Montez Mathis on ESPNU right now vs Hudson Catholic

NewJerseyHawk

Heisman
Jan 11, 2007
24,963
40,177
113
Pike and Brandon Knight under basket courtside...Quinerly helped Mathis up after he was fouled by one of Quinerly's teammates...that would be one combo of a 3 guard alignment with Baker
 

RU_fan435

Sophomore
Dec 6, 2017
98
103
0
Mathis looks good. A little raw when he’s not driving but he’s big for a guard and Pikiell and staff will develop him really well
 

BoxStater

Sophomore
Nov 28, 2017
165
110
0
Seems Mathis is going to need some work, especially with outside shooting, before he becomes an impact player as a freshman. He’s kind of disappeared in midst of the talent of the opposition.
 

NewJerseyHawk

Heisman
Jan 11, 2007
24,963
40,177
113
There's a stark difference between a one and two and done which is what king a d Quinerly and a normal 4 year starter in Mathis or Geo Baker. Mathis will be an immediate impact player at RU...
 
  • Like
Reactions: satnom

TDIrish27

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2001
4,438
2,666
0
Hawk I don't question that but would he be an immediate impact player at school's in the Top 5-6 in this league ?

I don't watch Highlight Tapes-----they don't mean much to me but watching him today his shot needs work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BoxStater

NewJerseyHawk

Heisman
Jan 11, 2007
24,963
40,177
113
I can rewind the same thing from last year talking about Baker....needs to work on his shot, not going to have much of an impact etc....shooting is one of 5 ways to impact a game....can he rebound, defend, dribble pass and shoot??

I'm not sure what fans are watching but player projection and development is what fans miss...no 16-17 year old enters college as a finished product and every evaluation mentioned he was not an elite shooter.

I guess my question is if the player is not a 1 and done player, there are things the prospect needs work with...even a player as talented as Quinerly, lacks strength, and isn't a knock down shooter.

The build of the program when you aren't landing 5* talents is recruiting at the level of your peers, building your roster and player development. Mathis and Baker with the others fit that profile. It looks worse because every other program has an established or coach that has their system in place and in almost every case, 3 to 5 years of players as upper classmen in most cases, filtered in and out of their programs.

I would place Mathis right up there with the other freshman in the B1G right now from Maryland, Nebraska, Iowa, and in some cases the majority of the programs in our league (yes even Ohio State, Michigan etc). Comparing them to 1 and done as a freshman, probably isn't a good idea on evaluation of a player. I would give the player a full 1.5 seasons before trying to determine what you have.
 
Last edited:

RU-ROCS

All-American
Feb 5, 2003
12,528
7,807
113
It seems that guys that can shoot right away choose other schools year after year.

Many good shooters don’t shoot well “right away.” Purdue is perhaps the best 3 point shooting team in the conference this year. But, take a look at the stats of their seniors guards. They were not very good three-point shooters as freshman. Mathias shot 32%, but now shoots 46%, Edwards went from 32% to 44% and Thompson went from 28% to 48%! A lot of freshman take time to acclimate to the size and speed of the game. I think Baker will be a very good one for RU.
 

TDIrish27

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2001
4,438
2,666
0
Rocs

32 % is pretty good shooting----when you're above 40 you're outstanding.

I'm not saying don't take Mathis--------that's silly bordering on ridiculous.

I'm saying this program needs guys who can shoot and a priority should be put on getting some guys in here who can do that be they JC's , Frosh or Grad Transfers. Coach P is certainly aware of that I'm sure and is trying to get that done.

The question ultimately comes down to what are you willing to sacrifice to bring in a shooter or shooters ? Is it height , strength , athleticism ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: G- RUnit

RUsojo

Heisman
Dec 17, 2010
30,229
29,693
113
OK

I'm old school------if you're a Guard you need to be a good shooter.

That’s not just old school that’s new school too.

Rocs

32 % is pretty good shooting----when you're above 40 you're outstanding.

I'm not saying don't take Mathis--------that's silly bordering on ridiculous.

I'm saying this program needs guys who can shoot and a priority should be put on getting some guys in here who can do that be they JC's , Frosh or Grad Transfers. Coach P is certainly aware of that I'm sure and is trying to get that done.

The question ultimately comes down to what are you willing to sacrifice to bring in a shooter or shooters ? Is it height , strength , athleticism ?

32% is below average. Definitely not good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kcg88

RutgHoops

Heisman
Aug 14, 2008
9,261
12,466
102
Mathis reminds me a bit of Eli Carter. Mathis has the one skill I consider the most valuable for a college player; the ability to put the ball in the basket. Defense, rebounding, the ability to play within a college offense, not taking plays off, conditioning, etc. are skills that can be taught and/or developed (in my opinion) by a good staff which I believe we have. The ability to score, at the college level, is an immensely valuable skill. Mathis looks like a kid who has the potential to score at this level.
 

