Expand to 6 not 8

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
I agree, it will be expanded because of money. But when you have a perfect 13-0 team NOT able to play for a Championship, that's not fair.

Who did they beat to make you think they deserved anything other than a shot to play in a major bowl game?

When Rutgers went undefeated they didn't finished in the top 4 either. It was true then and it is true now.

Schedule matters a lot.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
Who did they beat to make you think they deserved anything other than a shot to play in a major bowl game?

When Rutgers went undefeated they didn't finished in the top 4 either. It was true then and it is true now.

Schedule matters a lot.

They beat everybody they played. That's all they could do.

The best Group of 5 team plays in a New Years Bowl anyway, guaranteed....

Why not make it mean something?
 

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
They beat everybody they played. That's all they could do.

The best Group of 5 team plays in a New Years Bowl anyway, guaranteed....

Why not make it mean something?

It does mean something, they get a chance at playing for a major bowl title.

Do you honestly think that any team from any group of five conference could even hang with Bama or Clemson this year? REALLY?

OSU and UW couldn't even do that, and both would crush boat rowing team.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
It does mean something, they get a chance at playing for a major bowl title.

Do you honestly think that any team from any group of five conference could even hang with Bama or Clemson this year? REALLY?

OSU and UW couldn't even do that, and both would crush boat rowing team.

All I know is Western Michigan SHOULD HAVE gotten the chance to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loyal-Son

JQRU91

All-Conference
Apr 6, 2013
1,855
1,386
0
Six teams may not be a bad idea, but it will never happen. There's more money to be made going to eight.
 

BigLou

All-Conference
Jul 25, 2001
11,572
2,883
63
Did you watch this year's Rose Bowl? Did you watch this year's Cotton Bowl? Did you watch this year's Orange Bowl? Did you watch this year's Sugar Bowl?

You're telling me you wouldn't watch these 4 games, if they meant the winner would go to the Semis? Just cause they aren't the best teams?

Under my plan,

1. Alabama vs. 8. Western Michigan - Sugar, (much more intrigue than Auburn/Oklahoma)
2. Clemson vs. 7. Michigan - Orange - (Similar matchup with FSU/Michigan...but meaningful.)
3. Washington vs. 6. Ohio State - Rose - (Similar to USC/Penn State, but again, meaningful.)
4. Penn State vs. 5. Oklahoma - Cotton - (Blows out Wisconsin/Western Michigan.)

No way the New Years bowls agree to host quarterfinal games. Attendance would suffer-bowl travel is expensive and fans will travel once. If you go to 8 first game has to be on campus before Christmas. Of course than exams get in the way. In other words it ain't happening.
 

RUfinal4

All-Conference
Apr 24, 2006
15,759
1,931
0
Playoffs may never happen because of E$PN. Since they broadcast like all but 4 or 5 bowl games they control the inventory.

They want at least 1 game a night during prime time from Dec 17-Dec 27 before the bigger bowl games start.

If you have an 8 team playoff you are more likely to have games on Fridays and Saturdays the weekends of Dec 17th, New Years weekend, and the week after. You would need a plan to keep the inventory at bowl sites for the 2 weeks at the end of December.

It may work if:
Dec 16 / 17 - playoff quarterfinals on campus
Dec 18-27 regular bowl games for teams not in the top 8 (most likely G5 teams and 6-6 / 7-5 P5 teams)
Dec 28 - 30 - higher tier bowl games for mostly P5 teams that are 7-5 and 8-4
Dec 31 - semifinals
Dec 31 / Jan 1 - higher tier bowl games for losers of the Dec 16/17 games (ie. Michigan, FSU, USC, Oklahoma, etc...)

You would need bowl games for the losers of the quarterfinals for:
- bowls to have their traditional teams they want
- fans who want to see their team in a vacation location
- to prevent a coop where the bowls try work a deal with the P5 conferences to break away from the NCAA
- appease the networks (ESPN) since they make a lot of money with the bowls.
 

