting 3 point team is going to hit 40-50% here or there, especially with home crowd and momentum. The randomness is not due to luck though. It’s just due to it being a more difficult shot. A bad shooter isn’t going to get lucky and go 5-10 from 3.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
3 pointers may have more randomness than free throws, but a 35% team is still going to shoot that +\- 5% most games with a game here or there a bigger outlier. A better shooting 3 point team is going to hit 40-50% here or there, especially with home crowd and momentum. The randomness is not due to luck though. It’s just due to it being a more difficult shot. A bad shooter isn’t going to get lucky and go 5-10 from 3.

this basically agrees with me except for word choice, if you dislike the word “luck” to describe randomness outside the control of the player, okay
 

rubjk

All-American
Dec 16, 2013
2,352
5,114
113
It’s not luck though, should have actually used variability or something other than randomness or luck. It’s things you don’t see, like minute differences in spin on the ball, breeze from the heat, minute differences on how hard the ball is shot.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
It’s not luck though, it’s things you don’t see, like minute differences in spin on the ball, breeze from the heat, etc.

Yes, I agree with this.

I will amend my statement to "the difference between Wisconsin's three point shooting today and their average is almost entirely due to factors outside the control of the Rutgers defense."

I think the point, which is that our team did not actually perform badly today, remains correct.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SirScarlet

rubjk

All-American
Dec 16, 2013
2,352
5,114
113
rubjk said:

↑



It’s not luck though, it’s things you don’t see, like minute differences in spin on the ball, breeze from the heat, etc.

Yes, I agree with this.

I will amend my statement to "the difference between Wisconsin's three point shooting today and their average" is almost entirely due to factors outside the control of the Rutgers defense.
[/quote]
We are missing their kind of 3 point skill players and that was the difference in the game. We matched them everywhere else except 3s and FTs as we did in most of our close loses.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,450
13,340
113
@fluoxetine - still waiting for an answer this:

Rutgers season average FG% - 44.4%
Rutgers FG% vs Wisc - 50% (30 for 60).
Rutgers should have missed 4 more shots and scored 8 less points.

"Only reason Rutgers didn't get blown out by 16 points (instead of 8 points) was luck".

Now your turn to cite 1 individual stat and call it "luck".
 

GoodOl'Rutgers

Heisman
Sep 11, 2006
123,974
19,586
0
What do you think is the difference between a game like today, where Wisconsin is 11/22 from three, and a game like they played against New Mexico, where they were 2/26.

Clearly there is something to that.

Rutgers is ranked 93 in 3 pt defense
New Mexico is 279th

But do you know what New Mexico is top ten in? ALTITUDE

University of New Mexico
Albuquerque, New Mexico (elev. 5,312 feet)

I do agree with OP.. luck has some play in shooting baskets.. was Harper's banked 3 a case of extreme LUCK? I think so. You shoot a perfect shot you need no luck. But an average shot is not perfect.

The average shot will be off-center by some percentage.. within a certain variance it will go in. Then you have a zone of uncertainty.. it "might" go in. That is where luck plays a part, imho. Then comes the variance where that ball is not going in... and then... if you are way way off... you might bank it in.
 
Last edited:

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
@fluoxetine - still waiting for an answer this:

Rutgers season average FG% - 44.4%
Rutgers FG% vs Wisc - 50% (30 for 60).
Rutgers should have missed 4 more shots and scored 8 less points.

"Only reason Rutgers didn't get blown out by 16 points (instead of 8 points) was luck".

Now your turn to cite 1 individual stat and call it "luck".

The argument doesn't work for every stat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickRU714

BadgerInSpartyland

Sophomore
Mar 15, 2004
189
157
0
FYI, this was the 4th straight game that the Badgers hit at least 11 3s. So, the volume of makes wasn't particularly out of character.

The percentage was indeed high, but they were also at 48% 2 games ago. Having watched virtually every game, I can tell you that the quality of 3 that they're taking now is much better than it had been earlier in the year, so the recent improvement does not seem to be by accident. And a lot of that, IMO, has to do with the re-emergence of Trice as a true PG.
 

Scarlet Shack

Heisman
Feb 3, 2004
26,410
16,329
73
Wisconsin shot 11/22 from 3. 8/22 would still be over their season-long percentage.

We lost by 8.
Wisconsin shot 11/22 from 3. 8/22 would still be over their season-long percentage.

We lost by 8.

Way off...we lost because we allowed a good three point shooting team to get off 22 three point shots ...and more importantly, Gave the attempts to let them get into a sync and confidence

I keep saying we need to take the three away from our opponents at all cost ...especially because we can’t score in bunches
 

bethlehemfan

Heisman
Sep 6, 2003
15,489
17,117
113
Way off...we lost because we allowed a good three point shooting team to get off 22 three point shots ...and more importantly, Gave the attempts to let them get into a sync and confidence

I keep saying we need to take the three away from our opponents at all cost ...especially because we can’t score in bunches
We lost because we were out scored at the free throw line
 

satnom

All-American
Jun 28, 2002
7,517
9,712
88
Wisc deserved the W. They hit 3 pts at a high rate and made free throws. RU defense was better than what many are stating on this thread. Wisc hit contested 3s with hands in their face. That is their game. Kudos to them but doesn’t mean RU defense played like sh*t. RU missed opps to keep game close (single digit) throughout game by making shots and limiting TOs to stay within the margin of error to keep it close for a winnable run at the end for a tough road win. RU did not but now has to learn from this loss and focus on PSU for a different type of matchup.

I’m not giving up on this team. Let’s get a road win on Tues.

GO RU
 
  • Like
Reactions: fluoxetine

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Way off...we lost because we allowed a good three point shooting team to get off 22 three point shots ...and more importantly, Gave the attempts to let them get into a sync and confidence

I keep saying we need to take the three away from our opponents at all cost ...especially because we can’t score in bunches

This is a better way to look at it but is 22 a lot? That seems like a normal number of attempts.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
FYI, this was the 4th straight game that the Badgers hit at least 11 3s. So, the volume of makes wasn't particularly out of character.

The percentage was indeed high, but they were also at 48% 2 games ago. Having watched virtually every game, I can tell you that the quality of 3 that they're taking now is much better than it had been earlier in the year, so the recent improvement does not seem to be by accident. And a lot of that, IMO, has to do with the re-emergence of Trice as a true PG.

FWIW, and I understand how it could be taken that way, I don’t mean to say that Wisconsin was lucky to win.

I just mean that I don’t think that Wisconsin’s good performance shooting threes today is attributable to bad defense.
 

ILikePike

Sophomore
Nov 8, 2019
78
168
0
This game tied Wisconsin's season high for 3 point percentage. They shot 3-18 against Eastern Illinois, 10-28 against McNeese and 13-31 against Rider. I find it hard to believe that any of these 3 teams played better 3 point defense against Wisconsin than we did. If you don't think there is some serious randomness game to game in 3 point shooting I don't know what to tell you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fluoxetine

RutgersRaRa

Heisman
Mar 21, 2011
19,092
31,448
113
lol, no, dude, these arguments don’t work for every stat. Three point shooting is demonstrably a high variance thing where you will see large amounts of game to game variation that is attributable basically to chance

people have looked and basically the sustained difference between the BEST and WORST 3 point defenses is a few percent. that some of you jokers think our defense played so badly that the expected 3 point rate was 50 is laughable
There is variation game to game, but at what point do we look at the stats over an entire season and see a cause-and-effect, one that has a higher likelihood of impacting any given game? Your argument is basically, **** happens, and when we end up on the short end of the stick it's not cause-and-effect, it's just a roll of the dice. Statistics don't govern games, they are after-the-fact assessments of what we think contributed to the outcome of games, but they don't impact games.

When I look at the fact, for example, that Myles doesn't shoot from more than three feet out, that he doesn't face up to the basket and take a shot from any distance, I look to see how that impacts our three-point-efficiency. Given Myles's limited offensive arsenal, it is easier for defenders to shade toward the perimeter and help out on defense. The same rarely holds true for other teams, since most of them have bigs that have face-up skills that require more help down low. That opens up their perimeter shooters because we can't close out quickly enough. And though it is the case that variations occur between games vis-a-vis shooting percentages, over the course of a season luck isn't a legitimate argument as to why other teams beat us. There are more specific, identifiable reasons for our losses, which will hopefully lead to different scheming within games based on our personnel, different recruiting pursuits, and perhaps different hiring of coaches to coach up the personnel we have.

