PSU/OSU
- Thread starter RU206
- Start date
Well psu can't ever say they don't get the calls. I have no idea how they overturned that one.
I’m actually surprised they called an INT initially. Tie usually goes to the WR in that instance.
Well if we were the refs it looked like an int. to me. Indisputable evidence Int. stands. Remember it's not supposed to be a guess but indisputable evidence, I didn't see any. Call on the field should have stood either way TD or Int..
I think the ref didn't know who had it and was just seeing who had it last, not really noticing who had it first. I thought the evidence was good enough to overturn it myself.
They do that often though like I was saying above. He gets it near the receivers and they do a nice job of adjusting or going up getting it.
Dear Kim Jong Un,
40.7982° N
77.8599° W
Sincerely,
America
40.7982° N
77.8599° W
Sincerely,
America
Was just going to post something along that line. 35 points with fthat talent. He better get used too Columbus
B10/Delany like the BE in that WVU/Pitt game some time back. At least that's the thinking.
It would take an unlikely scenario for the B10 not to have a rep in the playoff most years. So as long as there is a rep I don't think he or the B10 cares who it is.
When I think applicable, not today though.
What I do know, is it damn sure wasn't the refs
I thought #3 controlled the bal with his left hand against his shoulder all the way to the ground and only after they were both on the ground the os guy pulled it away. Just my opinion but I thought it was pretty clearly a td.
I thought the OSU defender had a hand in their and a lot of jostling of the ball to the ground. Couldn't tell who had control until on the ground and the defender had it at the end. I likened the play to controlling it through the catch. As there wasn't definitive evidence that he did. Just like the Sterling Shepard play where he didn't control the ball all the way through the catch. So no TD. College rules are the same in that regard.
The refs didn't cause the loss. However had they called the game correctly and fairly then at least we would have had more of a chance. It's not asking for too much to make a proper call. There as absolutely no reason why the refs reviewed the spot to give UM the 1st down and then not review the 4th down, which IMHO was CLEARLY short. Curious as to your thoughts as to why that play wasn't reviewed?
Do you think the hold on Maietti was a good one? That gave UM 7 points. Do you thin UM was holding free for the whole game ?
Do you think that was not a blatant block in the back that was obvious to everyone on a key play ?
And btw I do not subscribe to conspiracy theories either. I don't think they "wanted " UM to win. I'm just tired of being shafted.
Call a ****** call a ****** call.
I have no problem calling a ****** call...******
I have a problem with you thinking refs purposely favor one team over another at this level...especially us, refs have zero reason to hose us.
I don't think they call it against us on purpose. See my "i don't believe in conspiracy theories" quote.
I do think that today we get screwed on several occasions.
Do you think those examples I mentioned were ****** or do you think the refs got it right?
I felt that way too on one of the replays but from another I thought it was clearly a catch and it was not a fight until they were both on the ground.
probably has a little something to do with having the best player in college football along with one of the top5 QBs
Well our Purdue game we were outgained and won. We had some good STs with the punter that day. PSU has had 2 KO returns leading to 14 pts. A few other big plays as well just like we had a couple big plays against Purdue.
Ok, I can buy that.
But when your O line is constantly fighting penetration and getting beat, your going to get called.
When your D line doesn't penetrate and cause havoc, you wont get calls
Schiano's defense is not responsible for the kickoff return TD that started the game and not fully responsible for the TD on the short field after that other huge kickoff return. Two borderline calls in the end zone (although I thought the PSU guy did have the ball first on that play) for another 14 pts. (Yeah, I know they didn't get the calls.make the plays.)
Exciting game.
Exciting game.