you are making the assumption of Corey as team player and one that would distribute the ball. The Freshmen would not have the voices on the team like they do now. You really think that Corey would defer to freshmen...and Caleb would not even be on the floor in fact Caleb wouldnt even be at RU
When has Corey ever had a supporting cast? If you remember his freshman year, he was throwing great passes that our bigs dropped or could not handle. Chemistry was growing between him and Geo last year and playing with a senior and a sophomore in this rough Big 10 as compared to freshman , who have really played well and are really coming on,is a better recipe for success. This is the first season since Echneque that we actually have a low post offensive game, so don’t you think Corey would be feeding the post more , instead of our offense being stagnant and he being asked to bale us out with less than 8 on the shot clock? You think he wouldn’t be throwing the lobs to Doorson that he has been dunking the last 5-6 games. I will tell you one thing that we would not see, and that is lousy ball handling , that we were getting from Geo, and led to some vicious posts on this board, about Geo. Corey could never be pressed and rarely did his handle cause turnovers and run outs by the other team. Have I mentioned his defense yet? No, it was outstanding last year and probably would have been the same and we would not have been torched by some point guard’s this year.
The only point you make is about Caleb, who I know we got later after Corey declared but Pike has found a way to slowly bring his freshman along and that still would have occurred with Corey. Plus you would still have a go to scorer at crunch time that we could go to just like Purdue has Edwards and Michigan State has Winston . In fact, the way Winston leads Michigan State by feeding their bigs but also knowing when it is time to score and he does it , would be how I envision this year playing out.
I like how this team is turning out and their toughness, but claiming we are better off without one of the better players in the Big 10 is just lunacy