How would Rutgers do running an Army type offense?

Nov 10, 2003
11,777
3,298
0
I'm sure it would kill recruiting certain types of QB's and WR's but if Army can succeed with a much smaller pool of kids to pick from, I would think Rutgers could have pretty good success with it. Lets face it Schiano and many other coaches have said it's a pain to prepare for given the fact hardly anyone runs it and players hate getting their legs tangled up in their type of blocking schemes. We are NEVER going to match up with the big boys running conventional offenses, and our defense needs to be off the field way more than it is with so many 3 and outs. We've tried the Pro Set, Spread,West Coast and most recent the **** Show Offense, so I'm ready to see them run it. Doesn't Georgia Tech run something similar?
 

shakes3858

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2009
22,143
1,079
0
I'm sure it would kill recruiting certain types of QB's and WR's but if Army can succeed with a much smaller pool of kids to pick from, I would think Rutgers could have pretty good success with it. Lets face it Schiano and many other coaches have said it's a pain to prepare for given the fact hardly anyone runs it and players hate getting their legs tangled up in their type of blocking schemes. We are NEVER going to match up with the big boys running conventional offenses, and our defense needs to be off the field way more than it is with so many 3 and outs. We've tried the Pro Set, Spread,West Coast and most recent the **** Show Offense, so I'm ready to see them run it. Doesn't Georgia Tech run something similar?
Please don't. I don't want to see that offense in the Big Ten as I like the health and safety of the players in the league. No need to bring in an offense where you dive at the Dline's knees EVERY PLAY.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rokodesh

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,838
50,365
98
It works because it slow down the game and gives teams less chances to score on you. It also works because it's not common and as a result, todays athletes tend to ignore their assignments. The MLB gets tired of hitting the football who never gets the ball on every play. When his eyes start to wander the FB goes for 18yds.
 

BlockR

Heisman
Dec 28, 2015
23,169
22,174
113
it only really works at service academies who run it out of need.
That said Monken is a great motivator as a head Coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: R U Crazy

BoogieKnight

Heisman
Oct 15, 2007
70,943
17,477
82
it only really works at service academies

Not true at all.

If you want to be competitive playing college football and don't care about recruiting/developing pro's on offense than it would work here too. It's dated in the modern game but Notre Dame, West Virginia and Nebraska all ran it in the late 80's. The Huskers ran it into the 90's. Syracuse ran the "freeze option" even with McNabb. Notre Dame's last national championship came running the option.

I'd hire Monken in a second but I doubt he'd take this job.
 

shakes3858

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2009
22,143
1,079
0
The spread was designed to even the playing field with the right coaching and right personnel. Not sure why Ash didn't stick with it in year 2
Not sure about that anymore. The spread was designed to get the ball to the outside away from bigger and stronger front 7s. Now the OSUs and Alabamas of the world have elite players on the outside and no how to defend against a spread.
 

sherrane

All-Conference
Aug 17, 2003
10,560
1,309
0
I know, but I thought they ran that before Paul Johnson and that was a reason they hired him. I could be wrong.

Johnson's flexbone was never run in the BCS / P5 conference before. Georgia Tech was coached by Chan Gailey and George O'Leary prior to Johnson. Gailey's and O'Leary's had some option plays, but were not option offenses. O'Leary's OC was Ralph Friedgen who did have some QB running plays / options with Joe Hamilton at QB.
 