KnightsofChrome

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2012
3,829
1,076
0
OK

I'm old school------if you're a Guard you need to be a good shooter.
And, in HS dominate the opposition, if Div. I is your goal. But, at the very least control the tempo of the game. I don't buy into this, "he is just a 15/16 yr old" mentality. Players don't change who they are, with age. To me he has a shooters mentality, which is shoot first, pass second. And, that's alright, as long as you can shoot, and create shots. Based on his performance against, better competition, he struggled.
 

zebnatto

All-Conference
May 7, 2008
5,071
3,818
0
To the guys with a better insider's perspective: My impression has always been that the Catholic High Schools steer kids to Catholic colleges (Villanova, Seton Hall, etc) or elite non-Catholics (Duke, Kentucky), making it real difficult for RU to compete for 4*+ talent. You think?
 

RutgHoops

Heisman
Aug 14, 2008
9,261
12,466
102
And, in HS dominate the opposition, if Div. I is your goal. But, at the very least control the tempo of the game. I don't buy into this, "he is just a 15/16 yr old" mentality. Players don't change who they are, with age. To me he has a shooters mentality, which is shoot first, pass second. And, that's alright, as long as you can shoot, and create shots. Based on his performance against, better competition, he struggled.

That was not normal high school competition. Hudson Catholic has six, maybe seven kids who will play college basketball and (at least) four that will play at the high major level. The Carroll kid going to Kentucky (Quickley) didn't "dominate" that game. Hudson Catholic's 6th and 7th best players would be the 3rd and 4th best players on Carroll. To expect Mathis to dominate is folly. There aren't going to be many players who play against Hudson Catholic who put 22 points up versus them.
 

KnightsofChrome

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2012
3,829
1,076
0
That was not normal high school competition. Hudson Catholic has six, maybe seven kids who will play college basketball and (at least) four that will play at the high major level. The Carroll kid going to Kentucky (Quickley) didn't "dominate" that game. Hudson Catholic 6th and 7th best players would be the 3rd and 4th best players on Carroll. To expect Mathis to dominate is folly. There aren't going to be many players who play against Hudson Catholic who put 22 points up versus them.
No, I agree. And, I stated that. But, it's how you play the game. And, I just felt he looked overwhelmed, 22 points or not. Don't get me wrong, it was just one game. I was looking at his mechanics, and how reacted to the type of pressure HC gave him.
 

TDIrish27

All-Conference
Aug 2, 2001
4,438
2,666
0
32 % is decent 3 point shooting for a frosh at the college level

I expect Baker will be around there at years end.
 

PatrickRU92

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
42,265
17,279
82
3 point shooting percentage is certainly nice to look at . But it doesn't necessarily point to who is the "best" or "better" shooters.

Who's the best shooter in the NBA? If you say anyone other than Curry I'd laugh. Pretty sure he isn't the highest percentage 3 point shooter, quite possibly even on the team.

you can tell who the guys who can shoot and who can't . Just use your eyes. I like statistics too but they are not the whole story.
 

RU-ROCS

All-American
Feb 5, 2003
12,528
7,807
113
Rocs

32 % is pretty good shooting----when you're above 40 you're outstanding.

I'm not saying don't take Mathis--------that's silly bordering on ridiculous.

I'm saying this program needs guys who can shoot and a priority should be put on getting some guys in here who can do that be they JC's , Frosh or Grad Transfers. Coach P is certainly aware of that I'm sure and is trying to get that done.

The question ultimately comes down to what are you willing to sacrifice to bring in a shooter or shooters ? Is it height , strength , athleticism ?

I guess we just disagree on what is a good 3-point shooter. If 32% is the standard than we already have a couple good shooters on the team - with Thiam (39%) and Baker (34%), and last year Williams (32%). I think a good 3-point shooter is closer to 40% and a great 3-point shooter is someone who shoots closer to 45%. But, this is admittedly subjective. Having said that, I do agree with you that a freshman who shoots 32% may well become a very good shooter because, as noted above, many good shooting freshman take at least a year to adjust to the speed and size of the college game. I think Thiam and Baker will end up being very good 3-point shooters in the future (Thiam is already at 39% as a sophomore showing great improvement from last year). But, I agree that RU needs to add more. I think Kiss may be another good shooter, although he shot only 28% from 3 as a freshman so that remains to be seen.
 

Scarlet Blind_rivals

All-Conference
Aug 5, 2001
4,743
4,819
62
There is a difference when you are playing with your High School team compared to AAU ball but he produces the same numbers in AAU ball as his HS team. He is well respected by all peers in top 100. He will be an impact freshman like Geo and produce similar numbers to Geo probably less assists more rebounds.
 

G- RUnit

All-American
Sep 13, 2004
14,418
8,038
113
We need shooters period. It’s a whole new ball game.

Duke has a freshman shooter who has just hit six 3’s in consecutive games.

Do we need to look at Oklahoma?

Gotta be able to shoot!
 
Last edited:
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game