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
51,266
63,357
113
Shrink the regular season to 9 games, use the results for seeding, and go to a 128 team playoff. That's the only fair way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loyal-Son

RU MAN

Heisman
Oct 29, 2001
23,760
10,496
113
Had to wait for the PSU loss before posting.

I dislike the subjectivity and politics surrounding the selection of the four "best" teams for the playoffs. Not to mention a Power 5 champ being left out. Make the Regular season count.

With a 6 team field you can take all five power 5 champs (Big 12 Campionship is coming). For the 6th slot you "award" the best remaining power 5 team OR You can award a deserving Group of 5 team (if they have a truly remarkable year).

The only subjective decisions that have to be made are which are the top 2 teams (they would get a first round bye) and which team deserves the 6th spot. You play your way in by winning your conference.... SIMPLE, FAIR, and IN LINE with every other sport where you are awarded for earning it and not just looking like you did.

Thoughts?
I actually like your idea, but thinking more about it, having six teams lends itself to more politics of who are the "best" top two. I say settle it on the field and have eight.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
Did you watch this year's Rose Bowl? Did you watch this year's Cotton Bowl? Did you watch this year's Orange Bowl? Did you watch this year's Sugar Bowl?

You're telling me you wouldn't watch these 4 games, if they meant the winner would go to the Semis? Just cause they aren't the best teams?

Under my plan,

1. Alabama vs. 8. Western Michigan - Sugar, (much more intrigue than Auburn/Oklahoma)
2. Clemson vs. 7. Michigan - Orange - (Similar matchup with FSU/Michigan...but meaningful.)
3. Washington vs. 6. Ohio State - Rose - (Similar to USC/Penn State, but again, meaningful.)
4. Penn State vs. 5. Oklahoma - Cotton - (Blows out Wisconsin/Western Michigan.)

No way the New Years bowls agree to host quarterfinal games. Attendance would suffer-bowl travel is expensive and fans will travel once. If you go to 8 first game has to be on campus before Christmas. Of course than exams get in the way. In other words it ain't happening.

Legitimate gripe...but they said the same thing before they expanded to four..that attendance would be affected by the extra game. Hasn't happened.

I think bowls would be fine with qtrfinal games...if not I wouldn't be totally opposed to playing round of 8 on campuses
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
All I know is Western Michigan SHOULD HAVE gotten the chance to.


WHY? they couldnt even beat Wisconsin who you left off, why shouldnt Wisconsin get the chance instead of them

As I've stated many times..they didn't lose all season. It's ridiculous they didn't get a chance. Why should any MAC teams play any games if wins are meaningless???

As far as Wisconsin, they didn't win their conference. PSU did. Hence, wisky isn't in, and psu was. Has PSU lost conf champ to Wiscy, they'd be out and badgers in.

Ohio State and michigan, imo, had best resumes of teams who didn't win CC. Hence they are in. Of course, that sets up controversy..can't avoid it totally.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
In this case... It called being in the MAC.

Not disagreeing, but then are MAC wins meaningless? Why does the MAC even have football? Why is the MAC FBS? All adds to the ridiculousness of the system of crowning a FBS champion if half the FBS doesn't even have the chance.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,298
182,392
113
As I've stated many times..they didn't lose all season. It's ridiculous they didn't get a chance. Why should any MAC teams play any games if wins are meaningless???

As far as Wisconsin, they didn't win their conference. PSU did. Hence, wisky isn't in, and psu was. Has PSU lost conf champ to Wiscy, they'd be out and badgers in.

Ohio State and michigan, imo, had best resumes of teams who didn't win CC. Hence they are in. Of course, that sets up controversy..can't avoid it totally.


because they are not at the big boy plate when it comes to determining the national champion..too bad, there are plenty of bowls for them to go to, 30 years ago they would be going to the Independence Bowl with that unbeaten record to face 6-4-1 No Carolina State, they should be happy
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
As I've stated many times..they didn't lose all season. It's ridiculous they didn't get a chance. Why should any MAC teams play any games if wins are meaningless???

As far as Wisconsin, they didn't win their conference. PSU did. Hence, wisky isn't in, and psu was. Has PSU lost conf champ to Wiscy, they'd be out and badgers in.