  • Like
Reactions: angmo and studed

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
27,144
19,426
113
Let's leave this year out of the equation. Look at where Georgia Tech generally ends up, a middle of the pack ACC team. That translates to a typical finish at 4th place in the B1G East, maybe 5th. And that's NOT where most of the people here want this team to be long term. And you'd never recruit the offensive talent, long term, to do better than that.
 

tico brown

Heisman
Oct 16, 2005
45,073
15,222
93
I'm sure it would kill recruiting certain types of QB's and WR's but if Army can succeed with a much smaller pool of kids to pick from, I would think Rutgers could have pretty good success with it. Lets face it Schiano and many other coaches have said it's a pain to prepare for given the fact hardly anyone runs it and players hate getting their legs tangled up in their type of blocking schemes. We are NEVER going to match up with the big boys running conventional offenses, and our defense needs to be off the field way more than it is with so many 3 and outs. We've tried the Pro Set, Spread,West Coast and most recent the **** Show Offense, so I'm ready to see them run it. Doesn't Georgia Tech run something similar?
Ive been saying this for years in trying to get Coach Ken Niumatalolo and now Jeff Monken. But fans rather lose in Pro Offense because "thats run on Sundays" then compete with the TO with above coaches or within their coaching trees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BoogieKnight

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,838
50,365
98
Let's leave this year out of the equation. Look at where Georgia Tech generally ends up, a middle of the pack ACC team. That translates to a typical finish at 4th place in the B1G East, maybe 5th. And that's NOT where most of the people here want this team to be long term. And you'd never recruit the offensive talent, long term, to do better than that.
People who wouldn’t be sold on being 4th place most years in the BIG east need to be medicated.
 

BoogieKnight

Heisman
Oct 15, 2007
70,943
17,477
82
Let's leave this year out of the equation. Look at where Georgia Tech generally ends up, a middle of the pack ACC team. That translates to a typical finish at 4th place in the B1G East, maybe 5th. And that's NOT where most of the people here want this team to be long term. And you'd never recruit the offensive talent, long term, to do better than that.
People who wouldn’t be sold on being 4th place most years in the BIG east need to be medicated.

Lol you beat me to it. 4th place in the division beats losing by 40 to the likes of Kansas, Buffalo and Illinois.

The option would make teams have to take us serious each week. You know, what Ash promised when hired but hasn’t delivered and actually made us worse.

We need to become a tough team to beat before we can even dream of being a winning team in this division.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
27,144
19,426
113
People who wouldn’t be sold on being 4th place most years in the BIG east need to be medicated.

This year that's true. But that certainly was not what I was hearing 3-4 years ago. I think you've got a little shorttermitis going on.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,838
50,365
98
This year that's true. But that certainly was not what I was hearing 3-4 years ago. I think you've got a little shorttermitis going on.
Nope. I have said over and over we would never consistently our recruit OSU, Michigan, PSU, and most likely MSU. If you can't consistently out recruit team you aren't beating them on a regular basis. 4th place means you beat at lease one giant every year.
 

ivan brunetti

Heisman
Nov 26, 2003
16,448
26,638
0
"most" run some variation of spread. I'd say the NW/Kill Minnesota version. Spread but normal tempo.

I think most high schools across the country now run some form of spread. The game is evolving, as always.

I think running an option attack could work to a point; but you would doom yourselves to missing out on much of the best high school offensive talent coming out of NJ. Just find yourself a Jeff Brohm.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
14,449
13,339
113
So for the time being, do you want to prepare whoever comes goes to Rutgers for the college game or the pros? Especially since the last part havent been working for a while.

You (many others - including McNulty) have it slightly wrong though.

Our current offense isn't being run on Sundays.
Well, unless you only watch the Giants (which I suspect most people do).

Ask any Eagles fan on here if we run a "pro-style"? We don't. We run an outdated, meathead pro-style from 10 years ago.

Look at KC, Rams, Eagles, NE.
The top teams are running up tempo, lots of motion, move the QB around. 11 personnel (1te, 1rb) is the base offense.

Not the Rutgers - 1rb 3TE, never move the QB offense.
 

miketd1

Heisman
Sep 26, 2006
59,714
13,917
66
Give me Indiana's offense:
  • mostly spread formations
  • mobile QB who's pass first, but is as likely to convert 3rd and medium with his legs
  • bubble screens
  • downfield shots
  • zone running
  • variable tempo depending on game situation
 

miketd1

Heisman
Sep 26, 2006
59,714
13,917
66
Ask any Eagles fan on here if we run a "pro-style"? We don't. We run an outdated, meathead pro-style from 10 years ago.
Eagles run perhaps the most multiple offense in football at any level.

