BAC'S FIRST ROUGH NCAA TOURNEY ANALYSIS WITH PECKING ORDER: 2/5

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
No...its not here yet

So just going through a preliminary dive into the nitty gritty of the NCAA tourney resumes. Since this is about two weeks early than I usually do it, I dont think I can quite do the in depth analysis yet because there are just too many games to play...some schools 8-9 games, that is alot of games to go. So my initial analysis will just focus on a sort of rough pecking order reminding everyone there are plenty of games to go which means there are tons of opportunities for some of the schools closer to the last in line to gather and collect quality wins while teams further up may stumble and not add much to their resume. Just a snapshot in time of what things look like today.

This year is somewhat odd in that quality wins in league such as the ACC, SEC, Pac 10, Big 12 are sort of hard to come by. The Big 10 is providing quality wins virtually every night for every school. The Big East also will end up doing well as we moved toward the end of the regular season. In the ACC and Big 12 the power is consolidated at the top, those 2 conferences will have 6 of the top 12 seeds. However in the both conferences there is a huge drop off, where beyond the top 3 in those leagues, I am currently projecting just one school from each league currently in...Texas Tech and Virginia who is in my last 4 in line.

And Rutgers......right now let's say the news is very good. Bridge jumpers take a deep breath. One thing you have to remember...BODY OF WORK. Body of work and conference strength are two huge factors to keep in mind. The selection committee does not use how you finish as a criteria. No one can take away the quality wins that RU has amassed. Certainly Rutgers want to build on what they already have but there will be plenty of opportunities going forward.

Currently when I match Rutgers' resume up against other schools, pretty favorable

More to come...stay tuned.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
So I am going to do this by giving lock status to seeds 1-5 which is 20 schools...either by being projected as conference winner or by receiving an at large. These at larges are basically locks though in reality I suppose each of them can lose all their games and finish on the wrong side of the bubble. Some of these schools can easily go from a 4 to 8 seed but for our purpose I lets project them in

BAYLOR Big 12
KANSAS
GONZAGA WCC
SAN DIEGO STATE MWC
DUKE
LOUISVILLE ACC
MARYLAND Big 10
DAYTON A10
VILLANOVA
WEST VIRGINIA
SETON HALL Big East
FLORIDA STATE
MICHIGAN STATE
AUBURN
BUTLER
OREGON Pac 12
PENN STATE
LSU SEC
IOWA
CREIGHTON


that takes care of 20 of the 68 spots including 9 of the automatic bids. There are 23 other automatic bids.


VERMONT AmerEast
TULSA AAC
LIBERTY Atl Sun
E WASHINGTON Big Sky
WINTHROP Big South
UC IRVINE Big West
CHARLESTON CAA
NORTH TEXAS CUSA
WRIGHT ST Horizon
YALE Ivy
MONMOUTH MAAC
BOWLING GREEN MAC
NC A&T MEAC
NO IOWA MVC
ROBERT MORRIS NEC
MURRAY ST Ohio Valley
COLGATE Patriot
FURMAN Southern
SFA Southland
PRAIRIE VIEW SWAC
SO DAKOTA ST Summit
LITTLE ROCK Sun Belt
N MEXICO ST WAC


that takes care of 43 of the 68 spots


Again because its early I am not going to go crazy with deep analysis and will limit this just to schools IN the field as of today and then I will list a bunch of schools who are outside the bubble that will certainly be in contention for a bid as February unfolds. Note anything in red is a red flag, you do not want red flags on your resume

Here is the pecking order for those 25 spots


1. (15) OHIO STATE 15-7.... key wins: Villanova, Penn St, Kentucky (N), Michigan, Indiana, Q1: 4-6, Q2: 3-1 SOS:47

2. (27) KENTUCKY 17-5....key wins: Louisville, Michigan St (N), at Tex Tech, Arky, Miss St, bad loss Q4 Evansville, Q1: 4-3, Q2: 3-1, SOS: 68

3. (31) ILLINOIS 15-6....key wins: Rutgers, at Wisconsin, at Michigan, Michigan, at Purdue, Purdue, Minnesota, Q1: 4-4, Q2: 3-0, SOS:73

4. (25) MARQUETTE 16-6....key wins: Villanova, USC, at Xavier, Xavier, Purdue, Q1: 4-5, Q2: 5-1, SOS: 18

5. (9) ARIZONA 15-6....key wins: Colorado, Illinois, Q1: 2-4, Q2: 3-2, SOS: 6,

6. (18) COLORADO 17-5....key wins: Dayton (N), Oregon, Q1: 4-2, Q2: 4-2, SOS: 31:

7. (29) RUTGERS 15-7....key wins: Seton Hall, Penn State, Wisconsin, Indiana, Purdue, Minnesota, Q1: 3-6, Q2: 3-0, SOS: 34, road/neutral: 1-7

8. (30) WISCONSIN 13-9....key wins: Maryland, Michigan State, at Ohio State, at Penn State, Marquette, Indiana, Q1: 6-6, Q2: 1-2, SOS: 3

9. (34) MICHIGAN 13-9....key wins: Gonzaga (N), Creighton, Iowa, Rutgers (N), Purdue, Q1:4-8, Q2: 3-1, SOS: 38

10. (26) TEXAS TECH 14-8....key wins: Louisville(N), West Virginia, Q1: 2-8, Q2: 3-0, SOS:51

11. (49) INDIANA 15-7....key wins: Michigan State, Ohio State, Florida State, Q1: 3-6, Q2: 2-1, SOS: 39

12. (46) USC 17-5....key wins: LSU (N), Stanford, Q1: 3-4, Q2: 4-0, SOS: 52


13. (32) ST MARY'S 18-5....key wins: BYU, Wisconsin (N), Q1: 2-2, Q2: 4-1, SOS: 91

14. (28) BYU 16-7....key wins: at Houston, St Mary's Q1: 1-4, Q2: 4-3, SOS: 22

15. (35) ARKANSAS 16-6....key wins: at Indiana, Tulsa, Q1: 2-4, Q2: 4-2, SOS: 15

16. (24) STANFORD 16-5....key wins: Oregon, Q1: 1-3, Q2: 3-0, 2 Q3 losses, SOS: 105


17. (41) RHODE ISLAND 17-5....key wins: at VCU, VCU, Q1: 1-4, Q2: 5-1, SOS: 37

18. (42) FLORIDA 13-8....key wins: Auburn, Xavier (N), Q1: 3-4, Q2: 2-4, SOS: 35


19.. (38) PURDUE 12-10....key wins: Michigan State, Wisconsin, VCU (N), Minnesota, Virgina, Q1: 3-7, Q2: 2-2, SOS: 56

20. (33) HOUSTON 17-5....key wins: at Wichita State, Q1: 2-4, Q2: 4-0, SOS: 108


21. (37) WICHITA STATE 17-4....key wins: VCU, Oklahoma, Q1: 0-2, Q2: 7-2, SOS: 93

LAST 4 IN

22. (44) XAVIER 15-8....key wins: at Seton Hall, Q1: 3-7, Q2: 3-1, SOS: 28

23. (45) MINNESOTA 11-
10....key wins: Ohio State, at Ohio State, Penn State, Michigan, Q1: 3-7, Q2: 2-3, SOS: 29

24. (39) MISSISSIPPI STATE 14-8....key wins: at Florida, Arkansas,
Q1: 1-6, Q2: 3-0, SOS: 23

25. (36) VCU 16-6....key wins: LSU,
Q1: 1-4, Q2: 2-2, SOS:85

LAST 4 OUT

26. (54) OKLAHOMA 14-8....key wins: Minnesota (N), Mississippi State, Q1: 2-7, Q2: 4-1, SOS: 53

27. (55) UTAH STATE 15-7....key wins: LSU, Florida (N), Q1: 2-4, Q2: 1-2,
SOS: 103

28. (56) VIRGINIA 14-6....key wins: Florida State, Q1: 2-2, Q2: 4-3, SOS: 66

29. (43) ALABAMA 12-10....key wins: Auburn, Mississippi State, Q1; 1-5, Q2: 2-4, SOS: 17


Other Contenders in no particular order. These schools really have their work cut out for them but a few of them will make their runs and might bounce into the field when all is said and done but as of now most of them have little if any wins of note to show for

Richmond, Cincinnati, Memphis, Georgetown, Providence, Tennessee, South Carolina, Virginia Tech, Syracuse, North Carolina State, Arizona State, Texas, East Tennessee State

So in totality there are probably about 42 schools competing for 25 spots. Note Northern Iowa if they do not win the MVC tourney will receive at large consideration.


I will take all types of questions and comments. In fact you guys better be asking question and commenting.

Again this analysis does not include the results of Tuesday's games, which strengthened the resumes of two Big 10 schools near the bottom of the pecking order. So those wins for Purdue/Minnesota over Iowa/Wisconsin were needed wins to keep them in the field.

Things are looking very very good for RU at this point. Rutgers has built a lot of cushion between them and the bottom of the bubble. I currently project Rutgers as a 7 seed and possible matchups as 10s would be Houston, Florida, and Rhode Island. Note RU has a red flag with the 1-7 road mark. Thats just something they have to improve hopefully in regular season play or in the Big 10 tourney, really I think just ONE win would be good enough. Should RU win 3 or 4 home games though, that road mark will be overlooked. Key for Rutgers is to beat Northwestern, you do not want a borderline Q3/Q4 loss at this point. Remember its body of work. No one can take away what RU has accomplished this year. It is far more than some of these other teams. However you also do not want to rest on laurels because some of these teams further down in the pecking order or out of the field can pick up bunches of quality wins down the stretch. There will be alot of jockeying because there are about 8 games or so to go for most schools.
 
Last edited:

RU MAN

Heisman
Oct 29, 2001
23,760
10,496
113
BAC, do you think the committee will take a B1G at large team with an under .500 conference record?

What do you think bare minimum does RU have to win down the stretch to be assured of the NCAA w/o counting any wins in the B1G tourney? Three wins?
 

NewJerseyHawk

Heisman
Jan 11, 2007
24,959
40,166
113
BAC, do you think the committee will take a B1G at large team with an under .500 conference record?

What do you think bare minimum does RU have to win down the stretch to be assured of the NCAA w/o counting any wins in the B1G tourney? Three wins?

Ohio state 8-12 in B1G....made NCAAs last year.
 

shields

Heisman
Aug 5, 2002
80,354
18,400
113
Glad no St. John's. Someone had them just out and now are 2-8 in conference. I know they beat West Virginia.
 

NewJerseyHawk

Heisman
Jan 11, 2007
24,959
40,166
113
The conference record is really not relevant to the selection. It is Q1 and Q2 Wins.

The grouping should separate or line up Q1/Q2 wins and or wins/losses and I know people don't agree with this, but the teams that avoid bad losses are just as important as statement wins.

RU has a resume that is strengthened by it's margin of victories in Q1 wins and smaller margin of defeat in Q1 losses.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
The conference record is really not relevant to the selection. It is Q1 and Q2 Wins.

The grouping should separate or line up Q1/Q2 wins and or wins/losses and I know people don't agree with this, but the teams that avoid bad losses are just as important as statement wins.

RU has a resume that is strengthened by it's margin of victories in Q1 wins and smaller margin of defeat in Q1 losses.

Rutgers has a bad loss Q3 to St Bonaventure but generally one bad loss is overlooked. Its when you have 2 or 3 or have a Q4 loss its an issue
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
Hope your right, bac. 7th out of 25 at-large bids is a great place to be.

Great for now. Movement will happen because 8 regular season game plus conference tourney play. Will RU slip and other schools rise? Those schools may have limited opportunities.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
Glad no St. John's. Someone had them just out and now are 2-8 in conference. I know they beat West Virginia.

Wins over Arizona and WVU are outstanding but literally have nothing to show gor in league play. 2-8 both over DePaul. Will need a serious form reversal and a long win streak
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
Ohio state 8-12 in B1G....made NCAAs last year.

Ohio State was an interesting case because by seasons end their profile was pretty meh.

Raced off to 12-1 start including wins over Cincy. Then dropped 5 in a row. Recovered to 16-7 and that point was considered safely in. Struggled to finish 18-13 and split Big 19 tourney games to finish 19-14. 4-10 Quad 1 and sos of 35. But really in addition to Cincy the only wins vs ncaa teams were Iowa and Minnesota. They slid down to an 11...last 6 in but really one can argue they didn't deserve a bid
 
Last edited:

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
BAC, do you think the committee will take a B1G at large team with an under .500 conference record?

What do you think bare minimum does RU have to win down the stretch to be assured of the NCAA w/o counting any wins in the B1G tourney? Three wins?