Ohio State and michigan, imo, had best resumes of teams who didn't win CC. Hence they are in. Of course, that sets up controversy..can't avoid it totally.


because they are not at the big boy plate when it comes to determining the national champion..too bad, there are plenty of bowls for them to go to, 30 years ago they would be going to the Independence Bowl with that unbeaten record to face 6-4-1 No Carolina State, they should be happy

Its very bad..which is why I'm trying to come up with a way to include them.

FBS should only be the power 5 conferences then.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,298
182,392
113
it basically is already, ever wonder why the bowl tie ins for the MAC, MWC, and AAC are awful
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
it basically is already, ever wonder why the bowl tie ins for the MAC, MWC, and AAC are awful

I agree, though that's another discussion. Why are they FBS then??

So long as all 10 conferences are in FBS, every team should have a chance at the FBS title. They don't as it is now. That's not right, in my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Loyal-Son

FanuSanu52

All-Conference
Nov 8, 2011
11,256
4,618
0
I agree, though that's another discussion. Why are they FBS then??

So long as all 10 conferences are in FBS, every team should have a chance at the FBS title. They don't as it is now. That's not right, in my opinion.

They do, but it's harder for G5s. Undefeated Houston gets in, WMU not so much.
 

Scarlet4ever

All-American
Feb 14, 2004
8,947
7,404
98
Why even have a season. Just pick two teams to play for the championship, and everyone else can go to class. Saves a bunch of time for me. I can do something else on Saturdays. Wouldn't want to waste peoples times with an extra couple of playoff games.
 

Scarlet4ever

All-American
Feb 14, 2004
8,947
7,404
98
Still haven't heard why/how 8 wates down the regular season....

Makes conference wins MUCH more important if CC is guaranteed. And if so, only 2 at-large spots...which makes OOC MUCH more important.

If teams that didn't win their division or conference make the playoff, then it minimizes the importance of some of those in conference games.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
Still haven't heard why/how 8 wates down the regular season....

Makes conference wins MUCH more important if CC is guaranteed. And if so, only 2 at-large spots...which makes OOC MUCH more important.

If teams that didn't win their division or conference make the playoff, then it minimizes the importance of some of those in conference games.

At the end of the year, sure. They don't know that during the season.
 

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
253,298
182,392
113
I agree, though that's another discussion. Why are they FBS then??

So long as all 10 conferences are in FBS, every team should have a chance at the FBS title. They don't as it is now. That's not right, in my opinion.


they have a chance...finish in the top 4
 

Wolv RU

All-Conference
Nov 7, 2003
7,761
2,218
113
If teams that didn't win their division or conference make the playoff, then it minimizes the importance of some of those in conference games.

And if you take only conference champs then the out of conference games mean nothing. Basically, you would encourage a team like Penn state to schedule Louisiana-monroe instead of Pitt in the early season.

The whole season should mean something. Out of conference schedules should matter and count. They don't in many of the revised proposals.

As for going to 8, one example of the regular season being devalued might be this year's Ohio State v. Michigan game. Would not have been nearly as interesting if it was clear prior to the game that both teams would make playoff. That is what would have happened with an 8 team playoff.
 

Mikemarc

Heisman
Nov 28, 2005
69,250
17,980
97
If teams that didn't win their division or conference make the playoff, then it minimizes the importance of some of those in conference games.

And if you take only conference champs then the out of conference games mean nothing. Basically, you would encourage a team like Penn state to schedule Louisiana-monroe instead of Pitt in the early season.

The whole season should mean something. Out of conference schedules should matter and count. They don't in many of the revised proposals.

As for going to 8, one example of the regular season being devalued might be this year's Ohio State v. Michigan game. Would not have been nearly as interesting if it was clear prior to the game that both teams would make playoff. That is what would have happened with an 8 team playoff.

That's just one game. Penn St/Wisconsin would have been much more interesting if they knew the winner would go...works both ways.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball HC Brandin Knight's UNLV Postgame Press Conference
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Basketball defeats UNLV, earns 7th place in Players Era 8