I have seen them gameplan tempo, spread, inside/outside zone, RPO-heavy, out of mainly "11" personnel.

And I have also seen them bring out multiple TEs and even a FB once in a while to run power and even trap(!).

I haven't even mentioned all the different one-off gadget and red-zone plays we have seen under Pederson...
 

tico brown

Heisman
Oct 16, 2005
45,073
15,222
93
You (many others - including McNulty) have it slightly wrong though.

Our current offense isn't being run on Sundays.
Well, unless you only watch the Giants (which I suspect most people do).

Ask any Eagles fan on here if we run a "pro-style"? We don't. We run an outdated, meathead pro-style from 10 years ago.

Look at KC, Rams, Eagles, NE.
The top teams are running up tempo, lots of motion, move the QB around. 11 personnel (1te, 1rb) is the base offense.

Not the Rutgers - 1rb 3TE, never move the QB offense.
Id be happy if Rutgers were wise to run what the RPOs that the Eagles, NE, KC are currently running. But most definitions of Pro Style here is still that old school 2 back, 1 TE offense that Schiano and Golden preferred. Heck. Bama and Wisconsin don't run pro style anymore.
 

BoogieKnight

Heisman
Oct 15, 2007
70,943
17,477
82
the type of kids who you would then recruit wouldnt be the ones who are full bore NFL 'athletic' type.

OK and? We are in the business of trying to win games on Saturdays, not prepare kids for Sundays. We've already shown we can send a bunch of kids to the NFL which wasn't happening in great numbers prior to Schiano (it was but RU pros were few and far between). We need to compete and win in our own division. And we could still recruit and develop defensive players with pro potential.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,838
50,365
98
Eagles run perhaps the most multiple offense in football at any level.

I have seen them gameplan tempo, spread, inside/outside zone, RPO-heavy, out of mainly "11" personnel.

And I have also seen them bring out multiple TEs and even a FB once in a while to run power and even trap(!).

I haven't even mentioned all the different one-off gadget and red-zone plays we have seen under Pederson...
I don’t like McNulty hire but I had hoped he would do this. I thought the year with Marriotta might have been the prep for an Eagle type O
 

miketd1

Heisman
Sep 26, 2006
59,714
13,917
66
I don’t like McNulty hire but I had hoped he would do this. I thought the year with Marriotta might have been the prep for an Eagle type O
While I love the Eagles offense, I don't think it's practical at the college level.

In the pros, you have lots of time to practice and far more roster continuity, especially at QB and OL.

I mean, it can be done, certainly. Chris Petersen does it. Jimbo Fisher as well.

But they normally enjoy a talent advantage. One could make a legit argument that they'd probably be successful regardless of what type of offense they ran.
 

tico brown

Heisman
Oct 16, 2005
45,073
15,222
93
While I love the Eagles offense, I don't think it's practical at the college level.

In the pros, you have lots of time to practice and far more roster continuity, especially at QB and OL.

I mean, it can be done, certainly. Chris Petersen does it. Jimbo Fisher as well.

But they normally enjoy a talent advantage. One could make a legit argument that they'd probably be successful regardless of what type of offense they ran.
If HS teams can run RPOs well, im sure a B1G team can.
 

studed

All-Conference
Mar 4, 2006
76,604
3,607
113
Let's leave this year out of the equation. Look at where Georgia Tech generally ends up, a middle of the pack ACC team. That translates to a typical finish at 4th place in the B1G East, maybe 5th. And that's NOT where most of the people here want this team to be long term. And you'd never recruit the offensive talent, long term, to do better than that.
G tech is still putting up good numbers this year on offense. they average 37.3 ppg and average 453 yards per game.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Staff Predictions for Rutgers Football versus Penn State
  2. 02 The Knight Report How to watch Rutgers / Penn State; Pregame Info, Spread, More: Gameday Central
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod