For those call for Ash's head....perspective

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
i am not comparing Ash to Saban but for the sake of some perspective, I figured I'd post some of Saban's early losses along his coaching career:
55-14 Nebraska
51-23 Washington
52-28 Purdue
51-28 PSU
41-9 Florida
31-0 Bama
50-10 Nebraska
38-0 Stanford
Also lost to a sunbelt team
 

RUwoz

All-Conference
Jul 20, 2014
3,266
1,982
0
i am not comparing Ash to Saban but for the sake of some perspective, I figured I'd post some of Saban's early losses along his coaching career:
55-14 Nebraska
51-23 Washington
52-28 Purdue
51-28 PSU
41-9 Florida
31-0 Bama
50-10 Nebraska
38-0 Stanford
Also lost to a sunbelt team
How many of these were with a bad, unestablished MSU team though? I think calling for Ash is stupid, but the frustration is that we have fallen back to being an "unestablished team" and hiring a co-defensive coordinator doesn't put you on the map as much as a big name, splash hire would. Only time will tell if it was a good move in the long run, but in the short run you have to put up with impatient losers on a message board. Check back with me in 3 years
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
How many of these were with a bad, unestablished MSU team though? I think calling for Ash is stupid, but the frustration is that we have fallen back to being an "unestablished team" and hiring a co-defensive coordinator doesn't put you on the map as much as a big name, splash hire would. Only time will tell if it was a good move in the long run, but in the short run you have to put up with impatient losers on a message board. Check back with me in 3 years
I'd imagine the B1G ten teams were with MSU.
 

RU from Jersey_rivals

All-Conference
Jan 16, 2002
2,622
1,655
113
I doubt many are calling for his head, but you have to admit that this team has taken a step backwards. Most would be OK, with taking a step backwards, if RU was playing a lot of Freshmen and Sophs, but when it comes to the D-line, O-line, wideouts and running backs there are many upperclassmen filling those positions. Where is the future? What can we be optimistic about? Hopefully the recruiting class comes through and that is what we are able to hang our hats on.
 

miker183

All-Conference
Sep 13, 2014
2,847
2,191
0
This year's losses are certainly worse than I expected as far as the score goes.

But, we left a couple games on the table; games that might have been won if Grant were available. The problem that I am seeing is, I expected real improvement as the season progressed. We really haven't seen that, so that part is disappointing. It could be any (or all) of talent, depth, or new system, but disheartening to say the least.

I still think Ash can do this job, but I also feel that he has some tough choices from a staff perspective in the off season. Time will tell.
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,305
23,008
0
I get it some people here are big ash people and loved the hire. But to ingbore the facts that he and his staff have looked lost and overmatched. Very questionable coaching and program management. On top of it the team packed it in last week.
So yeah I agree give ash time and hope for the best . But for people to double down on the support of ash right now and ignore the facts is mind boggling.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
I get it some people here are big ash people and loved the hire. But to ingbore the facts that he and his staff have looked lost and overmatched. Very questionable coaching and program management. On top of it the team packed it in last week.
So yeah I agree give ash time and hope for the best . But for people to double down on the support of ash right now and ignore the facts is mind boggling.
And Saban looked overmatched in the games I posted above. Point is you can only do so much as a coach. Is there room for improvement? Lots but slightly better talent puts us at 4 or 5 wins and people are signing a different tune.
 

BlockR

Heisman
Dec 28, 2015
23,170
22,178
113
I trust Ash with the defense,but Merringher has to NOT be the offense Cord next season.Get someone in here that has run an offense in power five prior,not Co cord at JMU.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
92,215
90,378
113
Was not aware people were calling for his head. Everybody needs to calm down about. I don't know where the hysteria is worse right now--Scarlet Nation or CNN. We lost two recruits. Big deal.
BTW, Jim Harbaugh had a very pedestrian year in his first year at Stanford with a couple of blowouts. But he did beat a #2 USC. But he is Jim Harbaugh, and he had 3 years of head coacing experience prior to taking the Stanford job. We have some really impatient fans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RutgersRaRa

Jackson206:)

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2006
3,594
3,304
113
Nobody is happy with the season but it is way to early to pick apart everything that has gone wrong. Bad things get magnified when it isn't working. Belicheck gets vilified in NE for that offensive series at the goal line Sunday night. If Gronk catches that pass no one says jack. If talent level was better, just a small percentage of the things the coaches do would be ripped. And that happens everywhere. If things don't improve by year 3, then there are legitimate issues. But you gotta let it play out.
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
And Saban looked overmatched in the games I posted above. Point is you can only do so much as a coach. Is there room for improvement? Lots but slightly better talent puts us at 4 or 5 wins and people are signing a different tune.
agree you can only do so much but Ash has shown nothing, nada, zip, zero.....
He'll be done in 3 year, 4 cause we're cheap
 

c_husk

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2012
1,543
1,002
113
agree you can only do so much but Ash has shown nothing, nada, zip, zero.....
He'll be done in 3 year, 4 cause we're cheap

He could be coaching and teaching the Melbourn Rebels rugby style tackling at that point. You know , the style where all the defenders look like swimmers when they dive at runners feet and come up for air after they are belly flat on the ground after a complete whiff.
 

RutgersRaRa

Heisman
Mar 21, 2011
19,092
31,448
113
Drama much Op...where are all these people calling for his head and bringing Saban into the conversation to make a point is ludicrous
Some people have been saying Ash has to go, and Opie's point is legitimate. Saban is the Gold Standard in coaching right now, and even he took his lumps early on. Not hard to understand the thought process there.
 

160louis_rivals149488

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2014
4,428
3,565
0
i am not comparing Ash to Saban but for the sake of some perspective, I figured I'd post some of Saban's early losses along his coaching career:
55-14 Nebraska
51-23 Washington
52-28 Purdue
51-28 PSU
41-9 Florida
31-0 Bama
50-10 Nebraska
38-0 Stanford
Also lost to a sunbelt team

Yup. Saban was almost fired from Michigan State and then he went 9-2 in his fifth year. The average college football fan really doesn't understand how long it takes to completely rebuild a program. They look at what Harbaugh is doing at Michigan and what Tom Herman is doing at Houston and want those results. Yet, they completely ignore the struggles people like Mike Macintyre, Brett Bielema, Steve Sarkisian had when they got to a school that needed to be completely rebuilt. Different coaches are handed different situations and the truth is that the coaches can do everything possible and still fail early on because they don't have the players to get them over the hump.

A coach needs at least four years before you can start to even say the word failure unless they're a cronic disaster. In Ash's second year as a head coach his first recruiting class will be freshmen and ultimately most of them won't be able to contribute. Once his fourth year comes around they will all be juniors or RS SO and the line up will consist on the majority of his players. It's at that season that you will be able to fully judge a coach based on on-field results.
 

160louis_rivals149488

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2014
4,428
3,565
0
You can't judge an OC who has no QB
DC is a figure head. This is Ash's D and he's calling it.

Exactly!

VJK, i'm on your side on this one so i'll ask you this. If we beat Maryland do you think our fans, or at least some of them will shut up about the coordinators? I say this because UMD has two ex head coaches on their staff, a much more experienced staff and equal talent level.

I know the answer is going to be no.. but you'd hope it would be yes.
 

c_husk

All-Conference
Nov 11, 2012
1,543
1,002
113
And Saban looked overmatched in the games I posted above. Point is you can only do so much as a coach. Is there room for improvement? Lots but slightly better talent puts us at 4 or 5 wins and people are signing a different tune.

How many of Saban's scores were 78-0 and the opposing team had to hold back from putting up a century on Saban?
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUmonster

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
oh boy. Only the Flood fans who are still upset that he was fired and the Golden Shower fanboys who wish we went with Al Golden as well as random trolls are the only ones calling for his head but they wanted him fired before he moved into his office at the Hale Center, so their opinions are completely worthless.

The Flood damage is real, this season drives that home pretty clearly, only the most clueless people thought we were going to do much this year and after Grant was hurt most people understood that was our season right there since no one else was doing much besides Grant.