They most certainly can take a sub 500 school. Some schools fare better than others. Body of work. Michigan at 9-11 likely has a better resume than Rutgers would at 9-11
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU MAN

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
RU MAN

They most certainly can take a sub 500 school. Some schools fare better than others. Body of work. Michigan at 9-11 likely has a better resume than Rutgers would at 9-11

And nothing is ever assured. We will know as we get in that last week if Rutgers needs more or if they have amplely seperated themselves. 4 us almost assuredly a lock. Beginning to think 3...but no one wants to sweat
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU MAN

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
thanks...its the NET formula that ranks the teams. NET is used a sorting tool. Its not the end all be all but its important. And yes quad 1 wins are home wins vs 1-30

Now there was movement last night. Purdue became a quad 1 win while Wisconsin dropped to Q2. There are a slew of Big 10 schools tightly packed either side of 30
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
I would think Illinois would have a stronger resume than Iowa and Penn State right now since they are currently ranked number1 in the B1G,

You can see how fluid things are. After last night Iowa who i had maybe as the last 5 seed would get replaced with Ohio State.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
To your recollection what is the least amount over .500 a team has made it at as an at large bid?

3?

like a 18-15


Georgia 16-14 in 2001. I also believe a 16-14 Nova team in 90s. There have been over a dozen schools with 14 losses given bids. OSU and Florida last year...actually Florida had 15 losses..19-15
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
I would take LSU and Iowa off the lock line and add Kentucky, Colorado, and Arizona.

BYU seems really low on your list as does Saint Mary's.

I agree with your last four in except for Xavier, who I have slightly higher up. I think Virginia is currently in the last four in. I think you have Alabama and Oklahoma too high even at first four out.

Was thinking something like
In
Mississippi State
VCU
Virginia
Minnesota

Out
Cincinnati
Northern Iowa (if they don't win their conference tourney)
East Tennessee State (if they don't win their conference tourney)
USC

I think Cincinnati has a pretty good shot. Memphis on the outside looking in but far from out of it. South Carolina is done unless they win the SEC. Ditto Virginia Tech, no shot.

Agree Rutgers is in very strong position currently.

If you compare us to something like Mississippi State:

Mississippi State
14-8 (5-4)
1-6 Q1 (win @ #42 Florida)
3-0 Q2
5-2 Q3 (losses vs #83 Louisiana Tech, vs #114 New Mexico State)
5-0 Q4
#41 NET, #39 KenPom

Rutgers
16-7 (7-5)
3-5 Q1 (wins vs #13 Seton Hall, vs #20 Penn State, vs #29 Purdue)
3-1 Q2
2-1 Q3 (loss vs #119 St Bonaventure (neutral)
7-0 Q4
#27 NET, #28 KenPom
 

Scarlet Blind_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 5, 2001
4,742
4,819
62
Margin of victory is a definite emphasis on NET.

Iowa dropped 8 with a 36 pt. loss 22-->30
Iowa has Q1/2 losses of 12(Mich-Dec before NET), 10(Md)no drop
Purdue went up 9 with the win 38--->29
Purdue has Q1/2 wins of 29(Va-Dec before NET), 29(MSU) up 9, 19(Wisc.) up 9

Wisconsin dropped 6 with 18 pt. loss 30--->36
Wisconsin has Q1/2 losses of 12(MSU) up 5, 19(Purd) down 1
Minnesota went up 2 with the win 45--->43
Minnesota has Q1/2 wins of 13(OSU-Dec. 15) no change, 20(Ok.St.) Up 26,

10 pt cap on results is wrong, definitely when it happens, who it is, by how much compared to other teams/computer models. As each results happen, it corrects itself. General thought, but big difference losing by 10, compared to 18, or even 28.

Since NET started Dec 15, Rutgers has no examples. Biggest loss has been 6 pts so hard to compare numbers. Rutgers dropped 10 in NET as a result of not covering Michigan +1, loss by 6, as well as Seton Hall and MSU losing all same day. We went up 2 today from road win Seton Hall @G'town, as well as Purdue win.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bac2therac

Fighter of the Nightman

All-Conference
Jul 8, 2019
2,477
2,633
0
The committee uses the NET to help them, not as the end all ... right? Then there are also the logistic considerations like making sure B1G teams don’t play each other before the Sweet Sixteen and trying not to punish top seeds too badly (e.g., hypothetically sending a 1-seed to Tulsa one year where they could play an 8-seed Oklahoma or something).

I think the human element will make its way in some how and punish Ohio State a bit more than their NET, not much but a bit. Also, it’ll obviously be all about how we finish. OSU will not have that ranking in two weeks, if you ask me.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
I would take LSU and Iowa off the lock line and add Kentucky, Colorado, and Arizona.

BYU seems really low on your list as does Saint Mary's.

I agree with your last four in except for Xavier, who I have slightly higher up. I think Virginia is currently in the last four in. I think you have Alabama and Oklahoma too high even at first four out.

