Laviano to start

DHajekRC84

Heisman
Aug 9, 2001
30,708
19,816
0
I don't think it is absurd at all. These people have gone from tearing down the kids TD pass, to now quoting criminal statutues regarding fake IDs on this board. and resorting to saying that his rule violation should be a reason to sit him. I honestly do not doubt they would stop at anything to get what they want. Laviano cannot do anything right apparently.

it IS absurd. I am the one who posted it for about 30 seconds by mistake because I thought it read it was a CRIME in NJ and I was responding to the posts about just going into a club. In NJ it is a very serious crime to have a fake ID...$10,000 fine and jail time..BUT when I realized having one to get alcohol is treated completely different per the statute I immediately deleted it.it.

So now go read all of my comments and tell me where I have trashed Chris? Worst you will find is me saying I would have preferred Retig but support whomever is our QB.
 

LotusAggressor_rivals

All-American
Oct 11, 2003
16,986
8,958
113
This is so typical Flood. This is why I never wanted him as HC. Now it gives greater credibility that Rettig never truly a fair shot, in camp or against NSU.

I would have been fine playing both against WSU as they appear to have slightly different strengths. Many schools successfully do this--Wisconsin did last year.

That said, based on what I've seen as a fan, I'm leaning with Rettig because I do think he has more upside and importantly, our offense features throwing the ball deep. Going back to Teel, and since continuing to play the pro style, thought Rettig fit the offense better.

I hope Flood's stubbornness on QBs doesn't cost us games.

There are no excuses against WSU.
Wisconsin played 2 QBs last year because both of their QBs sucked. Teams that run pro-style offenses at the college level usually don't shuffle QBs in and out unless neither one of them is any good.
 

RUbacker

Heisman
Dec 5, 2014
16,232
23,249
108
Oh, of course.. the fans are delusional! The coach is always right! Sorry to burst your bubble, but we may be the only team in power 5 history that has had a QB throw for 5 or more interceptions TWICE, and still inexplicably keep him in the game.

I doubt any other D1 coach would do the same thing.

Look, there is one insanely simple reason why this backup issue is a big deal for fans. We can all acknowledge Gary Nova was an incredible practice QB, he lit up mediocre teams marvelously, and had all the on-paper ability you could ever ask for in a QB... but when it came to game-time situations against good defenses... he crumbled. Time and time again. It was so apparent that opposing linebackers would joke about it after games, saying that they studied his film, and knew exactly how to target him to make mistakes.

Somehow Flood could not look beyond this glaring flaw. He just saw the perfect recruit. The perfect practice QB. And stubbornly would not explore ANY other possibilities. This is why so many of us are worried right now. In last year's case, thankfully the Fridge understood Nova's limitations and that's why the gameplan altered so much, and focused more on check downs, establishing the run, using kroft as a blocker, and keeping him comfortable. But it still didn't work against elite defenses! I mean you guys remember those massive blowouts right? Or how if we threw one less interception to PSU, we would have beat them, right?

The reality of the QB position is some kids are just gamers. They're wired for it. And most importantly, some may not seem the greatest on paper/practice, but have a way of bringing it against top competition. Drew Brees being the poster child for it.

As fans pushing for a backup all those years... our point was that we NEVER got to see anyone else. No one got a legitimate chance. And that's fine if you have an unbelievable QB up there, who brings it against the best... but was it worth committing to a QB that would falter against a solid defense?

In the case of Dodd, you can go ahead and knock him for a couple bad games (none of which were anything like the horror shows Nova put us through), but the guy went to a league of professional players that still pulls in former NFL and elite college players and absolutely destroyed it. To the point that he was put on the Italian Madden cover. Now, obviously who knows if he'd ever have been able to do it here, but the one takeaway is that this kid had some intangibles working for him. And there were plenty of times where he showed it here at RU. As for the Notre Dame game... we'll never know if it would have been a different outcome if he was given a full season to play, build chemistry and master the offense. Instead, the guy was kind of just thrown in there out of desperation at the end of the season.

As for this decision, I think some of us are just worried Flood is walking down another close-minded path. The simple pragmatic solution would have been to do a 2 qb system until one separates from the other, since it's so close - but he didn't. Thankfully, both look sharp... and like some people have already mentioned - as long as the entire offensive staff is in unison (fridge and mcdaniels) then sure. But I can't imagine everyone was in unison when Nova threw 6 ints, and Flood stubbornly kept him in there. Let's just hope Flood has learned from those mistakes, and of course wish both QBs best of luck.
I guess you are certainly one of the back QB cheer leaders. But nova was our best and he played. Maybe he wasn't as good as what we wanted but he was our best and glad we had him entering big last year. No need for you to personally attack him. He played his heart out and coach called his number. Time to move on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IL Lusciato

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
198,732
151,568
113
Although Rettig played well it appeared he did not have full command of the offense in the sense that there were a couple delay of game penalties and a couple timeouts called from the sideline to avoid delay penalties. I noticed that he spent much more time looking at his cheat sheet on his wrist than Laviano. When Laviano was in the game McDaniels felt he had enough command to go uptempo. IMO if the decision was based soley on talent Rettig would have gotten the job but due to Laviano's better command he was chosen, Hope he plays well but if not go to Rettig.