Ash was hired for a total and complete rebuild job from the ground up to be model after the best programs in the country. It is going to take years to turn things around. No amount of crying and dumb posts and threads will make that process happen any faster.

Time to face reality.

Recruiting, Recruiting , Recruiting, Recruiting!
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
Yup. Saban was almost fired from Michigan State and then he went 9-2 in his fifth year. The average college football fan really doesn't understand how long it takes to completely rebuild a program. They look at what Harbaugh is doing at Michigan and what Tom Herman is doing at Houston and want those results. Yet, they completely ignore the struggles people like Mike Macintyre, Brett Bielema, Steve Sarkisian had when they got to a school that needed to be completely rebuilt. Different coaches are handed different situations and the truth is that the coaches can do everything possible and still fail early on because they don't have the players to get them over the hump.

A coach needs at least four years before you can start to even say the word failure unless they're a cronic disaster. In Ash's second year as a head coach his first recruiting class will be freshmen and ultimately most of them won't be able to contribute. Once his fourth year comes around they will all be juniors or RS SO and the line up will consist on the majority of his players. It's at that season that you will be able to fully judge a coach based on on-field results.
ok then let's pay him accordingly and use the money on better assistants. You can't have it both ways, the money we pay demands results. He has trouble making adjustments for God's sake and you want to give him 4 years before we judge him?

I'd bet plenty that Shea would have done better this year.
 

RutgersRaRa

Heisman
Mar 21, 2011
19,092
31,448
113
Yup. Saban was almost fired from Michigan State and then he went 9-2 in his fifth year. The average college football fan really doesn't understand how long it takes to completely rebuild a program. They look at what Harbaugh is doing at Michigan and what Tom Herman is doing at Houston and want those results. Yet, they completely ignore the struggles people like Mike Macintyre, Brett Bielema, Steve Sarkisian had when they got to a school that needed to be completely rebuilt. Different coaches are handed different situations and the truth is that the coaches can do everything possible and still fail early on because they don't have the players to get them over the hump.

A coach needs at least four years before you can start to even say the word failure unless they're a cronic disaster. In Ash's second year as a head coach his first recruiting class will be freshmen and ultimately most of them won't be able to contribute. Once his fourth year comes around they will all be juniors or RS SO and the line up will consist on the majority of his players. It's at that season that you will be able to fully judge a coach based on on-field results.
^And this is a good reason to not let a program fall so low. It just takes too long to rebuild, and even that's no guarantee. Look at how long Michigan, who is one of the Bluebloods, sucked under Rich Rod and Brady Hoke, and even their previous coach, Lloyd Carr, had modest success given their resources (3-loss seasons were common under Carr). Harbaugh inherited a talent-rich roster and brought in an experienced staff thanks to an unlimited budget, but he is the exception. Programs that fall have years of rebuilding to do. Will be interesting to see how Oregon and MSU, for example, rebuild.
 

Perricone7

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2015
1,509
2,137
113
Threads like this remind me of the "well look at Wisconsin's recruiting rankings compared to their record" threads back when Flood was stinking it up on the recruiting front. I think the vast majority of the board realizes that Ash can't be fully analyzed until year 3 or so. However, the threads asking for people to find "perspective" after (yet another) ~50 yard passing game is giving me flashbacks to the "Flood is recruiting Rutgers guys" threads from years past.
 

RU85inFla

Heisman
Aug 4, 2003
15,577
10,567
73
Listen, a new coach can show improvement in year 1, it's not forbidden. He can get recruits even when hired late. He can hold classes together. He can get guys to play better than they have in the past. He can get some improvement out of easier areas to improve like special teams. I admit that it takes time to completely rebuild but it does not take time to show even minor improvement.

I will give Ash the benefit of the doubt and say that he has shown the absolute bare minimum amount of improvement that one might expect to see with a new staff that has a 1:50 chance of success. I am disappointed that I have not seen more.
 

RUSK97

All-American
Dec 28, 2007
10,460
6,551
0
Yes, there are about two people on here calling for Ash's head. There are many more, myself included who are questioning one or two of his staff choices. But this is not a thread for now. Ash needs time and most people understand that. I just wish he'd use the time wisely with a new ST coordinator and someone to help out DM.
 

vkj91

Heisman
Feb 7, 2007
188,840
50,367
98
Exactly!