All four of our coaches were guards in college. Would it help to have a big man on staff? Maybe, maybe not. But being torched by other teams who hurt us from three is not grounds to say, oh well, it's a roll of the dice. Let's try to weight those dice in our favor and hope the dice start to make us "lucky."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Unionst

RutgersRaRa

Heisman
Mar 21, 2011
19,092
31,448
113
This game tied Wisconsin's season high for 3 point percentage. They shot 3-18 against Eastern Illinois, 10-28 against McNeese and 13-31 against Rider. I find it hard to believe that any of these 3 teams played better 3 point defense against Wisconsin than we did. If you don't think there is some serious randomness game to game in 3 point shooting I don't know what to tell you.
"Randomness" is a circular argument and doesn't help, for example, in game preparation or recruiting. When you say randomness (or luck, as it's being alternately referred to) was the cause of the score of the game due to their 3-point shooting, what other factors were random that impacted the outcome of the game? You're selecting one stat and making the overly simplistic argument that if we isolate that one element and see that sometimes teams make more and sometimes less from one game to another, you've basically said nothing. All you've done is selected one statistic and retroactively assessed a game's outcome based upon it, as though that statistic was the sole, or even primary, cause of the outcome. It wasn't.
 

BadgerInSpartyland

Sophomore
Mar 15, 2004
189
157
0
This game tied Wisconsin's season high for 3 point percentage. They shot 3-18 against Eastern Illinois, 10-28 against McNeese and 13-31 against Rider. I find it hard to believe that any of these 3 teams played better 3 point defense against Wisconsin than we did. If you don't think there is some serious randomness game to game in 3 point shooting I don't know what to tell you.
But, you are assuming that Wisconsin's 3-point shooting is constant over the course of the season (at the season average) and that every game is a deviation off of that flat (zero-slope) line. There's a graph on the Badger site that shows a fairly significant upward trend over the course of the year in 3FG%. This supports the observation that they're getting higher quality shots, regardless of opponent (but still way better at home). They are now #2 in the B1G in 3FG%.

Earlier in the year, UW was struggling to adjust how to play without Ethan Happ. Double teaming in the post by the defense that were the norm with Happ were no longer necessary, and freed that defender to better guard the 3-point line and made the shooters less open. Over the course of the year, UW has adjusted to the new reality of being perimeter-oriented.

It isn't that RU was worse defense than Rider or McNeese St., it's that UW has figured out how to get better looks.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
Flux is 100% here. Wisconsin has a case of fools gold here. They normally don’t make so many 3s. Some were low quality attempts.
There was a lot not to like if you are A RU fan, but this is a evenish game is WISCONSIN has a normal shooting night

you look better than you are when you have a good shooting day and look worse than you are when u have a bad one
 

RUsince52

All-Conference
Apr 3, 2016
6,821
2,046
0
It can be stated that the root cause of 3 point shooting is partially based on luck. We aren't lucky enough to recruit good 3 point shooters and it continues every year.
 

Scarlet Shack

Heisman
Feb 3, 2004
26,410
16,329
73
This is a better way to look
at it but is 22 a lot? That seems like a normal number of attempts.

It was 13 in the first half ..and 9 in the second

I am a HUGE advocate of the importance of not letting teams get comfortable out of the locker room ..especially shooting the three ball..and one of my few criticism of coach pike is we don’t put enough emphasis, as a defensive minded team...of allowing teams to get off too many threes ...especially in the first half

If you trace the number of three balls attempted against us...the number is slamming high in halftime one ...and, to our major credits, down in the second half and waaaaay down in the last 10 minutes when we put the lock down. A lot of our rallies were fueled by locking down there theee ball attempts. Even those rallies in defeat

No one presses in the big ten ...so the way to prevent runs against us is defending the arc. We need to do more to let fewer attempts off
 
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
But, you are assuming that Wisconsin's 3-point shooting is constant over the course of the season (at the season average) and that every game is a deviation off of that flat (zero-slope) line. There's a graph on the Badger site that shows a fairly significant upward trend over the course of the year in 3FG%. This supports the observation that they're getting higher quality shots, regardless of opponent (but still way better at home). They are now #2 in the B1G in 3FG%.

Earlier in the year, UW was struggling to adjust how to play without Ethan Happ. Double teaming in the post by the defense that were the norm with Happ were no longer necessary, and freed that defender to better guard the 3-point line and made the shooters less open. Over the course of the year, UW has adjusted to the new reality of being perimeter-oriented.

It isn't that RU was worse defense than Rider or McNeese St., it's that UW has figured out how to get better looks.

It's certainly possible that Wisconsin is a better shooting team now than at the beginning of the season, and I agree that season-long 3pt% may be too simple a way to look at it.

That said, you guys are 50/116 (43.1%) over the last four games. You haven't improved that much, it isn't sustainable. That's just a hot streak.
 

Greene Rice FIG

Heisman
Dec 30, 2005
40,437
23,613
0
I wonder if there has been any analysis done looking at percentage differentials between contested, open, and wide open 3s.

In other words how much, on any given night, can a team influence 3pt fg %. I think 3pf FGA is a good measure of defense
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start