Was thinking something like
In
Mississippi State
VCU
Virginia
Minnesota

Out
Cincinnati
Northern Iowa (if they don't win their conference tourney)
East Tennessee State (if they don't win their conference tourney)
USC

I think Cincinnati has a pretty good shot. Memphis on the outside looking in but far from out of it. South Carolina is done unless they win the SEC. Ditto Virginia Tech, no shot.

Agree Rutgers is in very strong position currently.

If you compare us to something like Mississippi State:

Mississippi State
14-8 (5-4)
1-6 Q1 (win @ #42 Florida)
3-0 Q2
5-2 Q3 (losses vs #83 Louisiana Tech, vs #114 New Mexico State)
5-0 Q4
#41 NET, #39 KenPom

Rutgers
16-7 (7-5)
3-5 Q1 (wins vs #13 Seton Hall, vs #20 Penn State, vs #29 Purdue)
3-1 Q2
2-1 Q3 (loss vs #119 St Bonaventure (neutral)
7-0 Q4
#27 NET, #28 KenPom

They were put there for purpose to cut down on analysis somewhat. Had no cluue Iowa would lay a brainfart and Vandy stunning Lsu. Both should be alright in the long run though and as i go further in i will revisit that.
 

fluoxetine

Heisman
Nov 11, 2012
23,529
16,898
0
Fair enough. I didn't realize you had put that together before yesterday's Iowa / LSU results.

I mean, they are still virtual locks anyway.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
Fair enough. I didn't realize you had put that together before yesterday's Iowa / LSU results.

I mean, they are still virtual locks anyway.


as to your other points, not big fans of St Marys and BYU...yes they have great metrics but really neither has a win over Gonzaga and until they do that they are going to be vulnerable. BYU lost at Gonzaga by 23 while the Gaels have two more to go. BYU's best win was Houston I think has a poor resume themselves and St Mary's. St Mary's best wins are Wisconsin and BYU. I realize slack has to be given because they are in a midmajor but for me to move them up the seeding list they will have to keep winning...alot. Right now I have them as 9 seeds. I dont think they deserve better seeds that Big 10 schools.

also not a big fan of the Pac 12, Stanford has a few red flags. Stanford has a win over Oregon and that is basically it. Their next best win is Oklahoma. That is a weak resume.

when I got to the last 2 in line, I was throwing darts at that point. A ton of undeserving teams. I was stumped. Finally through out Virginia, wanted to throw VCU but kept them and added Mississippi State. These are all weak sauce resumes. Virginia has only one win of note...a big win in Florida State but nothing else..next biggest win is Arizona State who is trash.

I don't like Cincy..wins over Houston/Tulsa okay not bad but 0-4 in Q1 and then 3 Q3 losses...now one was to Bowling Green who may be the MAC winner but also losses to Tulane and Colgate. Its going to be too much to overcome and the AAC is not a good league this year. I do not expect Tulsa to win the league and get an at large. I see 2 maybe a third when all is said and done. Not a fan of Houston and where are the wins with Memphis.


Appreciate your commentary and can talk about this for hours. Love to hear different opinions
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,306
182,409
113
The committee uses the NET to help them, not as the end all ... right? Then there are also the logistic considerations like making sure B1G teams don’t play each other before the Sweet Sixteen and trying not to punish top seeds too badly (e.g., hypothetically sending a 1-seed to Tulsa one year where they could play an 8-seed Oklahoma or something).

I think the human element will make its way in some how and punish Ohio State a bit more than their NET, not much but a bit. Also, it’ll obviously be all about how we finish. OSU will not have that ranking in two weeks, if you ask me.


OSU has a very good resume right now, do not look at the conference record. They are playing very well right now. They just won a big game at Michigan. No one can take away their wins vs Nova and Kentucky. Its a better resume than RU and Illinois at this point. I see them in the 4 to 7 range when all is said and done

and the NET is a sorting tool a very important one but there are other variables that the committee balance within it. So you can have a school with a 20 net get seeded 7th and not a 5 seed. Or you can have a school make it with a 50 NET while one at 36 gets left out of the field
 

RU MAN

Heisman
Oct 29, 2001
23,760
10,496
113
I just noticed our NET rankings improved from 29 to 27. It shows that we need Seton Hall to keep winning with all the other teams we've beaten thus far. Now, we can cement our chances by taking care of business at home and holding serve. Do I want one more road win? Of course. But if we hold serve we're in.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's UNLV Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball defeats UNLV, earns 7th place in Players Era 8