VJK, i'm on your side on this one so i'll ask you this. If we beat Maryland do you think our fans, or at least some of them will shut up about the coordinators? I say this because UMD has two ex head coaches on their staff, a much more experienced staff and equal talent level.

I know the answer is going to be no.. but you'd hope it would be yes.
No. We could win the last two and they'd *****. Most of the people really bitching are trolls anyway
 

RUPete

Heisman
Feb 5, 2003
26,841
16,113
0
I don't see a ton of people calling for his head. I think people are realistic that Rutgers doesn't have the cash to fire guys after one or two seasons and attract a top shelf candidate while paying off the old coach. But I think it's reasonable for people to be disappointed. I'm among them.

When a new coach spends the offseason talking about how the previous team quit at times last season, wasn't conditioned properly and lacked tackling fundamentals and then we see the exact opposite on many occasions this year, it's cause for concern and disappointment.
 

Scarlet_Scourge

Heisman
May 25, 2012
26,537
13,622
113
I don't see a ton of people calling for his head. I think people are realistic that Rutgers doesn't have the cash to fire guys after one or two seasons and attract a top shelf candidate while paying off the old coach. But I think it's reasonable for people to be disappointed. I'm among them.

When a new coach spends the offseason talking about how the previous team quit at times last season, wasn't conditioned properly and lacked tackling fundamentals and then we see the exact opposite on many occasions this year, it's cause for concern and disappointment.

It is the same players....

Just saying...
 

ATIOH

All-Conference
Sep 3, 2004
986
1,078
0
i am not comparing Ash to Saban but for the sake of some perspective, I figured I'd post some of Saban's early losses along his coaching career:
55-14 Nebraska
51-23 Washington
52-28 Purdue
51-28 PSU
41-9 Florida
31-0 Bama
50-10 Nebraska
38-0 Stanford
Also lost to a sunbelt team
Well as long as you're not comparing Ash to Saban...... [eyeroll]
 
  • Like
Reactions: mdh2003

160louis_rivals149488

All-Conference
Aug 29, 2014
4,428
3,565
0
ok then let's pay him accordingly and use the money on better assistants. You can't have it both ways, the money we pay demands results. He has trouble making adjustments for God's sake and you want to give him 4 years before we judge him?

I'd bet plenty that Shea would have done better this year.

What? He makes 2 million a year. He's one of the lowest paid HC in the conference and all of the P5. If anything, we should have gave him more money.
 

MYHATINTHERING

All-Conference
Mar 25, 2015
9,163
4,043
0
What? He makes 2 million a year. He's one of the lowest paid HC in the conference and all of the P5. If anything, we should have gave him more money.
that thinking is part of the problem

Thank God we didn't give him more money and clearly my post went over your head
 

Steve91562

All-American
Oct 23, 2007
6,353
9,430
77
I doubt many are calling for his head, but you have to admit that this team has taken a step backwards. Most would be OK, with taking a step backwards, if RU was playing a lot of Freshmen and Sophs, but when it comes to the D-line, O-line, wideouts and running backs there are many upperclassmen filling those positions. Where is the future? What can we be optimistic about? Hopefully the recruiting class comes through and that is what we are able to hang our hats on.


You answered your own question. Recruiting is the future, and ultimately Ash will be judged on how he recruits. If he recruits well, this year will be forgotten.

It's pretty simple -- you are what you recruit. Alabama is perennially top 5 because they recruit in that position. Factoring the dismissals and what seemed to be a higher than normal transfer rate, our recruiting over the past 4 years was probably in that 60-70 range. Coupled with key injuries, new schemes, a rookie staff, and potentially lack of prior development -- this is what you get.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Postgame Show: Penn State Nittany Lions Edition - TKR Pod
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football HC Greg Schiano's Penn State Postgame Press Conference
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Stuns Penn State With Last-Second Touchdown
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball routs Delaware State after slow quarter for historic start