I call b.s. At least one of those was because the coaches got the play in way late in the play clock. That is on the coaches.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Raritan83

brookdale-soda

All-Conference
Oct 4, 2010
3,792
2,064
113
The game everyone watched was against inferior talent. So to even think that any valuable insight can be gained on the play of our Qbs or the team in general is probably a major leap of faith. I'm not sure how anyone is lobbying for either QB at this point? Nj.com seems to certainly be successful in stoking the fire though.....
 

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
You say this as if Flood has never displayed bias when it came to QBs. Is it going to take 8 more mentions of the Dodd/Nova scenario?
1 - the Dodd/Nova scenerio, just like this laviano/rettig debate is not some determined validated fact one way or the other. Dodd did not play well many times too. Either way, I do agree that Nova should have been pulled from games like Kent state.

2- still your post does not negate my point at all. Just b/c Flood has been (maybe) biased in the past, does not mean that he is being biased now, and certainly does not mean that Laviano is a downgrade from Rettig, or that Flood has made the wrong choice due to bias. If anything the Nova situation shows that when a QB implodes maybe flood wont pull him. Then again, that simply is not true anyway, since he did pull Nova in games/seasons subsequent to Kent. St.

In any event, Laviano has played VERY WELL all spring/summer/game 1. This is not a case of a QB playing poorly and Flood being biased and sticking with him. Laviano has played very well. So if Flood chooses him, there is absolutely no substantial strong evidence that says Laviano is an inferior player, and therefore Flood made this choice due to his own bias and it is inevitable Laviano will fail at some point. Unless of course, someone has seen every practice AND is a football coach, and can tell me, based on specific facts and analysis why they are certain that Laviano was definitively the lesser QB/player.

Now, if Laviano DOES fail, and implode, and Flood refuses to pull him even while we lose with multiple INTs and mistakes from Laviano, then your point will be more relevant against Flood based on past evidence.
 

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
The game everyone watched was against inferior talent. So to even think that any valuable insight can be gained on the play of our Qbs or the team in general is probably a major leap of faith. I'm not sure how anyone is lobbying for either QB at this point? Nj.com seems to certainly be successful in stoking the fire though.....

I agree to an extent. As far as actual ability - they both probably would have had worse outtings against a better team. I.E. Rettig definitly throws that INT that was dropped. I.E. Laviano does not get 3 easy scores, b/c even if the first pass did still make it (i actually think it was not a bad throw at all), it is probably doubtful that Carroo would have just run over and juked everyone on the additional 2 plays for the TDs.

Also, both guys would have tigher windows, less open guys, and have scarier DLs breathing down their necks.

HOWEVER, even if we account for this, they both played pretty even. Even if it would not have looked as good on either end. What I do see, IMO, is that when Laviano was in, we manhandled and destroyed NS the way we should against a team of that level.
 

IL Lusciato

Heisman
Oct 31, 2011
10,680
13,292
0
I guess you are certainly one of the back QB cheer leaders. But nova was our best and he played. Maybe he wasn't as good as what we wanted but he was our best and glad we had him entering big last year. No need for you to personally attack him. He played his heart out and coach called his number. Time to move on.

Yeah, Gary is going to go down as a RU great - whether we loved him at every game or not. Kid was a huge piece in our legacy. Lay off him already, guy is an alum who went out on top. . .
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruready07

BLewis1968

Senior
Feb 3, 2004
707
456
63
:uzi:

Yeah, that's why he got the fake ID.

Not everybody that goes out to a club does it with the intention of getting drunk. Or even having a single drink. (Not that I know what his intentions were, just pointing out for accuracy's sake I couldn't report that somebody was drunk or even had the intention to drink just because they were at a club).
 

PhDKnight

Junior
Dec 6, 2013
776
276
0
People need to relax. We were playing a low level FCS team. Just because our QBs completed a pass or put up points does not mean they made the right read or made a good throw - the talent/resouce gap is so large that a QB can look good while playing poorly in this situation.

If I had to guess I would say that what the coaches see is that -
A) Rettig has more arm talent and more upside, but his playbook is limited and his game management is a work in progress because he had not played a meaningful snap in 2 years AND
B) Laviano is a talented, although less so than Rettig, QB but does not have the liabilities that Rettig does.

We are a conservative football team so we go with Laviano. If our coach was Mike Leech we would go with Rettig. It's not a conspiracy it is a difference in personality and perspective. Relax.
 
The Knight Report

Latest

  1. 01 The Knight Report Rutgers Football Injury Report: Latest ahead of the Penn State game
  2. 02 The Knight Report Rutgers Football vs. Penn State Preview + Players Era 8 Basketball Recap - TKR Pod
  3. 03 The Knight Report Join The Knight Report TODAY and get it for 50% off!
  4. 04 The Knight Report WAR ROOM: Latest Recruit Scoop and Team News on Rutgers Athletics
  5. 05 The Knight Report Rutgers Women's Basketball HC Gary Redus II's Maryland Eastern Shore Press Conference